AdventAI

The Dime Novel and the Storybook

From The Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 65, No. 3., January 16, 1917

A MAN who has written many of the paper dime novels as well as a large number of the twenty-five-cent storybooks bound in cloth, claims that the latter is really the dime novel put up in a different dress. Of course it represents the better class of dime novel, which, however, is not saying a great deal. This writer further says:—

“Now the chief difference between the ‘half-dime novel’ and the ‘good series’ in paper covers is that the former deals with criminals and their capture or with Wild West thrills, while the latter deals with boys in school or in business, in travel, in history, or adventure. If the story is about business life, the hero, a poor but honest lad with boundless ambition, starts in as an office boy. He soon makes an enemy, a dishonest office boy or clerk, and then it is a battle of wits between the hero and the villain. They resort to all sorts of tricks and devices; the dishonest boy does not hesitate to commit crime in order to trap the hero; and the hero, the humble office boy, does not hesitate to rebuke any one up to the president of the concern in order to prove himself right. In the end he usually marries the president’s daughter.

“For the school story the only difference in the setting is that the scene is laid in the school or in a summer camp, or on a trip to some foreign country, instead of in the business office.

“Eliminate the school or the business setting, and you have practically the ‘half-dime novel.’ The hero takes the place of the detective; the bad boy, the criminal. Instead of cracking a safe, the bad boy steals books or examination questions, and hires thugs to beat his rival. The hero first suspects his enemy, then spies upon him, and finally traps him. All the excitement and thrills of the ‘half-dime novel’ are ‘rung in,’ no situations are impossible, and of course the hero always comes out on top—in accordance with the publisher’s instructions that ‘crime does not pay.’”

This writer calls these juvenile storybooks “wolves in sheep’s clothing;” and says that “the greatest curse of these cheap storybooks lies in the fact that they deaden and finally destroy the taste for real books. Their readers miss the fine, real things. They come to prefer impossible fiction to serious books, to biography, history, or even to stories that present life and character as they are.” The same thing applies to the sensational stories found in some of the best of the world’s papers and magazines. As a test for the character of stories some one gives the following rules to parents:—

“Read your children’s storybooks yourself.

“Does this book lay stress on villainy, deception, or treachery?

“Are all the incidents wholesome, probable, and true to life?

“Does it show young people contemptuous toward their elders and successfully opposing them?

“Do the young characters in the book show respect for teachers and others in authority?

“Are these characters the kind of young people you wish your children to associate with?

“Does the book speak of and describe pranks, practical jokes, and pieces of thoughtless and cruel mischief as though they were funny and worthy of imitation?

“Is the English good, and is the story written in good style?”

This is wholesome counsel. Some of our so-called high-class periodicals contain stories as unsuitable for youth to read as the twenty-five-cent thriller. Should we not provide our children and youth first with our own periodicals, and then with the Reading Course books, which have been selected with much care? Historical, biographical, and scientific books can then be found that will amply provide for the limited amount of time left them.

The conviction of this dime-novel and twenty-five-cent-story writer that such reading is injurious to the nation’s youth has become so strong that he has relinquished such writing, even though his livelihood has been obtained therefrom.

It is worth our while to look well to what we read and what we give the younger ones to read; for reading makes the man. Napoleon said: “Show me the man who reads good books, and I will show you the man who moves the world.” Henry Clay’s word must encourage parents to make great effort to supply the best to their children. He says: “When I was a boy my mother was very poor, but she was never too poor to buy her boy a good book, and to this more than anything else I owe my success in life.”