Accuracy or Intellectual Honesty
By Mary M. Crawford
SOME one has said that “accuracy is intellectual honesty” and that “honesty is the best policy.” The truth of these statements will not be questioned; but the application may not be altogether clear. There are two prominent forms of intellectual dishonesty,—overstatement and understatement, the former being perhaps the more common. It is called exaggeration. People addicted to this form of intellectual dishonesty are invariably making statements that stretch beyond the mark of honesty, as did the little fellow who watched the street parade, and who on returning from it remarked, “O papa, I saw a dozen elephants,” when there were only three or four. The young woman in describing her new hat would lead you to believe she paid about three times as much for it as she really did. In this age a false pretense of wealth is undoubtedly the most flagrant form of intellectual dishonesty. Thousands of instances of such forms of dishonesty are occurring every day. No wonder the child scarcely knows that such statements are dishonest, when he hears so many of his seniors constantly exaggerating. If he is an inquisitive child, he is often met with such remarks as, “Run away, Willie, you have asked me that question a thousand times already.” Probably he had asked it once or twice before, but did not receive a satisfactory answer according to his way of thinking. The answer was too superficial, and not explicit enough in the details. Children are usually curious to know all the whys and wherefores; and many of the little details, which to us seem a waste of time to mention, are of great concern to them. His fund of knowledge is limited, and the details help to enlarge it. Understatement of the truth is a falling short of the mark of honesty. One morning John’s father told him to saw a pile of wood before his return. John’s brother, James, also had a pile to saw, but James was not very industrious, and sawed only about one half of his pile, while John finished his completely. John was very eager to tell his father that James had not finished his work, so he said, “Papa, James has sawed only a few sticks of his pile.” This is still exaggeration, but it lies on the opposite side of the mark of honesty. It is that form of exaggeration which falls short of being honest, while the other form steps beyond the mark of honesty. Accuracy of statement in minor details is, therefore, of great importance in the development of honesty in the character. Honesty is reckoned at par value always. Its price never fluctuates, and no brokerage should be added or subtracted. Our statements should never be made above par nor below par, but always at par—a Yea, Yea, and a Nay, Nay, as saith the Lord. Let us therefore speak in mathematical precision. Our brokerage fees will be charged according to the trouble we make others by our overstatements and understatements.5 Poor Richard Junior’s philosophy states that Diogenes needed a lantern to find an honest man in his day, but that in these days he could see the whitewash a mile off. An insincerity of heart coupled with the prevailing habit of exaggeration makes a Pharisaical character, which Christ denounced as a whited sepulcher, being filled with dead men’s bones, or rank dishonesty. The Pharisees made many false pretensions and lived an exaggerated form of godliness without the power thereof. They used plenty of whitewash to hide the insincerity of heart and purpose within.