AdventAI

Which is the Largest City in the World?

By Clayton Keiser

From The Youth’s Instructor, Vol. LXIV, No. 15, April 11, 1916

If you ask an Englishman which is the largest city in the world, he will say London; but if you ask an American, he will say New York. According to the World’s Work, the largest city is “the city which houses the most people subject to the jurisdiction of one municipal government.” Taking this as a standard, let us draw our comparisons.

The Chinese fooled us in making us think that Peking is the largest city in the world, because we took for granted what they said. London also fooled us, but in a different way. According to the foregoing definition, London is that part of England which is governed by the city council, just as New York is that part of America which is governed by the aldermen and mayor.

According to this definition, London has a population of 4,522,964, and New York of 5,585,772 persons. The census for New York was taken in 1915 and for London in 1911. The Englishman, no doubt, will say that that isn’t fair. But it is very generous for London, because the census shows a decrease in population in 1911 over that of 1901. Probably it is smaller now than in 1911. You will ask, Where, then, are the 7,200,000 people claimed for London?

There are really three communities known as London: the old medieval city, the county which includes London, and the city of today. This will account for the 7,200,000. If New York followed the example of London, taking in everything within a radius of fifteen miles, she would have a population of 7,500,000. Figuring this way, she is still 300,000 to the good.

Mayor Mitchel is in charge of as many people in one place as many kings have in their whole realm. Denmark has a population of about one half that of New York City. The population of Sweden is just about the same as the “Great City.” The vast Dominion of Canada comes within 300,000 persons of reaching that of New York and her adjacent towns.

The number of people in the metropolis is greater than the combined population of Colorado, Wyoming, South Dakota, Nebraska, Kansas, New Mexico, Arizona, Utah, and one half of Texas. In the last ten years there has been an average annual increase of 135,000 persons. Think of adding a city like New Haven, Connecticut, every year to New York! In the ten years from 1900 to 1910, New York added enough people to make a city about as large as Philadelphia. One borough, Manhattan, is nearly as large as Chicago, and Brooklyn will almost come up to Berlin. Chicago, Los Angeles, and Seattle can boast of their growth, but none of them can compare with modest New York, whose growth has been double that of Chicago in the same period of time. One thirteenth of the population of the United States live in the metropolitan district. Yes, New York is the largest city in the world. CLAYTON KEISER.