The Ancient Condemnation

5%

Review and Herald Publishing Assn. · Takoma Park Station, Washington, D. C. · Sep 26, 1916

FromThe Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 64, No. 39.

Read the full edition

The Ancient Condemnation

The Tragedy of the Theater — No. 1

[The following article is from a chapter in Dr. Stough’s book, “Across the Dead Line of Amusements.” A notice of this inspiring and instructive book is given on page sixteen in this issue.]
The theater was intended, in its inception, to be the exponent of the drama, to further it in its work of education and culture, as one of the fine arts. But, because of the great revenues derived therefrom, the theater was soon organized as a commercial business, and as such was steadily developed until, within the past few years, so great has been the profit that it is now largely conducted as a consolidated trust, with an investment of millions of dollars in properties and in contracts with hundreds of actors and actresses.
Today every city in the country is being exploited, each has its various playhouses on what are called dramatic circuits. Companies, owned and operated by these trusts, are booked throughout the entire season. Into the coffers of these theaters pours a stream of millions of dollars spent each year by the pleasure-seeking public.
The theater has become a vital factor in American life, being one of the greatest teachers of the people, next in power to the press and the pulpit. As such it calls for the closest scrutiny and most searching inquiry upon the part of moral people. . . .
It may almost seem Don Quixotian for one to protest against the theater when some of the most moral and refined people, even of the churches and clergy, attend it, indorse it, and recommend it to their children and parishioners. How much good the presentation of the following arguments may do, I do not even venture to hope. If, however, they are in any way suggestive to inquiring minds and hearts, I shall feel amply repaid.

The Ancient Condemnation

Dramatic acting has existed from time immemorial, but even the ancient writers of moral truth, both Greek and Roman, frowned upon the theater and almost universally condemned it. Plutarch, Zenophon, Plato, Socrates, Solon, Seneca, Tacitus, Ovid, and many others have raised one common voice against it as hostile to morals. “An English writer in the time of Charles the First,” says Dr. Thomas Brainerd, “made a catalogue of authorities against the stage, which contains almost every name of eminence in the heathen and Christian world.” Plato once said, “Plays raise the passions and pervert the use of them, and of a consequence are dangerous to morality.” Aristotle said, “The seeing of plays and comedies should be forbidden to young people until age and discipline have made them proof against debauchery.” Tacitus said, “The German women were guarded against danger and preserved their purity by having no playhouses among them.”
Uhlhorn, writing of the theater in the Roman Empire, said, “The adventures of deceived husbands, adulteries, and amorous intrigues formed the staple of the plots. Virtue was made a mock of, the gods were scoffed at, and everything worthy of veneration was dragged in the mire.”
Philip Schaff, the historian, said, “The Roman theater became more and more the nursery of vice, and deserved to be abhorred by all men of decent feeling and refined taste.” Dramatic art took its rise at Athens, we are told, amid the orgies of Bacchus. “It was an exhalation from the frantic revels of a periodical national abandonment to intoxication and debauchery.”
All this was said about theaters where women never appeared, when their parts were acted by men and boys, as is the case at the present time in the Chinese theaters.
It is said no woman ever appeared on the stage until the time of the Restoration. The first time a woman ever acted was in Shakespeare’s “Othello,” in the part of Desdemona. It was regarded at first, Dr. Brand says, as shocking and monstrous.
Woman’s presence did not purify the stage, for Macaulay declares that from “the time the theaters (in England) were opened they became seminaries of vice. Nothing charmed the depraved audience so much as to hear lines grossly indecent repeated by a beautiful girl supposed not yet to have lost her innocence.”

The Church and the Theater

The church has tried both methods, to condemn and to condone. Dr. W. P. Breed said, “There was a theater in Jerusalem in the days of Jesus. Think you he ever attended it? Did the early disciples? So far from it that neither Jesus nor the apostles ever thought of forbidding their attendance upon stage plays.” When Herod introduced this theater, Josephus (not a Christian) denounced it as corrupting the morals of the Jewish people.
The church very early introduced into her conditions for membership an express prohibition against the theater. Dr. Tayler Lewis says, “At baptism the candidate was called upon to say ‘Vanis mundi pompus renuntio’—‘The vain pomp of the world I renounce.’ It can be clearly shown that this word ‘pompae’ was employed with special reference to theatrical shows.” Theophilus, Tertullian, St. Cyprian, St. Augustine, all denounced it.
The mystery and miracle plays were introduced during the Middle Ages and were acted very widely. The art of printing being not yet known, it was thought the people could be taught spiritual truths from the stage. However, the results were never satisfactory, and finally were deteriorating. Lecky says that after the thirteenth century they became one of the most powerful agents in bringing the church, and, indeed, religion, into disrepute. Reformers then tried to correct abuses. “Two hundred clergymen,” says Mrs. Mowatt, the actress, “wrote for the stage, but all in vain!”
Dr. Brainerd says that fifty-four ancient and modern general, national, and provincial synods, both of the Eastern and Western churches, have pronounced against the theater, and that the condemnatory sentence of seventy-one ancient fathers, and one hundred and fifty modern Catholic and Protestant writers, are on record. Conferences, assemblies, synods, associations, have all with one voice registered their protest. All these could not have been without worthy reasons, and it is to set forth these reasons that I am writing these words.