
Ma said we had too many dogs—we never had but four, And Tommy Brink let us have his, which only made one more. We just had Rover, Spot and Tige and Fido of our own, But Tommy Brink had gone away and left his dog alone, Which almost broke its heart, and so we let it come and play With all our dogs till after while it seemed to want to stay; But ma said three dogs were enough for three small boys, and so We'd have to pick out three to keep and let the other go.
We thought it over quite a while, and looked at them to find Which one to give away, and couldn't quite make up our mind. You see, they were such splendid dogs, and we all nearly cried When we looked at them in the yard, while trying to decide. Nobody knows how hard it was; they were such friends, you know, And each one liked us so we couldn't bear to let him go. But, after talking all forenoon, John told us, me and Jim, To lead up Rover to the house—we'd have to part with him.
My, he was such a handsome dog, and had such big brown eyes, That looked at us so friendly like, and O, so smart and wise! But we all led him to the porch, and John called ma to come, And tried to tell her how it was; but he was choked and dumb. So then I told her Rover was the dog that jumped for Jim One day when he fell in the creek, and was too small to swim, And Rover pulled him to the bank; but he is old, and so We told our mother he's the one we guessed we would let go.
And Rover wagged his tail at her, and barked as if to say He'd just as soon jump in the creek for us most any day. And we all waited, hoping she would change her mind; and then She shook her finger right at me, and then said, “O you Ben! You picked him out on purpose, sir!” And she pulled Rover's ears, And petted him; and John he smiled; and we all gave three cheers, Till mama said she guessed, perhaps, she really didn't know As much about a dog as boys, and not to let him go.
—J. W. Foley, in Youth's Companion.