Has the Gospel Taken the Place of the Law?
CARLYLE B. HAYNES
Donald Hunter was ready with his notebook to take down the passages when the meeting in the tent began on Tuesday night. Elder Harris had announced that he would speak that evening on the proper relation of the law of God to the gospel of Christ. This was a question upon which Donald had heard based many arguments against the Sabbath, and he wanted every text, so that at home he might carefully study the subject for himself. The tent was again crowded. The people seemed to feel that an understanding of this subject was vital in establishing the truth or falsity of Brother Harris’s position on the Sabbath question. The minister said:
“In order to do away with the obligation to observe the seventh day, the theory is advanced that the gospel has taken the place of the law, and therefore no Christian is under obligation to observe it. This theory teaches that the old dispensation was a dispensation of law, and continued to the death of Christ; but that the present dispensation is a dispensation of grace in which we have nothing to do with law, and hence all Christians are free from the law.”
“Now the truth of this subject is made so clear by the Bible that no one need remain in error concerning it. The law of God is that part of his divine revelation which was spoken by God himself to men in the thunders of Sinai (Deut. 4:12, 13), and written with his own finger on two tables of stone. Ex. 31:18; Deut. 4:13.
“The gospel is defined in Romans 1:16. It is the power of God to save men. This salvation is from sin. Matt. 1:21. It is evident therefore that the gospel has been made necessary because of sin. If there had been no sin, there would have been no need for a gospel. But sin came, and this made necessary a gospel to save from sin.
“But what is sin?—‘Sin is the transgression of the law.’ 1 John 3:4. This is God’s definition of sin.
“Now let us put these things together. The gospel is the power of God to save men from sin. Sin is the transgression of the law. Law, then, existed first, for there could have been no sin had there been no law to transgress. Transgression brought sin into the world. Sin made the gospel necessary.
“It is plain from this that the gospel was introduced to save men from transgressing the law; and to use the gospel, as some now do, as an excuse to transgress the law is a total perversion of its real purpose.
“If the law is now abolished, as some teach, then there is no need at all for the gospel. For if the law is abolished, it follows that sin also is abolished, for it is impossible to sin without the law, as ‘sin is the transgression of the law.’ Notice how clearly Paul puts this in Romans 4:15 and 5:13. Where there is no law there can be no sin. Hence if the law is abolished we are both without sin and without law.”
“But something else follows from this. The gospel is for the purpose of taking away sin. But by the abolishing of the law, sin has already been taken away, and thus the gospel is not needed, for the very purpose of the gospel is secured by abolishing the law, as this also abolishes sin. Hence the gospel, too, is abolished by this teaching of the abolition of the law.
“It becomes evident at once that this dangerous teaching of the abolition of God’s law destroys itself. It abolishes altogether too much, for it does away not only with the law, but also with sin, with the gospel, with the church, with the gospel ministry, and with the great sacrifice of Christ on Calvary, for that sacrifice was offered to take away sin. No person who loves Christ, who loves the gospel, who loves the church, ought ever to be found teaching such a God-dishonoring doctrine as the abolition of the law, a doctrine which today is so popular.
“The law does not save men. That is done by the gospel. No one can get salvation out of the law. By doing what the law requires he cannot secure salvation. Rom. 3:20. The law condemns the sinner to die. Rom. 7:10. It cannot save him. It is not the purpose of the law to give salvation. That is the purpose of the gospel.
“And when we come to the gospel, and are saved by it and our transgressions are forgiven, then the condemnation of the law, the condemnation to death, passes away. Then it becomes true that ‘ye are not under the law, but under grace.’ Rom. 6:14.
“This does not mean, as many seem to think, that we are free to break the law. Not at all. The man who breaks the law is not under grace, but under the law. It is the man who is under grace who keeps the law, and he remains under grace only so long as he keeps the law. When he breaks the law he is no longer under grace, but goes back under the law. Let me illustrate this:
“A man commits murder. He is arrested, tried, and convicted. He is sentenced to life imprisonment, and taken away to jail. He is now under the law. But why?—Because he has broken it. Why are you not put in that same jail with him? Why are you free from the law and out of prison?—Because you are keeping the law. The law has no terrors for those who obey it. The murderer is under the law because he has broken it. It is clear, then, that those who have broken the law are under the law, and those who are free from the law are those who are keeping the law.
“But because of good behavior, after serving ten years of his sentence, the governor pardons this murderer. When he walks out of the prison he is no longer under the law, but under grace, the grace of the governor. He is now in the same position as the sinner whose sin Christ has forgiven. Does this mean, however,p. 9 that the murderer, who is now free from the law, can go out and break the law? Does being under grace mean that he has a license to transgress the law? Can he now go out and kill another man because he is no longer under the law but under grace?
“It will be, I am sure, plain to all that the murderer will remain under grace only so long as he keeps the law. If he should again transgress the law, if he should kill another man, then he would be under the law again, and would go back to jail.
“Just so is the case of the Christian. The pardoning of our sins does not afford us a license to commit additional sins. It frees us from the condemnation of the law and puts us under grace, but we remain under grace only so long as we keep the law. When we break the law, when we break any of its ten commandments, the Sabbath commandment or any other, then we are back under the law again, and no longer under grace.
“Therefore those who keep the Sabbath are not under the law, but rather those who break the Sabbath.
“That we thus establish the law by faith in Christ is made plain in Romans 3:21.
“The purpose of the law is not, as I have said, to save men, but to point out their sin, and thus to reveal to them their need of a Saviour from sin. The law is a great sin detector. It points out sin, but it cannot remove it. But what law is it which points out sin, and to transgress which is sin? It is the ten-commandment law. This will be seen by reading Romans 7:7. The law which reveals sin is the one which says, ‘Thou shalt not covet.’ This is the law of ten commandments, the same law which contains the Sabbath commandment.
“Now the purpose of the gospel is to take away what the law points out. Hence the law and the gospel must go together, and can never be separated. Both are needed. This will be seen by reading James 1:22–25.
“Here the law is likened to a looking-glass, a mirror. When the laboring man comes home from work he looks into the mirror to see the condition of his face. The looking-glass reveals to him the fact that his face is soiled. It will not lie, it tells the exact truth. It points out to the man his need of cleansing.”
Here every one became especially interested, as Brother Harris brought out a basin of water, a piece of soap, a towel, and a mirror. He was about to give an object lesson of the teaching of the Bible. He said:
“Now what this looking-glass does for the man is like what the law of God does for the sinner. It points out sin. This soap and water represent the gospel, that which takes away sin.
“The man who looks into the looking-glass would not think of taking it from its hook, and rubbing it over his face to cleanse his face.” Here Brother Harris illustrated by rubbing the looking-glass over his face, which caused his listeners to smile. “That is not the purpose of the looking-glass, and neither can it do that work. The man should apply the soap and water [here the speaker plunged his hands into the water, lathered them well with the soap, washed them, and dried them with the towel, to the great interest of all] and cleanse his face and hands, when the glass has revealed their soiled condition, just as we go to Christ and wash away our sins in his blood when they are pointed out by the law.
“And now,” said the preacher, “what would you think of a man who, after seeing in a glass his need of cleansing, would take a hammer [then taking a hammer, the speaker struck the looking-glass a blow which shivered it to pieces, startling his big audience into the most intense attention] and break the glass to pieces, saying, ‘You are abolished’? This would not help his face, would it? Neither can a sinner get rid of his sins by saying that the law is abolished.
“The duty, then, of every person who learns that the seventh day is the Sabbath is not to claim that the law is abolished, but to confess his past transgressions of this commandment, and go to Christ for grace to keep the Sabbath in the future. When the law points out our sin, let us not try to get right by abolishing the law, for that we can never do, but get right by accepting Christ’s grace and bringing our lives into harmony with his law, and thus fulfil its requirements.”
When they arrived at home that night, Mr. Hunter said to his wife: “I always thought that subject of the law and the gospel was a most complicated and intricate subject, hard to be understood, and I never hoped to be able to understand it so clearly as this sermon has caused me to. Why, it is as clear as the sun at noon, so clear that a child can comprehend. Certainly Brother Harris has a most wonderful understanding of the Scriptures to make them so plain to his hearers. This subject clears up many things which have perplexed me, and I am profoundly thankful I heard it.”
Donald was glad, too, that he had heard it, for he felt now that no one would ever be able to confuse him about the relation of the law to the gospel. He would never forget that illustration of the looking-glass and the soap and water.