SUCCESSFUL business as well as successful church and social life requires the elimination of the grumbler. Mr. Collins, in Every Week, relates an incident where a professor had a happy way of carrying out this plan of elimination. He says:
“A Northern forestry professor wanted his class to make a thorough study of the Florida turpentine industry during vacation, in July and August. He was advised by a Florida lumberman to choose some other season of the year.
“That’s the hardest time in our pine woods,” the latter said. “The weather is hot, the mosquitoes bite, and your boys are pretty sure to get discouraged.”
“But midsummer is the only time we can come,” replied the teacher. “I believe I can handle them.”
So the professor brought his class, and disappeared in the woods; and the Floridian, after waiting a week, penetrated to their camp to see how the tender college boys liked it.
To his astonishment, they were all healthy, happy, and busy. The living was hard, the surroundings uncongenial; but they played at their work like a game.
“How do you do it?” asked the admiring Floridian of the professor.
“Why, it’s simple enough,” said the professor. “I just watch for the first grumbler, and squelch him on sight. Most of the fellows in a crowd like this will overlook the drawbacks for the sake of the work and the fun and the achievement. But two or three will be critical and on the lookout for something to complain about, and if you let them start growling they’ll infect the whole crowd. So I go after the first grumbler with an ax.
“It need not be a steel ax, of course—one of the most effective weapons is ridicule. If I make the normal fellows laugh at the grumbler, he must either get in line or get out.”
“Sometimes It’s the Boss Who Grumbles”
When the manager of men grumbles, a host of discontents are soon generated, for grumbling is both contagious and infectious. This is disastrous to the business in hand. So the boss grumbler must be eliminated. Mr. Collins relates an incident giving one successful way of accomplishing this happy end:
“A newly promoted office manager got his chance at authority. He had never bossed people before. His technical ability was excellent, but he did not get on well with the clerks in the first few weeks.
“Presently the office force was becoming disgruntled and careless. The new boss went to the general manager with a complaint about a man named Smith.
“‘Smith is a good detail man, and I do not want to discharge him,’ he explained, ‘But yesterday he made a mistake that was a real bonehead play. I want to fine him what it cost the firm in material and time.’
“‘That’s something new,’ said the general manager. ‘We have never fined anybody before. But you’re in charge, and must manage as you think best. Maybe your idea is right. But will you let me make a suggestion? If you have to fine people for their blunders, then you ought to have a system of rewards for their good work. Unless your books show a just balance in such matters, men will not have confidence in you as a boss. When you settle the amount of Smith’s fine in your mind, just give him credit for his merits.’
“‘That boss is a manager of managers.
“‘Smith was never fined.
“‘For, when the new office manager came to balance his good work against his mistake, he found so much in Smith that was worth keeping and praising that he took an ax to himself as a grumbler. He and Smith had a talk. The substance of it was that Smith was too good a man to let his batting average slump by such carelessness, and he decided that he must work to prevent such an error happening again. In the next month Smith made good a dozen times; and the office manager became a real boss, because he had found and weeded out the first grumbler—himself!’”