A TALK WITH BROTHER HARRIS

3%

Review and Herald Publishing Assn. · Takoma Park Station, Washington, D. C. · Apr 3, 1917

FromThe Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 65, No. 14.

Read the full edition

A TALK WITH BROTHER HARRIS

Donald Asks Why Moving Picture Shows are Wrong

CARLYLE B. HAYNES
WHEN Donald Hunter awoke the next morning after hearing the impressive sermon on the signs of the Lord’s coming, he did not feel so much like making the sacrifice of giving up going to moving picture shows as he had the night before. The sharpness of the first impression had dulled, and he was inclined to think that Brother Harris was narrow-minded on this particular point.
But he was troubled about it. He felt sure the Bible taught that Jesus was soon to come. The evidences presented on that point from the Bible had thoroughly convinced him of that truth. He was really honest in wanting to know what he must do to be prepared for that great event; but he did hope that it would not be necessary for him to give up moving pictures.
As the hours of the morning went by, he became more and more troubled about it. A special show was coming to town the next day, and it had been widely advertised as one of the greatest pictures ever put on the screen. While it was based on a novel, it had a historical background, and the advertisement said it would show hundreds of soldiers and horses. Donald had been planning for days to attend this show, and now he did not know what to do. He felt he must come to some decision at once.
About noon it occurred to him that he might get help in reaching a decision if he should talk it over with Brother Harris. So he turned his feet in the direction of the rooms which Brother Harris and his wife occupied. They were about half a mile from the tent. Soon Donald was knocking at the front door. The preacher himself opened the door and invited him in, telling him that he was glad he came.
Donald did not waste any words. The thing was too serious for that. He came right to the point, and said:—
“Brother Harris, I heard what you said last night about moving pictures. I know some of the shows are not very good, but isn’t it all right for a Christian to go to the better shows? They are not all bad, you know.”
“No, they are not,” said Brother Harris. “I know there are some things shown by moving pictures which are educational.”
“Yes, that’s what I mean,” eagerly said Donald, who began to think that after all, things were not going to be so bad as he had feared. “There are some shows which you can get a great deal of good from. Now, is it wrong to go to them?”
“Now, my boy, I don’t want you to get the idea that I am opposed to moving pictures as moving pictures. The invention by which they are produced is one of the most remarkable inventions of this age, and properly used, there are possibilities of great good in it. It can be used to teach geography and the customs of foreign people. It can be used to teach scientific truths. It can be used to teach some of the great truths of the Bible.”
“I have often wished to use the moving picture machine in explaining the prophecies of the Bible. Do you not think every one would enjoy it if I could throw on a screen a picture of Daniel walking by the seaside, while a great storm was beating the ocean into foam, and then show four great beasts coming up out of the sea, just according to the prophecy that is in the seventh chapter of Daniel?”
“My, wouldn’t that be great!” exclaimed Donald.
“And how interesting it would make the prophecy of the second chapter of Daniel, to show Nebuchadnezzar dreaming his dream of the great image, and Daniel coming in and explaining it to him; then by appropriate motion pictures to show the fulfilment of this prophecy, covering the rise and fall of the great nations of history.”
“No, I am not opposed to the invention of the motion picture, but I am opposed to the uses to which it is being put.”
“But, Brother Harris, some of the pictures which you see at the shows are good, that is, they teach good lessons,” said Donald, earnestly.
“Yes, I think that is true,” replied Brother Harris. “I think I could attend some of these shows without receiving much harm. I think I could look at some of the pictures which are not good without experiencing any serious effect upon my morals. But that is not the point, my boy. You cannot judge the moving picture show as an institution merely by an occasional good picture. It must be judged as a whole. And judged in this way, its tendency, with that of the theater, is downward. While there is a good picture once in a while, such pictures are in the minority, and are produced only to secure from the better class of people the indorsement of the moving picture show.”
“Pictures of crime, and of criminals at their work are really an education in crime to the young people who see them. Pictures of drinking parties, dances, or card playing may create a desire in those who witness them to indulge in the real thing. Such pictures hide the ugliness of sin, and make it desirable, and thus lead to sin. The tendency of the moving picture show is downward. It is toward sinfulness and worldliness. It does not lead to God. It does not lead toward heaven. It is destructive of spirituality. Did you ever feel like praying or reading the Bible after coming from a moving picture show, Donald?” “No-o, sir, I don’t think I did,” said Donald, with considerable hesitation. “It does not lead in that direction, does it? No, it debauches the morals; it makes sin familiar and thus makes it seem less sinful; it incites to crime and immorality; it weakens the character; and it leads away from God rather than to him. I have read of boys who from what they saw on the screen, came to believe that it was smart to carry a pistol. One such boy bought one of a pawnbroker, secured cartridges, loaded it, and then flourished it in the faces of his companions. His mother called him to run an errand. He declared he would not go, and as she started to punish him, he pulled out the pistol and shot her. Now do you think that a Christian can indorse an institution that leads to such things as that?”
“No, he cannot,” said Donald, a little more firmly.
“Can a Christian indorse an institution which leads to worldliness and away from God?”
“No, sir.”
“Well, when a Christian goes to a moving picture show, does he not, by his presence, indorse the institution?”
“I suppose he does,” said Donald.
“And has he not contributed five, or ten, or twenty-five cents, or whatever the amount of the entrance fee, to an institution which is opposed to the gospel, to the church of Christ, and to the object of the gospel, the building of perfect manhood in Jesus Christ?”
“I never thought of it in that way,” said Donald.
“When that same Christian contributes ten cents to the church once a week, and ten or twenty cents to the moving picture show twice a week, is he not supporting two opposite institutions, and giving the greater support to the institution which leads away from God? And is that consistent Christianity?”
“No, sir, it is not,” said Donald energetically.
“There is another thing, Donald. A Christian thinks of others besides himself. Suppose I should go to a moving picture show, and you should see me there. Knowing I was a minister, would you not feel that my example was a safe one to follow?”
“Yes, sir.”
“I would therefore be responsible for my influence upon you,” said Brother Harris. “It is not only ministers who have influence; we all influence others by our actions. And God holds us responsible for the influence we exert. The particular show which I might see would not harm me, but if my example should influence others to attend not only that particular show, but lead them to think that the institution was a good one, and start them to going to such shows as would ultimately ruin their lives, would I be free from blame? Would I not be held responsible by the Lord for the example which started that soul on its downward course? You see, my boy, that this thing is not an unimportant matter. Certainly a person who is expecting the Lord to come, and who wants to meet the Lord in peace when he does come, must guard his influence and actions with the utmost care, that he may not lead others astray.”
Donald went home in a thoughtful mood, but he had settled the thing. He did not go to the special show the next day, and he was kept from doing so not only by the talk he had had with Brother Harris, but also by the sermon which he heard that night at the tent. Donald had fully made up his mind that he must get ready to meet the Lord. The sermon he heard I shall tell you of in the next story.