It is the good fortune of editors to be told their faults. They are not left to go blindly along, trusting that all is well. The reason they are in this privileged class, may be due to the fact that the critic can make use of the telephone or of the pen. A person can lay bare his inmost feelings so much more easily when he does not have to face the one at fault. The pen or the telephone gives one the freedom of the gossipier. But if criticism will call forth from an editor as good a discussion as the note from a reader of Every Week recently did from Mr. Barton, its editor, criticism should be welcomed by editors and patrons, whatever the means used in conveying the message. The note reads:— “I am sorry to see an editorial by you urging young men to pay more attention to their clothes, when there are so many more important things in the world for you to write about. Doesn’t the average young man pay too little attention to what he really is and too much to what he appears to be? We look to you to hold up the Lincoln ideal rather than the Beau Brummel ideal.” Mr. Barton answers the critic in the following pertinent words:— “This man is right, in part. It is the business of this magazine to hold up the Lincoln ideal. “We who love Lincoln would not change one single line in the portrait of him that we carry in our hearts. His homely face and slouching figure and unkempt person are a part of the treasure of our lives. We would not remove one wrinkle; we would not smooth out one crease. “We love him so much that we are not afraid to tell the truth about him. And the truth is that Lincoln succeeded not because of his slovenly appearance, but in spite of it. “Seward underestimated him; Stanton gibed at him. Welles and Chase and the others had to be convinced by months of association that their first impression of him was unfair. “How much easier Lincoln’s task, how different the attitude of his associates might have been, had it been possible for Lincoln to look what Lincoln really was. “Even his young secretary, John Hay, who worshiped him, spoke of him with affectionate amusement as the ‘gorilla’ and found it hard to take quite seriously the man who would rush into his room at midnight, with a ragged nightgown flapping about his knees. “Foreign ambassadors left his presence with a keen appreciation of the man’s innate dignity and power. “But foreign peoples saw just the baggy trousers, the unkempt coat, and the scraggly beard, and thought him the freak figurehead of a hopeless cause. “Disraeli, who helped rule England while Lincoln ruled America, was Lincoln’s exact antithesis. “He thought too much about his clothes. His dandified appearance and his foppish mannerisms were one of the influences that kept him from the premiership long after he had become the ablest individual in his party. “Too little attention to his clothes hindered Lincoln: too much attention hurt Disraeli. “Is it fair to regard as unimportant a matter that has proved its power to help or hurt the lives of the world’s great men? “The wise man will seek so to dress his body that it may be the perfect, efficient instrument of his soul, giving him poise and self-respect and confidence in the presence of other men. “To achieve that happy medium of good taste is not easy. It requires thought, and repays it.”