AdventAI

The Tragedy of the Theater — No. 2

The Indictment

My indictment against the theater is twofold:—

I. The theater’s effect upon the audience. 2. The theater’s effect upon the profession.

The Theater’s Effect upon the Audience

The first harmful effect is the gloss that many plays put upon sin. The base, the wicked, the impure, are frequently exalted, and virtue is made sport of. Religion is scoffed at, blasphemy indulged in, the Bible standard is not recognized, and the ten commandments are frequently flaunted.

Hannah More was the friend of the actor Garrick, and in her earlier days a writer for the theater and one of its patrons. As her judgment, forced upon her by her own observation, she wrote,—though she says she had read none of the writings against the stage,—“The fruits of the Spirit and the fruits of the stage perhaps exhibit as pointed a contrast as the human imagination can conceive.”

She continues: “It is generally the leading object of the dramatist to erect a standard of honor in direct opposition to the standard of Christianity; and this is not done subordinately, incidentally, occasionally, but worldly honor is the very soul and spirit and life-giving principle of the drama. Honor is the religion of tragedy. It is her moral and political law. Her dictates form its institutes. Fear and shame are the capital crimes in her code. Against these all the eloquence of her most powerful pleaders, against these her penal statutes,—pistol, sword, and poison,—are in full force. Injured honor can only be vindicated at the point of the sword; the stains of injured reputation can only be washed out with blood. Love, jealousy, ambition, pride, revenge, are too often elevated into the rank of splendid virtues, and form a dazzling system of worldly morality in direct contradiction to the spirit of that religion whose characteristics are charity, meekness, and peaceableness, long-suffering, gentleness, and forgiveness.”

Too frequently the end is made to justify the means, provided it succeeds in the achievement of some noble and worthy purpose. The highest type of morality is to be found in Christianity and in the Bible, and whenever standards are raised and morals taught which are not in accord with these, but which, on the other hand, make light of them and scoff at them, such teaching is bound to be destructive to the moral sensibilities.

Dr. Joseph Stephan has said, “Religion is either ridiculed, or so presented as to become offensive. Criminals become heroes and the good appear simpletons. Murder, adultery, divorce, theft, and other great crimes are made light of, and the sacredness of love and the solemnity of dying are trifled with. Oaths, mock prayers, and turns and squibs in Scripture are frequent. By sly hints and cunning innuendoes the imagination is inflamed and evil thoughts are awakened. There is scarcely an incident, however debasing, that may not be learned at the theater, making it a university of vice and immorality for the youthful mind.”

A recent magazine writer has said, “In life there are two kinds of morals, yours and mine. In the drama there is a third kind, which has no relation to life whatever. We are often asked in the playhouse to accept as admirable and moral what is in reality contemptible, immoral; and what is worse, we do so accept it.

“We check our own moral code in the cloakroom before the play begins, and then are allured by the most immoral, impure things posing as virtue on the stage, and are warmed to a rich glow of sympathetic sanctity by situations which upon analysis are the negation of goodness.

“And this is entirely due to the fact that in the theater we are carried along from moment to moment without pausing to reflect upon cause or effect; and the dramatist is so carried along, also, in his desire to make each situation immediately effective, forgetting its larger significance. In other words, in the drama, as elsewhere, a lack of clear thinking, down to the bedrock of principles, is the cause of most of the falsity and misappreciation.” These words are the more forceful because the writer was not writing from the standpoint of the pulpit, but of the dramatic critic.

The disastrous effect of such a “checking of our morals in the cloakroom,” is that when people leave such plays, they, alas! too often leave their own code of morals permanently checked, and take home those the theater furnishes,—the “admirable and moral” exchanged for the “contemptible and immoral.”

The second harmful effect is the theater’s positive teaching of crime. For instance, methods and means by which murders, robberies, and other crimes are committed are set forth in all their lurid details, and instructions in crime are frequently given as explicitly as are the studies of the public schools. So common is this in many of the so-called melodramas, that even theatrical managers themselves have at times protested.

One of these, Mr. J. J. Butler, of Kansas City, was reported as saying that many dramas are morbid and unclean, and that many of the melodramas presented each year are “schools of crime,”—they actually make criminals.

In discussing the epidemic of crime which breaks out in Chicago nearly every season, Bishop Fallows said with regard to the various causes, “Worst of all, in myp. 7 judgment, are the realistic plays of robbery and murder in several of our lower theaters, which are frequented nightly by thousands of boys, and the advertising of such plays by immense posters portraying to the life the ‘holdups’ by masked gangs with pistol and rifle and dagger.” Other reformers and settlement workers have expressed themselves in a similar way.

Some instances in illustration of this fact are very striking. In Canada some time ago a thirteen-year-old girl confessed to the murder of a nine-months-old infant. It is said she was in the habit of stealing baby carriages from the front of department stores while the mothers were inside. One day she stole a baby, took it to the woods near the city, stripped it of its clothing, threw it over an embankment, and caused its death. She then placed the body in a culvert and buried the clothing. A few days later she made the announcement that she had discovered the baby in the culvert. When accused of the crime, she confessed that the plan of killing the child was suggested to her by a play she had seen at the theater.

In New York, a man was arrested as a pyromaniac, first for ringing in false alarms, then for a series of factory fires. He confessed, and said that he developed a desire to see fires burn through his interest in a play entitled “The Fire Bug,” in which he had taken part as an amateur actor.

This baneful influence has extended even to the moving-picture shows, through the exhibition of dramatic films. Recently a film was shown of a girl who deceived her parents by going to her room for the night, and fixing the bedclothes in such a way that they appeared as if some one were in the bed. She then crawled out of the window and spent the night in gay frivolity with her friends. A young girl who sat in the audience and saw the suggestive deception, thought it clever, and a few days later did precisely the same thing. In the morning her mother went to call her, saw the deceptive bedclothes, thought her daughter was overtired, and let her sleep. She called her a second time, but she did not respond, and, being an indulgent mother, she let her sleep a little longer. The third time, receiving no answer, and knowing it was time for her daughter to be up, she went over and touched the bedclothes, which immediately collapsed. The mother was frightened and ran shrieking from the room, to call the father over the phone, and send out the alarm. At last they found the girl in another part of the city, where she had spent the balance of the night with a girl friend, after going out on a lark. Thus the “show” had been a veritable school of deception, suggested immorality, and crime.

The police of our great cities have declared that certain theaters are the foster mothers of crime among the youth. The director of prisons in Paris once said, “Whenever a noted play of a vicious character is put on the boards, I soon find it out by the number of young fellows who come into my custody.” Three fourths of the young people who go wrong in our cities, can look back to the theater and the ballroom as the starting points of their downfall.—“Across the Dead Line of Amusements,” Henry W. Stough.