Very soon after the discovery of America, active missionary work was begun among the Indians by different Catholic orders, and priests who had no backing but unbounded zeal and faith. So far as history reveals, the latter seemed to accomplish no permanent good, though the number of their baptisms was usually large. But where the work was carried on by some order, and the missionaries acted under instructions from their superiors, who secured for them financial assistance and military protection, the results were generally of a more stable character.
In most cases the “father’s” authority over his converts was entirely of a spiritual nature. The Indian was given religious instruction, and taught some of the ways of civilization, while he still remained subject to the laws of his tribe. In California and New Mexico, however, a considerable number of missions were established upon different principles, and conducted in an entirely different manner.
In California the work was begun by the Jesuits, and the principle upon which they acted was that the children of the forest were not competent to decide what was best for them; in fact, were not entitled to exercise the power of choice. Therefore, they reasoned, it was perfectly justifiable to put them under restraint as far as that course was practical. A great deal of tact was necessary in beginning the work in a new place; but once firmly established, it grew and prospered in a way that seemed, for a time, to indicate that this principle was the correct one. Whether or not it was, however, can best be judged by the final outcome of the work.
In beginning the work in a new place, the usual plan was for two priests, accompanied by several families of converted Indians, to establish a colony. A church was erected, cottages were built for the Indian families, land was plowed, and farming and stock-raising on a large scale were begun. Then, chiefly through the Indian colonists, others were induced to sever their relations with surrounding tribes, and join themselves to the mission.
Once baptized, the convert was no longer free. He was assigned to some band, whose chief led all his men to prayers and to work, gave to each his task, and sternly enforced the severe discipline of the colony, punishing the offenders with prompt rebuke and often with blows. Against this, the proud spirit of the Indian usually rebelled, and many of the converts promptly deserted the colony, and returned to their tribes. Others, however, soon became accustomed to their new life. Their work was never severe; neither were their hours of labor long. They received religious instruction; they were taught to farm, to make adobe bricks and build them into substantial houses, to spin and weave both cotton and wool, and to practice many other simple trades and handicrafts. They never lacked food. The flocks and herds supplied them with mutton and beef; the mission granaries were always filled with wheat and corn; and an abundance of fruit and vegetables were obtained from the orchards and gardens. Grain, wine, wool, and other produce were exported, often in ship-loads; and in return the colony received tools, farming implements, and such articles of food and clothing as they were unable to raise or to manufacture.
A band of soldiers was stationed in a fort near each mission to protect the colonists and priests from the attacks of hostile tribes, but often they served rather to excite the attacks. The priests were nearly always honest, faithful men, who had the interests of their protégés at heart; but the soldiers were usually the riffraff of Spain, and by their overt acts of treachery and rapine provoked the Indians to retaliation, and brought about the death of the very men whom they had been sent to protect.
The work was only thoroughly established in California when the Jesuit order became so odious to the government of Spain that its priests were all expelled, and their places filled with Franciscan Fathers. They, however, continued the policy of their predecessors; and the colonies continued to grow until 1824, when the first Mexican governor was sent to California.
At that time the Mission Indians numbered over thirty thousand. They owned nearly half a million head of cattle, over three hundred thousand head of sheep, and about sixty thousand horses. Their yearly wheat and corn crop averaged a hundred and twenty-five thousand bushels. These figures, of course, do not represent the entire wealth of the colonies, but they will give an approximate idea of what it was. By assigning to each member of the colonies his proportionate number of live-stock, you will see that there were then no poor Mission Indians.
The Mexican government was unfriendly to the church; and when its first governor took charge of affairs in California, he began at once to curtail the power of the priests. Some of the latter resented this intrusion upon what they considered their rightful authority, but the most determined of them were promptly expelled from the country. Personally, the Fathers had nothing to lose, as they were bound by vows of perpetual poverty. But they were well aware of the inability of their charges to cope with the more shrewd Spaniards, and resisted every advance of the latter as long as there was any hope of success.
It was not till 1834 that the power of the priests was entirely broken. Three years later, Congress decreed a change of the policy upon which the missions were conducted. All the personal property held by the missionaries was then turned over to the civil authorities, who assigned to each family in the colonies its proportionate allotment. A few of the missionaries were able to cope with the intriguing whites, and, for a time at least, save much of the property given to the families in their charge; but the greater portion of it quickly went to enrich the Spaniard, while the poor Mission Indian was left in abject poverty.
In 1842 several of the missions were entirely abandoned, and their once substantial buildings fell rapidly into ruin. The stock that were wont to graze upon the surrounding hills had all disappeared; the farming implements and craftsman’s tools were idle, broken, and rusting; the farms and gardens were overgrown with weeds; the orchards and vineyards were running wild, and rapidly dying for want of care. At other stations there was still a handful of Indians surrounding some faithful priest, who was doing his best to keep them together under the new order of things. Inp. 258 very few of the missions was even a small measure of their former prosperity retained.
At that time the Mission Indians had decreased to four thousand five hundred. Their cattle numbered fewer than thirty thousand, and the other live-stock had decreased in proportion. The remainder of the Indians were scattered, and living in abject poverty. Unused to the ways of the world, and untrained in self-reliance, they could not live as the white men did; and equally unaccustomed to the woods and the mountains, and strangers to the arts of the chase, they could not subsist as their ancestors had. No alternative was left them but beggary and petty thievery. They were a source of constant trouble to the authorities. True, they never rose in open rebellion; for their lives of semi-slavery had tamed the fierce spirit that reddened the tomahawks of their ancestors with the white man’s blood, and left the Mission Indian but a cringing dolt. Had the change of policy been more gradual, history might have written a different record, but of that we can never be sure.
Most of the Indians themselves were strongly opposed to giving up the socialistic plan. That the Fathers were almost universally loved and respected, is proved by the following statement of a writer whose personal observation qualifies him to speak intelligently: “The best proof of the good conduct of the Franciscan Fathers is to be found in the unbounded affection and devotion invariably shown them by their Indian subjects. They venerate them, not only as friends and fathers, but with a degree of devotion approaching adoration. When their pastors have been removed for political reasons, the distress of the Indians knows no bounds. They entreat to be allowed to follow them in their exile, with tears and lamentations, and with all the demonstrations of true sorrow and unbounded affection.”
When I read this, I was reminded of a story told of the late Mr. Moody. He was walking down the street one day, when he was accosted by a man who was partially intoxicated.
“How do you do, Mr. Moody?” said the man, extending his hand.
Mr. Moody took the proffered hand, and asked the man’s name.
“Why, don’t you know me?” was the reply; “I’m one of your converts.”
“I thought as much,” said the great evangelist. “If you had been one of the Lord’s converts, you would not now be in this condition.”
So it was with the Mission Indians. Had they been converted to God, they would undoubtedly have been sorry to lose their pastors, but they would have bidden them Godspeed, and claimed the promise: “I will never leave thee, nor forsake thee.” But when the Indians lost their priests, they lost the head to whom they had been taught to look, and were left as sheep without a shepherd.
J. Edgar Ross.