I LIKE to write with a stub pen, for the broad mark it makes does not show the irregularities in my writing as much as a finer pen. If I want to draw a rude pencil sketch, a carpenter’s pencil will serve the purpose; but if I desire to retouch a photographic negative,—to fill up the tiny, transparent lines and patches on the film,—my pencil must have a point like a needle. So for the ordinary use to which I put language, I like to use a verbal stub pen or carpenter’s pencil, in the form of the short Saxon words in every-day use. The mental impression thus given is as plain and broad and forcible as the line made by a large paint-brush; but there are no delicate shadings of thought, no fine lines of exact expression.
To illustrate: In the little word “ask” I have a verbal paint-brush; for I may mean request, beg, petition, solicit, entreat, implore, beseech, or supplicate. “Dislike” may mean aversion, reluctance, repugnance, disgust, antipathy. “Say” is broad enough to include allude, remark, utter, pronounce, proclaim, and assert.
If these words are not the “Jacks of all trades,” they are at least Jacks of several trades; for you can see that they do the work—though with little attention to details—of half a dozen or more specialists. If you wish to build a wood-house, or a barn, or a fence, a Jack of all trades may do the work satisfactorily; but if it is a magnificent piece of architecture that you are planning to erect, you must have men who are specialists in their respective lines.
For ordinary use, and even for the beautiful, mist-enshrouded word-pictures of poetry, the paint-brush words are the best; but for the precise language of science, those words likened to fine-pointed pens must be used. The physician, when he talks to a miscellaneous audience, uses short words, and consequently general terms, to express his thought, because he knows that the precise, or technical, words are unfamiliar to the public. Thus he may be able to tell the audience about the location of some particular muscle or nerve in the body about as accurately as I could locate the Fiji Islands by saying they are in the middle of the Pacific Ocean, several hundred miles southeast of the Hawaiian Islands; or as accurately as I could locate a certain star in the heavens by saying that it is about half-way from the horizon to the point directly overhead, in the regions of the north.
But we all know that there is a way, by the proper use of some many-syllabled words, to locate any one of the hundreds of muscles and nerves of the body; to give the exact position of any square mile of surface upon the entire earth; to point out without possibility of being misunderstood, any one of the millions of stars visible to the eye on a clear night, yet all this involves the use of technical words, and these words are to the majority of people as mysterious and incomprehensible as Hebrew. So the learned man of good sense does not attempt to use exact terms when talking to those unfamiliar with technical terms, but he uses the shorter words that convey as nearly as possible what he has in mind. The wise always remember that it is better to use a short word, even if it does not express an exact thought, than to use an exact technical term that, to his hearers, may mean nothing at all.
The reason young people often make ridiculous mistakes when they use big words, is that they have no exact thought to express; and having nothing precise in mind, they have no occasion to use other than commonplace words. Another thing it is well to bear in mind: Better use a familiar word that you know does not exactly express your thought than a word you have recently met, and merely suppose will convey your thought exactly. If the boy had borne that rule in mind, he would not have said, “The scholars all treated the teacher very respectively;” nor would the dull boy, after explaining to his teacher that the reason he was absent the day before was because of his cutting his head, have added that there was danger of information setting in unless he was very careful.
So when you hear somebody condemning the use of long words, and insisting that they should never under any consideration be used; when you hear people using long words when short ones would do as well; when you hear people talking learnedly in long and learned words about something they do not understand, be charitable and reasonable enough to grant that long words have their places, even though we may not understand them, and remember that it is the height of folly to criticize the way anybody expresses his thought unless you yourself are an acknowledged authority on that subject.
L. T. CURTIS.