AdventAI

Correct English¹

By D. D. Rees

From The Youth's Instructor, Vol. LI, No. 30, July 30, 1903

I am asked to distinguish between shall and will, sit and set, and lie and lay.

SHALL AND WILL.—Shall is the regular auxiliary to use with the first person to express future action; as, “In due season we shall reap, if we faint not.” Will with the first person expresses determination, resolve, or promise; as, “I will have my rights;” “All that the Lord hath spoken we will do.”

Will is the regular auxiliary to use with the second and third persons to express future action; as, “They will leave at six o’clock.” Shall with the second and third persons expresses command or promise; as, “Thou shalt not kill;” “The debt shall be paid.”

In questions, shall with the first and third persons asks permission or direction; as, “Shall we comply with his request?” With the second person it denotes simple futurity. Will, in questions, implies simple futurity in all three persons.

A very common mistake is the use of will with the first person to denote simple futurity.

SIT AND SET.—Sit and set are two distinct verbs, and should not be confused one with the other. The present of the former is sit, the past is sat, and the past participle is sat; the present of the latter is set, the past is set, and the past participle is set. Sit is never transitive; that is, its action is never transmitted to anything. Set is transitive; its action is transmitted to something. We may “set the table;” but we sit down at the table. We may set a hen; but the hen sits. A hen that sits on her eggs is a sitting hen, not a setting hen.

The verb set is used intransitively when denoting the “going down” of the sun or other heavenly bodies. The sun sets, not sits. The word is used in this instance in the sense of settles.

LIE AND LAY.—Lie and lay are also two distinct verbs. They are confused many times because the past of the verb to lie is spelled the same as the present of the verb to lay. The principal parts of the former are lie, lay, lain; of the latter, lay, laid, laid. A book lies on my desk; it lay there yesterday; it has lain there for a week. Notice that no action is transmitted. But lay takes an object. I now lay the book down; I laid it down yesterday; I have laid it down many times.

All these verbs are very commonly abused; but with a little study and painstaking any one can master them. There is no better time to set yourself right than now. D. D. REES.

Notes

  1. ¹PROFESSOR REES will be glad to answer, in the INSTRUCTOR, or by letter, any queries concerning the correct use of words and phrases that may occur to our readers. Address, inclosing two-cent stamp, Prof. D. D. Rees, College View, Nebraska. ↩