AdventAI

Some Mysteries of History

From The Youth's Instructor, Vol. LI, No. 49, December 8, 1903

Perkin Warbeck

THE little Princes in the Tower — what a pathetic tragedy was theirs, as we look at it across the centuries! No wonder that, when the two royal children disappeared from their rooms in the Tower, there were many followers of the House of York who still hoped against hope that these Babes in the Wood had somehow escaped their wicked uncle, the terrible hunchback Richard, and might be in hiding somewhere, ready to come back when it was safe to appear. The only thing known about their fate was the brief announcement, by Richard, in 1483, that they were dead. But there had been no funeral, no date of death given, even; and for ten years no one could say, authoritatively, what had really become of the sons of King Edward the Fourth after the Tower gates had closed upon the royal lads.

Meanwhile, England was at peace again, after the long agonies of the Wars of the Roses. King Richard the hunchback was dead long ago — slain on Bosworth Field. His conqueror, Henry Tudor, had married King Edward’s only known surviving child, the Princess Elizabeth, and was reigning as Henry the Seventh. It was well understood that he was not searching for his young brothers-in-law, nor did he propose to yield the crown to them if they appeared and claimed it. It was, therefore, not altogether safe, even now, for any claimant to come forward. Yet, in the same year that the caravels of Columbus crossed the Atlantic, a handsome, golden-haired youth, resembling the royal House of York most astonishingly, came to Ireland from the Low Countries,p. 6 and proclaimed himself to be Richard, Duke of York, the younger of the two Princes in the Tower.

He wrote letters to the Earls of Desmond and Kildare, great Irish nobles of that day; and, later in 1492, Desmond himself wrote a letter to King James of Scotland, setting forth the claims of the young prince, and forwarding a statement from him, to this effect:—

Young Perkin Warbeck (for so he had been known thus far) was the younger son of King Edward. His brother and he, boys of thirteen and eleven, had indeed been doomed to death in the Tower by Richard the Third. The murderers had killed Edward the Fifth (poor, helpless little king, whose title was but a fatal mockery!), but the one who was told off to kill the younger boy was moved with pity at his childish pleading, and not only spared his life, but smuggled him out of the Tower, and sent him abroad secretly, to friends in the Low Countries. Little Richard, in return, made a solemn promise that he would not reveal who he was for eight years. During these eight years, he had wandered in various countries, under the name of Perkin Warbeck. He had been in the service of an English noblewoman, a Portuguese knight, and a Breton merchant, and it was on business for the latter that he had come into Ireland, where so many had recognized him as the true heir of the House of York that he felt the time had come to avow his identity and assert his rightful claim to the throne of England.

“The news,” says an old historian, “hereof came blazing and thundering over into England that the Duke of York was sure alive.” It also went abroad in France and Flanders. The Duchess Margaret of Burgundy, sister of Edward the Fourth, had lately made a very bad blunder by believing the claim of a lad named Lambert Simnel, a flagrant impostor, to be the little Duke of York. However, she was still hoping to find her lost nephews, and so, by her influence, succeeded in inducing King Charles the Eighth of France to invite the new pretender to court. When the young Perkin arrived in France, his claims were received without doubt; Charles assigned him a magnificent suite of apartments, settled a princely pension upon him, and gave him a special guard, and other marks of royal honor. Some prominent nobles of the Yorkist party came over from England to see the young Plantagenet. Sir George Nevil, Sir John Taylor, and above a hundred of the lesser gentry attached themselves warmly to his cause, and he began to have a court of his own about him. He bore himself, all agreed, with great dignity, and had a personal fascination which strongly recalled that of Edward the Fourth, whom he also, by common report, resembled most strikingly.

France and England were at this time at war. Henry the Seventh was the craftiest and wisest king of his time, and he thought the situation was too dangerous to continue. So he made peace at once with France, but asked, as one of the conditions, that Perkin Warbeck should be given into his hands. To the honor of Charles the Eighth, he refused to do this, but warned the youth to leave his court, as he could no longer protect him. Perkin accordingly sent word to the Duchess of Burgundy, asking her to receive him in Flanders.

Just here comes in a contradiction—the first one of the many which we find in the story. Some historians say that Margaret, having been deceived by Lambert Simnel, would not receive this new pretender until she had thoroughly sifted his claims, and that he convinced her, against her will, of his identity. Others say that she was so anxious to support his claim—any claim against Henry the Seventh, in fact, whom she hated—that she sent for him, and instructed him in his part, teaching him many details which he did not know. When we learn, however (even from those who do not believe that Perkin was the Duke of York), that Margaret had not been in England for forty-five years, and had really seen nothing of her brother’s family, it is hard to see what she could have taught any one about the details of the youth of the little duke. Besides, Perkin, before meeting her, had already convinced Scotland, Ireland, France, and many of the most close and familiar adherents of the House of York, that he was the true prince. He and his little court, at any rate, now removed to the Low Countries, where the Duchess of Burgundy, the Archduke Philip, and the Emperor Maximilian all backed his claim, and acknowledged him as royal. The Duchess gave him the title of “The White Rose of England,” and his “gracious and princely behavior” won all hearts.

Henry the Seventh became a good deal disturbed over the matter. He demanded the surrender of the pretender into his hands, but the Archduke Philip refused. Then Henry banished all Flemings from England, and laid a strict embargo upon Flanders goods. He executed several English nobles for plots in favor of Perkin, and thus “did extremely quail the design of Perkin and his complices.” But the Duchess of Burgundy, at the same time, was writing to Ferdinand and Isabella of Spain, and to the pope himself, and getting encouragement all round. An invasion was planned, backed by Philip and Maximilian, and on July the third, 1495, the Plantagenet pretender and his little army landed on the coast of Kent.

There is no doubt that he expected all England to rise in his behalf. But the Wars of the Roses had done their work. No such bloody, useless, and exhausting wars had ever been known in England. When they ended, the great barons were all destroyed, and, indeed, the whole nobility reduced to a mere handful. There were left only the monarchy and the people; and the people were so exhausted by war that they wanted only peace, and would not have risen for anybody, no matter what his claim or his charm. Besides this, Henry had caused to be published everywhere a statement concerning the two Princes in the Tower, purporting to be the confession of Tyrrel and Dighton, the two murderers hired by Richard the Third to kill his little nephews. The real examinations of Tyrrel and Dighton, however, were not given out, even to the king’s council, “the matter being left somewhat perplexed,” and Tyrrel was disposed of by being beheaded for treason. Dighton, “who, it seemeth, spake best for the king, was forthwith set at liberty,” and told to spread his statements everywhere.

This revised version was, that Brackenbury, keeper of the Tower, had refused to murder the princes; that one night he had been removed, and Tyrrel put in power in his stead; that the children, by Tyrrel’s command, had been smothered in bed, and that their dead bodies had been seen by Tyrrel and Dighton afterward, and had been buried under the stairs. When King Richard, however, was told where his nephews had been buried, he said, “It was too base a place for them that had been king’s children.” So the little bodies, by the king’s warrant, were taken up by the “priest of the Tower,” and buried again by this priest in some unknown place. The priest and King Richard both being dead, this place could not be found; but there was no doubt that the little princes were both dead. This was Dighton’s story; and as the young Queen Elizabeth and the queen-mother, Elizabeth Woodville, showed no belief in Perkin Warbeck’s claim, the people of England refused to believe it, either, and the men of Kent, so far from rising and joining him when he landed, drove his followers back to the ships, after capturing eighty of them. The pretender weighed anchor at once, and sailed for Ireland, where he besieged Waterford and failed again. Then he took his little fleet and army to Scotland, and there he found welcome, friends, and a wife.

James of Scotland evidently believed thoroughly in the last heir of the Plantagenets. He made tournaments for him, helped him invade England, and gave him the beautiful Catherine Gordon, his own kinswoman, to wife. Henry of England employed spies in Scotland, and tried to seize Perkin, but did not succeed. The young pretender seems to have been of a merciful, as well as a gracious, disposition. When James raided English villages and plundered the peasants, Perkin “entreated him not to thus afflict his people.” If he were not the Duke of York, he certainly showed every characteristic of a kingly nature, and James of Scotland admired him greatly. He remained in Scotland until 1497, but now his romantic career was drawing to a close.

From Scotland, after an ineffectual invasion of the northern counties, Perkin went back to Ireland, and thence to Cornwall, where he gave battle to Henry at Taunton, with some seven thousand men at his back. The battle went against him, and he fled for sanctuary to Beaulieu, where he was besieged, and at last, on a solemn promise of pardon from the king, surrendered. He was at this time but twenty-five years old, but his days of liberty and life were well-nigh over. His “confession” was proclaimed everywhere, by order of the king, but this printed paper (setting forth that he was not the Duke of York, but the son of John Osbeck, of Tournay) was so confused and unsatisfactory that “men were in more doubt than before.” Before long, Perkin, though kept under guard, found means to escape, and it was believed that Henry was only too glad to have this excuse for more severity when he was recaptured. This time he went to the Tower, where Richard of Warwick, son of Clarence Plantagenet, was also confined. The two became great friends; and both of them won the favor and kindness of the keepers to such a degree that a plot was formed for their escape. It is charged by many historians that Henry the Seventh actually allowed and encouraged this plot, so that he might, by its discovery, get rid of the two last scions of the family of York, and clear the way for his own son Arthur’s marriage with Catherine of Spain, whose father would not permit her to marry the heir of Henry until the Tudor succession was thus absolutely established. We can believe anything of Henry the Seventh in the line of policy and treachery; and certain it is that he seized his chance, when the plot was revealed, to send both Warwick and the pretender to the block. In 1499 both were beheaded by order of the king, after Perkin’s confession had been repeated, and thus ended the short career of Perkin Warbeck.

But his mystery survived. King James of Scotland, to the end of his life, upheld that he was no pretender, but the true Duke of York. Catherine, his wife, had the same absolute belief in him, and the Duchess of Burgundy and the king of France never changed their opinion that he was the real heir of the English crown. Historians have taken sides for and against ever since. Bailey, in his interesting history of the Tower, upholds Perkin Warbeck’s claim, and believes his confession to have been a fraud, or wrung from him by threats of torture. Walpole, in his “Historic Doubts,” sides with the young pretender. Yet the finding of the bones of two children under some stairs in the Tower, in Charles the Second’s reign, is a strong fact on the other side—although Tyrrel and Dighton’s testimony that the bodies had been removed from beneath the stairs seems to conflict, again, with this discovery. If Perkin Warbeck were not the Duke of York, who was he? Nobody (as in the case of Lambert Simnel) ever came forward to identify him, either before or after his death, which, if he were an impostor, would have been very likely to happen. This golden-haired, gracious, kingly mannered unknown moves across the page of English history a living mystery.

Would not the “White Rose of England” have made a better king than Henry the Eighth? It is an idle question, and yet it inevitably suggests itself as we read the story of the Princes in the Tower, and wonder whether little Richard really did escape the assassin only to die under the executioner’s ax at Tyburn.—The Well Spring.