I HAD not thought to write again so soon concerning the friendships of young men and young women; or, as most of my correspondents name them, “the boys and girls.” But circumstances seem to make it wise to do so; no topic which we have considered in this department has called out so general and wide-spread comment. Mothers and teachers, in some instances fathers and pastors, to say nothing of the young people themselves, have written to me with regard to the little talk I gave you some weeks ago about “Some Mistaken Ideas.”
I have decided to share the letters with you. Here is one from a mother of several daughters. She is convinced, she says, that I live in a choicer environment than many have, or I should not write of the exchange of familiarities between girls and boys, such as holding each other’s hands, etc., as if they were comparatively rare experiences. She assures me that her young daughter, not yet seventeen, is spoken of by some of her schoolmates as a “prude” because she will not submit to such customs. The mother, who has recently moved to the neighborhood, affirms that, so far as she can judge, there is much more laxity in these matters than was to be found in the back-country district where she spent her girlhood. She admits that many of the old-fashioned kissing games have become obsolete, but considers the modern dances which have taken their place, together with the modern custom of singling out one favorite for special attentions, instead of bestowing them generally, distinct steps backward.
She thanks me for my written words, but thinks that I dealt much too mildly with the subject, and believes that the time has come for very plain speaking.
The next letter is also from a mother, a slightly indignant one. She wonders what my peculiar environment can be; she can not think it possible that there is in these days any self-respecting young woman who allows other boys than her own brothers any liberties whatever. She is very familiar with young women; is a teacher, indeed, of many; has chaperoned many more; and is “perfectly certain” that in the circle in which she moves—“which is one that any young woman of ordinary refinement can join”—there is not a girl who would not be shocked to the point of indignation if one of her young men acquaintances should attempt to retain her hand, or indulge in anything of the nature of a caress. And as for “kissing,” that is really “too offensive to be talked about”!
Now I will give you a bit from a dear girl’s letter, a motherless girl. She wants to know whether I really mean that a certain friend of hers, of whom she thinks a great deal, mustn’t rest his head on her shoulder when he is tired. She wouldn’t do anything improper for the world, and she has always lived in cities, where of course girls have to be very careful; but out there in the country it seems different. “Real nice girls do not think it wrong to let a boy kiss them if they like him, although they have no idea of being engaged.”
She has talked quite seriously with one “nice boy” about such things; and he thinks she is wrong, and that she must not expect boys to act like saints.
Poor little motherless, ill-treated girl, with her sweet nature and innocent heart! My heart goes out to her, and I should like to strike out from her list of acquaintances every rude, untrained, untamed, selfish “boy,” and have her associate only with—not saints, but—gentlemen. I like that old-fashioned word, in its place.
But let me tell you of another letter, also from a girl, and a country girl at that, one born and bred there. She is dignified even in her indignation. She “can not imagine” where I have found the girls about whom I wrote. Receiving calls in their sleeping-rooms! the idea! Why, every one knows that college girls could not do such things if they would; it is against the rules. It doesn’t have to be talked about, either; nor do any of those offensive things that I mention in my paper; they are simply not “good form,” and every respectable girl knows it. She thinks it is “too bad” that such things are written. People who do not know anything about the girls and boys of this day will get the idea that such ways are common.
Do not she and my little motherless city girl in the country need in some way to be made acquainted with each other? Bless her! I am not in the least offended with her letter, nor even “hurt.” I wish the world was the safe, refined, “cultured” place that she thinks it is.
But it was left to a “boy correspondent” to give me the fiercest rating. He would like to know what authority I have for calling little exchanges of friendliness between girls and boys “coarse.” There are plenty of refined girls of his acquaintance who allow such things; he knows them “by the thousand” (!), and no “breath of suspicion has ever blown their way.” He thinks there are quite enough “old maids” in the world now, but there will be “plenty more” if my “kind of girl ever gets to be plenty.” He wants to know how he is expected to visit his girl friends, if they have no place but their rooms to see folks in. Shall he stand on the street corners with them? He closes his outburst of wrath with a fierce hint that I am a sour old woman, and ought to pray to be taken out of the way, since the “milk of human kindness” has evidently dried up within me.
I owe him a debt of gratitude; I haven’t had so much amusement in a good while as his letter afforded. Albeit there was an undertone of sadness about it, in the realization that here is at least one evidently honest, good-intentioned, ignorant boy, who is too wise in his own conceit to be helped.
I could give you more quotations on both sides of this question, but these will suffice to show you that there are two sides, and that there are young people, and older ones, who have yet much to learn.—Pansy, in Christian Endeavor World.