We all agree that October is the month of ripeness, of fruits; but as to what a fruit really is, we are not equally positive.
Once when I was talking to some young folks in the schoolroom about autumn outdoor interests, I asked this question: “Who will tell me what fruit is?” A few hands were raised. One boy seemed especially eager to reply, so I asked him to give his definition. Promptly came the reply, “Things that grow on trees and bushes, and are good to eat.” I confess I joined with teacher and pupils, and even the boy, too, in the laugh that followed, not so much at the wording of the definition as at the enthusiastic manner in which it was given.
The more I have recalled that boy and his definition, the more I have appreciated both. From his point of view and just what he had in mind, his definition was concise, complete, and most certainly very expressive.
But perhaps some of you young people, of a critical turn of mind, will maintain that the boy’s definition was neither complete nor correct: that there are fruits that do not grow on trees or bushes, and that all fruits are not good to eat.
Well, if you will insist on taking a view of fruits wider than that which the boy had in mind, you probably will make it difficult for us to insist that the definition was just right. But we will get even with you. If you keep thinking and thinking of fruits that the boy did not have in mind, you will make it the more difficult for yourself to tell just what a fruit is. The more you advance from that boy’s point of view, the more you know about plants and their products, the greater will be the difficulty.
Professor Coulter, a very learned botanist, says: “The term ‘fruit’ is a very indefinite one, so far as the structures it includes are concerned.” He mentions as fruits such plant products as seeds of clematis, dandelion, wild carrot, burdock, nutmeg, maple seeds, etc. Not all of these are “good to eat!”
Professor Bergen tells us: “It is not easy to make a short and simple definition of what botanists mean by the term fruit. It has very little to do with the popular use of the word. Botanically speaking, the bur, beggar’s-ticks, the three-cornered grain of buckwheat, or such true grains as wheat and oats, are as much fruits as is an apple or a peach.”
Then as to the edible parts. Do we eat the seeds or the parts around the seeds? Perhaps our boy, thinking only of the apple or pear, would at once claim the thing around the seeds. You, thinking a little wider, of the nuts, would say the seeds, and not the thing (bur or husks) around them.
Then, perhaps, some thoughtful girl might say, “There is one fruit that I like of which I eat neither the seeds nor the thing around it, but the thing that holds up the seeds.” You see, she is thinking of the strawberry, of which the edible part is what the botanist would call “an enlarged pulpy receptacle,” on the surface of which are the tiny seeds—the real fruit.
Then some one, trying to surpass all the rest, tries, conundrum-like, to make us guess a fruit of which “we eat not the seed, nor the thing around it, nor what holds it up.” The wild grape seems to fit that definition, for the juice is the only part that tempts us.
In this broad view of the word fruit—so extensive, as we have seen, that the botanist has difficulty in defining it—what a variety there is in uses, sizes, forms, and color! This variety, with the variegated colors of the foliage, in its ripeness and in its tintings by Jack Frost is, I suppose, what suggested to the Rev. Henry Ward Beecher the name “the picture month” for October.
Perhaps that boy, in his impulsiveness, defined better than he was aware of. Is not the fruitage of the year, to the naturalist, the things on the trees and other plant life that are good to “eat,” with our mental as well as with our physical appetite? Certainly all is highly and deliciously seasoned with the October sunshine. — St. Nicholas.