AdventAI

Messages and Vetoes

By Editor

From The Youth’s Instructor, Vol. LIII, No. 17, April 25, 1905

THE message of the president at the opening of a session of Congress is always an important document. It is awaited with interest not merely by Congress itself, but by the whole country. Frequently it causes earnest discussion in other countries.

The Constitution requires the president from time to time to “give to Congress information of the state of the Union, and recommend to its consideration such measures as he shall judge necessary and expedient.”

Washington and John Adams obeyed this mandate of the Constitution by delivering oral addresses. The democratic Jefferson set the precedent of written communications, and all of his successors have followed this precedent.

It has thus come about that an American president never enters either house of Congress for the purpose of influencing its action, nor has he any official representative in the Capitol, although certain senators and congressmen may be identified with his policies. His only recognized means of initiating legislation is by a message; even in that he does not submit specific laws. Lincoln once sent the draft of a bill with a brief message asking for its passage, but a debate at once arose as to the president’s right to submit bills, and the example has not been followed.

But the president finds it easy enough to let Congress know what he desires. The cabinet officers are frequently public men of long experience and large personal followings, and they are expected to support the recommendations of their chief.

The importance of a message may lie in the information it conveys, no less than in its recommendations. This is particularly true of messages in regard to foreign affairs. The famous message concerning the Venezuelan boundary commanded the attention of the world for both reasons. An obscure situation was explained, and a policy was announced in which two continents were intensely interested.

The provisions of the Constitution regarding the president’s veto are very general. When a bill is presented to the president, “if he approve, he shall sign it, but if not, he shall return it, with his objections.” Taken literally, this clause justifies the president in exercising a perfectly free judgment upon every act submitted to him.

But taken in connection with the first sentence of the Constitution, “All legislative powers herein granted shall be vested in a Congress of the United States, which shall consist of a Senate and House of Representatives;” there is reason for a more limited conception of the veto power.

While Congress is in session, if in ten days the president neither signs nor vetoes the bill which is passed, the bill becomes a law without his signature. The effect is precisely the same as if he had signed it.

Presidents have at times used this method to emphasize the fact that they were not satisfied with a measure which they were yet unwilling to veto.

Early presidents were sparing in the use of the veto power. They signed bills which they did not in the fullest sense of the word “approve,” because they held that they had not the right to employ the constitutional privilege for the purpose of reviewing the acts of Congress. When they returned bills, they did so because they regarded the measures as unconstitutional; what seemed merely inexpedient they signed.

The first president to transgress this rule when great measures were at stake was Mr. Tyler. His practise was roundly condemned by the Whigs, who regarded Mr. Tyler as a political traitor, and the Democrats, on the other hand, stood up as advocates of the “constitutional veto.”

The more free interpretation of the president’s right and duty grew gradually but steadily in favor, at least with the presidents themselves, and is now universally accepted. Each president has to decide questions for himself under the responsibility of his oath of office.

The veto power has, on the whole, been a useful and conservative instrument; and so long as the people are vigilant, it can never be an engine of oppression. It may delay, but can not prevent, what the people wish to have accomplished.—Editor of Youth’s Companion.