2 Timothy 2:17
And their word will eat as doth a canker: of whom is Hymenaeus and Philetus;
Translations
And their word will eat as does a canker: of whom is Hymenaeus and Philetus;
And their word will eat as doth a canker: of whom is Hymenaeus and Philetus;
KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
And their word will eat as doth a canker: of whom is Hymeneus and Philetus;
and their word will eat as doth a gangrene: of whom is Hymenaeus and Philetus;
and their word will eat as doth a gangrene: of whom is Hymenæus and Philetus;
and their word as a gangrene will have pasture, of whom is Hymenaeus and Philetus,
and their word will spread as a gangrene; of whom is Hymenaeus and Philetus;
And, their discourse, as a gangrene, will eat its way;—of whom are Hymenaeus and Philetus,
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
and the talk of such men will spread like gangrene. Among them are Hymenaeus and Philetus,
and those words will consume like gangrene, of whom is Hymenaeus and Philetus:
And their words will be like poisoned wounds in the flesh: such are Hymenaeus and Philetus;
And their worde shall fret as a canker: of which sort is Hymeneus and Philetus,
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And their speech spreadeth like a canker: of whom are Hymeneus and Philetus:
Cross-references
- 1 Timothy 1:19-20
Holding faith, and a good conscience; which some having put away concerning faith have made shipwreck:
Hymenaeus is named among those whose shipwrecked faith led to being handed over to Satan.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
13 sources
Their word eating like a canker means that words promoting error spread like a consuming disease that eats through what it reaches, corrupts and eats away faith, and leads people away from truth.Ms 16, 1897, par. 18–20Lt 58, 1900, par. 9–15Lt 193, 1905, par. 4–7 Hymenaeus and Philetus are named as examples of such teachers, whose error concerning the truth was claiming that the resurrection had already occurred, and their teaching overturned and destroyed the faith of some.Ms 16, 1897, par. 18–20Lt 58, 1900, par. 9–158MR 286.1–2 Such teaching mixes some truth with profane and vain babblings and the doctrines of error, in contrast to the precious truth God gives by the Holy Spirit.Ms 16, 1897, par. 18–20Ms 12, 1893, par. 22–238MR 286.1–2 It springs from undue curiosity and idle speculation that shuns plainly revealed truth for supposition and human theories, sown as seed in the heart that springs to life in temptation and leads minds away from God into ungodliness.Ms 16, 1897, par. 18–208MR 286.1–2Lt 58, 1900, par. 7–8RH Feb 5, 1901 Believers are therefore to refuse such deceptive words, stand firm for the right and constantly on guard, keep a pure line of study, and work together to remove errors that have eaten into the church.Lt 193, 1905, par. 4–78MR 286.1–2Lt 5, 1853, par. 4Lt 197, 1904, par. 10
Image and Historical Example
Their word eating like a canker means false teaching spreads destructively like a consuming disease and a destroying sore that eats through whatever it reaches.Ms 16, 1897, par. 18–20Lt 58, 1900, par. 9–15Lt 193, 1905, par. 4–78MR 286.1–2RH Feb 5, 1901 Words that promote error corrupt those who receive them, eat away faith, and lead minds away from God and away from truth into ungodliness.Ms 16, 1897, par. 18–20Lt 58, 1900, par. 9–158MR 286.1–2Lt 58, 1900, par. 7–8RH Feb 5, 1901 Such words act as seed sown in the human heart that springs to life in time of temptation.8MR 286.1–2
Hymenaeus and Philetus are named as examples of such teachers.Ms 16, 1897, par. 18–20Lt 58, 1900, par. 9–15Lt 193, 1905, par. 4–78MR 286.1–2RH Feb 5, 1901 Their error concerning the truth was saying that the resurrection is past already, claiming that the resurrection had already occurred and had already taken place.Ms 16, 1897, par. 18–20Lt 58, 1900, par. 9–158MR 286.1–2RH Feb 5, 1901 They thus erred by shunning plainly revealed truth for supposition and imagination and for vain, unessential human theories with nothing sure or substantial in them.Lt 58, 1900, par. 7–8RH Feb 5, 1901
Their teaching overthrew and overturned the faith of some, destroying it.Ms 16, 1897, par. 18–20Lt 58, 1900, par. 9–158MR 286.1–2RH Feb 5, 1901
How False Teaching Spreads
The canker-like word is teaching that mixes some truth with profane and vain babblings, empty ungodly talk, fables taken for counsel, and the wine of Babylon, the doctrines of error.Ms 16, 1897, par. 18–20Ms 12, 1893, par. 22–238MR 286.1–2 Against this is set God's cup full of precious truth given by the Holy Spirit.Ms 12, 1893, par. 22–23 Such error grows out of undue curiosity and idle speculation that shuns plainly revealed truth for supposition and imagination.Lt 58, 1900, par. 7–8RH Feb 5, 1901 That course leads into more ungodliness and keeps the mind dwelling on vain unessential human theories with nothing sure or substantial in them.Lt 58, 1900, par. 7–8RH Feb 5, 1901
These novel, human-made theories are put forward as something remarkable and wonderful.Lt 58, 1900, par. 7–8RH Feb 5, 1901 Error is clothed in a new garment thought to cover something wonderful, which when uncovered proves to be empty nothingness.RH Feb 5, 1901 Even apparently conscientious people then grasp the shadow instead of the substance and take error for truth.RH Feb 5, 1901 Words of this kind are seed sown in the human heart that spring to life in time of temptation.Ms 16, 1897, par. 18–208MR 286.1–2 Once quickened they lead minds away from God and away from truth into ungodliness.Ms 16, 1897, par. 18–208MR 286.1–2
The same pattern of foolish heresies presented as truth in the days of the apostles will be repeated and will recur in different times.Lt 58, 1900, par. 9–15RH Feb 5, 1901 The words of those who have turned from the truth to fables spread destructively because they will not break from the fellowship of unholy angels.Lt 197, 1904, par. 10 Remaining in that fellowship, they say whatever the enemy puts into their minds.Lt 197, 1904, par. 10
Guarding Against Its Spread
False words spread like a destroying sore that eats away faith, so books and teaching that contain some truth mixed with profane and vain babblings must not be placed in the hands of students.8MR 286.1–2 Teachers as well as scholars must keep a pure line of study like the schools of the prophets, because such words are seed sown in the human heart that will spring to life in time of temptation and lead minds away from God and away from truth into ungodliness, as seen in Hymenaeus and Philetus who erred by saying the resurrection is past already and destroyed the faith of some.8MR 286.1–2 The instruction of the chapter containing this warning is to be taken seriously and put into practice.Lt 193, 1905, par. 4–7 Such words are not to be believed, and believers must not be deceived by them but must stand firm for the right, stay constantly on guard, and be strong in the Lord and in the power of His might.Lt 193, 1905, par. 4–7Lt 197, 1904, par. 10
When errors and mistaken actions have eaten into the church, its members must work together to remove them and restore a healthy influence.Lt 5, 1853, par. 4 The same eating sore also describes unbelief in professed believers who do not let truth sanctify their lives.5T 96.2TBC1882 81.3 That unbelief is evident in conduct and character, deceives self, encourages continuance in sin, and corrupts like a spreading disease.5T 96.2TBC1882 81.3 In contrast to fables men take for counsel and the wine of Babylon, the doctrines of error, which eat like a canker, God presents a cup full of precious truth by the Holy Spirit, and souls are worth saving.Ms 12, 1893, par. 22–23
Minds and thoughts must therefore be brought into captivity to the will of Christ with His superscription upon them, beholding Him to be changed from glory to glory and from character to character under the controlling influence of God.Ms 12, 1893, par. 22–23 They must fall upon the Rock and be broken in conversion in order to feel the power of Christ and stand to the front.Ms 12, 1893, par. 22–23 The same eating image describes living trouble in the home, which can consume the soul and weaken a person's life forces.CH 328.2 A bitter, oppressive spirit also eats the heart like a canker, seen in marriage when a tyrannical husband's harshness, fault-finding, censure, and revengeful disposition consume his wife from within, crushing out her ambition and cheerfulness, destroying her pleasure of life, making her prematurely old, and killing her by inches.Lt 19, 1862, par. 3–5
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
52 sources
Their word eats like a canker because false teaching spreads through the church like a consuming disease, gradually corroding faith until it overthrows the faith of some.RH Oct 19, 1916RH Oct 31, 1907RH Nov 19, 1901ST Jan 1, 1885RH Nov 19, 1901 Hymenaeus and Philetus are named as examples of this, in that they erred concerning the truth by saying that the resurrection is past already.RH Oct 19, 1916RH Oct 31, 1907ST Jan 1, 1885RH Oct 19, 1916 Their doctrine denied the future, literal resurrection, which will occur when Christ comes at the last day in the raising of the whole person, physical as well as spiritual, and not merely a past spiritual experience.ST May 27, 1908ST Mar 25, 1897RH Oct 27, 1859 Such profane and empty teaching is to be shunned and every trace of its corruption promptly removed, yet even when men fall away God's foundation stands sure, for the Lord knows His faithful servants.RH Mar 6, 1866RH Nov 19, 1901ST May 19, 1881RH Sep 2, 1873RH Nov 19, 1901 The same destroying spread belongs to careless, irreverent and trifling words about sacred things, to discord, gossip and slander, and to self-indulgence and worldly pleasure, which eat away vital godliness like moral poison while gracious speech builds up.RH Jan 1, 1861RH Nov 19, 1901ST Feb 25, 1889RH Apr 3, 1866RH Apr 30, 1914
Meaning of Canker Image
Their word eating as a canker means that false teaching spreads destructively through the church, gradually corroding faith and overthrowing the faith of some.RH Oct 19, 1916ST Jan 1, 1885ST Jan 6, 1887RH Dec 9, 1902ST Jun 5, 1901 Hymenaeus and Philetus are the named examples, who erred concerning the truth by saying that the resurrection had already taken place.RH Oct 19, 1916ST Jan 1, 1885ST Jan 6, 1887RH Dec 9, 1902ST Jun 5, 1901 Their error shows how such teaching damages faith like a canker and overturns it.RH Oct 19, 1916RH Oct 31, 1907ST Jan 1, 1885ST Jan 6, 1887RH Dec 9, 1902
Profane and vain babblings and empty talk are destructive, spreading into greater ungodliness and consuming harmfully like a disease.RH Oct 31, 1907RH Mar 6, 1866RH Jan 1, 1861ST Oct 10, 1878 Profane and empty teaching of this kind spreads destructively, and profane and vain words exert influence for good or evil next to acts.RH Oct 31, 1907RH Mar 6, 1866RH Jan 1, 1861ST Oct 10, 1878 Such teaching is to be shunned.RH Oct 31, 1907RH Mar 6, 1866
The image is gangrene, a spreading disease that destroys tissue.RH Nov 19, 1901RH Nov 19, 1901 Applied to the soul, spiritual corruption fastens upon it and spreads, so every trace should be removed with earnest urgency by the means the Lord provides to cure it.RH Nov 19, 1901RH Nov 19, 1901 Evil words spread like a canker and through association can injure and lead astray even the most spiritually minded.ST Mar 31, 1914
Indulging undue curiosity and idle speculation spreads destructively like a consuming disease, because shunning revealed truth for supposition and imagination leads into more ungodliness.RH Feb 5, 1901 Vain unessential human theories keep the mind dwelling on nothingness with nothing sure or substantial in them.RH Feb 5, 1901 The same pattern of foolish heresies presented as truth in the days of the apostles will be repeated, when even apparently conscientious people grasp the shadow instead of the substance and take error for truth because error is clothed in a new garment thought to cover something wonderful which when uncovered proves to be nothingness.RH Feb 5, 1901
Resurrection Error Exposed
Hymenaeus and Philetus are named as examples who erred concerning the truth by saying that the resurrection had already taken place, and their teaching overthrew the faith of some.RH Oct 19, 1916RH Oct 31, 1907ST Jan 1, 1885ST Jan 6, 1887RH Dec 9, 1902 Their profane and empty talk spread destructively like a canker into greater ungodliness, harming and overturning faith.RH Oct 19, 1916RH Oct 31, 1907ST Jan 1, 1885ST Jan 6, 1887RH Dec 9, 1902 Despite having benefited from Paul's ministry, they taught that the resurrection was already past and thereby overthrew the faith of many Christians, showing that proximity to the apostles did not prevent church members from serious error.ST Jan 6, 1887RH Dec 9, 1902ST Mar 10, 1887
Their doctrine denied the future, literal resurrection of the dead.ST Mar 25, 1897RH Jan 23, 1866ST Jan 18, 1883 The resurrection is future, occurring when Christ comes at the last day, and is the raising of the whole person, physical as well as spiritual, not only a past spiritual experience.ST May 27, 1908ST Jan 18, 1883 Paul rejected the claim that resurrection was only a spiritual experience in the past, and the claim opposed the literal raising of the dead to life through Christ.ST Jan 18, 1883 Their example warns that people who once held the truth can turn from it and harm others.RH Jan 23, 1866
The error is linked to the belief that people go to heaven or hell at death as released spirits.RH Oct 27, 1859 If the dead are already alive in that way there is no need for a future resurrection, a heathen fable that undermines the resurrection Paul taught.RH Oct 27, 1859 Paul condemned the claim that the resurrection had already occurred because it cannot be said to be past for people who have died, whether the dead of earlier generations or those recently deceased.ST Feb 15, 1883 If it occurred at death as the spirit's release from the body, that claim would necessarily apply to the dead of earlier generations and those recently deceased.ST Feb 15, 1883
Turning the first resurrection into an allegory is warned against, since doing so could lead to treating the resurrection of the rest of the dead as figurative too. Teaching that the resurrection has already occurred is false and destructive, its words spreading like a canker, leading people away from the truth and overthrowing some believers' faith.ST Jun 25, 1896 The warning applies to teachings that depreciate the resurrection and weaken the Christian hope.ST Jun 25, 1896
History Behind the Error
Hymenaeus and Philetus fixed on one point and went astray, building their case on the raising of many saints when Christ arose, whereas wider knowledge of Scripture would have shown the truth about the resurrection of the dead. Their claim that the resurrection was already past looked plausible and was calculated to deceive, because there had been a partial resurrection in which many bodies of sleeping saints arose at Christ's death, came out of the graves after His resurrection, went into Jerusalem and appeared to many, and later ascended with Him.RH Oct 19, 1916 Living people who had seen and talked with those saints confirmed the false teaching by saying the resurrection had already taken place because they had seen it in Jerusalem.RH Oct 19, 1916 It was a counterfeit with a semblance of truth that failed to distinguish that partial resurrection from the general resurrection at the last day, accepting the words of men who had seen something instead of the plain teaching of the Word of God, and it overthrew faith and wrecked hope.RH Oct 19, 1916
They were members of the Ephesian church who once stood in God's favor and held the truth, having benefited from Paul's ministry as former laborers for Christ.ST Mar 10, 1887ST Feb 2, 1882RH Jan 23, 1866ST Apr 25, 1906 Their earlier standing could make them influential opponents when they turned against the truth, yet their apostasy did not prove false the doctrines they had once proclaimed.RH Jan 23, 1866ST Apr 25, 1906 Proximity to the apostles did not keep church members from teaching grave error, proving that nearness to the apostolic age gives no extra light on obscure or disputed passages.ST Mar 10, 1887ST Jan 13, 1887 The apostles had no successors whose historical witness is a safe guide for doctrine or rites.ST Jan 13, 1887
Their example shows false teaching was already troubling the early church, with words spreading destructively through turning away from the truth.RH Apr 29, 1909 The mystery of iniquity and of lawlessness was already at work in Paul's day, entering through unconverted men and through heathen converts in a rapidly growing membership that perverted the church's purity.ST Dec 26, 1906ST Mar 12, 1896 Perversion of prophecy and teaching by people within the church could gain influence and lead believers into doubt.ST Nov 28, 1906
They belong with Korah, Dathan, and Abiram and with Judas as men who proved false to Christ, showing that even prominent men being mere flesh can let go of God and be blown about by every wind of doctrine.ST Nov 4, 1897 They are instances of self-deception who fell away from the truth and helped draw others off its course.RH Apr 15, 1909ST Jun 5, 1879 Dishonest or fanatical opposers of God's work may appear to prosper for a time, but their end is darkness and despair.RH Apr 15, 1909
Answering False Teaching
Profane and empty teaching that spreads destructively must be shunned, for it declares that the resurrection has already taken place and overturns the faith of some.RH Mar 6, 1866 Spiritual corruption can fasten upon the soul and spread like gangrene, a disease that destroys tissue, so every trace of it should be removed with earnest urgency.RH Nov 19, 1901 Harmful words act as such a spreading disease of the soul, whose first symptom is excessive sensitivity that leads a person to take offense at a remark or at how church or Sabbath-school matters are handled, even when the offense is imagined.RH Nov 19, 1901 Prompt use of the means the Lord provides is the cure for it.RH Nov 19, 1901RH Nov 19, 1901
Delivering Hymenaeus to Satan because of false doctrine means putting that person out of the church.CO 12.4–6 It is casting him out and withdrawing the church's sanction, so he would recognize that he stood outside its authority and learn not to blaspheme.ST Apr 21, 1898 Alexander's opposition to apostolic doctrine, destructive like a spreading canker, was met the same way.ST Apr 21, 1898 The discipline or chastisement so applied to Hymenaeus was not effective in his case.ST Dec 24, 1896
Some labor with canker-like words to overthrow the faith, yet even when forsaken and standing alone in defense of the truth confidence in the truth can be kept because God's foundation stands sure.ST May 19, 1881RH Sep 2, 1873 The Lord knows His faithful servants and will approve their course.ST May 19, 1881RH Sep 2, 1873 Men who proved false to Christ belong with Korah, Dathan, and Abiram and with Judas and others who defect from the truth, showing that even prominent men being mere flesh can let go of God and be blown about by every wind of doctrine.ST Nov 4, 1897 Their falling away gives no cause for alarm, for God's Word still stands sure and the Rock abides, while those who forsake the Word to follow them are the only losers, breaking themselves against what was meant to heal them.ST Nov 4, 1897
The arising of apostates and hypocrites among God's people was foretold in prophecy, so their presence is evidence of truth rather than a reason to stay out of all churches.ST Jul 4, 1911 God still calls His remnant people not because they are perfect but to a perfect standard, and it is always better to have associates in the pilgrim way than to remain alone because the church contains sin.ST Jul 4, 1911 Hymenaeus and Philetus were former laborers for Christ who later turned against the truth and whose teaching opposed the gospel, and their earlier standing could make them influential opponents.ST Apr 25, 1906 Their apostasy did not prove that the doctrines they once proclaimed were false.ST Apr 25, 1906
Doctrine and Prophecy Connections
False doctrines arose in the church early and were to grow more pronounced as the age approached its close.RH Feb 5, 1901RH Oct 8, 1908 The teaching of those who indulge undue curiosity and idle speculation spreads destructively like a consuming disease, because shunning revealed truth for supposition and imagination leads into greater ungodliness.RH Feb 5, 1901 Vain, unessential human theories keep the mind dwelling on nothingness, with nothing sure or substantial in them.RH Feb 5, 1901 Hymenaeus and Philetus are the named examples of such teachers, having erred concerning the truth by saying the resurrection is past already and overthrowing the faith of some.RH Feb 5, 1901
The same pattern of foolish heresies presented as truth in the days of the apostles will be repeated.RH Feb 5, 1901 Even apparently conscientious people will grasp the shadow instead of the substance, taking error for truth.RH Feb 5, 1901 Error is clothed in a new garment and thought to cover something wonderful, which when uncovered proves to be nothingness.RH Feb 5, 1901
The canker-like spread of corrupt teaching applies to Greek philosophy and later Gnostic mysticism and Neoplatonism, which gave Christian teachings a mystical meaning.RH May 21, 1914 This was especially so with teachings about the resurrection and the future state.RH May 21, 1914 Such doctrinal decay, eating away at doctrine through the church, helped prepare the way for a church that claimed to be God's kingdom and for human rule taking Christ's place.RH May 21, 1914
Romish error is such a destroying gangrene.ST Mar 11, 1889 It eats out the very vitals of Protestant nations.ST Mar 11, 1889 Those who are Protestants in truth must protest against it.ST Mar 11, 1889
Practical Warnings Today
Next to actions, words are the great means by which people exert influence for good or evil, and profane and vain words are destructive, spreading and consuming harmfully like a disease.RH Jan 1, 1861ST Feb 25, 1889RH Apr 3, 1866RH Mar 20, 1866ST Oct 17, 1900 Careless, irreverent words spread and destroy like such a disease, acting as moral poison destructive to the soul, and lightly spoken words can make an indelible impression and lead to results of a most serious character.RH Jan 1, 1861ST Feb 25, 1889RH Apr 3, 1866 This is especially true of light and trifling words about solemn and sacred things, which must instead be spoken of with reverence and thoughtfulness, while a word fitly spoken produces much good.ST Feb 25, 1889 Speech should instead be gracious and seasoned with grace so as to build others up, and a wisely chosen, loving word can encourage one who is despairing and help bear life's burdens, since words and everyday conduct can hinder or advance a soul.RH Apr 3, 1866RH Mar 20, 1866ST Oct 17, 1900
Corrupt words spread and destroy like a canker, and evil jokes and idle talk in the same way eat away at vital godliness.RH Aug 4, 1863 Sins can spread and destroy spiritual life like a canker, and in the last days worldliness, pride, indulgence of appetite and passion, fault-finding, murmuring, and gossip are especially prevalent and damage spirituality.ST Jun 30, 1881 Discord, hatred, gossip, and slander spread through the church like gangrene, eating away at the heart of true religion.RH Nov 19, 1901RH Mar 27, 1913 Those who cherish such conduct cannot receive the fulness of the Holy Spirit until they confess and put it away, and in many cases must also make things right with those they have wounded by their words.RH Mar 27, 1913 Its first symptom is excessive sensitivity that leads a person to take offense at a remark or at how church or Sabbath-school matters are handled, even when the offense is imagined, warning of spiritual harm and calling for prompt use of the means the Lord provides to cure it.RH Nov 19, 1901
Soul-destroying pleasures eat into the vital life of the Christian church like a canker, eating away at its spiritual life in the same consuming way.RH Apr 30, 1914RH Apr 16, 1914 Self-indulgence eats into its heart like a canker, betraying Christ, putting keeping good terms with the world ahead of honoring God, and denying Christ rather than denying self.ST Jun 23, 1881 The spreading canker or cancer pictures how destructive words and teaching can consume and corrupt, here applied to criminal infection eating into the center of personal and national life.ST May 22, 1884
Sources