Acts 1:21
Wherefore of these men which have companied with us all the time that the Lord Jesus went in and out among us,
Translations
Why of these men which have companied with us all the time that the Lord Jesus went in and out among us,
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Wherefore of these men which have companied with us all the time that the Lord Jesus went in and out among us,
Wherefore, of these men who accompanied us, all the time that the Lord Jesus went in and out among us,
Of the men therefore which have companied with us all the time that the Lord Jesus went in and went out among us,
Of the men therefore that have companied with us all the time that the Lord Jesus went in and went out among us,
'It behoveth, therefore, of the men who did go with us during all the time in which the Lord Jesus went in and went out among us,
It is necessary therefore, that of the men who have assembled with us all [ the] time in which the Lord Jesus came in and went out among us,
It is needful then that, of the men who companied with us during all the time in which the Lord Jesus came in and went out over us,
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Therefore it is necessary to choose one of the men who have accompanied us the whole time the Lord Jesus went in and out among us,
“ Of the men therefore who have accompanied us all the time that the Lord Jesus went in and out among us,
For this reason, of the men who have been with us all the time, while the Lord Jesus went in and out among us,
Wherefore of these men which haue companied with vs, all the time that the Lord Iesus was conuersant among vs,
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Wherefore of these men who have companied with us all the time that the Lord Jesus came in and went out among us,
Cross-references
- Luke 6:13
And when it was day, he called unto him his disciples: and of them he chose twelve, whom also he named apostles;
Jesus chooses apostles from among his disciples.
- Acts 1:26
And they gave forth their lots; and the lot fell upon Matthias; and he was numbered with the eleven apostles.
Matthias is chosen to replace Judas and numbered with the eleven apostles.
- Acts 1:3
To whom also he shewed himself alive after his passion by many infallible proofs, being seen of them forty days, and speaking of the things pertaining to the kingdom of God:
The risen Jesus appeared to his followers over forty days.
- Psalms 109:8
Let his days be few; and let another take his office.
It foretells another taking Judas’s office.
- Acts 1:17
For he was numbered with us, and had obtained part of this ministry.
Judas lost his part in the ministry, prompting the choice of a successor.
- Mark 3:13-14
And he goeth up into a mountain, and calleth unto him whom he would: and they came unto him.
Jesus chooses and appoints the twelve to be with him and preach.
- Hebrews 2:3
How shall we escape, if we neglect so great salvation; which at the first began to be spoken by the Lord, and was confirmed unto us by them that heard him;
The apostles confirmed the salvation first proclaimed by Jesus.
- Acts 1:9
And when he had spoken these things, while they beheld, he was taken up; and a cloud received him out of their sight.
The gathered followers saw Jesus ascend.
- Acts 10:37
That word, I say, ye know, which was published throughout all Judæa, and began from Galilee, after the baptism which John preached;
Jesus’ public work began after John’s baptism.
- John 15:27
And ye also shall bear witness, because ye have been with me from the beginning.
Both require eyewitnesses of Christ’s work.
- 1 Corinthians 15:8
And last of all he was seen of me also, as of one born out of due time.
Paul grounds his apostolic claim in having seen the risen Christ.
- Acts 2:32
This Jesus hath God raised up, whereof we all are witnesses.
The apostles were witnesses that God raised Jesus.
- 1 Corinthians 9:1
Am I not an apostle? am I not free? have I not seen Jesus Christ our Lord? are not ye my work in the Lord?
Paul links being an apostle with having seen Jesus.
- Psalms 69:25
Let their habitation be desolate; and let none dwell in their tents.
Its judgment on Judas explains the vacancy in the apostles’ ministry.
- Luke 24:51
And it came to pass, while he blessed them, he was parted from them, and carried up into heaven.
Jesus is carried up into heaven after blessing the disciples.
- Matthew 10:1-10
And when he had called unto him his twelve disciples, he gave them power against unclean spirits, to cast them out, and to heal all manner of sickness and all manner of disease.
Jesus appoints the Twelve and sends them to preach and serve.
- 1 John 1:3
That which we have seen and heard declare we unto you, that ye also may have fellowship with us: and truly our fellowship is with the Father, and with his Son Jesus Christ.
Both texts emphasize eyewitness testimony of Christ’s work.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
14 sources
After Judas fell from his ministry and apostleship, one place stood empty in the ranks of the apostles that had to be filled by another taking his place.9T 263.3–4Ms 37a, 1909, par. 6–8Ms 61a, 1895, par. 2–3 The man ordained had to be one who had stayed with the disciples through the whole public life and work of Jesus among them, from the baptism of John until He was taken up, so he could stand with them as a witness of His resurrection.9T 263.3–4Ms 37a, 1909, par. 6–8Ms 61a, 1895, par. 2–3SLP ix.1 The first apostolic brotherhood was made up of men who had so accompanied Jesus, while Paul, who had not seen Jesus in His earthly life, was numbered among the apostles by a distinct divine choice.SLP ix.1 The account gives instruction for choosing men to bear responsibility in the church, that the Lord has certain men for certain positions and His people must be guarded, move carefully, and make wise choice of those who will not betray sacred trusts.9T 263.3–4Ms 37a, 1909, par. 6–89T 264.1 The disciples set forward two men they knew to be upright and worthy, yet knowing human judgment could not reveal the heart they laid the case before God in earnest prayer for Him to choose, and Matthias was selected, teaching care and prayer in placing people in positions of trust rather than putting workers forward without weighing their fitness.Ms 37a, 1909, par. 6–83SP 264.2–37RED 3.3–4.1
Setting and Qualification
Judas by transgression fell from ministry and apostleship, leaving one place vacant in the ranks of the apostles that had to be filled with another to take his place.9T 263.3–4Ms 37a, 1909, par. 6–8Ms 61a, 1895, par. 2–3Lt 32, 1910, par. 8Lt 88a, 1895, par. 1–3 Peter required that the one ordained be a man who had companied with the disciples all the time the Lord Jesus went in and out among them.9T 263.3–4Ms 37a, 1909, par. 6–8Ms 61a, 1895, par. 2–3Lt 32, 1910, par. 8Lt 88a, 1895, par. 1–3 That meant one who had stayed with them through the whole time Jesus lived and worked among them, throughout His public ministry and active life and work among them.9T 263.3–4Ms 37a, 1909, par. 6–8Ms 61a, 1895, par. 2–3Lt 88a, 1895, par. 1–3Ms 113, 1909, par. 4–8
That companionship had to run from the baptism of John until He was taken up.9T 263.3–4Ms 37a, 1909, par. 6–8SLP ix.1 Its purpose was that the man could be ordained a witness with them of His resurrection.9T 263.3–4Ms 37a, 1909, par. 6–8 The original apostolic brotherhood was made up of men who had so accompanied Jesus from His baptism until His ascension.SLP ix.1 Paul, who had not seen Jesus during His earthly life, was numbered among the apostles through a distinct divine choice.SLP ix.1
The verse belongs to the account of Christ's commission to His disciples and the promise of the Holy Spirit, with the message of the angels to the waiting disciples.Lt 177, 1899, par. 5Ms 23, 1891, par. 15 It describes the men considered for the place left vacant among them as those who had accompanied the disciples throughout the time Jesus lived and worked among them.Ms 23, 1891, par. 15
Guidance for Choosing Leaders
The verse gives instruction about choosing men to bear responsibilities in the church when a vacancy must be filled in the ranks of leadership.9T 263.3–4Ms 37a, 1909, par. 6–8 Its chapter and the early-church history around it, including the events surrounding Pentecost, is a lesson book to be studied for instruction.Lt 170, 1907, par. 9Lt 32, 1910, par. 8 That history teaches lessons about setting things and the work in order and the need for special work, and the experiences of the apostles provide an example of experiences God's people in later times must also face.Lt 170, 1907, par. 910MR 17.2–3Ms 113, 1909, par. 4–8
The verse means the Lord has certain men to fill certain positions, and His people must be guarded, move carefully, and make wise choice of men who will not betray sacred trusts.Ms 37a, 1909, par. 6–89T 264.1 In filling the vacancy the disciples considered two men they knew to be upright and worthy, but recognized that their own human judgment could not reveal the heart.Ms 37a, 1909, par. 6–83SP 264.2–37RED 3.3–4.1 They presented the case before God and in earnest prayer asked Him to choose, and Matthias was selected.Ms 37a, 1909, par. 6–83SP 264.2–39T 264.1
The account teaches care and prayer in choosing people for positions of trust, rather than putting forward workers without properly considering their fitness.3SP 264.2–37RED 3.3–4.1 If believers in Christ's day needed to be guarded in their choice of men for positions of responsibility, those living in this time need to move with great discretion.9T 264.1 Joined to the word, Let not your heart be troubled, the account of Christ's commission to His disciples and the promise of the Holy Spirit with the message of the angels to the waiting disciples teaches the necessity of being educated to believe the Word of God and to show faith by works in practical godliness.Lt 177, 1899, par. 5
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
36 sources
The verse names the men to be considered for Judas's place as those who had companied with Jesus and the disciples all the time the Lord went in and out among them through His public ministry.RH Nov 26, 1872ST Mar 23, 1882RH Jan 9, 1855 That whole time runs from the beginning of His public work at John's baptism until He was taken up in the ascension.ST Jun 17, 1897ST Jan 2, 1893RH Dec 23, 1852 Only such a constant companion could be chosen to keep the number twelve complete and to become with the apostles a witness of the resurrection.ST Jun 17, 1897ST Jan 2, 1893ST Jun 17, 1897 Such continual presence made a man an eye and ear witness of Christ's life, teaching, miracles, death, resurrection and ascension who could teach the gospel accurately, and from men so qualified Matthias was chosen by prayer and lot and numbered with the eleven.RH Jan 19, 1869RH Jun 19, 1856ST Aug 9, 1905ST Jun 28, 1883ST Jun 17, 1897
Words and Historical Setting
The men under consideration were those who had companied with the disciples and with Jesus all the time the Lord went in and out among them throughout his public ministry.RH Nov 26, 1872ST Mar 23, 1882RH Jan 9, 1855RH Jan 19, 1869RH Jun 19, 1856 They had accompanied the apostles throughout that ministry among them and had witnessed his life and work, his resurrection and ascension.RH Nov 26, 1872ST Mar 23, 1882RH Jan 19, 1869ST Jun 2, 1909 The qualification for choosing a replacement apostle was drawn from this companionship, requiring one of those men who had been with them through Jesus' ministry among them.RH Jan 9, 1855RH Jun 19, 1856ST Jun 2, 1909
From the beginning means from the commencement of Jesus' public work, namely the period beginning with John's baptism and continuing until Jesus was taken up in the ascension.ST Jun 17, 1897ST Jan 2, 1893RH Dec 23, 1852ST Aug 13, 1874ST Mar 25, 1897 The man had to have been present through the whole three and a half years of Christ's ministry, because Christ chose the twelve at the beginning and kept them constantly with him to prepare them by his instruction for preaching the gospel after his ascension.RH Sep 29, 1874 This period is identified with the first half of the prophetic week of years, which is dated from Jesus' baptism to his crucifixion.RH Dec 23, 1852
The setting is the forty days after the resurrection, with Jesus spending forty days with his disciples and ascending on a Thursday.ST Aug 13, 1874RH Mar 31, 1874RH Dec 17, 1857 Those forty days expired on Thursday at his ascension, leaving ten days of earnest prayer before the day of Pentecost fifty days from the resurrection.ST Aug 13, 1874RH Mar 31, 1874 Christ's final interview with his disciples when he ascended from the Mount of Olives was on that Thursday, and his meetings with the disciples during the forty days, including on a Thursday, do not make a meeting day sacred.RH Dec 17, 1857RH May 12, 1874
After the resurrection Jesus was with his disciples only at intervals rather than continuously during the forty days before his ascension.RH Aug 31, 1869 The ascension recorded in Acts 1 from Olivet was his first public ascension, distinct from an earlier ascension to the Father for acceptance.ST Jun 7, 1905 Acts presents the work of the apostles as the practical application of Jesus' teachings and as a pattern shown to them by the Lord and the Holy Spirit.
Qualification and Witness Work
The one to take the place left by Judas had to be chosen from the men who had companied with the disciples all the time the Lord Jesus went in and out among them, in order to keep the number twelve and to be ordained with the apostles as a witness of the resurrection.ST Jun 17, 1897ST Jan 2, 1893ST Jun 17, 1897RH Feb 12, 1901RH Apr 19, 1906 The period measured was from the baptism of John until the day Jesus was taken up, and the man so qualified was to become with them a witness to the resurrection.ST Jun 17, 1897ST Jan 2, 1893ST Jun 17, 1897RH Feb 12, 1901RH Apr 19, 1906 To fill the vacant ministry and apostleship from which Judas fell, two were put forward, Joseph called Barsabbas who was surnamed Justus and Matthias, prayer was offered to the Lord who knows the hearts of all men to show which He had chosen, lots were given, and the lot fell upon Matthias and he was numbered with the eleven.ST Jun 17, 1897
Such continual companionship through the whole public ministry meant firsthand acquaintance with Jesus and the events of His work, qualifying the man to testify as one who had directly seen and known Him.RH Jan 19, 1869ST Aug 9, 1905ST Oct 27, 1898RH Jan 14, 1862 The twelve were thus taken from men who had been with Him in His work and had seen Him, so they could witness to Israel concerning His work and character as eye and ear witnesses of what He did and of His resurrection.ST Aug 9, 1905ST Oct 27, 1898RH Jan 14, 1862 A witness could testify only to what he had actually seen and known by direct observation, and that firsthand access to the ministry was not available to those living later.RH Jan 14, 1862 Their continual presence covered His life, teaching, practice, miracles, death, resurrection and ascension.RH Jan 19, 1869ST Jun 28, 1883ST Oct 27, 1898
The rule required presence through the whole three and a half years because Christ chose the twelve at the beginning and kept them constantly with Him to prepare them by His instruction for preaching the gospel after His ascension.RH Sep 29, 1874 He taught the people cautiously as they were able to receive, but expounded all things fully to the disciples so they would know what to teach in the future.RH Sep 29, 1874 The requirement therefore ensured the new apostle knew all the doctrine and truths Jesus had given and was prepared to teach the gospel accurately and correctly to others.ST Aug 13, 1874RH Sep 29, 1874 For Paul to stand equal with those firsthand witnesses who had accompanied Jesus and knew His teaching and practice, he had to be sent by Jesus Himself and receive his knowledge of Christ directly and not from other people.ST Jun 28, 1883 The choice also showed remembrance that Christ had spent all night in prayer before He ordained the first twelve, in whose prayer and in whose number twelve meaning and reason were seen.ST Jan 2, 1893
Choice of Matthias
The men under consideration were those who had been with the disciples throughout Jesus' ministry among them, and this identified the field from which the vacancy among the apostles was to be filled.RH Jun 19, 1856ST Jun 17, 1897 To fill the vacant apostleship one of those companions had to become a witness with the others of the resurrection, and they proceeded by putting forward two men, Joseph called Barsabas who was surnamed Justus and Matthias.RH Jun 19, 1856ST Jun 17, 1897 Prayer was offered to the Lord who knows the hearts of all men to show which of the two He had chosen to take the place in the ministry and apostleship from which Judas fell, lots were given for them, and the lot fell upon Matthias and he was numbered with the eleven apostles.ST Jun 17, 1897 By this choosing Matthias became one of the twelve, and the choice was approved by the Lord and made under God.ST Mar 14, 1911 His lack of later mention does not count against his apostleship, since several of the twelve are not mentioned again after Acts 1.
Christ chose no one man to take His place and left no apostle appointed to fill the place of Judas, leaving that vacancy for the church as an organized body to settle as its first step in administration after He ceased to be its visible head. The choice was not settled by a single individual, but the eleven apostles called together the believing disciples residing at Jerusalem to join with them in choosing an apostle to succeed the apostate Judas.RH Apr 15, 1909ST Mar 6, 1884 With earnest prayer for divine guidance they appointed and ordained one of their own number to the office of apostle, recognizing the church as a legitimate body after the ascension and acting through the Holy Spirit.RH Apr 15, 1909ST Mar 6, 1884 That office is general, not local, for the whole church, given to the ministry of the Word and to general oversight and unity of the work as it enlarged.RH Apr 15, 1909 The successor had to be one who stayed with the disciples the whole time Jesus lived and worked among them, from the baptism of John until He was taken up, in order to be ordained with them as a witness of His resurrection, and the disciples in this remembered that Christ spent all night in prayer before He ordained the first twelve and saw meaning in that prayer and reason in the number twelve.ST Jan 2, 1893 Keeping the number twelve complete corresponded to the twelve tribes of Israel.RH Aug 18, 1874
Prophecy guided the apostles' conduct in choosing a successor to Judas, including the requirement that the candidate had accompanied them throughout Jesus' ministry among them.RH Nov 29, 1853 The eleven were still called the twelve while another was chosen to take Judas's place after he failed.
Prophetic Time and Chronology
The time during which Jesus went in and out among the disciples, beginning with John's baptism and continuing through His personal public ministry to His being taken up, is the first half of the final seven years of Daniel's seventy weeks, a half ending at the crucifixion.RH Dec 23, 1852ST Mar 18, 1889ST Mar 26, 1912RH Dec 19, 1907 That ministry began about A.D. 27 with Jesus' baptism and ended with the crucifixion in A.D. 31.ST Mar 18, 1889
The ascension came forty-three days after the crucifixion.ST Mar 18, 1889ST Mar 26, 1912 Those who reckoned it as forty-two days after the crucifixion placed it at the same close of that first half of the final week.RH Dec 19, 1907 The remaining half of that final week then ran on to its end at Stephen's martyrdom in A.D. 34.ST Mar 26, 1912
Church Order and Practical Use
The choosing described here is the pattern for selecting and ordaining persons to church office, and it is the first act of administration by the primitive church after Christ ceased to be present as its visible head.RH Aug 29, 1854 No single man was designated to take His place, and no successor to Judas was appointed by Him, the vacancy being left for the church as an organized body to settle rather than by any one individual. The eleven therefore met in council with the believing disciples at Jerusalem, and with earnest prayer for divine guidance through the Holy Spirit appointed and ordained one of their own number to the apostleship.RH Apr 15, 1909 That office is general and not local, belonging to the whole church for the ministry of the Word and for general oversight and unity as the work enlarged.RH Apr 15, 1909
An apostle is one sent forth with a message, a title given to the original twelve because they were selected in a special manner to do God's work.ST Oct 27, 1898RH Aug 18, 1874 The same title belonged to Matthias together with Barnabas, Paul, Epaphroditus, Silvanus, and Timothy, since continual companionship with Jesus all the time He went in and out among His followers made a man an eye and ear witness of His work and resurrection.ST Oct 27, 1898RH Aug 18, 1874 No other election to this office is recorded, although others certainly were apostles, and the church is nowhere directed to choose men to this office in succeeding ages.RH Aug 18, 1874 When providence makes manifest that God has raised up a man for a special work, the church should still grant him his proper degree of influence and position.RH Aug 18, 1874 The same transaction establishes that God having chosen the original messengers for a work, the work is not to be taken from them and handed to a new group, and the presence of even one unfaithful person among those chosen does not justify displacing the faithful majority.RH Dec 18, 1855
The meetings of Jesus with the disciples during the forty days before the ascension, including on a Thursday, do not establish Sunday as the Sabbath.RH Dec 17, 1857 His final interview at the ascension from the Mount of Olives says nothing about making that Thursday a Sabbath, showing that Christ meeting with His disciples on a day does not make that day sacred.RH May 12, 1874 The day of the ascension is memorable in His history, but it is not thereby the Lord's day.ST Apr 6, 1882 The forty days of His going in and out among them expired on Thursday at the ascension, leaving ten days of earnest prayer before the day of Pentecost fifty days from the resurrection.RH Mar 31, 1874 Two first days were included in those ten days, with Pentecost falling on the last of them, proving that God designed to honor the antitype of the feast of Pentecost and not the first day of the week.RH Mar 31, 1874
Sources