Ecclesiastes 1:9
The thing that hath been, it is that which shall be; and that which is done is that which shall be done: and there is no new thing under the sun.
Translations
The thing that has been, it is that which shall be; and that which is done is that which shall be done: and there is no new thing under the sun.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
The thing that hath been, it is that which shall be; and that which is done is that which shall be done: and there is no new thing under the sun.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
That which hath been is that which shall be; and that which hath been done is that which shall be done: and there is no new thing under the sun.
What [is] that which hath been? it [is] that which is, and what [is] that which hath been done? it [is] that which is done, and there is not an entirely new thing under the sun.
That which hath been is that which shall be; and that which hath been done is that which will be done: and there is nothing new under the sun.
That which hath been, is the same that shall be, and, that which hath been done, is the same that shall be done,—and there is, nothing new, under the sun.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
What has been will be again,
and what has been done will be done again;
there is nothing new under the sun.That which has been is that which shall be, and that which has been done is that which shall be done; and there is no new thing under the sun.
That which has been, is that which is to be, and that which has been done, is that which will be done, and there is no new thing under the sun.
What is it that hath bene? that that shalbe: and what is it that hath bene done? that which shalbe done: and there is no newe thing vnder the sunne.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
What is it that hath been? the same thing that shall be. What is it that hath been done? the same that shall be done.
Cross-references
- Ecclesiastes 3:15
That which hath been is now; and that which is to be hath already been; and God requireth that which is past.
Both say that what has been will recur.
- Luke 17:26
And as it was in the days of Noe, so shall it be also in the days of the Son of man.
The days of Noah foreshadow the days of the Son of man.
- 2 Peter 3:4
And saying, Where is the promise of his coming? for since the fathers fell asleep, all things continue as they were from the beginning of the creation.
Both describe the claim that everything has continued unchanged since creation.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
3 sources
The verse means that history is being repeated, so that which has been will be again.Ms 141, 1902, par. 1Lt 34, 1899, par. 15–19 All that God has planned in His mind and touched with His hand in past history has been written as lessons of admonition for those upon whom the end of the world has come.Lt 34, 1899, par. 15–19 Christ's words of approval or disapproval spoken in the Old Testament come sounding down the line to the present time.Lt 34, 1899, par. 15–19 Obedience to the voice of God spoken in creation and through the holy men of old therefore involves present spiritual and eternal interests, because the Lord means what He says and says what He means.Lt 34, 1899, par. 15–19
It is a message from heaven to ministers, physicians, and workers connected with institutions, calling for careful consideration of the state of the churches.Ms 141, 1902, par. 1 Fanatical persons taking extreme views will always appear alongside genuine spiritual work, as the normal repeated pattern.Lt 10, 1885, par. 13–14 Their presence is no reason to stand off and denounce the whole work, which must still be tested and visited by its fruit.Lt 10, 1885, par. 13–14
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
54 sources
Solomon learned by tasting every earthly pleasure and achievement that all life apart from God is empty and fleeting, ending only in weariness of spirit.ST May 17, 1910ST Jul 15, 1913RH Sep 19, 1854 What has happened before will happen again, because human nature and the conditions of life remain essentially the same from age to age.RH Jan 3, 1856ST Oct 15, 1885ST Oct 30, 1879ST Mar 13, 1884 Every right principle is as old as God and every wrong principle is only a perversion of the right, so sin has introduced no new element and required no new plan in God's government.ST Dec 24, 1902RH Dec 30, 1902 In the last generation every apostasy since the fall will be revived, with Satan pursuing the same end by the same spirit though with more intense and subtle deceptions.RH Nov 21, 1907ST Nov 29, 1899RH Feb 4, 1904RH Nov 21, 1907 What is offered as new religion or new light is therefore old error restated, and interest and duty should rest on what is right rather than on mere novelty.ST Nov 17, 1909RH Dec 24, 1872RH Dec 30, 1902RH Mar 5, 1914
Author and Setting
The verse belongs to the preaching of Solomon, the son of David and king in Jerusalem, written about 977 in his last days.ST May 17, 1910ST Jul 15, 1913ST Sep 15, 1909 It came after he had tasted all the pleasures this world could give and yielded to all the desires of the heart and the flesh, seeking pleasure in luxury and power and feasting and wine and women and human invention and idolatry.ST May 17, 1910ST Jul 15, 1913ST Sep 15, 1909 His many wives turned away his heart and led it away, and his sad and unsatisfying experience in wealth and luxury left him to record what he had learned.ST May 17, 1910ST Jul 15, 1913ST Sep 15, 1909
What he learned by actual experience, and what he in his wisdom sought to find in luxury and human invention but found not, was that all such wisdom and glory and wealth and popularity would not bring rest of soul.ST May 17, 1910ST Jul 15, 1913 All such things produce nothing but vanity and vexation of spirit, presenting the vanity of human life and the utter uselessness of all human pursuits apart from God.ST May 17, 1910ST Jul 15, 1913ST Sep 15, 1909 This points out the folly of earthly pursuits without hope in God and the nothingness of humanity without God.ST May 17, 1910ST Sep 15, 1909 The joys of sin are fleeting and insubstantial, like dreams and shadows.RH Sep 19, 1854
The only wise conclusion, and the blessed conclusion, is that man's whole duty is to fear God and keep His commandments.ST May 17, 1910ST Jul 15, 1913ST Sep 15, 1909 That keeping is joined to trusting Him.ST May 17, 1910
What Nothing New Means
From God's perspective there is nothing new under the sun and no things are new with Him, while from the human perspective there are things both new and old.ST Dec 24, 1902 He never makes a mistake and never must say, as men do, that He would have done differently had He known what would happen, for what He does stands forever and endures, so belief must rest on His testimony alone in order to draw sweetness from Scripture, and in His work past patterns recur without bringing anything fundamentally new.ST Nov 12, 1885 His Word expresses truths of lasting, unlimited reach that remain true even when people do not fully comprehend what He has said, and His dealings do not change, for as He was near to His people and guided them in the past He remains near to His children and abides with them today, so that the holiness, fellowship with Him, and obedience seen in earlier times are available in the present as well.RH Jul 25, 1912
Every right principle and every truth are as old as God and as enduring as eternity, and every wrong principle and every error, whatever form it assumes, is only a perversion of the right and the true.ST Dec 24, 1902RH Dec 30, 1902 Sin has introduced no new element into His character and has required no new plan for His government, for the principles of salvation existed before sin and sin has had no new essence since its beginning, so ideas presented as modern new light or philosophy may be old errors restated in appealing language and their novelty of appearance does not make them true.RH Dec 30, 1902 Nothing originates under the sun in the sense that present conditions could have continued unchanged from the beginning, for the claim of no change would imply that the world is eternal, so an account of the world's beginning must appeal either to God's special creation or to life evolving from nonliving matter.ST Sep 24, 1912
The verse does not prove that humans are naturally immortal, for claims about immortality must be established by Scripture as the only unerring guide.RH May 5, 1863 Nor does it rule out the origin of genuinely new diseases, though it is invoked to express the belief that nothing is new by those who trace newly reported diseases back to ancient times.ST Apr 24, 1879 The bereaved may hope that loved ones who return will be the same persons with recognizable identity and presence, and their bodies need not be kept above ground, for God preserves them and Christian hope rests in His keeping rather than in preserved remains.ST May 28, 1885
History Repeats Itself
Events in history repeat in later ages, for what has happened before happens again and there is no wholly new pattern under the sun.RH Jan 3, 1856ST Apr 13, 1904 Earlier events therefore serve as examples that help explain later events fulfilled in like manner.RH Jan 3, 1856 Studying the past can help people learn what may happen in the future, even apart from prophecy.ST Apr 13, 1904
Human affairs follow recurring cycles, so what has happened will happen again and what people do will be done again, with past controversies and events returning in the final movements of earth's history on a wider scale and at a faster pace.ST Oct 21, 1930 When circumstances and human situations recur, biblical instruction given for an earlier occasion applies with the same authority when the same principles arise again.RH Jul 30, 1908 Such application must be grounded in the recurring circumstances and principles and may not assign a text arbitrarily to the present generation.RH Jul 30, 1908
Israel's wilderness experience and recovery from Egypt can serve as a type of the remnant's recovery in the last days, since events repeat and nothing is new under the sun.RH Jul 30, 1867 Israel's rejection of prophetic warnings likewise shows the recurrence, for God continued warning both kingdoms until captivity and persecution taught in suffering lessons they could have learned in peace by heeding His prophets.RH Dec 14, 1905
Nations gain power through self-denial, energy and endurance, then pass through wealth and luxury into corruption and decay, and present and future nations follow patterns already seen in past nations, with the nations of the day standing in the corruption stage of this recurring course. The governing laws of causes and their effects are inexorable, as illustrated by the history of church-and-state rule in Massachusetts.RH Jun 25, 1908 The same recurrence applies to nations in political decline, where the United States repeats causes that felled the Roman Republic, warning that similar causes can lead to similar consequences.RH May 15, 1900
Past biblical accounts of volcanoes and earthquakes provide examples that help explain and understand later disasters, including recent ones, because events and human experience recur with nothing fundamentally new under the sun.ST Aug 13, 1902 The revolutions that began in Sicily in 1848 and spread across Europe illustrate how history can repeat itself, so that renewed agitation in Italy could lead to similar upheaval if it gained strength and spread.ST Sep 3, 1894 People also repeat the folly of the past with its resulting destruction when they rebuild and return to cities despite the losses and dangers they have already suffered.ST May 9, 1906
The present age's inventive genius is no proof of unique intellectual superiority, since there is nothing new under the sun. Human activity and innovation do not produce endless, universal progress, for advances occur in particular lines, often through discoveries that bring rapid change, but their potential is eventually exhausted.ST Aug 30, 1883 Many practices and inventions are ancient, some supposed modern discoveries are rediscoveries, and civilization can also lose valuable arts and skills, so a society's level of civilization does not measure how long ago people lived or the abilities of human beings.ST Aug 30, 1883
There is nothing new to be discovered in the sense that the discovery of a thing may be new, but the thing itself or its principle is old, as old as the plan of the universe.ST Apr 8, 1897 This holds for the triangle and for chemistry, botany, astronomy, navigation, light, heat, motion, radiation and all the sciences and arts, with a great basic principle firmly laid in fact and in truth by the Master of the universe through all existence, whether animal, vegetable, mineral or Spirit.ST Apr 8, 1897 Therefore any discovery that is not a discovery of fact founded in truth is not worthy of the name of discovery, great or small.ST Apr 8, 1897
What people do has been done before, so apparent innovations are not truly new under the sun, as illustrated by fruit canning whose method was already used at Pompeii twenty centuries earlier.ST Feb 12, 1885 Ancient Assyrians likewise had knowledge of the sun's spots and used practices also belonging to later life, such as selling and leasing property, lending money at interest, and farming on shares.ST May 28, 1885 International expositions, though they may seem modern, have an ancient counterpart in the fair Xerxes held at Shushan in 521 B.C., where people spent six months viewing exhibits from across his kingdom.ST Jun 2, 1914
Human Nature Unchanged
Human nature and the basic conditions of life remain much the same across the ages, so events and experiences recur and there is nothing fundamentally new under the sun.ST Oct 30, 1879 In Noah's day and in Solomon's day, as now, people pursued pleasure, commerce, display, power, trade, building, status and gain, while greed and wrongdoing recur from age to age.ST Oct 15, 1885 Activities and fashions may vary in form, but the same patterns of worldly conduct return.ST Oct 15, 1885
Human life repeats across generations toward death, with people seeing and experiencing much as their ancestors did.ST Mar 13, 1884ST Sep 26, 1878RH May 9, 1865 They encounter the same sights, thoughts, feelings, hopes, fears, attachments, loves, joys, griefs and changing fortunes as those who came before them.ST Mar 13, 1884ST Sep 26, 1878RH May 9, 1865 Each generation follows the same course and all pass away in succession.ST Mar 13, 1884ST Sep 26, 1878RH May 9, 1865
In Christian life changing circumstances bring out the character people already possess, so true followers of Christ in different ages bear the same kind of fruit.ST Sep 16, 1880 The lives of past believers reveal God's providential care and provide examples of self-sacrifice and humility as well as warnings about the fruits of pride, arrogance and selfishness.ST Sep 16, 1880 When circumstances provide an excuse, people repeat earlier errors and rebellions, and history echoes itself even when different people play the roles.RH May 28, 1861 That blindness includes wrongly blaming God's judgments on those who obey and teach His commandments and failing to respect those God appoints for His work.
People in one age may condemn their predecessors yet follow the same course without recognizing the likeness, driven by motives they consider right and failing to foresee the results of their choices.RH May 28, 1861 Apart from the transforming grace of the gospel, human nature continues the same.RH May 28, 1861 Unsanctified people repeatedly bring forth similar and sometimes essentially identical wrongdoing, so that obstacles to missionary work in Christian lands have counterparts among heathen peoples.ST Jan 20, 1904 Reproof itself is not new, having existed from the beginning of sin and continuing to the end of sin, and a newly perceived social danger is not actually unprecedented.RH Dec 10, 1914ST Aug 6, 1896
Last Days Foretold
What has happened before will happen again in the last generation before Christ's second coming, for old controversies and past apostasies will be revived and every kind of apostasy since the fall will be repeated.RH Nov 21, 1907 The history of God's people under similar circumstances was recorded as warnings and examples for those living at the end of the world, teaching how to recognize and escape these apostasies.RH Nov 21, 1907
In the final conflict Satan will use the same policy, show the same spirit, and pursue the same end as in earlier ages.ST Nov 29, 1899RH Feb 4, 1904RH Nov 21, 1907ST Oct 11, 1905ST May 2, 1906 That coming struggle will be more intense than any the world has seen, repeating the pattern with unprecedented intensity.ST Nov 29, 1899RH Feb 4, 1904ST Oct 11, 1905ST May 2, 1906ST May 23, 1906 His deceptions in it will be more subtle than any yet seen.RH Nov 21, 1907
Because human nature remains the same, history repeats itself in the use of civil law to advance religious aims.ST Jan 27, 1890 Those who seek religious power over civil government repeatedly use civil law for religious ends and persecute dissenters, and when divine authority is lacking to support human inventions people resort to civil power to enforce them.ST Jan 27, 1890 So the darkness of the Dark Ages can come again, and any attempt by civil law to regulate religious days, ceremonies, or beliefs is a step toward union of church and state.ST Jul 7, 1898
Efforts to establish a Christian nation by law are not new, having been made in the early Christian centuries and under English Puritanism.ST Mar 26, 1896 Popular ministers have never led a reformation, for the clergy did not support the first-century reformation associated with the Sanhedrin or the sixteenth-century Reformation associated with the pope, and will not support the nineteenth-century reformation, which would otherwise be unprecedented.RH Apr 7, 1863 Opposition to the truth is likewise not new, as when people are warned against Seventh-day Adventist publications and preaching while the devil keeps people in darkness.RH Apr 20, 1876 In the Sabbath controversy this recurrence is plain, for objections raised in 1905 had already been raised and answered in 1850.RH Aug 17, 1905
Testing Novelty Claims
In church history there is nothing new under the sun, for a claimed new religion is not new but old pieces from church history put together again.ST Nov 17, 1909 Such piecing together comes after every imaginable expedient has been exhausted for evading the simple duty of believing the truth and escaping responsibility for doing plain duty to God and man.ST Nov 17, 1909 The forms of evasion include Unitarianism, deism, rationalism, natural evolution, and infidelity.ST Nov 17, 1909 What happens under the sun is not fundamentally new, because sin has introduced no new element into God's character and has required no new plan for His government.RH Dec 30, 1902 The principles of salvation existed before sin, and sin has had no new essence since its beginning.RH Dec 30, 1902 Ideas presented as modern new light or philosophy may therefore be old errors restated in appealing language, so novelty of appearance does not make them true.RH Dec 30, 1902
Christian Science is a supposed new thing under the sun, to which the point that there is nothing new under the sun applies as a claimed new discovery. Nothing under the sun is truly new, so interest and effort should rest on what is right and dutiful and not merely on the appeal of something new.RH Dec 24, 1872 Nothing is wholly new under the sun, as shown when a tent meeting seemed new to a discouraged visitor because of its clean, peaceful setting.RH Mar 5, 1914 The message preached there was the old gospel story presented in a new setting.RH Mar 5, 1914
Sources