Hebrews 3:10
Wherefore I was grieved with that generation, and said, They do alway err in their heart; and they have not known my ways.
Translations
Why I was grieved with that generation, and said, They do always err in their heart; and they have not known my ways.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Wherefore I was grieved with that generation, and said, They do alway err in their heart; and they have not known my ways.
Wherefore I was grieved with that generation, and said, They do always err in their heart; and they have not known my ways.
Wherefore I was displeased with this generation, And said, They do alway err in their heart: But they did not know my ways;
Wherefore I was displeased with this generation,
And said, They do always err in their heart:
But they did not know my ways;wherefore I was grieved with that generation, and said, Always do they go astray in heart, and these have not known My ways;
Wherefore I was wroth with this generation, and said, They always err in heart; and they have not known my ways;
Wherefore I was sore vexed with this generation, and said, Always err they in their heart;—howbeit, they, learned not my ways:
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Therefore I was angry with that generation,
and I said,
‘ Their hearts are always going astray,
and they have not known My ways.’Therefore I was displeased with that generation,
and said, ‘ They always err in their heart,
but they didn’ t know my ways.’So that I was angry with this generation, and I said, Their hearts are in error at all times, and they have no knowledge of my ways;
Wherefore I was grieued with that generation, and sayde, They erre euer in their heart, neither haue they knowen my wayes.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Forty years: for which cause I was offended with this generation, and I said: They always err in heart. And they have not known my ways,
Pictures

Cross-references 20 of 45
- Psalms 95:10
Forty years long was I grieved with this generation, and said, It is a people that do err in their heart, and they have not known my ways:
Describes Israel’s wayward hearts in the wilderness.
- Hebrews 4:1-2
Let us therefore fear, lest, a promise being left us of entering into his rest, any of you should seem to come short of it.
Israel heard the gospel but failed to enter God’s rest because they lacked faith.
- Hebrews 4:8-9
For if Jesus had given them rest, then would he not afterward have spoken of another day.
Joshua’s rest in Canaan did not exhaust the promised rest that remains for God’s people.
- Hebrews 3:19
So we see that they could not enter in because of unbelief.
Unbelief kept Israel from entering God’s rest.
- Numbers 14:22-23
Because all those men which have seen my glory, and my miracles, which I did in Egypt and in the wilderness, and have tempted me now these ten times, and have not hearkened to my voice;
Israel repeatedly tested God and, in unbelief, was barred from entering the land.
- Hebrews 4:3-4
For we which have believed do enter into rest, as he said, As I have sworn in my wrath, if they shall enter into my rest: although the works were finished from the foundation of the world.
Believers enter God’s rest, identified with his seventh-day rest after creation.
- Hebrews 4:2
For unto us was the gospel preached, as well as unto them: but the word preached did not profit them, not being mixed with faith in them that heard it.
The word heard did not benefit those who lacked faith.
- 1 Corinthians 10:11
Now all these things happened unto them for ensamples: and they are written for our admonition, upon whom the ends of the world are come.
Israel’s wilderness history is written as a warning and example for believers.
- Hebrews 4:7
Again, he limiteth a certain day, saying in David, To day, after so long a time; as it is said, To day if ye will hear his voice, harden not your hearts.
It refers again to the quoted appeal to hear God’s voice and not harden the heart.
- Psalms 95:7-8
For he is our God; and we are the people of his pasture, and the sheep of his hand. To day if ye will hear his voice,
Warns against hardening the heart when hearing God’s voice.
- Numbers 14:29-30
Your carcases shall fall in this wilderness; and all that were numbered of you, according to your whole number, from twenty years old and upward, which have murmured against me,
Israel’s murmuring and unbelief brought judgment in the wilderness, barring that generation from Canaan.
- Hebrews 4:11
Let us labour therefore to enter into that rest, lest any man fall after the same example of unbelief.
Believers are warned not to follow Israel’s example of unbelief.
- Deuteronomy 1:34-35
And the LORD heard the voice of your words, and was wroth, and sware, saying,
God is angered by the generation’s rebellion and swears they will not see the promised land.
- Psalms 95:11
Unto whom I sware in my wrath that they should not enter into my rest.
The oath denies the disobedient generation entry into God's rest.
- Numbers 21:5-6
And the people spake against God, and against Moses, Wherefore have ye brought us up out of Egypt to die in the wilderness? for there is no bread, neither is there any water; and our soul loatheth this light bread.
Israel’s complaints against God and Moses are followed by judgment through fiery serpents.
- Numbers 13:31
But the men that went up with him said, We be not able to go up against the people; for they are stronger than we.
The spies magnified the difficulties, showing the people’s erring hearts and unbelief.
- Hebrews 3:15
While it is said, To day if ye will hear his voice, harden not your hearts, as in the provocation.
Repeats the warning not to harden hearts.
- Hebrews 4:4-5
For he spake in a certain place of the seventh day on this wise, And God did rest the seventh day from all his works.
The seventh-day rest pledges God’s rest, which that generation failed to enter.
- Hebrews 4:10
For he that is entered into his rest, he also hath ceased from his own works, as God did from his.
Entering God’s rest means ceasing from one’s own works, as God did.
- Joshua 21:43-44
And the LORD gave unto Israel all the land which he sware to give unto their fathers; and they possessed it, and dwelt therein.
Israel’s land and rest under Joshua prefigure the promised rest.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
28 sources
It speaks of the forty years after the coming out of Egypt, when Israel tempted and proved God though they saw His works, and He was grieved with that generation.Ms 8, 1914, par. 42–43Lt 307, 1903, par. 1–2Lt 87, 1898, par. 20–24 To always err in heart is persistent inward unbelief and rebellion that departs from the living God, showing itself in murmuring and complaining, distrust and fault-finding, judging fellow workers and sitting on the judgment seat, and in pride and selfishness.Lt 97, 1898, par. 1–7Ms 65, 1895, par. 3–4Lt 11, 1904, par. 17–23Lt 87, 1898, par. 20–24Lt 209, 1904, par. 11–12 To have not known His ways is failing to believe He was leading, refusing to look to Him instead of men, trying to shape His work to human minds, and hearing His voice yet not receiving it by faith or putting it into practice.Lt 97, 1898, par. 1–7Ms 5, 1904, par. 8–1013MR 379.2–380.1 Because the word preached was not mixed with faith, God could not give the blessings He designed, but poured out wrath so that all but two of the adults who left Egypt fell in the wilderness and He swore they should not enter His rest.Ms 8, 1914, par. 42–43Ms 5, 1904, par. 8–1013MR 379.2–380.1 It is the voice of the Holy Ghost saying Today if you will hear His voice harden not the heart, calling everyone who hears it now, especially those who have received light, to guard against unbelief, to daily exhort one another and hold confidence firm to the end, for this history will be repeated intensified in the last years as God's people stand on the borders of the heavenly Canaan.Ms 8, 1914, par. 42–43Lt 97, 1898, par. 1–7Lt 307, 1903, par. 1–2Ms 5, 1904, par. 8–10Lt 117, 1897, par. 33–34
Israel Grieved God in Wilderness
The forty years after coming out of Egypt were the time when Israel tempted and proved God though they saw His works, and for that whole generation He was grieved.Ms 8, 1914, par. 42–43Lt 307, 1903, par. 1–2Lt 87, 1898, par. 20–24Lt 100, 1900, par. 15–16Ms 13, 1892, par. 42–44 They sinned after coming out by Moses, their bodies fell in the wilderness, and He swore they should not enter His rest because they did not believe and could not enter in because of unbelief.Ms 8, 1914, par. 42–43Lt 307, 1903, par. 1–2 The same gospel was preached to them as to believers now, but the word preached did not profit them because it was not mixed with faith in those who heard it.Ms 8, 1914, par. 42–43 Their unbelief and departure brought His grief and wrath and barred them from His rest.Lt 100, 1900, par. 15–16Lt 54, 1908, par. 26–27
To always err in heart was persistent inward unbelief and rebellion that departed from the living God.Ms 65, 1895, par. 3–4Lt 11, 1904, par. 17–23Lt 209, 1904, par. 11–12Lt 100, 1900, par. 15–16Lt 324, 1907, par. 8–10 It was going astray and going wrong in heart again and again, resisting and refusing to know His ways.Ms 65, 1895, par. 3–4Lt 11, 1904, par. 17–23Lt 209, 1904, par. 11–12Ms 13, 1892, par. 42–44 That unbelief and resistance grieved Him and led to the judgment that they would not enter His rest.Lt 11, 1904, par. 17–23Lt 209, 1904, par. 11–12Lt 324, 1907, par. 8–10
Erring in heart showed itself in murmuring and complaining, in suspicion and distrust of fellow workers, and in cherishing doubt and distrust planted by suspicious minds.Lt 97, 1898, par. 1–7Lt 87, 1898, par. 20–24ST Sep 13, 1899 It weighed fellow workers in human scales and put wrong constructions on their words and movements, blamed others when appearances were not encouraging, and charged blame where it did not belong.Lt 97, 1898, par. 1–7Lt 87, 1898, par. 20–24 It wanted to sit on the judgment seat and take the scales out of God's hands, with persistent personal feeling and fault-finding that bring His rebuke.Lt 97, 1898, par. 1–7Lt 87, 1898, par. 20–24 It also showed itself in unbelief, pride and selfishness, for they heard Christ's words from the pillar of cloud but did not receive them by faith or put them into practice.ST Sep 13, 1899
The hardening works through the deceitfulness of sin, for Satan presents his temptations under the guise of goodness.Ms 9, 1903, par. 24–25RH Jan 7, 1904 One violation of straightforward truthfulness prepares the way for a second until wrongs repeated harden the heart of unbelief and the conscience loses its sensitiveness.Ms 9, 1903, par. 24–25RH Jan 7, 1904 Speaking words of unbelief that cast reflection on Him who is too wise to err and too good to do harm belongs to this erring and requires humbling the heart before God and asking forgiveness.Ms 9, 1903, par. 24–25RH Jan 7, 1904
Not to have known His ways was failing to believe God was leading, refusing to look to Him instead of men and the arm of flesh, and trying to fix His work to suit human minds.Lt 97, 1898, par. 1–7 It was disobeying His voice though truth was kept before them again and again, so that they might have known His ways.Ms 5, 1904, par. 8–1013MR 379.2–380.121MR 440.5–441.4 It was separating from God to follow the wisdom of men not under His direction.21MR 440.5–441.4 It was hearing Christ's words from the pillar of cloud without receiving them by faith or putting them into practice, in persistent failure to trust and obey from hearts that did not know His ways.ST Sep 13, 1899
Their wrong-heartedness was obstinate refusal to receive warnings from God and persistent backsliding in unbelief, obstinacy and idolatry.Lt 229, 1903, par. 13–1421MR 440.5–441.4 It was seen in the unfaithful spies and the murmuring congregation who acknowledged the goodness of the land yet declared the inhabitants too strong.Ms 6, 1892, par. 38–42 They magnified difficulties into insurmountable obstacles, wept and murmured against God-appointed leaders, wished to return to Egypt, and rejected the faithful testimony of Caleb and Joshua.Ms 6, 1892, par. 38–42 Such cherished doubts and criticisms and complaints sowed seeds of unbelief and distrust to leaven the whole congregation, let the golden opportunity pass by, and kept God's prepared work of manifesting His greatness and favor from being done because of wicked unbelief and rebellion.Ms 6, 1892, par. 38–42
God was grieved and could not give the blessings He designed them to have, because leaders and people yielded to Satan's temptations and did not obey His voice.Ms 5, 1904, par. 8–1013MR 379.2–380.1 He poured out wrath for their destruction so that their bodies fell in the wilderness and all but two of the adults who left Egypt died.Ms 8, 1914, par. 42–43Lt 229, 1903, par. 13–1421MR 440.5–441.4 He swore they should not enter His rest because of unbelief, except for the two who wholly followed Him.Ms 8, 1914, par. 42–43RH Jun 25, 1861 He would have brought them quickly into the promised land if they had submitted to Him and loved His leading.RH Jun 25, 1861
Hear His Voice Today
The verse is the voice of the Holy Spirit speaking now, saying Today if you will hear His voice, harden not the heart as in the provocation in the day of temptation in the wilderness.Ms 8, 1914, par. 42–43Lt 97, 1898, par. 1–7Lt 307, 1903, par. 1–2Ms 13, 1892, par. 42–44Lt 117, 1897, par. 33–34 It belongs to the forty years in which Israel tempted and proved God though they saw His works, and it declares that God was grieved with that generation because they always erred in heart and had not known His ways.Ms 8, 1914, par. 42–43Lt 97, 1898, par. 1–7Lt 307, 1903, par. 1–2Ms 13, 1892, par. 42–44Lt 117, 1897, par. 33–34 Those who sinned after coming out of Egypt could not enter in because of unbelief, their bodies fell in the wilderness, and He swore they should not enter His rest.Ms 8, 1914, par. 42–43Lt 307, 1903, par. 1–2Lt 117, 1897, par. 33–34 The same gospel was preached to them as to believers now, but the word preached did not profit them because it was not mixed with faith in those who heard it.Ms 8, 1914, par. 42–43
Its warning must be taken personally, especially by those who have received light but do not walk in it.Lt 228, 1908, par. 2–5 No one is to harden the heart when God speaks, or turn from the living God through an evil heart of unbelief, or fail to enter His rest by refusing to trust Him.Lt 228, 1908, par. 2–5Lt 307, 1903, par. 1–2Lt 11, 1904, par. 17–23Lt 209, 1904, par. 11–12Lt 324, 1907, par. 8–10 Hardship is not to be answered with doubt, but faithfulness and heed to His voice are required.Lt 24b, 1896, par. 13–19 The heart must be guarded against unbelief and against being hardened through the deceitfulness of sin.Lt 307, 1903, par. 1–2Lt 11, 1904, par. 17–23Lt 209, 1904, par. 11–12Lt 324, 1907, par. 8–10
Instead there must be fear lest, a promise being left of entering His rest, anyone should seem to come short of it.Ms 8, 1914, par. 42–43 There must be daily exhorting of one another while it is called Today, lest any be hardened, and a cherishing and talking and acting of faith because God manifests His grace and power again and again.Lt 97, 1898, par. 1–7Lt 307, 1903, par. 1–2Lt 24, 1896, par. 12–15Lt 117, 1897, par. 33–34 Character is to be molded after the divine likeness and there is to be cooperation with God so He will work with human effort.Lt 87, 1898, par. 20–24 Believers are to hold the beginning of confidence and the rejoicing of the hope firm and steadfast to the end as His house and partakers of Christ, with patience doing His will, living by faith and not drawing back, not casting away confidence which has great recompense of reward, in order to enter His rest.Ms 8, 1914, par. 42–43Lt 97, 1898, par. 1–7Lt 307, 1903, par. 1–2Lt 24, 1896, par. 12–15Lt 117, 1897, par. 33–34
The passage about God's discipline of His church is meant to purify His people.Lt 54, 1908, par. 26–27 In times of distress God remains their refuge and His Word their sure defense.Lt 54, 1908, par. 26–27
The warning applies to every worker, and to teachers and students as a lesson for God's people in the last days.Lt 87, 1898, par. 20–24Ms 55, 1898, par. 9–10 It warns the children who entered Canaan and all who hear it now not to follow the course their fathers took and to avoid the same mistakes.Lt 229, 1903, par. 13–14 Trust is to be in God alone rather than seeking help from those who do not serve Him.RH Jun 25, 1861 Those who refuse present invitations and persist in disobedience are urged not to harden their hearts while mercy still calls, but to answer with immediate repentance and obedient action rather than a mere promise.RH Aug 22, 1907RH Feb 27, 1900
God is grieved now by believers who hinder His work by working at cross-purposes with Him and clinging to their own way.RH May 10, 1906 He will not be trifled with, and His judgments are His reproof to arouse them.RH May 10, 1906 Those who have defied Him must stop dishonoring Him and must take up His work intelligently and unitedly, proclaiming with one voice the message of warning and salvation.RH May 10, 1906
This experience will be repeated in the last years of the history of God's people, when history is repeated and the perils encountered in past ages are encountered again intensified.Ms 5, 1904, par. 8–1013MR 379.2–380.1 Men whom God has greatly honored will pattern after ancient Israel, as Satan obtained influence over men honored above all human intelligence as he honored Solomon, when leaders yielded to temptation and did not obey His voice so God could not give the blessings He designed them to have.Ms 5, 1904, par. 8–1013MR 379.2–380.1 The history stands as admonition for those living just on the borders of the promised land before entering the heavenly Canaan, who face the same danger of falling under the oath that they shall not enter His rest.Lt 117, 1897, par. 33–34Ms 6, 1892, par. 38–42 The call is urgent because the end is near, Christ may come suddenly and find them unready with no second probation, and now while it is called Today if they hear His voice and turn fully to Him when He that shall come comes and will not tarry, He will have mercy and abundantly pardon.Lt 117, 1897, par. 33–34RH May 10, 1906
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
61 sources
God was indignant with the Exodus generation after the deliverance from Egypt, though they saw his works for forty years.RH Jul 21, 1868ST May 30, 1895RH Sep 17, 1901 They continually strayed inwardly in rebellion, murmuring and testing him despite continual provision, and they would not learn from his works to know his character well enough to trust him.ST Jan 22, 1894RH Jul 21, 1868ST May 30, 1895RH Nov 12, 1901RH Jun 6, 1907 By that unbelief and disobedience they provoked his oath in wrath that they should not enter his rest, for the promise preached to them did not benefit them because it was not united with faith.ST Jan 22, 1894ST Aug 9, 1910ST Jul 15, 1897ST Sep 23, 1913 That rest is God's own rest from the finishing of creation, Christ's own soul rest entered by ceasing from self-effort and sin, typified by Canaan under Joshua but remaining as the future everlasting inheritance of the new earth.ST May 15, 1884RH Feb 14, 1865RH Feb 14, 1865RH Sep 17, 1901RH Sep 17, 1901 The warning was renewed long afterward through David and still sounds today, calling all who hear his voice not to harden their hearts in unbelief but to hold confidence firm, exhort one another daily, and enter by faith and obedience.RH Jun 14, 1867RH Nov 13, 1856ST Aug 22, 1911ST Jun 17, 1889ST Oct 27, 1909
Words and Wilderness Setting
God was grieved, that is indignant, with the Exodus generation after the deliverance from Egypt, though they saw his works for forty years.RH Jul 21, 1868ST May 30, 1895RH Sep 17, 1901RH Jun 6, 1907RH Sep 17, 1901 That grief was for slow pupils under a great teacher who labored lesson after lesson to make them know him, while journeying from one wilderness to another as from one school to another.RH Jun 6, 1907 They tempted and proved him while he was testing and proving them to humble them, hardening their hearts instead of learning.RH Sep 17, 1901RH Jun 6, 1907RH Sep 17, 1901
They do alway err in their heart means continual inner straying and going wrong in heart, repeatedly sinning and not believing.ST Jan 22, 1894RH Jul 21, 1868RH Nov 12, 1901 It was expressed in rebellion, murmuring despite signs and provision, testing God's patience and faithfulness, and distrust of his guidance.RH Jul 21, 1868RH Nov 6, 1866 It included ingratitude despite continual bread and water, unreasonable prejudice and opposition strengthened by unbelief, and reversing his proving work by tempting and proving him.RH Jun 6, 1907 Such hardening comes when men let deceitfulness of sin take root in the human heart, which is deceitful above all things and desperately wicked, for sin never makes good its fair promises yet infatuates men.RH Nov 12, 1901
They have not known my ways means they would not learn his ways and the lessons given to make them know him.ST Jan 22, 1894RH Jun 6, 1907 Though they witnessed his works for forty years, they forgot them and failed to know his character well enough to trust him.ST May 30, 1895 Knowing his ways comes through recognizing what his works reveal of his love and power.ST May 30, 1895 By contrast Moses desired to know God's way and was promised rest, while they through an evil heart of unbelief departed from the living God, hearing without faith and without practice, with murmuring, pride and selfishness bringing guilt.ST Sep 13, 1899ST Nov 4, 1886
That generation was those old enough to know good from evil, those over twenty, who were barred from Canaan to wander forty years until consumed in the wilderness.RH Jul 21, 1868RH May 27, 1862RH Dec 9, 1858 Excepted were Caleb and Joshua, the two who wholly followed him.RH Jun 25, 1861RH Dec 9, 1858 The children who had not yet known good from evil belonged to the next generation and entered the land.RH Dec 9, 1858 The sentence to wander until those over twenty had died did not mean every person was finally lost, for some may have repented.RH Jul 21, 1868
The voice they rejected was Christ as their wilderness leader, heard from the pillar of cloud but not received by faith nor put into practice.ST Sep 13, 1899ST Apr 22, 1889 The words are the Holy Spirit's quotation through David, addressed to the brethren as warning against rebellion and calling for present obedience.RH Jul 21, 1868ST Oct 21, 1889ST Jun 23, 1881 The passage stands in the first part of Hebrews as a divine commentary on the priesthood and sanctuary service, showing how the sacrifices and offerings and work of the sanctuary in the old dispensation met fulfillment in Christ's ministry and sacrifice.ST Jun 30, 1914
Unbelief That Bars Rest
The wilderness generation was grieved over by God because they continually went astray in heart, sinned, disobeyed, wandered, and did not know His ways, and by that unbelief they failed to enter the promised rest and fell in the wilderness.ST Jan 22, 1894ST Aug 9, 1910ST Jul 15, 1897RH Nov 13, 1856RH Mar 3, 1853 Their erring heart provoked His oath in wrath that they should not enter His rest, and that oath stands as a warning to guard against an evil heart of unbelief departing from the living God.RH Nov 13, 1856ST Nov 4, 1886 Their rebellion kept them from the rest offered to Israel, and the rest afterward given under Joshua was only a type of the future rest that remains for God's people.RH May 11, 1869RH May 27, 1862
The gospel and promise preached to them did not profit them because the word heard was not mixed, joined, and united with faith, and hearing without faith brings no benefit and shuts out the rest.ST Jul 15, 1897ST Nov 4, 1886RH Sep 17, 1901 True rest comes by believing and by accepting God's righteousness in place of one's own, for faith is the condition of entering the rest they lost.ST Sep 23, 1913ST Nov 4, 1886 Those who believe enter that rest by holding confidence and hope firm to the end, lest any come short of the promise left of entering His rest.ST Nov 4, 1886 The same promise and the same gospel preaching were extended long afterward through David's call not to harden the heart when hearing His voice today, bringing them down to the present.RH Sep 17, 1901
Even the generation that went into Canaan did not in that enter the land and the rest to which God would have taken the people when they first left Egypt had they only believed, for they believed Him not, missed His call, and fell in the wilderness.RH Feb 5, 1901 Joshua did not give them that contemplated rest, although up to that time not one thing had failed of all the Lord had promised to the house of Israel.RH Sep 17, 1901 The warning renewed through David proves the rest Joshua gave was only a type, with the true rest still future to be inherited by God's people.RH May 27, 1862 The same erring heart continued in David's day, when Israel failed exactly as their fathers had and drifted further from God until they rejected Him to be like the nations and became like all the nations.RH Feb 5, 1901
They did not receive spiritual rest in God, and so they could not enjoy lasting physical rest in Canaan.ST Sep 23, 1913ST Mar 11, 1897 God meant to give rest not only from Egyptian bondage but from the bondage of sin, from slavery, war, and their own works, and He did give temporal rest from enemies, yet unbelief and erring in heart shut them out from the completed holy spiritual rest from sin of which His seventh-day Sabbath is a pledge.ST Jan 18, 1916 By hearing without faith they failed to realize the full extent of the promise and to glorify God by acting rightly upon it.RH Sep 17, 1901
Nature of Promised Rest
The rest denied to the erring heart is called God's own rest, dating from the foundation of the world when His works were finished.RH Feb 14, 1865RH Sep 17, 1901RH Sep 17, 1901 It began on the first seventh day when He ceased from work and beheld it as very good with delight.RH Feb 14, 1865RH Sep 17, 1901 He purposed His people finally to enter just such a rest as He then enjoyed, but sin and the fall interrupted the work until the time seemed ripe in Moses' day.RH Sep 17, 1901 That same rest is Christ's own soul rest, the rest God enjoyed on the seventh day of creation week when He rested from all His works, given to those who come to Him and trust Him.ST Jul 15, 1897ST Oct 20, 1914 It is entered by ceasing from one's own works and by trusting God, for surrendering self-effort and sin to God brings rest in Christ.ST Jul 15, 1897ST Jun 24, 1913
Canaan possessed under Joshua was only a type of the true, real and permanent rest that remains for God's people.RH May 11, 1869RH Sep 17, 1901ST Feb 23, 1882 That true rest is the future rest of the new earth, the everlasting inheritance and possession typified by the land of Canaan.ST May 15, 1884RH Feb 14, 1865 It is Eden restored, of which the Sabbath was a weekly reminder of that promised inheritance.ST Oct 4, 1905 Its ultimate inheritance is the redeemed, renewed earth, shared by the saints as joint-heirs with Christ through the new covenant, not through the broken old covenant.RH Jan 19, 1860 The rest spoken of is menoo-hah, a resting-place, a possession and inheritance, not a time or period of rest like the Sabbath.ST May 15, 1884
The oath barring entrance proves the rest denied was not the seventh-day Sabbath.RH May 27, 1862 God commanded Israel to keep the Sabbath under fearful penalties and continued to enforce its observance through the prophets, and Israel did in fact keep the Sabbath.RH May 27, 1862 The rest denied to that generation was the rest afterward given to them by Joshua.RH May 27, 1862 Their failure to obtain the spiritual rest God placed in the Sabbath kept them from Canaan.ST Oct 4, 1905 God meant to give them rest not only from Egyptian bondage but from the bondage of sin, from slavery, war, and their own works, and He did give them temporal rest from their enemies, yet unbelief and erring in heart shut them out from the completed holy spiritual rest from sin of which God's seventh-day Sabbath is a pledge.ST Oct 4, 1905ST Jan 18, 1916
Because Israel comprehended only the literal and temporal fulfillment and not the spiritual and eternal rest, God afterward set apart another day.RH Sep 17, 1901 That day is not any particular day of the week but an indefinite period including the whole gospel dispensation, during which the invitation to enter His rest is still extended.RH Sep 17, 1901 That later day carries the spiritual and eternal elements of the new covenant, and its full entrance includes the blessings and privileges of the eternal state.RH Sep 17, 1901 Since God's purpose that some enter that rest still stands, another limited day was set in which people on earth may hear His voice and accept the gospel invitation, and that gospel call is sounding now while the great controversy between good and evil is not yet finished.RH Sep 17, 1901 That rest promised to them is promised still, and as their unbelief brought God's displeasure and shut them out even from the typical land, which worked forfeiture of the true inheritance, so following their example of unbelief will cause failure to receive the true inheritance.ST May 15, 1884 The rest still offered is spiritual rest for those who give themselves to Christ, and eternal rest in the inheritance prepared for God's children, completed when the saved enter the earth made new at Christ's second coming.ST Jun 24, 1913ST
Warning to Later Generations
The warning was renewed long afterward through David to people already in possession in Canaan, calling them not to harden their hearts, and that renewed call proves the rest given under Joshua was not the final rest.ST Jun 23, 1881RH Sep 17, 1901 The call to hear his voice to-day reaches across the wilderness time, David's time, apostolic time, and the present time, for those who believe enter God's rest while those who harden their hearts through unbelief shut themselves out, and God's purpose that some enter still stands so another limited day is set in which the gospel invitation sounds now while the controversy is not yet finished.ST Aug 22, 1911RH Sep 17, 1901 Israel's history is used emphatically in the New Testament to teach spiritual lessons, recorded as warning and instruction for those living in the last days, and belongs to the appeal to Hebrew believers not to harden their hearts in unbelief in light of past transgression.ST Jun 17, 1889ST Oct 27, 1909
To harden the heart is to do as that generation did in tempting and provoking him, for they always erred in heart and did not know his ways with an evil heart of unbelief departing from the living God.RH Nov 12, 1901 God works powerfully with people and gives them light before they are left to the blindness of sin and Satan, and Pharaoh likewise became obstinate through resisting the light he had received.RH Oct 5, 1869 Hearts are hardened when men suffer them to harden under the deceitfulness of sin, letting its deceit take root in the human heart which is deceitful above all things and desperately wicked and just the soil for that deceit to take root in.RH Nov 12, 1901 Sin is phenomenally deceitful, never making good one of the fair promises it makes yet infatuating men, and Satan often presents temptation under guise of goodness.RH Jan 7, 1904RH Nov 12, 1901 One violation of straightforward truthfulness prepares the way for the second until wrongs repeated harden unbelief and the conscience loses its sensitiveness and can no longer discern good from evil, and continued resistance to the Spirit makes the mind less responsive the longer it continues, so the right time to yield to light received is now and the conscience must be kept tender by faith in Christ and turning from sin.RH Jan 7, 1904ST Feb 13, 1893ST Dec 7, 1915 That unbelief is a warning to believers to resist sin's deceit and hold confidence firm to the end, with humbling before God and asking forgiveness for words of unbelief that reflect on him who is too wise to err and too good to do harm, and with exhorting one another daily while it is called To-day.RH Jan 7, 1904RH Jun 14, 1867
Their repeated hardening by murmuring through unbelief and strengthening themselves in unreasonable prejudice and opposition, though long borne with, culminated at the border when commanded to go up and possess the land they sent spies who reported inability to take it, producing murmur and hardening throughout the whole camp. Then God made that generation an example by swearing in wrath that they should never enter his rest, turning them back to waste their carcasses in the wilderness. Continued hardening has prevented conversion and if continued will prevent it forever, with danger of being given up of God, so that hardening the heart again today may seal doom by the same lifted hand and oath excluding from his rest, and therefore today if his voice is heard the heart must not be hardened. In that rebellion not a few committed the unpardonable sin.RH Apr 21, 1874 The more powerfully the Lord works by his Spirit the greater the danger of sinning against the Holy Ghost by giving way to a rebellious spirit, and as through trials and mighty workings of his Spirit he fits up a people for the final conflict with the powers of darkness and for the final deliverance, many will close their probation in the same way.RH Apr 21, 1874
Even holy people must heed God's words and fear falling short of the promised rest through unbelief.RH Dec 22, 1868 Even a people given great spiritual privileges can fail to receive their inheritance, for that wilderness generation repeatedly went astray in heart and did not know God's ways and their unbelief kept them from the promised rest.RH Dec 2, 1858
Call to Faithful Obedience
Believers must take heed lest an evil heart of unbelief cause departure from the living God, guarding the heart against straying and holding confidence and hope firm to the end.ST Sep 10, 1896RH May 6, 1909RH Jun 14, 1867RH Nov 13, 1856 They must watch lest they come short of the promise of rest, responding in faith rather than hardening the heart when they hear his voice.ST Sep 10, 1896RH Nov 13, 1856 Hardening comes through the deceitfulness of sin, for temptation often presents itself under the guise of goodness, and one violation of straightforward truthfulness prepares the way for a second until repeated wrongs harden unbelief and the conscience loses sensitiveness.RH Jan 7, 1904RH May 6, 1909 Therefore they are to exhort one another daily while it is called To-day, humbling the heart before God and asking forgiveness for words of unbelief that cast reflection on him who is too wise to err and too good to do harm.RH Jan 7, 1904RH May 6, 1909
Entrance into God's rest comes by the opposite of what Israel did, by faith and obedience rather than unbelief.ST Jul 15, 1897RH Sep 17, 1901 Hearing the gospel without faith brings no benefit, for true rest comes from believing before entering and from accepting God's righteousness in place of one's own.ST Jul 15, 1897ST Sep 23, 1913 That trust means ceasing from one's own works in order to enter his rest.ST Jul 15, 1897RH Sep 17, 1901
Those saved by the God whose foreknowledge gave prophecy and whose providence guides and controls its fulfillment must gratefully acknowledge his benevolent hand reaching down to save from the evil heart of unbelief.RH Nov 6, 1866 They must follow trustingly wherever his providence guides, never looking back to what was left behind in Egypt and never murmuring at roughness or privation of the way, believing he knows best what is for their good.RH Jun 25, 1861RH Nov 6, 1866 He intends and is able to lead to a land flowing with milk and honey, and will do so unless unbelief and the sin that follows it causes falling short of the promised land.RH Nov 6, 1866 They must trust in him alone rather than seek help from those who do not serve him, wholly following him as the two faithful spies did, and follow his voice even when it leads into the wilderness rather than turning from his ways.RH Jun 25, 1861ST Mar 28, 1878
Disappointment does not prove God has not led his people, so they must not cast away confidence but correct their errors and not fall after the same example of unbelief.RH Feb 6, 1855 Failure to keep moving toward Canaan warns that turning back or making no spiritual progress leads away from the promised kingdom. No one has finished his course until he reaches the end of the race, for to have shared in the work and stood shoulder to shoulder through the heat of battle counts for nothing if he falls by the way just short of the promised Canaan when home is nearly in sight and the shout of victory is almost heard.RH Aug 19, 1909
The warning calls for immediate response to his invitation while mercy still calls, with repentance and obedient action rather than mere promise.RH Aug 22, 1907RH Feb 27, 1900 The danger is not that sin exhausts mercy, since pardon is available in Christ, but that continued resistance to the Spirit hardens the heart until it loses sensitivity to truth and mercy and the conscience can no longer discern good from evil.ST Feb 13, 1893 The conscience must therefore be kept tender by faith in Christ and by turning from sin.ST Feb 13, 1893 Since resisting the Holy Spirit and refusing received light makes the mind less responsive the longer resistance continues, the right time to yield to light received is now.ST Dec 7, 1915
God is now grieved when his people always err in heart and have not known his ways, and that grief rests on believers who hinder his work by working at cross-purposes with him and clinging to their own way.RH May 10, 1906 Lack of faith withholds blessings he wants them to receive, and unbelief, murmuring, pride and selfishness bring guilt when his words are heard without being received by faith or put into practice.ST Oct 4, 1899ST Sep 13, 1899 He will not be trifled with, and his judgments are reproof to arouse those who have defied him to stop dishonoring him and to take up his work intelligently and unitedly, proclaiming with one voice the message of warning and salvation.RH May 10, 1906 The call is urgent because the end is near, Christ may come suddenly and find them unready, and there will be no second probation; yet now, while it is called to-day, if they hear his voice and turn fully to him, he will have mercy and abundantly pardon.RH May 10, 1906
That same grief is still seen when those who hear Christ's invitation to come forget and forsake him, wandering bewildered and dismayed and making crooked pathways away from his loving will.ST Aug 25, 1887 They go a little onward and then fall backward lured by mocking mirages, cleaving to the arid sand of a long sad wilderness of travel while the happy promised Canaan with streams and fruits lies straight before them with eyes holden from seeing the way to set their feet.ST Aug 25, 1887 They need the patient, wise and tender Shepherd to teach wandering sheep to know his voice and not fail to go in right paths amid life's falling shadows.ST Aug 25, 1887
Sources