Hosea 4:8
They eat up the sin of my people, and they set their heart on their iniquity.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, Webster Bible
They eat up the sin of my people, and they set their heart on their iniquity.
They eat up the sin of my people,
And they set their heart on their iniquity.Revised Version, American Standard Version, World English Bible
They feed on the sin of my people, and set their heart on their iniquity.
The sin of My people they do eat, And unto their iniquity lift up their soul.
They eat the sin of my people, and their soul longeth for their iniquity.
The sin of my people, they do eat,—and. unto their iniquity, lift they up every man his desire.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
They feed on the sins of My people
and set their hearts on iniquity.The sin of my people is like food to them; and their desire is for their wrongdoing.
They eate vp the sinnes of my people, and lift vp their mindes in their iniquitie.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
They shall eat the sins of my people, and shall lift up their souls to their iniquity.
Cross-references
- 2 Corinthians 5:21
For he hath made him to be sin for us, who knew no sin; that we might be made the righteousness of God in him.
Cited in support of the sin-offering sense of the word.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
4 sources
Hosea 4:8 belongs to a warning that as Israel increased the people sinned against God, and that He would turn their glory into shame and punish them for their ways and deeds.PK 281.3 It sets forth the sinful condition of the inhabitants of the land, underscoring the preparation needed for the coming of the Lord.Lt 100, 1902, par. 10–11 It describes unfaithful priests and false shepherds who feed on the sin of God's people and set their hearts on their iniquity.Ms 60, 1900, par. 17–18
These shepherds turn men away from the laws of God's kingdom to exalt their own theories and suppositions in opposition to God's law, so that prevailing impiety and wickedness grow to fearful proportions.Ms 60, 1900, par. 17–18 In its modern application the verse exposes priests and human lawmakers who trample upon God's law and make human laws that they force the people to accept.Ms 163, 1897, par. 24–26 They press Sunday observance on the plea that the whole world keeps Sunday and that God's people are few in number.Ms 163, 1897, par. 24–26
It means the people are blinded by error, taking their words from the lips of priests and human lawmakers and supposing it does not matter whether they keep God's law.Ms 163, 1897, par. 24–26 That law was instituted in Eden when the foundations of the earth were laid, as God's memorial to honor the living God who made the world in six days and sanctified and blessed the day of His rest.Ms 163, 1897, par. 24–26 The verse will be fulfilled when God's judgment falls upon mystic Babylon, when the shepherds' work reacts back upon themselves and priest and people alike are punished for their ways and repaid for their doings.Ms 60, 1900, par. 17–18
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
15 sources
The priests live off the wrongdoing of God's people and fix their inner desire upon it, eagerly sharing in the corruption instead of correcting it or feeding on God's word.ST Aug 21, 1907ST Sep 7, 1904ST Apr 14, 1909 Priests and people thus become alike in wrongdoing, taking pleasure in sin amid rejected knowledge and broken law, and God will punish both for their ways.RH Jan 29, 1914ST Jun 9, 1914ST Feb 4, 1889ST May 31, 1877 The warning reaches ministers who let their hearers shape their teaching and withhold unpopular truth to keep position and income, serving the people's wishes rather than Christ.ST Feb 4, 1889ST May 31, 1877 Taking part in the sins of professed believers gives no share in their virtues and gives no license to sin presumptuously.RH Aug 17, 1869
Language and Historical Context
The Hebrew term rendered as wrongdoing can also mean an offering for wrongdoing, which confirms that Genesis 4:7 describes such an offering crouching at Cain's entrance.RH Feb 16, 1869 The term rendered as inner inclination is nephesh, making this one of fifteen Old Testament places where nephesh is translated heart rather than soul, life, person, mind, body, will, appetite, lust, or thing.ST Jun 6, 1878 Heart here means the soul or inner self as the seat of desire and affection, showing that the people fixed their cravings upon wrongdoing, not that the soul is an immortal immaterial part of the person.ST Dec 14, 1882
The passage belongs to Hosea 4-14, composed about 734, while Hosea 1-3 was composed about 785 or 748.ST Sep 2, 1913 The prophet's name means salvation, and he was the last of the great prophets of the northern kingdom.ST Sep 2, 1913 His work strongly foretells the coming captivity of the tribes, warns against alliance with Egypt, and lays bare the sad moral degeneration and decay of the nation and the gross iniquity of priests and princes.ST Sep 2, 1913 It closes with remonstrance and tender exhortation joined to rich promises of blessing from God upon repentance.ST Sep 2, 1913
Priestly Corruption and Judgment
The priests feed on the sin of the people and are devoted to their wrongdoing, sharing in the corruption rather than correcting it.ST Aug 21, 1907ST Sep 7, 1904 They eagerly join in the wrongdoing instead of turning the people from it, setting their hearts on iniquity.ST Sep 7, 1904 Religious leaders take pleasure in the wrongdoing of those who profess to belong to God, amid widespread wickedness, rejected knowledge, and disregard for God's law.ST Jun 9, 1914 They feed on the people's sin instead of God's word and take pleasure in wrongdoing by yielding to the people's worldliness rather than faithfully warning them, despite knowing better and being charged to do so.ST Apr 14, 1909
Together with verse 9, priest and people become alike in wrongdoing, and God will punish both for their ways and conduct.RH Jan 29, 1914ST Feb 4, 1889ST May 31, 1877 As Israel's sin increased, both people and priests were to be punished for their ways.RH Jan 29, 1914 The leaders take advantage of the people's sin and are eager for their wrongdoing, shaped by their hearers to teach what pleases them and serve the people's wishes rather than Christ.ST Feb 4, 1889 They feed on the people's sin and give their hearts to wrongdoing, refusing to practice or teach God's word when doing so might make them unpopular or cost them position and income, and by that failure they become responsible for the people's condition.ST May 31, 1877
In the context of Hosea 4:6-8, God's people are destroyed for lack of knowledge when they fail to seek the right knowledge in the right way and from the right source.ST Knowledge alone is not wisdom, and it can lead to pride or evil when used unwisely.ST In the broader context of Hosea 4, transgression of God's Ten Commandments is the real cause of calamity.ST Nov 14, 1906
Doctrinal Use and Application
Spiritual unfaithfulness is turning away from divine law and testimony to give worship to idolatrous or false religious bodies, and this eating up of wrongdoing and setting of desire upon iniquity stands among the proofs of that apostasy.RH Aug 28, 1860 Such misuse of spiritual union is wholly different from orderly recourse to civil law for managing temporal business.RH Aug 28, 1860 The same devouring of the people's failure and eagerness for their wrongdoing marks religious leaders who let hearers mold the message, teaching what pleases the crowd and serving human wishes instead of Christ.ST Feb 4, 1889 Where priest and people thus grow alike, both face punishment for their conduct.ST Feb 4, 1889
Ministers who will not practice or teach the word for fear of becoming unpopular or losing position and income repeat that guilt, and by withholding correction they become answerable for the condition of those they lead.ST May 31, 1877 Priest and people then share the same wrongdoing.ST May 31, 1877 To join eagerly in the faults of professed believers gives no share in their virtues, any more than licking filth proves kinship with goodness.RH Aug 17, 1869 The faults of otherwise godly persons therefore grant no license for presumptuous imitation.RH Aug 17, 1869
Sources