AdventAI

Job 4:17

Shall mortal man be more just than God? shall a man be more pure than his maker?

King James Version

Translations

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Pioneers and periodicals

64 sources

The verse asks whether a dying man can be more right than God or more pure than the One who made him, setting frail humanity over against its Maker as the standard of rightness and purity.STST May 30, 1895ST Sep 18, 1884 Mortal means liable to death, perishable and able to die, unlike God who alone has underived life and lives forever.RH Aug 7, 1916ST Mar 29, 1905ST Sep 18, 1884 By nature man is mortal and not inherently or unconditionally immortal, nor does he possess a deathless principle that lives on conscious after death.ST Aug 12, 1886ST May 30, 1895ST Nov 11, 1886RH Mar 10, 1868RH Jul 29, 1875 Immortality is not natural to man but conditional, to be sought by obedience and put on as a gift through the gospel, given to the righteous by resurrection or translation at the coming of Christ who abolished death.ST Feb 11, 1913ST Aug 24, 1915RH May 25, 1916 No mortal can exceed God in justice or his Maker in purity, for God does not set justice aside, and human sin and condemnation come from breaking His law which remains in force.ST Aug 9, 1905ST Jan 10, 1911PGGC 8.1RH Oct 6, 1863

Language and Setting

The question is whether a mortal person can be more just than God or more pure than his Maker, setting humanity over against God who made it.STST May 30, 1895ST Sep 18, 1884ST Jan 10, 1911 God is the standard of justice and purity whom human beings cannot surpass, while human beings are presented as mortal in contrast to God who alone has immortality.STST May 30, 1895ST Jan 10, 1911PGGC 8.1 Mortal means subject to death, perishable and able to die, subject to decay, unlike God who alone has immortality and lives forever.RH Aug 7, 1916ST Mar 29, 1905ST Sep 18, 1884ST Feb 11, 1913

The saying belongs to Eliphaz's speech within the debate between Job and his three friends over his afflictions, a debate formed by three circles of speeches.STRH Jun 24, 1858 It came after a spirit passed before his face, the hair of his flesh stood up, a form stood still that he could not discern, an image was before his eyes, and there was silence and then a voice.RH Jun 24, 1858RH Dec 15, 1910 Its near context describes man as dwelling in houses of clay founded in dust, crushed before the moth, perishing and dying without wisdom.ST Jul 9, 1896RH May 5, 1874ST Jun 23, 1881

That true fact about human mortality and God's superior justice and purity was appealed to in order to overwhelm Job in affliction, put in the mouth of a spirit, yet it was used wrongly to condemn Job whom God had not condemned.ST May 13, 1889ST Nov 3, 1909 The friends' words are often generally true but can be misapplied, since suffering does not prove a person is under God's displeasure and God may use suffering for good.ST Mar 27, 1893 Statements about God and Job of this kind must therefore be tested against inspired Scripture, since the Lord said these speakers had not told the truth.ST Sep 21, 1904

Human Mortality Affirmed

The verse teaches that man by nature is mortal, not naturally, inherently, unconditionally or by nature immortal.ST May 30, 1895ST Nov 11, 1886RH Mar 10, 1868ST Aug 27, 1894 It calls human beings mortal in contrast with God their Maker, who alone has immortality.ST May 30, 1895ST Nov 11, 1886ST Aug 27, 1894ST Aug 8, 1906 Their only hope of eternal life is in Jesus.

Mortal describes the man himself and the whole person without exception of parts, not merely a body that houses him.RH Jul 12, 1864RH Dec 23, 1862ST Jan 23, 1879ST Jan 10, 1878RH Nov 14, 1871 It means the thinking, intelligent, conscious, responsible part capable of being just or unjust and of transgression, for only that part can be just or unjust.RH Jul 12, 1864RH Jul 29, 1875RH Dec 23, 1862 That living soul is capable of transgression and subject to death, ceases to live and to act when the body dies, returns to dust, and at the resurrection all that is mortal belonging to a person puts on immortality.RH Jul 12, 1864RH Dec 23, 1862RH Nov 14, 1871 The soul or spirit understood as the real person is not inherently immortal, and what is immortal is exempt from death.RH Jul 12, 1864ST Jan 10, 1878 That mortal man dwells in a house of clay creates desire for something better.RH Jul 29, 1875

Mortal humanity is corruptible and frail, in contrast with God who is incorruptible, just and pure and superior to death.ST May 27, 1880ST Oct 11, 1877RH Feb 20, 1872 Fallen human beings are under the sentence of death because sin made them subject to death.ST May 27, 1880ST Oct 11, 1877 After Adam disobeyed he was judged and appointed to die and was no longer fit to endure, and unlike God people do not possess life independently or inherently but depend on God for future life. God alone is inherently immortal, and there is no immortality apart from Christ. Being God's offspring or bearing likeness to God does not give man the Creator's immortality, and the contrast of mortal humanity with God its Maker rejects that inference.ST May 22, 1884ST Apr 26, 1905ST May 22, 1884

Man does not now possess inherent immortality or eternal life and does not possess an inherent deathless principle or immortal soul that survives the stroke of death.ST Aug 12, 1886RH Jul 29, 1875ST Oct 19, 1915ST Apr 14, 1909 At death he passes into unconsciousness until the resurrection, without uninterrupted consciousness after death.ST Aug 12, 1886ST Oct 19, 1915ST Apr 14, 1909 Sheol is a place of silence, secrecy, sleep, rest, darkness, corruption and worms, where man dwelling in houses of clay founded in dust and crushed before the moth lies down in the dust, makes his bed in darkness, says to corruption Thou art my father and to the worm Thou art my mother and my sister, and does not rise, with hope going down to its bars when rest together is in the dust.RH May 5, 1874ST Jun 23, 1881 Belief in natural immortality is mistaken and leaves no true hope, the universal love of life does not prove such an endowment, the doctrine of human consciousness living on after death is in absolute conflict with this plain positive teaching, and eternal life remains a future gift to be given at the revelation of Christ.RH Jul 29, 1875ST Apr 14, 1909 Interpreting the plain declaration of human mortality to mean man is immortal reverses what it says.RH Aug 4, 1874ST Jul 23, 1874 Claiming man is immortal contradicts the verse, proves human mortality is real and not a myth, and repeats Satan's first lie in Eden that sinners shall not surely die.RH Aug 4, 1874ST Dec 30, 1913 The verse by itself does not prove that every part of man is mortal; it can describe the human organization formed from dust as mortal without proving that the breath of life added by God is mortal.RH Feb 14, 1865

Immortality as Conditional Gift

Mortal humanity does not possess life independently, inherently or in a self-sustaining way, but depends on God for future life and continued existence.ST Nov 7, 1892RH Aug 7, 1916RH Mar 16, 1916 Human life continues only through connection with Christ as its source, was conditional on obedience, and sin brings death with subjection to death.RH Aug 7, 1916RH Mar 16, 1916 Life and immortality are two different things, for by nature man is dead in trespasses and sins and has in himself neither life nor immortality.ST Nov 11, 1913ST Nov 11, 1913 Life is received now through believing on Christ, while immortality will be bestowed later at the resurrection of the just when this mortal puts on immortality.ST Nov 11, 1913ST Nov 11, 1913

Immortality is not inherent in man but conditional, something that must be put on and sought through obedience.ST Aug 24, 1915ST Jun 15, 1904ST Nov 11, 1913 It is an attribute belonging to God alone by nature, who alone has immortality, in contrast to human beings as mortal and naturally mortal and subject to death.ST Aug 24, 1915ST Jun 15, 1904ST Dec 13, 1905 Human immortality is made possible only through the gospel and as a gift through faith in Christ.ST Jun 15, 1904ST Dec 13, 1905ST Nov 11, 1913 It is given to the righteous by resurrection or translation at the coming of the Lord and revelation of Christ, with most who receive it receiving it through the resurrection, and only those who have accepted Christ's spiritual character beforehand receiving it.ST Feb 11, 1913ST Aug 24, 1915ST Jun 15, 1904ST Dec 13, 1905ST Nov 11, 1913

Job knew he would die, but his faith rested in God and his trust was not in himself.ST Feb 15, 1899ST Nov 3, 1909 Being reminded of his dying nature as mortal, subject to corruption and death in contrast to God his Maker who is just and pure and superior to death, did not shake him.ST Feb 15, 1899ST Nov 3, 1909 He believed that through his living Redeemer, One superior to death, he would one day receive immortal life as a gift and see God.ST Feb 15, 1899ST Nov 3, 1909 Mortal human beings are not inherently immortal, and their only hope of eternal life is in Jesus.RH May 25, 1916ST Dec 8, 1898 Though mortal and subject to death because they have sinned and were not created with a naturally immortal soul, man is given hope of immortality through the gospel, because Christ truly died and made atonement for sin, abolished death, and brought life and immortality to light.RH May 25, 1916ST Dec 8, 1898

God's Justice and Purity

No mortal can be more just than God or more pure than his Maker, for God himself is the standard of justice and purity which no human being can surpass.ST Jan 10, 1911PGGC 8.1RH Oct 6, 1863ST Nov 15, 1883ST Apr 11, 1878 The regard for justice and purity planted in human hearts proves that God's own justice and purity are not less but infinitely greater and stricter.RH Oct 6, 1863ST Nov 15, 1883ST Jun 1, 1882 Those who come before him owe him greater respect than would be owed to a human commander, and should not knowingly bring bodily filthiness into his presence.ST Apr 11, 1878 The question was joined to Job's account of God speaking through dreams and night visions.PGGC 8.1

The gospel does not set aside or lessen justice, excuse it, or diminish it in the divine government.RH Oct 6, 1863ST Nov 15, 1883ST Jun 1, 1882 God does not commute justice for any reason, and the principles of justice recognized in human governments apply also to his government, and more so.RH Oct 6, 1863ST Nov 15, 1883 Justification by faith does not release a person from works or from obedience to the divine law, but brings him to work, obligates him to work, and fits him to work.ST Nov 15, 1883 Since God planted regard for justice in human hearts, he himself regards it, and all is in favor of strict justice on his part.ST Nov 15, 1883ST Jun 1, 1882

God's condemnation is not unjust, for it results from violating his law, since without law there is no transgression, so the law remains in force and human sin and condemnation arise from breaking it.ST Aug 9, 1905 The comparison also shows that God's dealings are just, for it would be unreasonable to claim that God gives humanity a world without revealing its purpose or what is expected of people, since doing so would make human dealings seem more just than God's.ST Feb 11, 1913

The question came after a spirit passed before the face, the hair of the flesh stood up, a form stood still that could not be discerned, an image was before the eyes, and there was silence and then a voice.RH Dec 15, 1910 Job thought he was about right until that close contact with God, when the awful silence revealed to him an infinitude beyond anything he had ever experienced of everything really desirable in purity and goodness and love.RH Dec 15, 1910 Learning this requires becoming still to listen and sensing helplessness and reaching out, for God can help only the one who senses his helplessness, and the proper response is to accept God's truth rather than reply against him.RH Dec 15, 1910RH Jun 3, 1858 Mortal, sinful people cannot claim to be sinless or justify themselves before God, since their own condition condemns them, and they cannot rightly scorn God's law and expect pardon while defying it through disobedience and teaching others to disobey.ST May 13, 1889ST Nov 13, 1884 Eliphaz appealed to this true fact to overwhelm Job in affliction, but used the truth wrongly to condemn Job whom God had not condemned.ST May 13, 1889

Obedience and Human Pretension

Frail mortal men who dwell in houses of clay, founded in dust, crushed, perishing and dying without wisdom, cannot surpass God in rightness or surpass their Maker in purity.ST Jul 9, 1896 The question condemns men who in the name of the Lord command Sunday rest and worship which God in wisdom did not command.ST Jul 9, 1896 Such lawmaking attempts a work from which God refrained, as if clay dwellers could succeed where God would not act.ST Jul 9, 1896

The same principle exposes the claim that God's Sabbath law was burdensome and had to be replaced or supplemented by human Sunday laws.ST Mar 26, 1885 God specified the seventh day, and human law cannot make an alternative day holy or correct God's provision.ST Mar 26, 1885 Such laws impose unequal burdens on those who keep the Sabbath God appointed, exposing the injustice of human claims to protect others' rights.ST Mar 26, 1885

Human wisdom must not claim to improve on God's work by deciding that a humanly chosen observance would honor Christ better than obedience to God.RH Jan 13, 1852 Amending God's Sabbath command by making the first day a Sabbath on the grounds that Christ's resurrection is more important than creation is challenged by the question.RH Jan 13, 1852 Obedience to God is better than such a humanly devised act of worship.RH Jan 13, 1852

No mortal can claim a stricter standard than God about taking collections or donations on the Sabbath, especially while careless about Sabbath conversation. God who made the Sabbath commanded special offerings on that day, so he is the proper authority on what is permissible. Jesus gave over three years of living examples of proper Sabbath observance, and zeal for God's house and day brings delight in proper Sabbath observance.

The meaning of God's law must not be altered, for the law by which humanity will be judged must be treated with greater care than human laws.ST Feb 24, 1914 Its meaning remains what it was when given, since no mortal can be more just than God.ST Feb 24, 1914 No human league or nation can outdo God in justice in choosing officers and making laws to bring in righteousness.ST Sep 1, 1898

Seeking the reign of what is true, honest, just, pure, lovely and of good report through national citizenship cannot succeed.ST Sep 1, 1898 Even ancient Israel failed under the old covenant when God himself appointed its rulers and gave its laws directly from heaven.ST Sep 1, 1898 God as the standard of purity deserves greater respect than a human commander, so those who come before him should not knowingly bring bodily filthiness into his presence.ST Apr 11, 1878

Sources

  1. ST Signs of the Times, Vol. 34, No. 1 — Christian Science in the Light of Reason and Revelation
  2. ST May 30, 1895 Signs of the Times, Vol. 21, No. 21 — Man Is Mortal May 30, 1895
  3. ST Sep 18, 1884 Signs of the Times, Vol. 10, No. 36 — The Sabbath-School September 18, 1884
  4. RH Aug 7, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 39 — Conditional Immortality August 7, 1916
  5. ST Mar 29, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 13 — NATURE OF MAN March 29, 1905
  6. ST Aug 12, 1886 Signs of the Times, Vol. 12, No. 31 — Immortality a Gift S. P. Bollman, August 12, 1886
  7. ST Nov 11, 1886 Signs of the Times, Vol. 12, No. 43 — Bible Answers to Bible Questions Concerning Man J., November 11, 1886
  8. RH Mar 10, 1868 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 31, No. 13 — DISCUSSION WITH ELD. JOHNSON, Dudley Marvin Canright, March 10, 1868
  9. RH Jul 29, 1875 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 46, No. 5 — Things Written A. H. Vankirk, July 29, 1875
  10. ST Feb 11, 1913 Signs of the Times, Vol. 40, No. 6 — A Bible Study on Man L. A. Reed, February 11, 1913
  11. ST Aug 24, 1915 Signs of the Times, Vol. 42, No. 33 — IS MAN IMMORTAL? George B. Thompson, August 24, 1915
  12. RH May 25, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 26 — Immortality Through Christ L. L. C., May 25, 1916
  13. ST Aug 9, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 32 — FREEDOM FROM CONDEMNATION G., August 9, 1905
  14. ST Jan 10, 1911 Signs of the Times, Vol. 38, No. 2 — OUR BIBLE BAND January 10, 1911
  15. PGGC 8.1 The Prophetic Gift in the Gospel Church — PART ONE John Norton Loughborough, John N. Loughborough, 1901
  16. RH Oct 6, 1863 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 22, No. 19 — The Atonement—Part II John Harvey Waggoner, Third-Day, October 6, 1863
  17. ST Signs of the Times, Vol. 34, No. 28 — Suggestive Notes
  18. RH Jun 24, 1858 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 12, No. 6 — The Richest Man June 24, 1858
  19. RH Dec 15, 1910 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 87, No. 50 — Be Still and Know T. E. Bowen, December 15, 1910
  20. ST Jul 9, 1896 Signs of the Times, Vol. 22, No. 27 — MAKING VOID THE WORD OF GOD W. N. Glenn, July 9, 1896
  21. RH May 5, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 43, No. 21 — Dives and Lazarus John Nevins Andrews, May 5, 1874
  22. ST Jun 23, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 24 — DIVES AND LAZARUS John Nevins Andrews, June 23, 1881
  23. ST May 13, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 18 — QUESTIONS ANSWERED May 13, 1889
  24. ST Nov 3, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 43 — What Is Man? C. P. Bollman, November 3, 1909
  25. ST Mar 27, 1893 Signs of the Times, Vol. 19, No. 21 — LESSON II.—SUNDAY, APRIL 9, 1893 Editor, Monday, March 27, 1893
  26. ST Sep 21, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 37 — JOB F. D. Starr, September 21, 1904
  27. ST Aug 27, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 42 — NATURE OF MAN, AND HIS STATE IN DEATH Ida Hilliard, Monday, August 27, 1894
  28. ST Aug 8, 1906 Signs of the Times, Vol. 32, No. 30 — THE SIGNS OF THE TIMES August 8, 1906
  29. RH Jul 12, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 24, No. 7 — Eld. Cottrell's Second Reply R. F. Cottrell, Third-Day, July 12, 1864
  30. RH Dec 23, 1862 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 21, No. 4 — Scriptural Investigation M. E. Cornell, Third-Day, December 23, 1862
  31. ST Jan 23, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 4 — General Articles Dudley Marvin Canright, January 23, 1879
  32. ST Jan 10, 1878 Signs of the Times, Vol. 4, No. 2 — Discussion at Vacaville William M. Healey, January 10, 1878
  33. RH Nov 14, 1871 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 38, No. 22 — The Destiny of the Wicked D. T. Bourdeau, Third-day, November 14, 1871
  34. ST May 27, 1880 Signs of the Times, Vol. 6, No. 20 — THE SIN OF WITCHCRAFT May 27, 1880
  35. ST Oct 11, 1877 Signs of the Times, Vol. 3, No. 39 — SAMUEL AND THE WITCH OF ENDOR; John Nevins Andrews, Fifth-day, October 11, 1877
  36. RH Feb 20, 1872 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 39, No. 10 — QUESTIONS ON IMMORTALITY William S. Ingraham, February 20, 1872
  37. ST May 22, 1884 Signs of the Times, Vol. 10, No. 20 — Who Only Hath Immortality May 22, 1884
  38. ST Apr 26, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 17 — NATURE OF MAN E. R. Palmer, April 26, 1905
  39. ST May 22, 1884 Signs of the Times, Vol. 10, No. 20 — Who Only Hath Immortality May 22, 1884
  40. ST Oct 19, 1915 Signs of the Times, Vol. 42, No. 41 — ARE THE DEAD CONSCIOUS? G. B. T., October 19, 1915
  41. ST Apr 14, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 15 — The Spirit World and a Future Life Geo. W. Rine, April 14, 1909
  42. RH Aug 4, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 44, No. 8 — The Reasons Why Dudley Marvin Canright, August 4, 1874
  43. ST Jul 23, 1874 Signs of the Times, Vol. 1, No. 5 — The Reasons Why D. M. Canright, July 23, 1874
  44. ST Dec 30, 1913 Signs of the Times, Vol. 40, No. 50 — Christian Science and the Bible James Taphouse, December 30, 1913
  45. RH Feb 14, 1865 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 25, No. 12 — NATURE AND DESTINY OF MAN N. V. Hull, Third-Day, February 14, 1865
  46. ST Nov 7, 1892 Signs of the Times, Vol. 19, No. 1 — MAN IS NOT IMMORTAL George C. Tenney, Monday, November 7, 1892
  47. RH Aug 7, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 39 — Life Only in Christ W. A. Spicer, August 7, 1916
  48. RH Mar 16, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 14 — Life Only in Christ W. A. S., March 16, 1916
  49. ST Nov 11, 1913 Signs of the Times, Vol. 40, No. 43 — Life Through Christ G. B. T., November 11, 1913
  50. ST Nov 11, 1913 Signs of the Times, Vol. 40, No. 43 — Life Through Christ G. B. T., November 11, 1913
  51. ST Jun 15, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 24 — A DEVICE OF THE ADVERSARY June 15, 1904
  52. ST Dec 13, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 50 — IMMORTALITY December 13, 1905
  53. ST Feb 15, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 7 — WHAT IS MAN? C. P. B., February 15, 1899
  54. ST Dec 8, 1898 Signs of the Times, Vol. 24, No. 49 — Immortality Only through Christ December 8, 1898
  55. ST Nov 15, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 43 — Justification and Obedience Editor, November 15, 1883
  56. ST Apr 11, 1878 Signs of the Times, Vol. 4, No. 14 — Victory Alonzo T. Jones, April 11, 1878
  57. ST Jun 1, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 21 — The Law a Perfect Rule of Life Editor, June 1, 1882
  58. ST Feb 11, 1913 Signs of the Times, Vol. 40, No. 6 — The Inheritance of the Righteous John Norton Loughborough, February 11, 1913
  59. RH Jun 3, 1858 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 12, No. 3 — "LET GOD BE TRUE," Rom. iii, 4 June 3, 1858
  60. ST Nov 13, 1884 Signs of the Times, Vol. 10, No. 43 — Contempt for God's Law Editor, November 13, 1884
  61. ST Mar 26, 1885 Signs of the Times, Vol. 11, No. 13 — The Sunday Law Agitation W. N. Glenn, March 26, 1885
  62. RH Jan 13, 1852 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 2, No. 10 — THE SABBATH C. Stowe, January 13, 1852
  63. ST Feb 24, 1914 Signs of the Times, Vol. 41, No. 7 — THE LETTER AND THE SPIRIT OF LAW February 24, 1914
  64. ST Sep 1, 1898 Signs of the Times, Vol. 24, No. 35 — SEEKING RIGHTEOUSNESS W. N. G., September 1, 1898

Cross-references

  1. Romans 3:23

    For all have sinned, and come short of the glory of God;

    Both affirm that all have sinned and fall short of righteousness.

  2. 1 Timothy 6:16

    Who only hath immortality, dwelling in the light which no man can approach unto; whom no man hath seen, nor can see: to whom be honour and power everlasting. Amen.

    Contrasts mortal man with God, who alone has immortality.

  3. 1 Timothy 1:17

    Now unto the King eternal, immortal, invisible, the only wise God, be honour and glory for ever and ever. Amen.

    God is immortal, unlike mortal man.

  4. Job 9:2

    I know it is so of a truth: but how should man be just with God?

    Both ask how a mortal can be just before God.

  5. Ecclesiastes 12:13-14

    Let us hear the conclusion of the whole matter: Fear God, and keep his commandments: for this is the whole duty of man.

    God judges every work by his commandments.

  6. Ezekiel 18:25

    Yet ye say, The way of the Lord is not equal. Hear now, O house of Israel; Is not my way equal? are not your ways unequal?

    The passage quotes the challenge that God’s way is equal, unlike human ways.