John 7:12
And there was much murmuring among the people concerning him: for some said, He is a good man: others said, Nay; but he deceiveth the people.
Translations
And there was much murmuring among the people concerning him: for some said, He is a good man: others said, No; but he deceives the people.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
And there was much murmuring among the people concerning him: for some said, He is a good man: others said, Nay; but he deceiveth the people.
And there was much murmuring among the people concerning him: for some said, He is a good man: others said, No; but he deceiveth the people.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And there was much murmuring among the multitudes concerning him: some said, He is a good man; others said, Not so, but he leadeth the multitude astray.
and there was much murmuring about him among the multitudes, some indeed said — 'He is good;' and others said, 'No, but he leadeth astray the multitude;'
And there was much murmuring concerning him among the crowds. Some said, He is [ a] good [ man]; others said, No; but he deceives the crowd.
and there was great, murmuring, about him among the multitudes: some, indeed, were saying—Good, is he! [but], others, were saying—Not so! but he is leading the multitude astray.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Many in the crowds were whispering about Him. Some said, “ He is a good man.”But others replied, “ No, He deceives the people.”
There was much murmuring among the multitudes concerning him. Some said, “ He is a good man.” Others said, “ Not so, but he leads the multitude astray.”
And there was much discussion about him among the mass of the people. Some said, He is a good man; but others said, No, he is giving people false ideas.
And much murmuring was there of him among the people. Some said, He is a good man: other sayd, Nay: but he deceiueth the people.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And there was much murmuring among the multitude concerning him. For some said: He is a good man. And others said: No, but he seduceth the people.
Cross-references
- John 7:7
The world cannot hate you; but me it hateth, because I testify of it, that the works thereof are evil.
The world hated Jesus because he testified that its works were evil.
- John 7:3-4
His brethren therefore said unto him, Depart hence, and go into Judæa, that thy disciples also may see the works that thou doest.
His brothers challenged him to display his works publicly.
- John 7:1
After these things Jesus walked in Galilee: for he would not walk in Jewry, because the Jews sought to kill him.
Jesus avoided Judea because the leaders sought to kill him.
- John 7:28
Then cried Jesus in the temple as he taught, saying, Ye both know me, and ye know whence I am: and I am not come of myself, but he that sent me is true, whom ye know not.
Christ declares that the Father sent him.
- John 7:37
In the last day, that great day of the feast, Jesus stood and cried, saying, If any man thirst, let him come unto me, and drink.
The same Feast of Tabernacles account continues.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
15 sources
At the Feast of Tabernacles in Jerusalem the people held quiet but earnest debate about Jesus, murmuring among themselves both while he was absent and when he was present.DA 447.1–2DA 4471RED 84.1–3DA 451.3–452.1ST Jun 14, 1877 They were divided, with some declaring him a good man sent by God and others accusing him of misleading the people.Ms 14, 1900, par. 30–34Ms 31, 1889, par. 45–47DA 447.1–2 Although his works testified that his work was from God, fear of the priests, rulers and religious leaders kept many from openly professing faith in him.Ms 14, 1900, par. 30–34Ms 31, 1889, par. 45–47DA 451.3–452.1 Their conflicting verdicts did not make his mission a failure or his teaching false, for those who rejected him were moved by prejudice and unbelief while those who loved truth recognized his righteousness.Lt 189, 1909, par. 12–16RH Feb 24, 1916 That division still sets before all a choice to receive him as God's messenger or to refuse him, and calls his followers to lives shaped by his character and love for one another rather than by criticism and backbiting.STGC 49.1–2Lt 189, 1909, par. 12–16Lt 73, 1900, par. 1
Setting and Divided Response
The murmuring took place at the Feast of Tabernacles in Jerusalem.DA 447.1–2DA 4471RED 84.1–3LC1 84.2 The dispute began while Jesus was still absent, and his absence itself stirred public debate about him.LC1 84.12SP 338.1 When he was present the talk continued as quiet but earnest debate over his character.DA 447.1–2DA 451.3–452.1ST Jun 14, 1877
The crowd was divided, with some calling him a good man in the sense of one sent by God, while others accused him of deceiving or misleading the people.Ms 14, 1900, par. 30–34Ms 31, 1889, par. 45–47LC1 84.12SP 338.11RED 84.1–3 The discussion was at its height when Jesus entered the temple court, and his sudden appearance astonished the crowd and silenced them.LC1 84.2 Although his works testified that his work was from God and many might have accepted him as the Messiah, fear of the religious leaders, priests, rulers, and Jewish authorities kept people from openly professing faith in him or speaking openly in his favor.Ms 14, 1900, par. 30–34Ms 31, 1889, par. 45–47DA 451.3–452.1
Lessons and Present Application
The divided judgments did not make His mission a failure nor prove His teaching false, for those who rejected Him were moved by prejudice and unbelief, while those who loved truth recognized His righteousness.RH Feb 24, 1916 The people stood before His message with a choice to receive Him or to refuse Him, for He came as God's messenger speaking sacred truth.Lt 189, 1909, par. 12–16 Those who refuse Him also refuse to forsake their own way and to practice His virtues.Lt 189, 1909, par. 12–16 The charge that He misled the people echoed the charge that He cast out demons by the power of the prince of demons, and the same kind of false accusation was afterward directed against His apostles.SLP 59.1–2 The division over Him calls His followers to lives shaped by His character rather than by criticism and backbiting, and love for one another is how they show that they are not of the world.STGC 49.1–2 The verse warns against imperiling God's cause and one's own influence through perverted ideas, and the counsel is to follow God and heed His instruction.Lt 73, 1900, par. 1
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
14 sources
At the Feast of Tabernacles the people were divided in their judgment of Jesus, some defending Him as a good man sent by God while others accused Him of misleading and leading the people astray.ST Oct 15, 1896 They expressed their disagreement in quiet murmuring rather than openly, because fear of the Jewish authorities kept them from speaking freely about Him.ST Oct 15, 1896ST Oct 15, 1896 Their conflicting verdicts did not make His mission a failure or His teaching false, for those who rejected Him were moved by prejudice and unbelief while those who loved truth recognized His righteousness.RH Feb 24, 1916 The charge that He deceived the people was itself a deception, since Satan the arch-deceiver persuaded men to accuse Christ the Faithful and True Witness of the very work Satan himself was doing, and the same divided response repeats whenever truth is preached.ST Oct 15, 1896RH May 20, 1858
Feast Setting and Division
The verse belongs to the account of Jesus at the Feast of Tabernacles, one of the three annual feast-days appointed by God, distinct from the weekly Sabbath of the Lord. The feast was kept by living for a week in booths to commemorate dwelling in tents during the wilderness sojourn, and it continued through the last great day of the feast.ST Nov 5, 1896 Afterward every man went to his own house, while Jesus, who had no permanent dwelling, went to the Mount of Olives for solitude and communion with the Father as the shadow of the cross deepened and the climax of His earthly career neared, seeking from the Father the help made necessary by His humanity.ST Nov 5, 1896
The setting is after the Feast of Tabernacles, when opposition had plotted against Him and He had withdrawn to the Mount of Olives before returning to the temple to teach. It is part of a recorded instance of observance of a festival in the seventh month, showing that biblical silence about another religious observance does not prove it was never kept.RH Oct 31, 1854 More fully, it stands inside the account of John 7:2-14, 37 that records the observance of the Feast of Tabernacles, the lesser festival of the seventh month that follows the Day of Atonement by five days.RH Dec 10, 1861 With Ezra, Nehemiah, Kings and Chronicles it shows that the other festivals of the seventh month were repeatedly and particularly recorded while no observance of the Day of Atonement itself is recorded anywhere in the Bible, proving that silence about a holy day does not prove it was not observed.RH Dec 10, 1861
The verse shows the people were divided in judgment concerning Him, with some calling Him a good man and defending Him as sent by God, while others accused Him of deceiving, misleading and leading the people astray.ST Oct 15, 1896ST Nov 17, 1881ST Oct 15, 1896ST Oct 15, 1896 Their conflicting judgments arose as people discussed Him at the opening of the feast. The disagreement was expressed in murmuring rather than openly, because fear of the Jewish authorities kept the people from speaking openly about Him.ST Oct 15, 1896ST Oct 15, 1896
The dispute was at its height when Jesus entered the temple court and taught with striking authority, prompting astonishment at His knowledge of Scripture despite His lack of formal schooling.ST Oct 15, 1896
Meaning, Doctrine, and Application
In the setting of this verse Jesus instructs his hearers, reasons with them from the Scriptures, and then calls upon them to judge and decide with regard to the truth, so that reason and judgment are not laid aside but are made use of and appealed to in order that men may be persuaded to choose the truth.RH Aug 9, 1864 The conflicting verdicts of the people did not make his mission a failure or his teaching false, for those who rejected him were moved by prejudice and unbelief, while those who loved truth recognized his righteousness.RH Feb 24, 1916 The charge that he deceived the people was itself a deception, for Satan the arch-deceiver persuaded men to accuse Christ the Faithful and True Witness of the very deceiving that Satan himself practiced.ST Oct 15, 1896 Even though he was the promised Messiah, men called him a deceiver, and those who had studied the prophecies and professed to long for his coming nevertheless despised and opposed him when he came.RH Jun 27, 1871
That men called him a deceiver, and also a demoniac and a publican and many other names, did not change who he was, for human names do not alter true character, just as calling the seventh day Saturday after the god Saturn does not alter its character as God's holy Sabbath day.ST Apr 30, 1896 The accusation that he deceived the people illustrates the condemnation of Christ in comparison with the Papacy's condemnation of those it called heretics and traitors, in which such labels were used to justify putting them to death.ST Jul 4, 1911 The same divided response repeats whenever truth is preached, with some hearing gladly and searching the Scriptures to see whether it is truth, while others mock and dismiss the messenger as deceiving the people.RH May 20, 1858
Sources