John 7:52
They answered and said unto him, Art thou also of Galilee? Search, and look: for out of Galilee ariseth no prophet.
Translations
They answered and said to him, Are you also of Galilee? Search, and look: for out of Galilee rises no prophet.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
They answered and said unto him, Art thou also of Galilee? Search, and look: for out of Galilee ariseth no prophet.
They answered and said to him, Art thou also from Galilee? Search, and look: for out of Galilee ariseth no prophet.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
They answered and said unto him, Art thou also of Galilee? Search, and see that out of Galilee ariseth no prophet.
They answered and said to him, 'Art thou also out of Galilee? search and see, that a prophet out of Galilee hath not risen;'
They answered and said to him, Art thou also of Galilee? Search and look, that no prophet arises out of Galilee.
They answered and said unto him—Surely, thou also, art not, of Galilee? Search and see! That, out of Galilee, a prophet is not to arise.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
“Aren’ t you also from Galilee?” they replied. “ Look into it, and you will see that no prophet comes out of Galilee.”
They answered him, “ Are you also from Galilee? Search and see that no prophet has arisen out of Galilee.”
This was their answer: And do you come from Galilee? Make search and you will see that no prophet comes out of Galilee.
They answered, and said vnto him, Art thou also of Galile? Searche and looke: for out of Galile ariseth no Prophet.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
They answered, and said to him: Art thou also a Galilean? Search the scriptures, and see, that out of Galilee a prophet riseth not.
Cross-references
- John 7:41-42
Others said, This is the Christ. But some said, Shall Christ come out of Galilee?
Both texts raise Galilee as an objection to the Messiah.
- Micah 5:2
But thou, Beth-lehem Ephratah, though thou be little among the thousands of Judah, yet out of thee shall he come forth unto me that is to be ruler in Israel; whose goings forth have been from of old, from everlasting.
Names Bethlehem as the place from which Israel’s ruler would come.
- John 1:46
And Nathanael said unto him, Can there any good thing come out of Nazareth? Philip saith unto him, Come and see.
Both passages dismiss Jesus because of his Galilean origin.
- Acts 2:5-11
And there were dwelling at Jerusalem Jews, devout men, out of every nation under heaven.
At Pentecost, the apostles spoke to people from many nations in their languages.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
25 sources
Nicodemus had urged that the law requires a fair hearing before judging a man, challenging the effort to condemn and arrest Jesus.STMW9 27.1Lt 55, 1895, par. 56–60Lt 54, 1895, par. 50–54 In reply the rulers turned on him with cutting scorn, asking if he too was from Galilee and telling him to search the Scriptures for proof that no prophet comes from Galilee, using His Galilean association to humble Him as a mere Galilean rabbi and dismiss His claims.DA 455.1–22SP 348.2–349.1ST Jun 3, 1886LC1 93.2–95.1Ms 111, 1897, par. 59–62 Their charge was prejudiced and false, for it treated Jesus as a Galilean when some present knew He was born in Bethlehem yet stayed silent, twisting evidence and Scripture to uphold what they had already decided.Ms 31, 1889, par. 52–56 They made no answer to the demand for fairness, showing hostility and unwillingness to consider Jesus honestly.Lt 376, 1906, par. 3–8Ms 111, 1897, par. 59–62Lt 97, 1895, par. 9–12 Even so, his protest stopped them from condemning Jesus without a hearing, so lacking unanimous agreement they were for the moment defeated and dispersed to their homes.2SP 348.2–349.1LC1 93.2–95.1ST Jun 14, 1877
Context and Wording
The saying belongs to the night the temple officers sent to arrest Jesus came back without him, held by his teaching and by what they had seen of his compassion and authority and his power to set people free from Satan, when the chief priests charged those officers with being deceived, though some rulers themselves believed in him yet would not own it for fear of public reproach.EW 130.2 It was drawn out by Nicodemus, who pressed for a fair hearing on the ground that the law does not judge a man before hearing him, thereby challenging the grounds for condemning and arresting Jesus and opposing the steps being taken to bring about his death.STMW9 27.1Lt 55, 1895, par. 56–60Lt 54, 1895, par. 50–54SPBC 187.2–3 He spoke at the risk of losing his place on the council for his belief in Jesus.5RED 94.3–95.1
The rulers met him with scornful, cutting sarcasm, asking whether he too was from Galilee.2SP 348.2–349.1ST Jun 14, 18771RED 94.2–95.1ST Jan 11, 1877 They took his defense as proof that he also had been deceived.2SP 348.2–349.1 Their question implied that to be from Galilee was to be ignorant.ST Jun 3, 1886
They bade him search and look into the Scriptures and laid it down that out of Galilee arises no prophet.LC1 93.2–95.1ST Jun 3, 1886ST Jan 11, 1877 They used the Galilean association to humble Jesus before the people as a mere Galilean rabbi.DA 455.1–2 By that claim they meant to discredit and dismiss both him and the plea for a fair hearing, in hostility and unwillingness to consider his case fairly.Ms 111, 1897, par. 59–62DA 459.5–460.11RED 94.2–95.12SP 134.1–2
Prejudice and Outcome
The assertion that no prophet arises from Galilee was false and prejudiced, implying Jesus belonged to Galilee when some present knew He had been born in Bethlehem yet stayed silent and let the false claim stand.Ms 31, 1889, par. 52–56 It twisted plain evidence and Scripture to support what was already believed rather than honestly examining the case.Ms 31, 1889, par. 52–56 The reply dismissed Nicodemus's appeal for a hearing before judgment without addressing it, answering his call for fairness with scorn and attack.Lt 376, 1906, par. 3–8Ms 111, 1897, par. 59–62Lt 97, 1895, par. 9–12ST Jun 14, 1877ST Jul 23, 1896 It reflected hostility, prejudice, and unwillingness to consider Jesus fairly, showing the opposition Nicodemus faced in trying to defend Him.Lt 376, 1906, par. 3–8Ms 111, 1897, par. 59–62Lt 97, 1895, par. 9–1212MR 419.2–420.1ST Jul 23, 1896
Those who so answered had received light about Jesus but suppressed conviction and turned from the truth.Lt 97, 1895, par. 9–12ST Jul 23, 1896 Nicodemus himself had received light from Christ and could have searched the prophecies and testified, as the officers had, that no one spoke like Jesus.ST Jul 23, 1896 Yet his words still stopped the council from condemning Jesus without a hearing.2SP 348.2–349.1LC1 93.2–95.1ST Jun 14, 1877ST Jun 3, 1886DA 459.5–460.1 Unable to carry out their plan for lack of unanimous agreement, the rulers were temporarily defeated, dispersed, and went home.2SP 348.2–349.1ST Jun 14, 1877DA 459.5–460.14RED 18.25RED 94.3–95.1
Nicodemus and Joseph had previously prevented condemnation and had protested the grounds for condemning Jesus and for His arrest on other occasions.ST Aug 1, 18785RED 94.3–95.1DA 538.3–539.1 Nicodemus believed in Jesus but risked losing his place on the council if he openly declared his faith.5RED 94.3–95.1 Because the council that sought to silence Jesus was divided, the priests later called a secret meeting without summoning Nicodemus and Joseph and excluded them to reach its aim.ST Aug 1, 18785RED 94.3–95.1DA 538.3–539.1 The conflict over Jesus and rejection by leaders is an experience some of God's people will also face.Lt 376, 1906, par. 3–8
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
19 sources
The rulers answer Nicodemus with cutting sarcasm when he demands that Jesus be heard and judged fairly, asking if he too is a Galilean disciple and telling him to search the Scriptures because no prophet comes from Galilee, so they can dismiss his plea without giving Jesus a hearing.ST Jun 3, 1886ST Oct 29, 1896ST Nov 24, 1881ST Oct 30, 1884RH Jul 1, 1902 Their taunt expresses Judean contempt for humble Galilee and obscure Nazareth as uncultured and incapable of producing a prophet, the Messiah, or anything good.ST Jun 3, 1886ST Feb 8, 1899ST Apr 19, 1883 The proverb is mistaken, for Jonah, Hosea, and Nahum were Galileans, and Jesus sprang as Isaiah's root out of dry ground and was born in Bethlehem the city of David and not in Nazareth.ST Nov 24, 1881ST Aug 6, 1894 It shows how preconceived ideas blinded them to reject Jesus as the Christ on their own interpretation rather than yield to the evidence of prophecy and God's works, stifling conviction and turning from truth.ST Jul 23, 1896RH Apr 15, 1909RH Dec 27, 1853 Their effort to condemn Him without a hearing fails, so the council breaks up without agreement and only later gains its aim in a secret meeting held without summoning Joseph and Nicodemus.ST Jun 14, 1877ST Jun 3, 1886ST Aug 1, 1878
Context and Contempt
The setting is the dispute in the temple during the Feast of Tabernacles, at its close after the last day, that great day of the feast, when the week of living in booths was finished.ST Nov 5, 1896ST Nov 5, 1896 The plotting of the priests and rabbis against Jesus had been defeated by the end of the feast. Then the assembly breaks up with every man going to his own house while Jesus goes to the Mount of Olives.ST Nov 5, 1896ST Nov 5, 1896 He comes early the next morning again into the temple, where all the people come to him and he sits down and teaches them.ST Nov 5, 1896
It is the answer of the Pharisees and rulers to Nicodemus after he protests their condemnation of Jesus.ST Oct 29, 1896ST Oct 30, 1884RH Jul 1, 1902 He appeals to law, justice, and common fairness, asking that the law hear Jesus before judging him.ST Oct 29, 1896 His point is that a man must first be heard and his deeds known before he is judged.ST Jun 14, 1877ST Jun 3, 1886 They use their reply to reject his call for fairness and to dismiss his argument in Jesus' favor and to dismiss Jesus himself rather than answer his demand for a hearing.ST Jun 14, 1877ST Oct 29, 1896ST Oct 30, 1884
They answer with cutting sarcasm and bitter derision.ST Jun 14, 1877ST Oct 30, 1884 They ask if he also is of Galilee, whether he too is from Galilee or came from Galilee.ST Oct 29, 1896ST Oct 30, 1884 They treat his defense as evidence that he too is from Galilee and imply that being from Galilee makes him ignorant.ST Jun 3, 1886ST Jun 3, 1886 They ridicule him and reproach him as if he were a Galilean disciple, as one of their own number who defends Jesus, and treat belief in Jesus as evidence of ignorance.ST Oct 29, 1896ST Nov 24, 1881RH Jul 1, 1902
The question reflects Judean prejudice against Galileans, who were held in low esteem.ST Jun 3, 1886ST Apr 19, 1883 Galileans were looked down on for lack of culture and rough dialect, and humble Galilee and obscure Nazareth were despised.RH Aug 21, 1913ST Aug 6, 1894 It was held impossible for a prophet, the Messiah, his followers, or anything good to come from there.ST Apr 19, 1883ST Aug 6, 1894 That judgment helps explain doubt about the Messiah coming from Nazareth and Nathanael's objection that anything good could come from Nazareth, since Nazareth was a small, obscure village in Galilee.ST Feb 8, 1899ST Aug 6, 1894
False Claim and Lessons
They answered his plea for law and fairness with a command to search and look, laying down as a settled proverb that no prophet arises out of Galilee.ST Jun 3, 1886ST Oct 29, 1896ST Nov 24, 1881ST Oct 30, 1884 The scornful question whether he too was from Galilee treated his defense as proof of ignorance and of discipleship to Jesus, and the proverb was used to dismiss his argument and to reject Jesus rather than to grant the hearing he demanded.ST Jun 3, 1886ST Oct 29, 1896ST Oct 30, 1884RH Jul 1, 1902 Belief in Jesus was in this way made itself evidence of ignorance, and the call for a just hearing was set aside by contempt.ST Nov 24, 1881ST Oct 30, 1884RH Jul 1, 1902
The assertion was mistaken, for Jonah and Hosea and Nahum were Galileans.ST Nov 24, 1881 The proverb helped explain the doubt whether any good thing could come from Nazareth, for Nazareth was a small obscure village in Galilee, and Galileans were despised for lack of culture and rough dialect.ST Aug 6, 1894 Yet Jesus fulfilled Isaiah's image of a root out of dry ground, and he was born not in Nazareth but in Bethlehem, the city of David.ST Aug 6, 1894
Preconceived ideas blinded the Jews so that they wrongly rejected Jesus as the Christ because they believed no prophet had come from Galilee.ST Jul 23, 1896RH Apr 15, 1909RH Dec 27, 1853 They dismissed him on their own confident interpretation rather than yielding to the evidence of prophecy and of God's works, demanding more evidence while resisting the truth.ST Jul 23, 1896RH Apr 15, 1909RH Dec 27, 1853 They stifled conviction and turned from the truth instead of searching the prophecies as Nicodemus might have done.ST Jul 23, 1896RH Dec 27, 1853
Their attempt to condemn Jesus without a hearing failed and left them unable to carry out their plan, and the council dispersed without unanimous agreement to condemn him.ST Jun 14, 1877ST Jun 3, 1886ST Jan 11, 1877 Joseph and Nicodemus had also protested the grounds for condemning him on other occasions, and their opposition kept the council from its aim until the priests held a secret meeting without summoning them.ST Aug 1, 1878 The answer to Nicodemus expressed the bitterness of rulers startled and chagrined that one of their own number defended Jesus, furious toward servants who presumed to think for themselves, toward the believing multitude they called cursed, and toward Nicodemus himself.ST Jul 23, 1896RH Jul 1, 1902ST Oct 29, 1896 Nicodemus had received light from Christ and could have searched the prophecies and testified with the officers that none spoke like Jesus, while other learned and influential believers stifled conviction and would not confess Christ for fear of the priests and rulers and of risking reputation.ST Jul 23, 1896ST Oct 29, 1896RH Aug 21, 1913
Sources