Mark 5:10
And he besought him much that he would not send them away out of the country.
Translations
And he sought him much that he would not send them away out of the country.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible, Revised Version, American Standard Version, Darby Translation
And he besought him much that he would not send them away out of the country.
and he was calling on him much, that he may not send them out of the region.
and he was beseeching him much that he would not send them forth outside the country.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
And he begged Jesus repeatedly not to send them out of that region.
He begged him much that he would not send them away out of the country.
And he made strong prayers to him not to send them away out of the country.
And hee prayed him instantly, that hee would not send them away out of the countrey.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And he besought him much, that he would not drive him away out of the country.
Cross-references
- Matthew 8:31-32
So the devils besought him, saying, If thou cast us out, suffer us to go away into the herd of swine.
The demons ask to enter the swine, and Jesus permits them.
- Luke 8:31-33
And they besought him that he would not command them to go out into the deep.
The demons plead not to be sent away and enter the swine.
- Mark 5:19-20
Howbeit Jesus suffered him not, but saith unto him, Go home to thy friends, and tell them how great things the Lord hath done for thee, and hath had compassion on thee.
Jesus sends the restored man to tell others what God has done for him.
- Mark 5:17
And they began to pray him to depart out of their coasts.
The people ask Jesus to leave after the swine are destroyed.
- Luke 8:32
And there was there an herd of many swine feeding on the mountain: and they besought him that he would suffer them to enter into them. And he suffered them.
The demons beg Jesus to let them enter the swine.
- Mark 5:20
And he departed, and began to publish in Decapolis how great things Jesus had done for him: and all men did marvel.
The healed man proclaims throughout Decapolis what Jesus did for him.
- Matthew 8:29
And, behold, they cried out, saying, What have we to do with thee, Jesus, thou Son of God? art thou come hither to torment us before the time?
A parallel account of the encounter with the demons.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
24 sources
The demons were speaking through the afflicted men as their mediums, begging Jesus earnestly not to drive them out of that country or region, and asking instead to be allowed to enter the great herd of swine feeding nearby on the mountainside, which He permitted.ST Feb 4, 18892SP 311.1–312.23RED 91.1–2ST Feb 4, 1889ST Feb 4, 1889 The account reveals the great cruelty and tormenting power of a legion of evil spirits whom human strength alone cannot overcome, and Christ's supreme power and mercy in commanding them to come out and forcing them to release their victims.GC 514.2–515.1ST Mar 26, 1885Ms 31, 1889, par. 65–66 He let their destructive power fall upon the swine as a rebuke to those raising unclean animals for gain, while He restrained them from harming the keepers and owners and the people.ST Mar 26, 1885GC88 514.2–515.14SP 332.3–333.2 Satan meant the plea to remain and the loss of the herd to hold that region, prevent the preaching of the gospel there, and turn the people from Jesus, so they valued property above deliverance, feared further loss, and asked Him to leave.MH 98.4–52SP 312.3–313.1MH 97.2–98.1 The evil was overruled for good, for the loss roused the whole country to Christ, and though He departed when rejected He left the healed men as witnesses, who told their households and Decapolis what He had done and became the first missionaries there.MH 98.4–5MH 98.2–3DA 340.2–3
The Plea in Context
The voices in the plea were not the men's own, but those of evil spirits speaking through two afflicted men and using them as mediums to communicate with Jesus.ST Feb 4, 18892SP 311.1–312.23RED 86.1–88.2DA 338.2–3 When asked their name they answered through the men that their name is Legion, because they are many.ST Feb 4, 18892SP 311.1–312.23RED 86.1–88.2DA 338.2–3ST Jul 14, 1881 Through the men they besought Him much not to send them away out of the country or district.3RED 86.1–88.23RED 91.1–2DA 338.2–3ST Feb 4, 1889ST Jul 14, 1881 They could not approach Him to make that appeal when He restrained the men.ST Feb 4, 1889
With that plea to remain was joined the request to be allowed to enter a great herd of swine feeding not far distant on the mountainside.ST Feb 4, 18892SP 311.1–312.23RED 86.1–88.2DA 338.2–3 At first, when Jesus commanded the unclean spirits to come out, the men fell at His feet in worship with a dim sense that He could save them from torment, but when they opened their mouths the demons took their voices to utter the plea. That further request to enter the swine Jesus granted and permitted.ST Feb 4, 18892SP 311.1–312.2DA 338.2–3ST Jul 14, 1881
Immediately after permission a panic seized the herd, so they rushed madly and headlong down the steep place and plunged into the sea and lake and perished by drowning.MH 97.2–98.1ST Mar 26, 1885GC88 514.2–515.1DA 338.2–3 At the same moment a marvelous change came over the demoniacs, for they were freed from bondage and left calm, intelligent, mild in countenance, quiet in hands, and beaming with light in mind and eyes.MH 97.2–98.1MH 97.14SP 332.3–333.2DA 338.2–3 Their voices, once seized for the demons' pleading, now praised God for deliverance.MH 97.1DA 338.2–3 Even in driving the swine to destruction the spirits were kept under control, so that the keepers and owners and people were protected from harm.ST Mar 26, 1885GC88 514.2–515.14SP 332.3–333.2
The whole healing of the demoniacs at Gadara recorded in Mark 5:1-20 took place just before Jesus returned to where Jairus met Him.ST Jul 28, 1881
Christ's Power and Purpose
The account displays the great power and cruelty and malice of a legion of evil spirits in seizing control of their victims and tormenting them, and in one telling that legion tormented one person, a work no human wisdom or strength alone can overcome.GC 514.2–515.1ST Mar 26, 1885Ms 31, 1889, par. 65–66 Against that bondage stands Christ's supreme power and mercy, for He commanded the spirits to come out and forced them to release their victims, holding even demonic power under His own control.GC 514.2–515.1ST Mar 26, 1885MH 97.1DA 340.2–3 In freeing the men He also protected the people round about from harm, preserving even the keepers and owners of the swine from the demons' violence.GC 514.2–515.1ST Mar 26, 1885GC88 514.2–515.14SP 332.3–333.2
He permitted the demons' destructive power, once loosed, to sweep the herd of swine into the sea, and that permission was a rebuke to those who were raising the unclean animals for gain.GC88 514.2–515.14SP 332.3–333.2 At the same time He restrained the demons from harming the keepers and owners themselves, so that mercy guarded human life while judgment fell on unlawful gain.GC88 514.2–515.14SP 332.3–333.2 The restored men were left calm and restored, intelligent and mild in countenance and voice, praising God for deliverance from Satan's bondage.GC88 514.2–515.1MH 97.14SP 332.3–333.2
Satan meant the plea to remain in the country and the destruction of the swine to hold that region, to prevent the preaching of the gospel there, and to turn the people from Jesus.MH 98.4–52SP 312.3–313.1ST Feb 4, 1889DA 340.2–3 The loss of property stirred anger and brought Jesus before public notice, and the people valued the loss of the swine more than the men's deliverance.2SP 312.3–313.1MH 97.2–98.13RED 91.1–2 Fearing further financial loss after seeing the healed men, the owners and the Gadarenes asked Jesus to leave, and He departed.2SP 312.3–313.1MH 97.2–98.1ST Feb 4, 18892SP 314.1
The working of evil was overruled for good, for the very loss meant to turn the people away roused the whole country and directed attention to Christ and opened a door to the gospel throughout that region.MH 98.4–5DA 340.2–3 Though Jesus Himself departed when rejected, the demons' request to remain was answered in another way, by leaving the healed men as witnesses to His power.MH 98.4–5DA 340.2–3 They longed to remain near Him, but were sent to tell their households and neighbors and the people of Decapolis how He had freed and saved them, serving as the first missionaries there.MH 97.2–98.1MH 98.2–3ST Aug 4, 1914 When Jesus returned to Decapolis thousands from all the surrounding country flocked to Him and heard the message of salvation, taught by men who had heard little of His teaching and could not instruct as His disciples could, yet could testify to what they had seen and heard and felt of His saving power.MH 98.4–5DA 340.2–3ST Aug 4, 1914 The Gadarenes' rejection warns that concern for worldly interests can lead people to turn Jesus away, and the same full possession that tore and cut the afflicted can control one who gives soul, body and spirit to Satan to rule a husband in mind and body, perverting his senses and poisoning his mind against his brethren and sacrificing his manhood and integrity and turning married life into a reign of terror, until the demon is dispossessed and the character is transformed to sit meekly at the feet of Jesus learning in His school.2SP 314.116MR 307.1
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
66 sources
The plea is made by many evil spirits speaking through the possessed man at Gadara, earnestly begging Jesus not to banish them out of that country but to let them enter the nearby herd of swine instead, which He permitted.ST Feb 4, 1889ST Jan 26, 1915ST Dec 26, 1892ST Oct 21, 1930ST Nov 15, 1910 Their begging shows they recognized His authority to cast them out, and they could go only where He allowed.ST Feb 27, 1907ST Jan 26, 1915ST Mar 14, 1906 The account shows demons are real, personal beings distinct from the man himself, not merely disease, madness, or human nature.ST Feb 4, 1889ST Dec 26, 1892ST Sep 24, 1902RH Oct 13, 1859 It displays the power and compassion of Jesus, who freed the man at once to clear reason and calm mind, and can set at liberty anyone however deeply bound by Satan.RH Oct 30, 1860ST Nov 7, 1900RH Oct 13, 1859 The destruction of the swine was permitted and not forced by Him, but caused by Satan to turn the people away, so that while the demons begged to remain, the people counted the loss greater than the deliverance and begged Jesus to leave their land.ST Feb 4, 1889ST Feb 27, 1907ST Oct 7, 1930ST Nov 15, 1910RH Feb 16, 1905
Setting and Details
The plea belongs to the deliverance of the demon-possessed man in the country of the Gadarenes, also called the country of the Gergesenes in Decapolis.ST Feb 27, 1907ST Nov 7, 1900ST Jul 7, 1898 It took place on the south-east side of the Sea of Galilee, on the shore near a steep slope, where the district of Gadara included Kersa, which explains the different regional names.ST Jul 7, 1898RH May 27, 1858 It happened across the sea from Capernaum, just before Jesus returned to where Jairus met him to heal his dying daughter.ST Jul 28, 1881ST Feb 25, 1897
Mark names one demoniac while Matthew names two, and the one Mark names was the more conspicuous person and spokesman for his companion.ST Feb 4, 1889ST Mar 18, 1889 The demons spoke through the two afflicted men as mediums, taking their voices to communicate with Jesus.ST Feb 4, 1889ST Jul 14, 1881 When Jesus restrained the men the demons could not approach Him, and when the men fell at His feet the demons used their mouths to make the plea.ST Feb 4, 1889
The spirit calls itself Legion because it is not a single spirit but many spirits in one man tormenting and controlling him.RH Nov 11, 1862RH Feb 24, 1859RH Mar 31, 1859RH Sep 8, 1853 The name Legion means many, showing that evil spirits are very numerous and act as messengers of the devil.ST Mar 17, 1887RH Feb 24, 1859RH Aug 28, 1853 Their great number answers that the great number of modern spirit manifestations is no objection to identifying them as lying spirits and not the spirits of the dead, nor the Spirit of God, nor good angels.RH Feb 24, 1859RH Aug 28, 1853
Nearby was a herd of about two thousand swine being carefully fed and watched and kept by their owners.ST Jan 11, 1877RH Aug 4, 1874ST Jul 7, 1898 After Jesus gave leave the herd plunged headlong down the steep place into the sea and perished in the waters, rushing into the lake and drowning.ST Jan 11, 1877RH Aug 4, 1874ST Jul 7, 1898RH May 27, 1858
Meaning of the Plea
The voice begging not to be sent away out of the country is the many evil spirits pleading through the possessed man, distinct from him, begging Jesus much, earnestly and urgently not to banish or drive them out of the country or region.ST Jan 26, 1915ST Dec 26, 1892ST Oct 21, 1930RH Nov 11, 1862ST Nov 15, 1910 Their cry stands in contrast to the people afterward, who begged Jesus to leave their land.ST Oct 7, 1930 The plea not to leave the district is joined to the request to be allowed to enter the nearby feeding herd of swine instead, which Jesus granted and permitted.ST Feb 4, 1889ST Jul 14, 1881ST Oct 21, 1930ST Nov 15, 1910 After He commanded the unclean spirits to come out, the men fell at His feet in worship with a dim sense that He could save them from torment, but when they opened their mouths the demons took their voices to make the plea to remain in that district. The swine at once rushed headlong down the steep place and drowned in the sea, and the men were restored to clear intelligence, calm countenance, and praise for deliverance from demonic bondage, while the people then asked Jesus to leave because they valued the loss of the swine more than the men's deliverance.ST Aug 4, 1914
The demons could go only where Jesus allowed, and their begging and submission show they recognized His power to cast them out and His authority over them.ST Feb 27, 1907ST Jan 26, 1915ST Mar 14, 1906 They showed personal desires and fears, recognized God's authority, and were cast out by His word in a literal account.ST Mar 14, 1906 They resisted leaving the man and sought to remain because Satan wanted to keep his hold on that region and prevent the preaching of the gospel there.ST Nov 15, 1910RH Feb 16, 1905 Their very life is maintained from the vitality they draw from others, having lived upon the life of the demoniac, so when cast out of him they sought another living host on the sin-possessed earth and asked leave to enter the swine, not knowing the effect it would have upon them.ST Feb 27, 1907 The swine became insane and rushed into the sea and perished, but the evil spirits themselves did not perish.ST Feb 27, 1907
The torment among the tombs ended when Jesus drove out the demons and directed the healed man to tell his friends what the Lord had done for him, without explaining the specific reason for the request not to be sent out of the country.ST Jul 30, 1912 The possession was manifested in wild, violent behavior and supernatural strength under the control of evil spirits, and the specific request in the verse is likewise left unexplained.ST Feb 4, 1889
Reality of Evil Spirits
The plea belongs to a literal, miraculous account in which evil spirits, or demons, show themselves as real, personal beings with their own desires and fears.ST Feb 4, 1889ST Sep 24, 1902RH Oct 13, 1859ST Mar 14, 1906ST Oct 8, 1912 Jesus recognized them, spoke to them directly, and by His word cast them out, with the demon called Legion speaking and pleading not to be sent away.ST Feb 4, 1889ST Sep 24, 1902ST Mar 14, 1906 The record is not to be set aside when it conflicts with scientific ideas, nor treated as mere figure of speech for bad habits, personal qualities, disease, or a disordered mind, nor as only an idea or illusion.RH Oct 13, 1859ST Oct 8, 1912
To replace devil or demons here with human nature or an evil principle makes both the plea not to be sent out of the country and the request and entry into the swine nonsensical.RH Jun 26, 1856 The demons speak, plead, and then enter the herd, which proves they are distinct personal beings and not a name for human nature, bad habits, personal qualities, an evil principle, an idea, or an illusion.RH Jun 26, 1856RH Oct 13, 1859
The spirits are distinct from the man himself, speaking and pleading through him while he is enthralled by them.ST Dec 26, 1892RH Oct 13, 1859RH Oct 13, 1859 Jesus could drive them out of the man and send them elsewhere, leaving the man at once restored to himself without a long process of reforming habits, which He could do even though the man himself could not clearly distinguish himself from them.RH Oct 13, 1859RH Oct 13, 1859 The violent, self-destructive behavior could resemble madness, yet possession is not merely disease, insanity from sickness or inherited weakness, or a disordered mind, but control by a demon with the person's will subject to the demon's will, from which Christ can deliver.ST Dec 26, 1892RH Oct 13, 1859RH Oct 13, 1859 Those afflicted in Christ's first advent were insane because they were truly possessed by demons, and many such demon-possessed insane were then present, with many evidences that those afflicted with insanity now are similarly affected.ST Mar 27, 1907
Possession manifests in wild, violent behavior and supernatural strength that no chains could hold, as with the man who lived among the tombs, and Satan by demonic power can gain control of mind and body, drive people into madness and afflict them, and use the possessed to speak and act.ST Jan 17, 1911ST Feb 4, 1889ST Jan 28, 1875 The same irresistible force that held the man could act physically upon animals, driving the herd of swine into the sea.RH Nov 13, 1860 The demons are called Legion because they are many, showing that many devils can act in many places without one personal devil being omnipresent.ST Mar 17, 1887 Their great number also illustrates the many agents of evil standing behind visible human opponents of Christ.ST Mar 17, 1887ST Jan 26, 1915
Christ's Power and Mercy
The deliverance belongs to a portrait of Jesus as a benevolent King who respects others and acts without selfish ambition, displaying both His power and His compassion.RH Oct 30, 1860 The man's bondage under Satan's control shows the extreme power of evil, yet Jesus was able to free him immediately, proving He can save anyone however deeply bound by sin and set a captive soul at liberty. He is ready to free people enslaved by sin, as seen in the country of the Gadarenes, where even one possessed by many demons, by a legion, was restored to sit at Jesus' feet.ST Nov 7, 1900RH Dec 22, 1863
Jesus could drive the spirits distinct from the man himself out of him and send them elsewhere, leaving the man restored to himself at once, without a long process of reforming his habits.RH Oct 13, 1859 The unclean spirits spoke through the two possessed men, using them as mediums, so that when the men fell at His feet in worship with a dim sense He could save them from torment, the demons took their voices to plead to remain in that district, joined to the request to enter the nearby feeding herd, which He granted, whereupon the swine at once rushed headlong down the steep place and drowned in the sea, and the men were restored to clear intelligence, calm countenance, and praise to the Lord for deliverance. They were given reason, freedom, and salvation, sitting clothed and in their right mind, released from demonic control and restored to reason.RH Oct 13, 1859ST Feb 25, 1897 The episode thus exposes the demons' power and malice and Christ's power and mercy in releasing their victims, and the miracle stands as an example of the power of Jesus' faith which His children will have.ST Mar 26, 1885ST May 5, 1914
The power that expelled the evil spirits is His power as Creator to control what He has made, the same power that created heaven and earth, that now upholds the worlds in their places and causes the atoms of matter to cohere, and only one who has power to create can perfectly preserve and control all creation, and that same creative power is the power that redeems.ST Nov 14, 1892 In going to the degraded men among the tombs and casting the unclean spirits out, feeding the hungry, healing sickness, and pointing to the way of life, He shows He mingles freely with all classes even the most degraded and uses every opportunity to help them.RH Jan 8, 1914 This proves He is no respecter of persons but labors to save high and low, rich and poor, without making any difference, because He loves the sinner and the outcast as much as anyone else, while sin itself is still hated.RH Jan 8, 1914
His intervention also protected the people from harm when the demons departed to the destruction of the swine.ST Mar 26, 1885 He restrained the demons from also killing the swine's keepers and owners, even as the destruction rebuked those raising swine for gain and the people valued their financial loss above the blessing of Christ's deliverance, allowing Satan to use their blame of Jesus to stir selfish fear and keep them from hearing Him.RH Nov 8, 1906
Swine and People's Response
Jesus gave the demons leave to enter the swine and only permitted the destruction that followed; He is not responsible for their drowning, for it was Satan who caused it to turn the people away from the Saviour.ST Feb 27, 1907RH Feb 16, 1905 Knowing beforehand that the swine, about two thousand in number, would immediately rush into the sea and all perish, He destroyed eight or ten thousand dollars worth of another man's property whose carcasses were not even saved, purposing on purpose to show His abhorrence of the unclean dirty scavenger full of trichina and scrofula and to teach the owners, who were Jews not living according to God's law, that in violation of that law they ought not to rear, feed and deal in swine.ST Feb 27, 1907ST Jan 11, 1877 The loss was permitted in mercy to owners absorbed in earthly things and caring nothing for spiritual life, to rebuke raising swine for gain, while Christ restrained the demons from also killing the swine's keepers and owners, and the event roused the whole country as nothing else could have done and directed attention to Christ.RH Feb 16, 1905RH Nov 8, 1906
Though the people saw the demoniacs delivered, clothed and in their right mind sitting at the feet of Jesus and listening to His words, with the demons' power and malice exposed, they counted the loss of the swine of greater moment than the deliverance of these captives of Satan.ST Feb 4, 1889RH Feb 16, 1905RH Nov 8, 1906 They feared financial loss, blamed Jesus, and were frightened by the destruction that the demons drove upon the swine.ST Feb 4, 1889RH Jan 8, 1875RH Nov 8, 1906 In contrast to the demons' plea to remain and not to be driven out of the region, the people begged Jesus to leave their land and country.ST Feb 4, 1889ST Oct 7, 1930ST Nov 15, 1910 With Satan's use of selfish fear and blame, the destruction helped turn them against Him and kept them from hearing Him, while the healed man alone longed for Jesus.ST Feb 4, 1889RH Jan 8, 1875RH Nov 8, 1906
The healing shows Jesus did not require even mad men to believe in or acknowledge Him as Messiah before healing them.ST Nov 1, 1910 The restored men were sent as the first missionaries to Decapolis to go home to friends and testify to what they had seen, heard and felt of His saving power and what the Lord had done for them.ST Aug 4, 1914ST Jul 30, 1912RH Sep 29, 1910ST Nov 15, 1910 Though they had heard little of Christ's teaching and could not instruct others as His disciples could, they could bear that testimony.ST Aug 4, 1914 Their favorable reports spread through Decapolis and probably helped Jesus receive a warm welcome there when He returned.ST Sep 22, 1881
Doctrinal Lessons and Application
The many spirits in the one man show that evil spirits are very numerous, so the great number of modern spirit manifestations is no objection to identifying them as lying spirits, the messengers of the father of lies.RH Feb 24, 1859RH Aug 28, 1853 They are not the spirits of the dead, nor the Spirit of God, nor good angels.RH Feb 24, 1859 The unclean spirit that called itself Legion because it was many supports comparison with the unclean spirits of the dragon, beast, and false prophet.RH Sep 8, 1853 The entering of evil spirits into people in Christ's time shows that spirits of devils are more than mere deception or humbug.ST Aug 24, 1888
The demoniac's resistance pictures sinners living under Satan's power who cry to be left alone.ST Feb 4, 1889 Like the man among the tombs they are spiritually degraded, yet Jesus has compassion on them, and when anything in them responds to His love He rebukes the evil power and gives them power to become God's children.ST Feb 4, 1889 His casting out of the spirits and the man's deliverance brings sunshine into a darkened life, illustrating that decisive reform can bring relief while regenerating grace is still needed.RH Apr 21, 1868
The man's full surrender, so that Satan used him to the fullest extent and spoke and pleaded through him not to be sent away out of the country, shows what happens when God's message is rejected and souls surrender without doubt to seducing spirits and doctrines of devils.ST Apr 10, 1907 Then Satan can use them completely as his instruments, even speaking through them with tongues and with signs and wonders on the wrong side in the final conflict.ST Apr 10, 1907 The bondage of the men at Gadara wandering among the tombs compares to enslavement by drink, and alcohol is a means by which the prince of evil gains entrance into people today.ST Sep 5, 1900ST Nov 29, 1899
The account gives a parallel for one believed possessed whom the Lord set free.RH Feb 25, 1915 It also gives a touching lesson in which the twelve learned to distinguish common natural selfishness and harshness from proud perverted fanaticism.ST Aug 4, 1881RH Aug 7, 1913 That lesson came after long wanderings and continuous trials and brought the apostles to modest self-distrust over their faint-heartedness, irresoluteness, and want of faith, fitting them to rise from dependent followers to co-workers with Jesus in spreading the kingdom.ST Aug 4, 1881
Sources