Translations
American King James Version, Webster Bible
But as for you, your carcasses, they shall fall in this wilderness.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
But as for you, your carcases, they shall fall in this wilderness.
But as for you, your carcases shall fall in this wilderness.
American Standard Version, World English Bible
But as for you, your dead bodies shall fall in this wilderness.
as to you — your carcases do fall in this wilderness,
And as to you, your carcases shall fall in this wilderness.
But, your own dead bodies, shall fall in this desert;
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
As for you, however, your bodies will fall in this wilderness.
But as for you, your dead bodies will be stretched in this waste land.
But euen your carkeises shall fall in this wildernes,
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Your carcasses shall lie in the wilderness.
Cross-references 20 of 45
- Hebrews 3:17-19
But with whom was he grieved forty years? was it not with them that had sinned, whose carcases fell in the wilderness?
The wilderness generation’s sin and unbelief led to death and barred them from entering God’s rest.
- Numbers 13:32-33
And they brought up an evil report of the land which they had searched unto the children of Israel, saying, The land, through which we have gone to search it, is a land that eateth up the inhabitants thereof; and all the people that we saw in it are men of a great stature.
The spies’ fearful report of Canaan’s giants preceded Israel’s rebellion and wilderness sentence.
- Numbers 14:2
And all the children of Israel murmured against Moses and against Aaron: and the whole congregation said unto them, Would God that we had died in the land of Egypt! or would God we had died in this wilderness!
Their wish to die in the wilderness is fulfilled in the sentence.
- 1 Corinthians 10:11
Now all these things happened unto them for ensamples: and they are written for our admonition, upon whom the ends of the world are come.
wilderness as warning example
- Numbers 14:10
But all the congregation bade stone them with stones. And the glory of the LORD appeared in the tabernacle of the congregation before all the children of Israel.
The congregation threatens to stone Joshua and Caleb for their truthful report.
- Numbers 14:40-45
And they rose up early in the morning, and gat them up into the top of the mountain, saying, Lo, we be here, and will go up unto the place which the LORD hath promised: for we have sinned.
Israel goes up despite Moses’ warning and is defeated.
- Deuteronomy 1:34-40
And the LORD heard the voice of your words, and was wroth, and sware, saying,
God condemns the unbelieving generation to die in the wilderness and bars them from the promised land.
- Numbers 14:24
But my servant Caleb, because he had another spirit with him, and hath followed me fully, him will I bring into the land whereinto he went; and his seed shall possess it.
Caleb’s wholehearted loyalty distinguishes him from the condemned generation and earns entry into the land.
- Hebrews 4:8
For if Jesus had given them rest, then would he not afterward have spoken of another day.
Israel’s failure warns against missing God’s promised rest through unbelief.
- Numbers 26:65
For the LORD had said of them, They shall surely die in the wilderness. And there was not left a man of them, save Caleb the son of Jephunneh, and Joshua the son of Nun.
Confirms the condemned generation died in the wilderness, except Caleb and Joshua.
- Psalms 95:8-11
Harden not your heart, as in the provocation, and as in the day of temptation in the wilderness:
Recalls Israel’s wilderness rebellion and God’s refusal to let that generation enter his rest.
- Hebrews 3:7-11
Wherefore ( as the Holy Ghost saith, To day if ye will hear his voice,
Israel’s wilderness rebellion led to God’s judgment that they would not enter his rest.
- Numbers 13:30-31
And Caleb stilled the people before Moses, and said, Let us go up at once, and possess it; for we are well able to overcome it.
Caleb urged them to take the land, but the people’s rejection led to their fall.
- Numbers 14:19-20
Pardon, I beseech thee, the iniquity of this people according unto the greatness of thy mercy, and as thou hast forgiven this people, from Egypt even until now.
Moses pleads for pardon, and God grants it while judgment remains.
- Numbers 14:4
And they said one to another, Let us make a captain, and let us return into Egypt.
The people’s plan to choose a captain and return to Egypt brought the sentence.
- Numbers 14:22-23
Because all those men which have seen my glory, and my miracles, which I did in Egypt and in the wilderness, and have tempted me now these ten times, and have not hearkened to my voice;
The rebellious generation is barred from seeing the promised land.
- 1 Corinthians 10:5
But with many of them God was not well pleased: for they were overthrown in the wilderness.
Both describe Israelites falling in the wilderness under God’s displeasure.
- Numbers 13:32
And they brought up an evil report of the land which they had searched unto the children of Israel, saying, The land, through which we have gone to search it, is a land that eateth up the inhabitants thereof; and all the people that we saw in it are men of a great stature.
The evil report brought the sentence of death in the wilderness.
- Hebrews 4:1-3
Let us therefore fear, lest, a promise being left us of entering into his rest, any of you should seem to come short of it.
Israel’s wilderness failure warns against falling short of the promised rest through unbelief.
- Numbers 13:25
And they returned from searching of the land after forty days.
The forty days of spying correspond to forty years of wilderness wandering.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
28 sources
God Himself, present in Christ, sentenced the rebellious generation addressed to die in the wilderness, their bodies falling and being buried there instead of entering and possessing the promised land.15MR 292.1–215MR 289.1–290.3PP 387.2–3 The sentence fell after the fearful report of the spies, when the people refused to trust Him to conquer Canaan, believed the faithless spies, sided with rebellion, sought to stone the faithful witnesses and sought to return to Egypt.CNA 124.415MR 289.1–290.3ST Oct 21, 1880 It rested upon all who were numbered from twenty years old and upward who murmured against Him, with only Caleb and Joshua excepted and spared, while the little ones said to be a prey would be brought in to know the despised land.Lt 106, 1897, par. 10–201SP 293.2–294.1RH May 20, 1902 He did to them as they had spoken in His ears in wishing to die in the wilderness, after they had seen His glory and miracles in Egypt and in the wilderness yet tempted Him ten times and would not hearken to His voice, so though Moses interceded and He pardoned them from pestilence and disinheritance, the adult tempters would not see the land sworn to their fathers.Lt 106, 1897, par. 10–201SP 293.2–294.1PP 391.2–3RH May 20, 1902 Their children must wander forty years and bear their unfaithfulness until the bodies were wasted, a year for each day of searching the land, proving His promises are upon condition of obedience, and the same history is re-enacted today when professed Israel refuses faithful reports and true counsel and perishes by the same unbelief.Lt 106, 1897, par. 10–204T 154.3–155.2PP 391.2–3PP 391.4–392.1PP 417.4
Sentence on Faithless Generation
But as for you, your carcasses shall fall in this wilderness is God's own sentence upon the rebellious Israelites addressed, spoken by Christ, that they would die in the wilderness with their bodies falling and being buried there instead of entering and possessing the promised land.15MR 292.1–215MR 289.1–290.3PP 387.2–34T 152.3Ms 110, 1899, par. 15
The sentence came after the spies' evil and fearful report, when the people refused to trust God to conquer Canaan, believed the faithless spies, sided with rebellion inspired by Satan, sought to stone the faithful witnesses, and sought to return to Egypt.Lt 106, 1897, par. 10–2015MR 289.1–290.3ST Oct 21, 1880Ms 135, 1899, par. 17Ms 11, 1903, par. 6–8
It applies to all who were numbered from twenty years old and upward who murmured against God, with only Caleb son of Jephunneh and Joshua son of Nun excepted and spared, while the little ones whom they said would be a prey would be brought in to know the land they had despised.Lt 106, 1897, par. 10–201SP 293.2–294.1RH May 20, 19024T 152.3Ms 11, 1903, par. 6–8
God did to them as they had spoken in His ears when they wished they had died in the wilderness, so their death there fulfilled their own wish and their murmuring against God and against their leaders.1SP 293.2–294.1PP 391.2–3RH May 20, 1902Ms 144, 1903, par. 10–13
The judgment came after great light and deliverance, when those who had seen His glory and miracles in Egypt and in the wilderness tempted Him ten times and did not hearken to His voice, passing the boundary of His forbearance.Lt 106, 1897, par. 10–20RH May 20, 1902 Though Moses interceded, God pardoned them from being smitten with pestilence and disinherited, yet the adult tempters would not see the land sworn to their fathers.Lt 106, 1897, par. 10–20RH May 20, 1902
Their children would wander forty years and bear their whoredoms until the carcasses were wasted, each of the forty days of searching the land counted for a year, so they would know His breach of promise and the altering of His purpose, proving His promises are upon condition of obedience.Lt 106, 1897, par. 10–20PP 391.2–3PP 391.4–392.1
Because their hearts were filled with bitter murmurings they were in no fit state to appreciate what God would do for them, would not sanctify Him in their hearts and give Him glory, and a display of His power against their enemies would only fill them with pride and self-importance.ST Sep 2, 1880 So He mercifully turned them back to enclose them where they would see neither city nor town until the continual murmurers died, and the perishing of the ten unfaithful spies before their eyes signified the destruction of all above twenty whose unbelief and rebellion cost them all.ST Sep 2, 1880
The forty years of weary wandering need not have happened and was not an unnecessary delay but followed their cowardly rebellion.CNA 124.4ST Oct 21, 1880Ms 135, 1899, par. 17 God had brought them from bondage to give them Canaan including Jericho forty years before its capture, but wicked murmurings, jealousy, insulting unbelief, rejection of His guidance through Moses, and indulgence of appetite provoked His wrath and forfeited the gift, and their later complaints showed they still distrusted His dealings.ST Oct 21, 18804T 162.1LC1 142.1–3Ms 144, 1903, par. 10–13
Had Israel obeyed, Christ present in the camp as general with heaven's army of angels would have led them safely into Canaan long before, as was later shown when Jericho's walls were leveled without human power and its capture declared their fathers might have possessed it forty years before had they trusted as their children did.4T 162.1Ms 135, 1899, par. 17Ms 144, 1903, par. 10–13
After God declared the forty years they tried too late to enter Canaan by reversing course.CNA 124.4Ms 110, 1899, par. 15 Moses distinctly warned them God would not be with them, but they went up presumptuously contrary to direction and were defeated by their enemies.CNA 124.4Ms 110, 1899, par. 15 Their grief over losing the land was sorrow for the judgment, not repentance that could reverse the sentence.PP 391.4–392.1
Denial and Warning Today
The sentence that the carcasses would fall in the wilderness is the word of God Himself spoken through Moses, and it must be received as true.3T 351.13T 347.2–348.1 Dathan and Abiram with their followers, and Korah with his company, refused to believe that God had said they would die in the wilderness and not enter the promised land, claiming Moses alone had said it and not the Lord, and dismissing it as imposture and deception.3T 351.13T 347.2–348.1SG4 29.2–30.1SG4 33.1 They twisted that judgment into charges that Moses was the cause of their not entering Canaan, had arranged never to bring them there, had prevented their inheritance, had brought them out of Egypt—which they called a land flowing with milk and honey—to kill them in the wilderness to enrich himself with their possessions, and had caused the deaths of Korah and his company, and by this denial they utterly refused the authority of Moses and Aaron.3T 347.2–348.1SG4 29.2–30.13T 346.2SG4 33.1 Korah, Dathan, and Abiram turned the judgment into a charge that Moses had designed it himself from selfish interest in order to come into possession of their property.3T 346.2
Korah and his company had flattered the people that they were good people wronged by Moses, leaving their minds filled with the rebellious spirit and blind prejudice of those who had perished, so that they were unwilling to believe and submit to the sentence.3T 351.1 Their broken ranks and dwindling numbers stood before them as visible signs of the doom God had pronounced, yet the people failed to learn from them and again rebelled by blaming Moses for it.3T 351.1PP 396.1 When at last fully convinced of their wrong in unjustly accusing Moses and Aaron and seeing their past rebellion in its true light, they were terrified and compelled to believe the unwelcome fate, crying out that they die and perish.1SP 306.1 Believing the sentence led them to acknowledge that Moses and Aaron were right, to confess they had sinned against the Lord in rebelling against their authority, and to confess that Korah and those who perished with him were sinners against the Lord who had justly suffered His wrath.1SP 306.1SG4 35.1
The first generation was condemned to perish in the wilderness by unbelief, and the same spirit of unbelief appeared among their children.PP 417.4 The verse shows the end of those who join in cowardly complaining and draw back from action when risks must be met, refusing faithful reports and true counsel.4T 154.3–155.2 Ancient Israel was repeatedly tested and found wanting, few received the faithful warnings given them of God, and the cowards and rebels perished in the wilderness while the faithful like Caleb and Joshua were spared.4T 154.3–155.2
The same history is re-enacted among professed Israel today whose minds have been enlightened by divine wisdom, with the same unwillingness to heed faithful reports and true counsel manifested.4T 154.3–155.2 God's burden-bearing servants who bear the burden of His cause with strict self-denial and suffering privation for the sake of helping His people are seldom better appreciated, and because those chosen to conduct His work will not turn from integrity to gratify the selfish and unconsecrated they become the target for hatred and malicious falsehood.4T 154.3–155.2 Though the Lord has long borne with His people, forgiven their wanderings, and waited for them to give Him room in their hearts, false ideas, jealousy, and distrust have crowded Him out.4T 154.3–155.2 As the time of the second advent nears darkness and unbelief do not decrease, truth becomes less palatable to the carnally minded, hearts are slow to believe and tardy to repent, few dare come boldly forward as Caleb did and stand firmly for God and the right, while Satan is wide awake and working warily in these last days, calling for men of spiritual nerve and stamina to resist his artifices.4T 154.3–155.2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
68 sources
God swore with a solemn oath that all who were numbered from twenty years old and upward and murmured against Him would fall dead in the wilderness and never set foot in the good land promised to their fathers, with only Caleb and Joshua excepted for wholly following Him.ST May 31, 1899RH Sep 14, 1916ST May 13, 1889ST Jun 23, 1881RH Nov 9, 1916
The sentence came at Kadesh-barnea after the ten spies brought a fearful report and the people sided with them against Caleb and Joshua, choosing to appoint a captain to return to Egypt and seeking to stone those who urged trust in God.ST May 31, 1899RH Nov 9, 1916ST Sep 12, 1900RH Jan 12, 1869ST Jul 14, 1881
Its root cause was unbelief and hardness of heart, putting sight of walled cities and giants above the promise and the wonders shown in Egypt and the wilderness.RH Sep 14, 1916ST Apr 10, 1893RH Dec 27, 1906ST Sep 12, 1900RH Jul 29, 1873
Each of the forty days spent exploring the land was answered by a year of wandering, so the journey that could have taken a few days became forty years until that murmuring generation died.RH Sep 14, 1916ST May 13, 1889RH Dec 27, 1906
The land denied is the rest of God in Psalm 95, not the seventh-day Sabbath, for the rebels all had the Sabbath yet did not enter it, leaving a rest still remaining for the faithful.RH Jul 20, 1869ST Jun 23, 1881RH May 11, 1869
As hundreds and thousands who crossed the Red Sea fell through murmuring and unbelief, so those who now reject truth, talk discouragement, and turn back toward Egypt will wander and die in the wilderness of sin instead of entering the Promised Land.RH Oct 8, 1908RH Oct 19, 1905RH May 28, 1867RH Oct 29, 1903RH Sep 26, 1854
Setting and Divine Sentence
The sentence was spoken by the Lord to Moses and Aaron at Kadesh-barnea close to the border of the promised land in the second year, after eleven marching days from Sinai and after forty days spent exploring the land.RH Nov 9, 1916ST Jul 14, 1881ST Jan 30, 1907 At that trial Israel almost as one man broke out in rebellion upon the report of the spies, revealing evil hearts of unbelief unprofited by God's dealings.RH Nov 9, 1916ST Jul 14, 1881 Instead of an eleven days' journey to the land flowing with milk and honey in glad faithful worship, following where God led and resting where His presence indicated, their course was marked by carnal lustings, idolatries, provocations and murmurings, so the journey became a crooked, weary wandering of thirty-eight long years till they died by the way.ST Jan 30, 1907
At the borders of Canaan the people sided with the ten spies against Caleb and Joshua, voted to choose a captain and return to Egypt, and took up stones to stone Caleb and Joshua.ST May 31, 1899RH Nov 9, 1916 They wished they had died in the wilderness, said they could not take the land, trusted in the wisdom of returning to Egypt, and chose fear of circumstances over trust.RH May 20, 1902ST Sep 12, 1900ST Dec 2, 1886ST Nov 24, 1887 They did this forgetting their covenant-keeping and wonder-working power shown in Egypt and the wilderness, in spite of wonderful proof of fertility in the cluster of grapes carried on a staff and a land flowing with milk and honey, and in spite of the faith urged by the other two spies.RH May 20, 1902ST Sep 12, 1900RH Jul 29, 1873 They had seen His glory and miracles in Egypt and in the wilderness and had tempted Him ten times, yet they rejected His leadership and the leadership of those He had chosen.RH May 20, 1902RH Nov 9, 1916RH Jan 12, 1869
The doom that their carcasses should fall in the wilderness was pronounced by God, not by Moses on his own.RH Nov 12, 1903RH Nov 9, 1916 Moses led them only by directions received from Christ, the invisible leader and Angel of the covenant veiled by the cloudy pillar and the pillar of cloud and fire that had led the divinely started movement out of Egypt toward the Land of Promise.RH Nov 12, 1903RH Nov 9, 1916 Through the earnest intercession of Moses the people escaped for the time being smitten with pestilence and disinherited.RH May 20, 1902RH Aug 7, 1866 Moses pleaded on the ground of the honor of the Lord's name and the renown gained by bringing Israel out of Egypt with a mighty hand, lest abandoning them to perish would cause His name to be reproached and blasphemed among the heathen.RH Aug 16, 1870ST Oct 11, 1877ST Feb 9, 1882 God is not moved by ambition and vainglory, but He accepts prayer that asks Him to act for His own glory rather than personal benefit, shown in jealousy for His honor and love for Him.RH Aug 16, 1870ST Oct 11, 1877ST Feb 9, 1882
The ten unfaithful spies died by plague before the congregation, signifying the destruction of all in their ranks above twenty years of age.ST Sep 2, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873 The people's later attempt to go up and possess the place promised, against God's direct prohibition and without His presence, had no warrant from God and was only a new phase of the same unbelief.RH Aug 7, 1866RH Sep 26, 1854 That presuming ascent was defeated and smitten by the Amalekites and Canaanites, for the God who divided the sea, overthrew Egypt, brought water from the rock, and fed the multitude would not go with Israel to battle when they murmured.RH Aug 7, 1866ST Nov 24, 1887ST Mar 18, 1875 The passage belongs to the account of the spies and to the wanderings and murmurings of the children of Israel, presented as sad but important lessons.ST Mar 4, 1913ST Feb 20, 1912
Cause in Unbelief
The sentence of death in the wilderness fell because the heart had hardened in unbelief, a refusal to trust God's ability and willingness to lead safely into Canaan and a choice of the spies' fearful report over God's promise.RH Sep 14, 1916ST Apr 10, 1893RH Dec 27, 1906RH Feb 24, 1916 That unbelief is a sin abhorrent to God, with moral bearing on character and destiny and for which man is responsible.RH Dec 27, 1906RH Feb 24, 1916 For it the numbered generation from twenty years old and upward that murmured was condemned to die without entering the promised land, while Caleb the son of Jephunneh and Joshua the son of Nun were excepted for faithfulness and the little ones and younger generation would be brought in after forty years of wandering to know the land despised.RH Sep 14, 1916RH Nov 9, 1916ST Apr 10, 1893 The forty days spent exploring were answered by forty years, so a journey that could have taken only a few days was prolonged by thirty-eight years, and the later census confirmed the judgment had been carried out with only the two exceptions remaining alive.RH Sep 14, 1916RH Dec 27, 1906
That unbelief broke out as rebellion in a peevish, fretful, murmuring spirit under trials in the wilderness.RH Jun 26, 1860ST Jul 31, 1901RH Mar 13, 1866 It showed itself in persistent longing for Egypt and desire to live like the world, longing for Egypt's food and gods, worship of the golden calf, idolatry and Sabbath-breaking, despite God's care and miracles and deliverance from Egyptian tyranny and the overthrow of Pharaoh.RH Apr 17, 1879RH Jan 12, 1869RH Jan 7, 1862RH Jan 7, 1862 In God's sight such murmuring is great sin, and Christians who meet little trials in families and from other sources commit as much sin by peevishness and fretfulness and murmuring as Israel did.RH Jun 26, 1860 Every trial, affliction and pain is sent for good and for sanctification, so to rebel and murmur at a hard lot is to murmur because God is answering prayer for sanctification.RH Jun 26, 1860 The rebellion prolonged the stay many long years when a few months could have sufficed to pass from Egypt to Canaan if they had obeyed, the children witnessed those murmurings for forty years and felt the results, and the murmuring even caused Moses to sin so that Moses, the man fittest to lead into Canaan, was taken from them.RH Apr 17, 1879RH Mar 13, 1866
The people put circumstances before the Lord and looked with physical sight only.ST Sep 12, 1900ST Aug 13, 1902 They had wonderful proof of fertility in the cluster of grapes carried on a staff between two men and in a land flowing with milk and honey, yet above those assurances they saw only strongly fenced high-walled cities, very numerous inhabitants, and sons of Anak and giants in whose sight they were as grasshoppers.ST Sep 12, 1900RH Jul 29, 1873ST Aug 13, 1902RH Sep 8, 1874 Looking then on their own small stature and the way-worn host from Egypt with women and children, with weary feet and fearful hearts, they lost heart to go farther.RH Jul 29, 1873ST Aug 13, 1902RH Sep 8, 1874 Caleb and Joshua kept the obstacles and difficulties outside, refused to let the Anakim and great cities blot out sight of the Lord, declared that the Lord was with them, and remained calm and restful in spite of the foe, but the counsel of the ten prevailed and melted the heart of the people through forgetting their covenant-keeping and wonder-working Jehovah and all He had done.ST Sep 12, 1900RH Jul 29, 1873RH Feb 28, 1907 Because those who murmured chose fear of circumstances over trust, the ten discouragers died by plague before the congregation and the whole discouraged multitude fell in the wilderness, an example upon whom the ends of the world are come that to talk discouragement when God is on the side of His workers is sinful and loses His favor.ST Sep 12, 1900RH Jul 29, 1873
In the same unbelief they rejected those God had chosen to lead and rejected His arrangements and word.RH Nov 9, 1916RH Mar 7, 1907RH Apr 9, 1901 They rebelled against Moses whom God had appointed to lead the movement divinely started and divinely led by pillar of cloud and fire out of Egypt toward the Land of Promise, and refused to follow God's direction and submit to His arrangements.RH Nov 9, 1916RH Mar 7, 1907RH Apr 9, 1901 They resented and opposed Caleb and Joshua for urging confidence in God when truth was unpopular, choosing fear and discouragement after the report of high walls and giants.ST Sep 12, 1900RH Feb 28, 1907 Their fate warns later generations not to repeat that unbelief and not to fail to support those chosen to lead God's work.RH Feb 28, 1907RH Apr 9, 1901RH Jul 30, 1914 Terrible results come to individuals who so rebel, yet the nation God brought out still goes into Canaan, for He does not abandon it to start another, and those who in difficulties keep faith and stay with the movement go into the Promised Land.RH Nov 9, 1916
Scope and Duration
With a solemn oath God sentenced all who were numbered from twenty years old and upward who murmured to have their carcasses fall in death in the wilderness and never to come into the good land sworn for them to dwell in.ST May 31, 1899ST Jun 23, 1881RH Nov 9, 1916RH May 11, 1869RH Apr 8, 1858 They would never set foot on the soil of that land nor see the land sworn to their fathers, but would die there instead of entering what had been promised them.ST Jul 14, 1887RH May 11, 1869ST Jul 14, 1881RH Apr 8, 1858 Their death excluded them from the land-possession and rest that God later gave Israel through Joshua.ST Jun 23, 1881RH May 11, 1869
Only Caleb the son of Jephunneh and Joshua the son of Nun of that numbered generation were excepted, because they wholly followed the Lord and remained faithful when the people opposed them.ST May 31, 1899RH Nov 9, 1916ST Jul 14, 1887ST Dec 2, 1886RH Apr 8, 1858 Their little ones, whom they feared would be a prey and be taken captive, and the younger generation would be brought in to know the land they had despised.RH Sep 14, 1916ST May 13, 1889RH Nov 9, 1916 The judgment followed refusal to trust God and go up to possess the land, and after forty years of wandering the younger generation would enter.RH Sep 14, 1916ST May 13, 1889 The second and later census confirmed the judgment was carried out, with only Caleb and Joshua remaining alive of those first counted.RH Dec 27, 1906
Each of the forty days the spies spent examining the land was answered by a year of wandering.RH Sep 14, 1916ST May 13, 1889RH Dec 27, 1906ST Jul 14, 1881 After eleven marching days from Sinai to Kadesh-barnea close to the border of the promised land in the second year, the journey that could have taken a few days or a few months became forty years of wandering.ST Jul 14, 1881 It became thirty-eight years longer, with thirty-eight years of wandering before crossing the Jordan.
The word carcasses meant their living bodies that would fall in death in the wilderness, so it can refer to people still alive and not only to dead bodies.RH Jun 22, 1869 This usage is applied to the wicked cast into fire, whose bodies are called carcasses while they remain alive and suffer, being consumed gradually rather than at once.RH Jun 22, 1869 Their falling included destruction by fire, by earthquake, by pestilence, by serpents, and in war.ST Mar 1, 1910
Their sorrow after the decree was not true repentance and could not reverse the sentence or undo the consequence.RH Nov 5, 1903RH Jun 13, 1854ST Oct 7, 1897 They sorrowed for the disastrous result to themselves rather than from a sense of ingratitude and disobedience, and their hearts were unchanged.RH Nov 5, 1903 Had they mourned for their sin when it was faithfully laid before them, the sentence would not have been pronounced.RH Nov 5, 1903 The command to retire from the land of their enemies and go back into the wilderness tested their apparent submission and proved it was not real.RH Nov 5, 1903 Strong feelings and zeal could not undo the consequence of unbelief and disobedience.ST Oct 7, 1897
The decree that all over twenty years old would die did not mean that every person was finally lost.RH Jul 21, 1868 Many may have repented through Moses' instruction and the signs of God's presence, power, and glory.RH Jul 21, 1868
Meaning of Rest
The carcasses sentenced to fall in death in the wilderness were the murmuring rebels with hardened hearts who were shut out of Canaan, the land sworn to give them to dwell in, and that denied land is the same thing called God's rest in Psalm 95, the land-possession and rest afterward given to Israel through Joshua.RH Jul 20, 1869ST Jun 23, 1881RH May 11, 1869 They died in the wilderness instead of entering the promised land.RH Jul 20, 1869ST Jun 23, 1881RH May 11, 1869 That rest is not the seventh-day Sabbath, for all who fell already had the Sabbath yet did not receive this rest, Joshua did not give the Sabbath, and God never swore they should not keep the Sabbath but swore they should not enter Canaan.ST Jun 23, 1881 Since Joshua's rest still left a rest unentered, a final rest remains for the faithful.ST Jun 23, 1881
That rest to be entered is Paradise, with Canaan as its type.RH Jul 20, 1869 Whether the oath shutting the rebels out of Canaan also shut them out of that Paradise rest is left uncertain, with the hope that the oath concerned Canaan as a type of Paradise and did not end their opportunity to repent.RH Jul 20, 1869 Among the reasons that generation over twenty years old that came out of Egypt was barred from the land and left for their bodies to fall there were Sabbath violation and idolatry and Sabbath-breaking.RH Jan 7, 1862RH Jan 7, 1862 Descent from Abraham or Jacob did not protect that wilderness generation from dying under judgment, for ancestry in Israel did not guarantee inheritance of the promises or salvation.RH Jan 16, 1872
Faith, Presumption, and Courage
The sentence that their bodies would fall in the wilderness marks the line between faith that takes hold of God's testimony and confident presumption that opposes it.RH Aug 7, 1866 After the sentence for unbelief at the report of the ten spies, from which they had escaped death for the time only through earnest intercession, they changed course when they saw their fate and worked themselves up to believe they could still go up to the place promised.RH Aug 7, 1866 That later attempt to go up was not faith but presumption, because it had no warrant from God and was built against His direct prohibition not to go, and their enemies smote and discomfited them.RH Aug 7, 1866 It was only a new phase of the same unbelief, showing presumption and unbelief closely connected.RH Aug 7, 1866
Strong feelings and zeal could not undo the consequence of unbelief and disobedience that left them to die in the wilderness instead of entering Canaan.ST Oct 7, 1897 Indifference and neutrality in a decisive conflict are not acceptable to God but bring His curse, while those willing to enter the conflict as Caleb and Joshua were are blessed and permitted to enter.ST Mar 11, 1886ST Mar 11, 1886 Holding back in half-heartedness from a sense of unworthiness, unwilling or careless about accepting the first privilege to obey when almost gaining the promised land but fearing inability to possess it, sent them back to wander forty years till almost every man and woman who started from Egypt perished.RH Oct 9, 1866 It is better and happier to obey at once not in own worthiness but in the worthiness of Jesus, before the privilege is withdrawn and only weeping and lament remain.RH Oct 9, 1866
The sentence to turn back from the border and die in the desert through forty years of wandering came mainly because ten of the twelve spies discouraged the people.RH Jul 29, 1873 They testified that huge giants in whose sight Israel were as grasshoppers, thick high walls, and very numerous inhabitants made conquest impossible, in spite of wonderful proof of fertility in the cluster of grapes carried on a staff between two men and a land flowing with milk and honey, and in spite of the faith urged by the other two spies.RH Jul 29, 1873 The human heart being naturally unbelieving, the people lost heart to go farther, God was greatly displeased, the ten discouragers died by plague before the congregation, and the whole discouraged multitude fell in the wilderness for that act.RH Jul 29, 1873 To talk discouragement when God is on the side of His workers is therefore sinful and loses His favor, and stands as an example upon whom the ends of the world are come.RH Jul 29, 1873 Even when the account of difficulties is correct, discouragement of God's people brings destruction, and it requires courage in the Lord and intelligent zeal that moves right forward in God's last-days work, more active when danger, darkness and trials surround it, with no stopping to talk discouragement or darkness and no stopping for murmurers, grumblers, fault-finders, unbelievers, hurt feelings, or friends in the way.RH Jul 22, 1873
The end of putting circumstances before the Lord came when the ten, forgetting their covenant-keeping and wonder-working deliverer and all He had done for them, reported only the sons of Anak and strongly fenced cities and melted the heart of the people.ST Sep 12, 1900 Caleb and Joshua kept the obstacles and difficulties outside, refused to let the Anakim and great cities blot out their sight of the Lord, declared that the Lord was with them, and remained calm and restful in spite of the foe, but the counsel of the ten prevailed because those who murmured chose fear of circumstances over trust.ST Sep 12, 1900 Looking on difficulties with physical sight only brings discouragement and surrender, because obstacles then seem too great for human strength and wisdom.ST Aug 13, 1902 The ten saw the fertility, productiveness, and fruit of the good land just as promised, but above those assurances saw the great high-walled cities and gigantic men, then looked on their own small stature and the way-worn host from Egypt with women and children, and lost courage.ST Aug 13, 1902 Their despairing, fatal report to a murmuring people, with weary feet and fearful hearts telling of a good and precious land of sweet things for dwelling yet of strongly walled cities and fierce giants making Israel seem as nothing, turned the multitude back into the wilderness and buried that whole generation in desert graves, though the faithful two held God's truth undaunted and declared the land fair and appointed as heritage and urged going up at once to possess it trusting that God who led through the wilderness would cover feebleness with strength.ST Aug 13, 1902RH Sep 8, 1874
The God who divided the sea before Israel, overthrew their Egyptian masters in that same sea, brought water from the rock, and fed the multitude in a barren desert would not go with Israel to battle when they murmured against Him.ST Mar 18, 1875 The promise of the Spirit is to all but its manifestations are various and will not be dictated to in operations, serving no private purpose and gratifying no curiosity, asking faith and choosing its own method of trying faith.ST Mar 18, 1875 Murmuring under trials in the wilderness shows how a holy God views a peevish, fretful, murmuring spirit, and Christians who meet little trials in families and from other sources commit as much sin by peevishness and fretfulness and murmuring as Israel did.RH Jun 26, 1860 Every trial, affliction, and pain is sent for good and for sanctification, so to rebel and murmur at a hard lot is to murmur because God is answering prayer for sanctification.RH Jun 26, 1860 Because their hearts were filled with bitter murmurings they were in no fit state to appreciate anything God would do for them, would not sanctify the Lord in their hearts and give Him glory, and a manifestation of His power against their enemies would only fill them with pride and self-importance, so He mercifully turned their course backward to enclose them in the wilderness where they would see neither city nor town for forty years until those who continually murmured should die.ST Sep 2, 1880 The punishment was merited and was made known, and the perishing of the ten unfaithful spies before their eyes signified the destruction of all in their ranks above twenty years of age, whose unbelief and rebellion cost them all.ST Sep 2, 1880
Warnings for Later Generations
Unbelief that mightily shakes faith brings terrible results on rebelling individuals, yet the nation brought out still goes into Canaan, for it is not abandoned to start another, and those who keep faith amid difficulties and stay with the divinely started and divinely led movement go into the Promised Land.RH Nov 9, 1916 As hundreds and thousands who crossed the Red Sea on dry ground and sang the song of Moses fell in the wilderness through murmurings and unbelief, so hundreds and thousands in the great Advent movement in 1844 are falling by the way through unbelief in rejecting truth and sinning against light.RH May 28, 1867 Those who disregard the commandments cannot expect God to be with them, as proved when the later attempt to enter without His presence ended in defeat, and the community must not take a course that turns it back from going forward in faith to possess the land.RH Oct 29, 1903RH Sep 26, 1854
People standing on Canaan's border-land who reject the good report of the Calebs and Joshuas will not see the home but will wander and die in the wilderness of sin, and casting stones at the faithful spies, weeping and wailing through the long night, and choosing a captain to return to Egypt brings that sentence.RH Mar 26, 1901 The destruction of the complaining generation came before entrance into the land, and the account applies to delay followed by removal of murmurers and renewed united effort to do the work, since failure to enter when first directed meant that taking the land later came at greater cost and hardship.RH Oct 8, 1908RH Oct 19, 1905 Though they came out of Egypt physically they left their hearts there with unsanctified desire, crying Back to Egypt instead of On to Canaan, longing for its food and gods, worshiping the golden calf, and murmuring when the journey grew hard, showing they had not escaped spiritual bondage.ST Dec 13, 1905ST Aug 6, 1912 Egypt stands for all that is bad — darkness, unbelief, sin, idolatry, slavery and death — and the Promised Land for all that is good — light, faith, freedom and life, so dying in the wilderness fitly symbolizes staying in the spiritual Egypt of this world, while the call out of Egypt to everlasting freedom, salvation, love, obedience and service is fulfilled in Christ who as representative of humanity calls every son out, warning those called out of sin not to turn back in heart and fall along the way.ST Dec 13, 1905ST Aug 6, 1912
The murmuring host called out of Egypt who complained and rose in insurrection against the purposes and plans of God were rejected from the real church of God, and though given opportunity to show loyalty they acted from selfish motives and were not members of the body of Christ, proving the vast chasm between professing to belong to God and actually belonging.ST Mar 1, 1910 Their carcasses falling means destruction by fire, by earthquake, by pestilence, by serpents, and in war.ST Mar 1, 1910 The doom was pronounced by God, not by Moses on his own, for Moses led only by directions received from Christ, the invisible leader and Angel of the covenant veiled by the cloudy pillar, yet in bitterness of disappointment the people seized every pretext to believe he acted on his own, and even with broken ranks and missing numbers before them as marks of displeasure, doubts, jealousy, hatred and insubordination returned against the meekest man upon earth.RH Nov 12, 1903ST Sep 16, 1880 Having forgotten the Savior who had done great things in Egypt, they saw only an arbitrary usurper and treated the sentence as merely human testimony, which is how in fiery trial it is made to appear that God does not love His people and has forgotten or cast them off.RH Jun 7, 1906 Korah, Dathan, and Abiram with confused and darkened understanding saw only arbitrary will and despotic power determined to destroy those who would not blindly follow, blamed Moses for bringing them from a land flowing with milk and honey to kill them and seize possessions instead of giving fields and vineyards with inheritance, and insisted they desired only their rights as a holy people with the Lord among them.RH Nov 12, 1903RH Jul 25, 1907 As false prophets they contradicted the cutting true warning by declaring the people might go right on to the land, promising a peaceful prosperous direct journey if good deeds were dwelt upon instead of reproving sins, which shows the mark of false prophets who appear when admonition and reproof are needed, win every unsanctified heart wanting ease, and lead soothing promise to rough experience and catastrophe.RH Nov 12, 1903RH Nov 19, 1903
The collective failure brought consequences even on the willing, for the people endured years of wandering, hardship and temptation and many died, and the children witnessed the murmurings for forty years and felt and saw the results.RH Mar 13, 1866ST Apr 15, 1903 The delay though seeming a terrible misfortune was justified by the facts rightly understood, and the years were not unnecessary but followed cowardly rebellion and continued distrust, while Moses, Joshua and Caleb remained faithful and lived to see the land.ST Oct 21, 1880RH Jul 20, 1869 Rebellion prolonged the stay for many long years when a few months could have sufficed to pass from Egypt to Canaan if obedience had encouraged Moses as the younger generation afterward encouraged Joshua, and murmuring even caused Moses to sin so that the man fittest to lead was taken from them.RH Mar 13, 1866 A faltering mind brings wilderness wandering and any murmur or word of unbelief today brings the same result, for murmuring and unbelief at Kadesh-barnea caused death in the wilderness after thirty-eight years of wandering when courage would have brought eternal victory, and the people cannot afford to wander thirty-eight years more if this generation is to meet Christ.
Sources