Translations
American King James Version, Webster Bible
Why should the heathen say, Where is now their God?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Wherefore should the heathen say, Where is now their God?
Revised Version, American Standard Version
Wherefore should the nations say, Where is now their God?
Why do the nations say, 'Where, pray, [is] their God.
Wherefore should the nations say, Where then is their God?
Wherefore should the nations say, Pray where is their God?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Why should the nations say,
“ Where is their God?”Why should the nations say,
“ Where is their God, now?”Why may the nations say, Where is now their God?
Wherefore shall the heathen say, Where is nowe their God?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
For thy mercy, and for thy truth’s sake: lest the gentiles should say: Where is their God?
I said in my excess: Every man is a liar.
Cross-references
- Jeremiah 10:10-12
But the LORD is the true God, he is the living God, and an everlasting king: at his wrath the earth shall tremble, and the nations shall not be able to abide his indignation.
God is distinguished from idols as the living God who made the earth.
- Acts 17:24-25
God that made the world and all things therein, seeing that he is Lord of heaven and earth, dwelleth not in temples made with hands;
Both distinguish the living God by creation, unlike idols made by humans.
- Isaiah 44:9-17
They that make a graven image are all of them vanity; and their delectable things shall not profit; and they are their own witnesses; they see not, nor know; that they may be ashamed.
Both describe powerless images worshipped as gods.
- Romans 10:12-13
For there is no difference between the Jew and the Greek: for the same Lord over all is rich unto all that call upon him.
The same Lord saves all who call on him.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
3 sources
The question is the scornful retort of the enemies of God and His people, thrown out when the faith of God's children is tried.Lt 52, 1896, par. 1 They watch critically for such a moment, looking for a chance for Satan to wedge in with temptation by asking where God is now.Lt 52, 1896, par. 1 It is also the triumphing taunt of nominal Adventists, where is their God, spoken when God's people suffer affliction.Ms 7, 1850, par. 1–4 Satan brings sickness and the threat of death upon God's servants and their children, not as punishment for idolatry, to sadden their hearts and to provoke that mockery and thereby hinder God's work of publishing truth.Ms 7, 1850, par. 1–4
Those for whom God has done so much in love and mercy are expected to meet the trial with cheerful, trustful words that their God is in the heavens and does whatever He pleases.Lt 52, 1896, par. 1 They are to look in faith to the Source of all might and power and to sing of His mercies rather than depending on useless idols.Lt 52, 1896, par. 1
The question is also a prayer to God not to let unbelievers mock with, where is now their God.Lt 111, 1896, par. 18 It asks God to vindicate His own work and cause by working in power.Lt 111, 1896, par. 18 That prayer means going forward in soul-saving work as co-laborers with God instead of yielding to Satan's discouragement, not failing nor being discouraged even when means are lacking and the conference is in debt.Lt 111, 1896, par. 18 It means doing the human part to save poor perishing souls for whom Jesus died, while asking the Lord and expecting to receive according to His promise.Lt 111, 1896, par. 18
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
11 sources
The verse is the mocking taunt of the idol-worshiping nations who ask where Israel's God is when His people look forsaken, abandoned or powerless, and it denies them any ground to claim He is absent or to keep asking.RH Nov 29, 1906RH Jun 1, 1916HM Jun 1889 Its answer is that God is in heaven and does whatever He pleases, unlike idols made by human hands that cannot see, hear, speak, act or help their worshipers.HM Jun 1889 He is the true God who made heaven and earth, and He uses that power for the good of His people.ST Aug 18, 1909 Taking glory for self gives occasion for that reproach, which is answered only by giving all glory to God and counting self as nothing without Him, since all good done comes from Him.ST Nov 7, 1900 His presence and power must therefore be evident through His church, so that when it depends humbly on the Holy Spirit and He works with it, the nations have no reason to make that challenge.RH Jan 14, 1904ST Jul 22, 1880
Setting and Question
Psalms 113 to 118 were sung on paschal occasions, and this psalm was sung by Jesus just before His betrayal, the agony of Gethsemane, and the darkness of the cross.ST Aug 21, 1893 It was sung in faith in a Father too wise to err and too good to be unkind.ST Aug 21, 1893 It was sung as praise to Him from whom all blessings flow, praise that brings greater blessings.ST Aug 21, 1893
The verse voices the mocking, taunting challenge of the idol-worshiping nations and heathen who ask where Israel's God is.RH Jun 1, 1916HM Jun 1889 It asks why the nations should be able to say this, leaving them no ground to claim that God is absent.RH Jan 14, 1904ST Jul 22, 1880 It likewise denies them ground to keep on questioning where He is.RH Jan 14, 1904ST Jul 22, 1880ST Jun 1, 1904 The weight of teaching holds that this denial rests on God's assured use of His power for His people's good, on His presence and power made evident through a church humbly dependent on the Holy Spirit, on His past victories in the progress of His work giving reason for courage rather than discouragement, and on His protection claimed by faith shown in setting aside a tithe from crops.RH Jan 14, 1904ST Jul 22, 1880ST Jun 1, 1904
The question is raised when God's people appear forsaken, abandoned, or powerless.RH Nov 29, 1906RH Jun 1, 1916
Living God Versus Idols
The mocking question why the nations should ask where Israel's God is finds its answer in what follows, that God is in heaven and does whatever He pleases. That living power stands against idols made by human hands that cannot see, hear, speak or act. The nations who worship idols taunt God's people with that challenge, while the setting of the whole psalm sets the living God over against lifeless images that cannot hear or help their worshipers.HM Jun 1889
The psalm sets God's power over against the powerlessness of false gods and assures His people that He uses His power for their good. It sets the true God who made the heavens and the earth over against powerless false gods.ST Aug 18, 1909 It lays bare the senseless impotence of idols in contrast to the God who hears prayer, with idols disgraced and dethroned as the people who once feared and worshiped them turn to Him.
The living God is distinguished from false gods by the fact that the true God made heaven and earth.RH Mar 11, 1875RH Apr 29, 1875 That fact of creation lies at the foundation of the Sabbath institution.RH Mar 11, 1875RH Apr 29, 1875 The Sabbath alone makes the law of God valid by showing who the Lawgiver is, His title of royalty, the extent of His dominion, and His right to reign.RH Mar 11, 1875RH Apr 29, 1875 He is thereby distinguished from other gods as the Lord thy God, the Creator of heaven and earth and all that is in them.RH Mar 11, 1875 By that same creation distinction the Sabbath is the seal or sign of the living God, the outward sign between God and His people that they may know He is the Lord, marking allegiance to the one true and living God as distinguished from all other gods.RH Apr 29, 1875
Glory, Presence, and Trust
Taking glory for oneself gives the surrounding nations occasion to ask where God is, for those who glorify self appear merely human whatever they profess.ST Nov 7, 1900 That reproach is met by giving all glory to God and counting self as nothing without Him, since all the good done comes from God.ST Nov 7, 1900 The question presses why the nations should be able to level that challenge against God's people, and it highlights the need for His presence and power to be evident through His church.RH Jan 14, 1904 When the church depends humbly on the Holy Spirit and God works with it, the nations have no reason to make that challenge.RH Jan 14, 1904
God's past victories in the progress of His work show that He is present and active, so His people have reason for courage rather than discouragement and the heathen have no ground to claim that Israel's God is absent.ST Jul 22, 1880 The same question is pressed as a present challenge not to let the nations keep asking where God is.ST Jun 1, 1904 It is answered when God's people show faith by setting aside a tithe from their crops, thereby claiming His protection so that the world should no longer ask where their God is.ST Jun 1, 1904
Sources