AdventAI

Titus 3:10

A man that is an heretick after the first and second admonition reject;

King James Version

Translations

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Pioneers and periodicals

21 sources

A heretic is a factious, divisive person who works to mislead and draw followers after himself, and who persists in error contrary to Scripture and the faith he once held.RH Jun 22, 1916CO 12.9–13.3RH Mar 6, 1866ST Apr 16, 1885RH Aug 24, 1916 He is to be warned a first and second time, giving him time and counsel to turn back, and if he will not listen but grows worse he is to be rejected.RH Jun 22, 1916CO 12.9–13.3RH Mar 6, 1866 That rejection means withdrawing fellowship and removing him from membership, recognizing the separation he has made by his own course.CO 12.9–13.3RH Aug 24, 1916RH Jan 9, 1855 The church must carry out this discipline to preserve order and purity, yet do it kindly and firmly without hatred, seeking the welfare of the one who has erred.ST Apr 16, 1885RH Aug 24, 1916RH Oct 15, 1908RH Jan 9, 1855CO 21.1–2 The instruction gives no authority to put such a person to death or to punish him for his beliefs by civil power.RH Jan 2, 1908ST Oct 8, 1902RH Jul 2, 1908

Meaning and Context

The heretic is a factious, divisive person, a maker of factions who works subtly to mislead and divide the followers of Christ.RH Jun 22, 1916RH Mar 6, 1866ST Apr 16, 1885RH Jan 24, 1865RH Feb 28, 1856 He speaks perversely in order to draw disciples after himself and disturbs the peace of the church by creating or fostering contention.ST Apr 16, 1885RH Jan 24, 1865RH Feb 28, 1856RH Jul 2, 1857 He is also one who persists in error and in teaching contrary to Scripture and the faith of the church.CO 12.9–13.3RH Aug 24, 1916ST Oct 24, 1878RH Oct 15, 1908 He abandons doctrines taught by Scripture that he once believed, choosing his own way against God's word and against the claims of brotherhood.RH Oct 15, 1908RH Oct 16, 1900 The scriptural term does not mean merely anyone who separates from an established church or becomes unpopular.RH Oct 15, 1908RH Oct 16, 1900

The instruction follows a warning against foolish disputes and fights about ceremonial laws, which are unprofitable and vain.RH Jun 22, 1916 Those laws ended with Christ's sacrifice.RH Jun 22, 1916

The verse requires a first and second admonition or warning, and then rejection of the one who persists and will not listen.RH Jun 22, 1916CO 12.9–13.3RH Mar 6, 1866ST Apr 16, 1885RH Aug 24, 1916 The repeated warnings allow time for one who has gone astray to be converted and to return to the true faith.CO 12.9–13.3 Rejection therefore does not come at once, but after faithful caution, counsel, and exhortation for a suitable time, especially when the person grows worse rather than better.CO 12.9–13.3RH Aug 24, 1916RH Jan 24, 1865RH Feb 25, 1858 Admonition once or twice is followed by rejection if he will not listen, and creating divisions is treated as sin calling for this course.RH Mar 6, 1866ST Apr 16, 1885RH Aug 24, 1916RH Jan 24, 1865

The next verse explains the rejected person as perverted or subverted, sinful and sinning, and self-condemned or condemned by his own conduct.RH Jun 22, 1916CO 12.9–13.3RH Mar 6, 1866RH Jan 24, 1865RH Feb 28, 1856 He is turned aside and stands condemned by his own actions.RH Mar 6, 1866ST Oct 24, 1878 Persistent refusal of efforts to restore him shows that he has separated himself from the fellowship of the brethren.CO 12.9–13.3ST Oct 24, 1878RH Oct 16, 1900

Church Discipline Practice

In church practice rejection means disfellowshipping, withdrawing fellowship, avoiding and removing from fellowship, so that one who will not retract false teaching and return to the true faith should no longer remain a member or take part in meetings.CO 12.9–13.3RH Aug 24, 1916RH Jan 9, 1855 His connection with the church is dissolved, and the church recognizes the separation he has made by persistent refusal of efforts to restore him.RH Oct 16, 1900RH Aug 4, 1874 Discipline exercised according to the Word is valid, while action contrary to the Word is not confirmed in heaven.CO 21.1–2

The church has an imperative duty to carry out this withdrawal from the contentious person who creates or fosters factions and disturbs its peace, in order to preserve order in the household of faith.ST Apr 16, 1885 This is to be done faithfully and lovingly for the protection of the church and the good of the person, helping the church remain pure and fulfill its purpose.RH Oct 15, 1908RH Aug 4, 1874 The very direction to reject after first and second admonition shows that the church has a known membership and a responsibility to discipline its members.ST Jan 1, 1885

The work must be done kindly but firmly, without hatred or fighting, and with caution, judgment and meekness.RH Aug 24, 1916RH Jan 9, 1855 It must consider both justice and mercy and seek the welfare of the one who has erred.ST Apr 23, 1885 Faithful caution, counsel and exhortation are to be given for a suitable time, especially watching whether the person grows worse rather than better.RH Feb 25, 1858

The instruction applies to those who teach against sound doctrine and godly conduct.RH Jan 9, 1855 Departure from the faith is evidence of unsoundness serious enough to exclude from the communion of the saints, and agreement to differ is no substitute for faithfulness to Bible doctrine, including the Sabbath.RH Mar 6, 1866 It applies to faction-makers who speak perversely to draw disciples after themselves, to promoters of factions who withdraw fellowship from faithful messengers and leaders, seek pre-eminence, or try to reshape the message to suit their own views, since creating divisions is sin and leaves the person subverted, sinning and condemned by his own conduct.RH Jan 24, 1865RH Feb 28, 1856RH Jul 2, 1857 It applies likewise to a member who persists in error and shows no effort to improve after reproof and labor according to Scripture, and to a messenger whose wrong teaching causes discord and division and who refuses repeated earnest efforts to meet and settle the matter.RH Aug 4, 1874

Offenses against the church as a whole, the truth, society, or morality, not merely personal offenses, are to receive this first and second admonition.ST Apr 23, 1885 These public offenses differ from the private matters addressed in Matthew 18 and call for less private labor.ST Apr 23, 1885 When a member is unsure how to proceed, the church elders are the appropriate people to consult.ST Apr 23, 1885

Limits on Rejection

The instruction to warn a divisive person a first and a second time and then reject him does not authorize putting that person to death, and to turn reject into a warrant for execution is a distorted use of the command.RH Jan 2, 1908 The same direction was invoked to claim that an obstinate heretic should be excommunicated and exterminated, but rejection stops short of killing.RH Jan 2, 1908 The command concerns admonishing and rejecting, and it gives no authority to inflict bodily punishment for unbelief or to punish people for their beliefs by civil power.ST Oct 8, 1902RH Jul 2, 1908 To use it as a warrant for civil persecution after one or two admonitions is faulty, sophistical reasoning that violates rights of conscience.ST Oct 8, 1902RH Jul 2, 1908

No person has authority over another's beliefs or opinions, since each person answers to God for belief.ST Oct 8, 1902 To punish someone for belief usurps God's prerogative and puts the punisher in God's place.ST Oct 8, 1902 The scriptural term heretic does not mean merely anyone who separates from an established church or becomes unpopular.ST Feb 25, 1886 Separation that is condemned as heresy by those who regard their own beliefs as orthodoxy is not by that label alone shown to be heresy in the scriptural sense.ST Feb 25, 1886

Sources

  1. RH Jun 22, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 31 — The “Factious Man” T. E. BOWEN, June 22, 1916
  2. CO 12.9–13.3 Church Order — CHURCH ORDER. Halbert M. J. Richards, 1906
  3. RH Mar 6, 1866 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 27, No. 14 — Exclusiveness Jesse Dorcas, Third-Day, March 6, 1866
  4. ST Apr 16, 1885 Signs of the Times, Vol. 11, No. 16 — ADMINISTRATION OF DISCIPLINE Editor, April 16, 1885
  5. RH Aug 24, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 42 — Proper Treatment of Heretics L. H. CHRISTIAN, August 24, 1916
  6. RH Jan 9, 1855 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 20 — CHURCH ORDER J. B. Frisbie, January 9, 1855
  7. RH Oct 15, 1908 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 85, No. 42 — Has the Church Any Protection From Inward Foes? George I. Butler, October 15, 1908
  8. CO 21.1–2 Church Order — CHAPTER V. Halbert M. J. Richards, 1906
  9. RH Jan 2, 1908 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 85, No. 1 — The Inquisition and Its Fruits J. O. CORLISS, January 2, 1908
  10. ST Oct 8, 1902 Signs of the Times, Vol. 28, No. 41 — A CATHOLIC PLEA FOR THE DEATH PENALTY UPON HERETICS E., October 8, 1902
  11. RH Jul 2, 1908 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 85, No. 27 — The Rise and Fall of Religious Liberty in America C. M. S., Thursday, July 2, 1908
  12. RH Jan 24, 1865 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 25, No. 9 — Schism R. F. Cottrell, January 24, 1865
  13. RH Feb 28, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 7, No. 22 — OUR EXAMPLES R. F. C., February 28, 1856
  14. RH Jul 2, 1857 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 10, No. 9 — OUR EXAMPLES July 2, 1857
  15. ST Oct 24, 1878 Signs of the Times, Vol. 4, No. 40 — Correct Doctrine Important Dudley Marvin Canright, October 24, 1878
  16. RH Oct 16, 1900 Review and Herald, Vol. 77, No. 42 — STUDIES IN GALATIANS October 16, 1900
  17. RH Feb 25, 1858 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 11, No. 16 — Meetings in Hillsdale, Mich A. S. Hutchins, February 25, 1858
  18. RH Aug 4, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 44, No. 8 — THE NATURE, POSITION, AND RESPONSIBILITY OF THE CHURCH George Ide Butler, August 4, 1874
  19. ST Jan 1, 1885 Signs of the Times, Vol. 11, No. 1 — The Church January 1, 1885
  20. ST Apr 23, 1885 Signs of the Times, Vol. 11, No. 17 — The Church. No. 10. Editor, April 23, 1885
  21. ST Feb 25, 1886 Signs of the Times, Vol. 12, No. 8 — Heresy February 25, 1886

Cross-references

  1. Romans 16:17

    Now I beseech you, brethren, mark them which cause divisions and offences contrary to the doctrine which ye have learned; and avoid them.

    Both instruct believers to avoid divisive people who oppose received doctrine.

  2. Matthew 18:17

    And if he shall neglect to hear them, tell it unto the church: but if he neglect to hear the church, let him be unto thee as an heathen man and a publican.

    An unresponsive offender is treated as outside the church after repeated efforts to correct him.

  3. 1 Corinthians 5:11

    But now I have written unto you not to keep company, if any man that is called a brother be a fornicator, or covetous, or an idolater, or a railer, or a drunkard, or an extortioner; with such an one no not to eat.

    Both instruct the church to separate from a professing believer who persists in wrongdoing.

  4. 2 Thessalonians 3:6

    Now we command you, brethren, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that ye withdraw yourselves from every brother that walketh disorderly, and not after the tradition which he received of us.

    Both direct the church to withdraw from disorderly members.

  5. 1 Timothy 6:3-5

    If any man teach otherwise, and consent not to wholesome words, even the words of our Lord Jesus Christ, and to the doctrine which is according to godliness;

    Both direct believers to withdraw from those who reject wholesome teaching.

  6. 2 John 1:10-11

    If there come any unto you, and bring not this doctrine, receive him not into your house, neither bid him God speed:

    Warns against receiving or supporting those who reject Christ’s doctrine.

  7. 1 Corinthians 5:13

    But them that are without God judgeth. Therefore put away from among yourselves that wicked person.

    The church was instructed to remove a wicked person.

  8. 2 Thessalonians 3:13-15

    But ye, brethren, be not weary in well doing.

    Continues the instructions about dealing with a disorderly brother.

  9. 1 Corinthians 5:5

    To deliver such an one unto Satan for the destruction of the flesh, that the spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord Jesus.

    Cited as a related instruction concerning removal from the church.

  10. 2 Peter 2:1

    But there were false prophets also among the people, even as there shall be false teachers among you, who privily shall bring in damnable heresies, even denying the Lord that bought them, and bring upon themselves swift destruction.

    Warns that false teachers introduce destructive heresies.