Your ShelfYour Projects

Review and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 23.

LOVE ONE ANOTHER
Earlier text: LOVE ONE ANOTHER

THE PAPAL CHURCH AND THE SABBATH.

BY LOYD CALDWELL.
Cardinal Gibbons, chief Catholic prelate in the United States, thus, unconsciously perhaps, forecasts, in the North American Review of October, 1887, the probable future attitude of the papal church on the “Sunday Question”:—
The desecration of the Christian Sabbath is another social danger against which it behooves us to set our face and to take timely precautions before it assumes proportions too formidable to be easily eradicated. Whenever the enemies of God seek to destroy the religion of a people, they find no means so effectual for carrying out their impious designs as by the suppression of the Sabbath. Thus when Antiochus determined to abolish the sacred laws of the Hebrew people and to compel them to conform to the practice of idolatry, he defiled the temples of Jerusalem and Gerizim, he put an end to the Jewish sacrifices, and, above all, he forbade under pain of death the observance of the Sabbath and other religious solemnities, substituting in their stead his own birth day and the feast of Bacchus as days of sacrifice and licentious indulgence [refers to French Revolution as setting up a ten-day week, exiling priests, etc.]. And in our own times it is a well-known fact that the enemies of religion are the avowed enemies of the Christian Sabbath. A close observer cannot fail to note the dangerous inroads which have been made on the Lord’s day within the last quarter of a century in our own country; and if these invasions are not checked in time, the day may come when . . . the votaries of the theater and the drinking saloon will outnumber the church worshipers, etc. We might for a time worship God at irregular intervals, and would probably end by neglecting to commune with him altogether.
Daniel, John, and Paul foretold the career of persecuting Rome so clearly that all non-Catholic commentators are almost a unit in applying Dan. 7:25; Rev. 12:17; 13:4-10; 17:3-6; and 2 Thess. 2:3-9, etc., to the papal church. Passing by a striking variety of ways in which that church, and that alone, has literally fulfilled these predictions, let us address ourselves to a parallel of the work of the “enemies of God,” of whom the cardinal speaks, and the Sabbath career of the cardinal’s church:—

WHO CHANGED THE SABBATH?

THE CHURCH.

1. In A. D. 196 Victor, bishop (pope) of Rome, excommunicated all the churches of Asia for celebrating Easter on another day than Sunday. Doubtless this was the first papal edict—the first step in papal supremacy. See Bower’s “Hist. of Popes,” vol. 1, p. 18; Dowling’s “Hist. of Romanism,” p. 33; Torrey’s Neander’s Ch. Hist., vol. 1, p. 214; Maclaine’s Mosheim’s Ch. Hist., p. 49; Encyc. Britan. and McClintock and Strong’s Cycl., art. “Easter.”
2. In 305 the Council of Elvira denied communion to towns-people who were absent from church three Sundays. Confirmed by Council of Sardica, 345. See Schaff’s Ch. Hist., vol. 2, par. 75; Hessey’s “Sunday,” Lect. 3.
3. In 325 Constantine called the famous Council of Nice, chiefly to settle if Easter be fixed on a Sunday, or on a date of the month, regardless of the day of the week. See Euseb., Vita Const., chap. 18; Stanley’s “Eastern Church,” Lect. 5; or any good authority on Constantine or Easter or the Council of Nice.
4. In 364 the Council of Laodicea absolutely forbade Christians to observe the Jewish Sabbath, and enjoined resting on Sunday as far as they were able. See Torrey’s Neander’s Ch. Hist., vol. 2, p. 334; Lardner’s Works, vol. 4, p. 217; Shedd’s Guericke’s Ch. Hist., par. 78; Student’s Eccl. Hist., p. 293; Coleman’s Anc. Chris. Exemp., p. 331; Butler’s Eccl. Hist., p. 277; Smith’s Tables Ch. Hist., p. 19; McClintock and Strong’s Cycl., arts. “Lord’s Day,” “Laodicea”; Hessey’s “Sunday,” Lect. 3.
5. In 440 Pope Leo the Great forbade all Sunday labor, lawsuits, and sensual recreations. See Craft’s “Sabbath for Man,” pp. 555-6; Kingsbury’s “The Sabbath,” p. 210; Gesta Christi, p. 86.
6. In 538 the Council of Orleans ordered farm work to stop on Sunday, so as to allow attendance at church. See Chamber’s Encyc., art. “Sabbath”; Putnam’s Dict. Dates, art. “Sunday”; Guizot’s “Hist. of Civilization,” vol. 3, p. 264; Dict. Chronol., art. “Sunday.”
7. In 653 the twelfth Council of Toledo forbade the Jews to keep Sabbath, new moon, etc., or to labor on Sunday or on any of the great festivals of the Church, under penalty of one hundred lashes on the naked body; after that chains, banishment, confiscation of property. On the Jewish holy days they were all to assemble before the bishop. See Milman’s Hist. of the Jews, vol. 3, p. 117; Mores’s “Dialogue on the Lord’s Day,” p. 267.
8. In 1201 came Eustace, Abbot of Flaye, to England, with the Sunday Roll from Heaven, found on the altar of St. Simeon’s church, at Jerusalem, and confirmed by the pope! It forbade work from the ninth hour of Saturday till sunrise Monday; also on “the other festivals of my saints which you have not kept.” See Hessey’s “Sunday,” Lect. 3; Gillilan’s “Sabbath,” p. 309; Matt. Paris’ Hist. Major, p. 200; Mores’s “Lord’s Day,” p. 288.
9. In 1595 Rev. Nicholas Bound, D. D., an English Puritan, brought out the now famous “seventh part of time” theory of the Sabbath, thus basing Sunday (or any other day!) on the fourth commandment. This theory was eagerly taken up by the Presbyterians and later sects who are not satisfied to admit with the Catholic, Lutheran, and Episcopal churches, that “the church” could or did change the day. See Coleman’s Anc. Chris. Exemp., chap. 20; Neal’s “Hist. of the Puritans,” part 1, chap. 8; Craft’s “Sabbath for Man,” note 305; Hessey, p. 205; Gillilan, p. 67; Heylyn’s “Hist. of the Sabbath,” part 2, chap. 8.

THE STATE.

1. In A. D. 321 Constantine, Emperor of Rome, issued a decree that all labor but country farm work should cease on the venerable day of the sun (not Son). He also forbade lawsuits and military exercises on that day. See Milman’s Hist. Chr., vol. 2, pp. 296, 298-7; Schaff, Neander, Stanley, or any good authority on Constantine, Sunday, etc.
2. In 386 Theodosius I., the Great, confirmed the above, and forbade the public games, allowed by Constantine, on Sunday. In 425 Theodosius II. forbade theaters with the foregoings, and extended them to include Easter, Epiphany, Pentecost, and Christmas. See Milman’s Hist. Chr., vol. 3, p. 205; Student’s Eccl. Hist., p. 293; Robertson’s Ch. Hist.; Guericke’s Ch. Hist., p. 297; Neander’s Ch. Hist., vol. 2, p. 330; Hessey’s “Sunday,” Lect. 3.
3. In 469 Emperor Leo I. confirmed the decree of Pope Leo I., of 440. See Mosheim’s Eccl. Hist., Cent., 5, bk. 4; Moser’s Dialogues, pp. 259-60.
4. In 800 Charlemagne, Emperor of the West, forbade Sunday work and markets, and ordered all to come to church on that day. See Craft’s “Sabbath for Man,” p. 556; “Sabbath Essays,” p. 241 (Boston, 1880); Kingsbury’s “The Sabbath,” p. 209.
5. In 910 Leo Philosophus, Emperor of the East, forbade the Sunday farm work, allowed by Constantine, whom he censured strongly for such allowance. See Chamber’s Cycl., art. “Sabbath”; Mores’s “Lord’s day,” p. 293; Hessey’s “Sunday,” Lect. 3; Craft’s “Sabbath for Man,” p. 556.
6. Constantine forbade all non-Catholic worship, and confiscated all heretical places of worship. He forbade Christians to turn Jews, and ordered that any Jews who threw stones at or endangered a Christian’s life, should be burned alive! He bore the expense of the Nicene Council, exiled those who refused to obey it, and refused to hear charges against its bishops. He said that if he even detected a bishop in the act of adultery, he would throw his imperial robe over the unlawful deed, lest others might be depraved. See Milman’s “Hist. of the Jews,” vol. 3, p. 21; Lecky’s “Hist. of Rationalism” vol. 2, p. 23; Schaff’s Ch. Hist., vol. 2, chap. 1; Bagster’s Eusebius’ “Life of Constantine,” and Theodoret’s Eccl. Hist., pp. 129 and 46.
7. In 380 the three Roman emperors, Theodosius, Gratian, and Valentinian commanded all their subjects (the civilized world) to receive the faith of St. Peter as held by Pope Damasus. They forbade all heresy and apostasy, and here began the state-church system of persecution. See Gibbon’s Rome, chap. 27; Ranke, “Hist. of the Popes,” vol. 1, chap. 1; Schaff’s Ch. Hist., vol. 3, p. 142; Sozomen’s Eccl. Hist., bk. 7; Gieseler’s Eccl. Hist., vol. 1, p. 209; Butler’s Eccl. Hist., chap. 30.
8. In 445 Valentinian III. commanded all bishops of the Western church, to hold and observe as law whatever it should please the bishop (pope) of Rome to decree. See Encyc. Britan., art. “Leo I.”; Butler’s Eccl. Hist., chap. 49; Wylie’s “Hist. of Protestantism,” vol. 1, p. 9; D’Aubigne’s “Hist. of the Reformation,” vol. 1, pp. 42-3; Hase’s Ch. Hist., p. 144; Gieseler’s Eccl. Hist., vol. 1, p. 269; Torrey’s Neander’s Ch. Hist., vol. 2, p. 207.
9. In 533 Justinian decreed that the pope or bishop of Rome be head of all the churches, east and west; which was accomplished in 538. This decree was formally admitted by Phocas in 606. See Butler’s Eccl. Hist., chap. 26, p. 221; D’Aubigne’s “Hist. of the Reformation,” vol. 1, p. 49; Croly’s Apocalypse, p. 7.
Thus by the united and undeniable proof of these great authorities is shown the successive steps by which the papal church substituted Sunday for God’s Sabbath, and gave new reasons and rules for the weekly rest.
That the state lent its authority merely in order to aid the church is undeniable. Says an able writer: “The decrees of the Nicene Council were enforced as laws of the empire by Constantine. That of Constantinople (381) requested and obtained the legal confirmation of Theodosius the Great; Theodosius II., after much hesitation, confirmed the principal decrees of that of Ephesus (431). Marcian’s edicts are extant confirming the decrees of Chalcedon (451). The next four councils, ecumenical, so called (553, 680, 787, 869), were either signed or also enforced by a decree of the emperors who respectively summoned them.”—Dr. Wm. Smith’s Dict. Chr. Antiq., pp. 322-6. See also Hase’s Ch. Hist., par. 122; Butler’s Eccl. Hist., chap. 24; Coleman’s Anc. Chr. Exemp., 489; Stanley’s Eastern Ch., Lect. 2; Neander’s Ch. Hist., vol. 4, p. 95; Gieseler’s Eccl. Hist., vol. 1, pp. 202-3. Said Constantine, “For whatever is transacted in the holy councils of the bishops is to be referred to the divine will” (inspired!)—Eusebius, Life of Constantine, App. to Bagster’s Edition, p. 53. “Thus the canons of the councils held in the East during the schism, at Antioch A. D. 341, Laodicea about 363, and Gangra between 362 and 370, were still maintained in the East, and at length were adopted in the West.”—Gieseler’s Eccl. Hist., vol. 1, p. 206.
Compare the Bible Sabbath (seventh day) with the papal Sunday, and the result would be about as follows:—

BIBLE SABBATH.

1. A memorial of creation. Exodus 20.
2. From evening to evening. Lev. 23:32.
3. A universal twenty-four-hour rest from business and selfish pleasure.
4. A sign to recall the Creator. Ex. 31:17; Eze. 20:20.
5. Not a feast; rather a fast. Ex. 16:23.

PAPAL SUNDAY.

1. A mere church festival.
2. Midnight to midnight:—a day sandwiched between two half-nights!
3. One hour at mass; the rest, at work or play. See Craft’s “Sabbath for Man,” pp. 126-178.
4. A sign to show the “true church,” and her authority!
5. Always a feast; never a fast. See the catechisms.
Yet, with such a record on this question, this “cardinal prince” has the effrontery to talk piously about American desecration of the “Christian Sabbath,” and of taking “timely precautions”! Ah! sir, we are reaping the reward of your church’s trifling with and overturning the precepts and institutions of God; and no amount of pious cant or ominous threats will avert the storm that is coming! Only one old tried resource is left you; it is persecution by State law! And in this you will be backed, yea, by Protestant churches (so called) whom you did your best to “eradicate.” Still further, your united blows will fall thickest and hardest on the “remnant” which keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus. Rev. 12:17; 14:12. The greatest enemy of God is the papal church, that grossly perverted God’s truth and persecuted his people.
Battle Creek, Mich.

“KEEP THYSELF PURE.”

BY ELIZA H. MORTON.
The Bible injunction to seek purity of life is meant for the well-being of man physically, mentally, and morally. Although great genius may exist in connection with a depraved nature, yet the brilliancy of the intellect is dimmed by the dissipation, and the man is a wreck in contrast with what he might have become.
All nature is in harmony with the unclouded soul. The birds sing to that heart their sweetest songs, and the music is interwoven with human words and sent by lip and pen to other hearts to comfort and to bless. The flowers of the field, the trees of the forest, the lakes, hills, vales, and rivers leave their finest impress on that mind, and straightway a shadow of their beauty is thrown upon the canvas or in some way reflected to others. The power that moves the pen of the poet, guides the brush of the artist, and makes eloquent the tongue of the orator, is born of an inspiration not of earth; and that inspiration is most nobly used by the man who keeps himself “unspotted from the world.” The heights to which the human soul may attain are grand. All cannot be poets, artists, or orators, but all can be pure; and from that fountain gush thousands of rills increasing in volume as they flow, and making glad the earth.
Buddha taught a truth when he said, “Purity leads to inspiration, and inspiration to the elevation of the soul, and the elevation of the soul to the good of mankind;” but he failed to teach that purity of soul is the result of constant watchfulness and close communion with Him who is the source of all inspiration and purity.
Portland, Maine.

THE DOUBLE-MINDED MAN.

The people of New York City have been startled the last week by the tragic death of a man who was apparently living two lives. He was known as a decorous attender of church, a faithful and affectionate husband and father—to most of his acquaintances in the community known only so. Yet he dies at the house of an adventuress, under circumstances which point unmistakably to his fear that his double life would be brought to light. In endeavoring to escape the threatened exposure, he flees from the house which he has entered; escaping by a window, the tree on which he has relied to help him breaks, he falls, and is killed in the fall. And then the whole story of his double life is spread out in the daily papers.
How many men, one cannot but ask himself, are thus, though in lesser measure, living double lives? Single mindedness! Is it a rare or a common virtue? Religion! Is it our every-day dress or our ecclesiastical vestment? our handmaid or our chaplain? our life or our luxury? The double-minded man is like one of the great palaces in Europe that have a chapel and a chaplain. Every morning the family gather in the chapel, and the chaplain leads in prayers, and then the religion has been done for the day. The chaplain has no place in any other room, or at least not in his capacity as chaplain; none in the banqueting hall, in the armory, or in the steward's room. So the double-minded man has one little part of his nature which he calls religious, and he gets into that little chapel for a few moments every day, or one day every week, and then he is through religion for the day or the week. The notion that religion should go with him into the parlor, the kitchen, the banqueting hall, the common affairs of life—that scarcely even enters his thought. He likes to go to church and hear the minister preach; he likes to see him hold up a high ideal of life; but if conscience ever calls him to account for not living up to that standard, he replies, “That is very well to talk about, but no man can live in that way and get on in the world.”
Religion is the consecration of a man's whole nature—the giving of a man's whole life to God. People often think that they have become religious when they have not taken the suffrage of their whole nature on the question. The man, under some strong appeal, asks himself, Will I be a Christian? He says to Reverence, What do you say? Reverence says, Yes! He says, Love, what do you say? And Love says, Yes! He says, Faith, what do you say? and Faith says, Certainly, yes! And Conscience? Yes! And he says, Well, I have decided. I will be a Christian. Then he goes into the counting-room, and as soon as he gets into the counting-room he yields to Acquisitiveness, and violates the law of Christ, and Acquisitiveness says, I did not vote I would be a Christian. He goes into society, and does, for the sake of the applause of men, that which is unmanly and unchristian, and Conscience calls him to account, and Approbativeness says, I did not vote that I would be a Christian. And he goes where his passions are stirred, and the wrath of his nature rises, and, under the impulse of wrath, he violates the law of love, and Conscience again calls him to account, and Combativeness says, I did not vote to become a Christian. Now, no man is a Christian until he takes a vote and secures the approval of all his faculties. Whatever may do for politics, nothing less than universal suffrage will do for the Christian. He must vote for Christ with his acquisitiveness, and with his self-esteem, and with his approbativeness—with every power of his nature or he is not a Christian. A man cannot live in a house with garbage in the cellar and not, soon or later, have disease in the parlor; he cannot live with mortification in the feet and not have it ascend through the whole body. So no man can live with worldliness entering into half of his nature; the disease of worldliness will soon spread through the whole nature. . . .
To be a Christian is to give every faculty and power and activity of life to the law of God, to the law of Christ, to the law of love. Whatever is less than this is inadequate; whatever is more or other than this is superfluous. The holy man is simply a whole man and a healthful man. Who would be less? The double-minded man is not a whole man.—Christian Union.

THE CHEERFUL FACE.

NEXT to the sunlight of heaven is the cheerful face. There is no mistaking it—the bright eye, the unclouded brow, the sunny smile, all tell of that which dwells within. Who has not felt its electrifying influence? One glance at this face lifts us out of the mists and shadows into the beautiful realm of hope. One cheerful face in the household will keep everything warm and light within. It may be a very plain face, but there is something in it we feel, yet cannot express; and its cheery smile sends the blood dancing through the veins for very joy. Ah! there is a world of magic in the plain, cheerful face, and we would not exchange it for all the soulless beauty that ever graced the fairest form on earth.
It may be a very little face, but somehow this cheery face ever shines, and the shining is so bright the shadows cannot remain, and silently they creep away into the dark corners. It may be a wrinkled face, but it is all the dearer for that, and none the less cheerful. We linger near it, and gaze tenderly upon it, and say, “God bless this dear happy face!” We must keep it with us as long as we can, for home will lose much of its brightness when this sweet face is gone. And after it is gone, how the remembrance of it softens our wayward natures! When care and sorrow snap our heart-strings asunder, in memory we still see this wrinkled face, and the painful tension grows lighter, the way seems less dreary, and the sorrows less heavy. God bless the cheerful face! What a dreary world this would be without this heaven-born light!—Home Visitor.

DON'T HEAR EVERYTHING.

THE art of not hearing should be learned by all. It is fully as important to domestic happiness as a cultivated ear, for which so much money and time are expended. There are so many things which it is painful to hear, many which we ought not to hear, very many which, if heard, will disturb the temper, corrupt the simplicity and modesty, distract from contentment and happiness, that every one should be educated to take in or shut out sounds according to his pleasure.
If a man falls into a violent passion, and calls us all manner of names, at the first word we should shut our ears and hear no more. If, in our quiet voyage of life, we find ourselves caught in one of those domestic whirlwinds of scolding, we should shut our ears as a sailor would furl his sails, and making all tight, scud before the gale. If a hot and restless man begins to inflame our feelings, we should consider what mischief these fiery sparks may do in our magazine below, where our temper is kept, and instantly close the door.
If, as has been remarked, all the petty things said of one by heedless or ill-natured idlers were to be brought home to him, he would become a mere walking pin-cushion, stuck full of sharp remarks. If we would be happy, when among good men we should open our ears; when among bad men, shut them. It is not worth while to hear what our neighbors say about our children, what our rivals say about our business, or dress, or our affairs.
The art of not hearing, though untaught in our schools, is by no means unpracticed in society. We have noticed that a well-bred woman never hears a vulgar or impertinent remark. A kind of discreet deafness saves one from many insults, from much blame, and from not a little connivance in dishonorable conversation.—Treasure Trove.

THE DIVISIONS OF PROTESTANTISM.

The Northern Presbyterians are holding their General Assembly at Philadelphia, and the Southern Presbyterians are in General Assembly at Baltimore. The Southern Baptists have just closed their Annual Convention at Richmond, and the Northern Baptists have opened their anniversary meetings at Washington.
In both of these great denominations the sectional divisions do not represent any differences as to doctrine and order, and the fraternity of feeling between them seems to be complete. On Tuesday the attendance at the Baptist Convention at Richmond was small, because so many of the delegates had gone to Washington to participate in the meetings of their Northern brethren. Next Thursday the Southern General Assembly at Baltimore will go to Philadelphia, as a body, to unite with the Northern General Assembly in celebrating the Presbyterian centenary.
Yet the present indications are that the attempts in each of these denominations to bring about organic unity by the obliteration of sectional lines of separation, will not prove successful. It was the slavery question that provoked the division, and now it is the race question that keeps it up. The Northern and Southern Presbyterians seem to disagree only so far as concerns the organization of an independent African Church. The Southern Baptists provided for the appointment of a committee to meet a like committee of Northern missionary societies to arrange for co-operation in missionary work, but they expressly declared that it was “not with a view to organic union;” and when a motion was made to strike out that conditional clause, it was defeated by an overwhelming vote. All that is to be considered, is the adjustment of the “several fields and agencies, so as not to have a conflict” between the sectional divisions of the denomination. Here, too, difference of opinion as to the colored brethren and churches undoubtedly prevails, according to geographical lines.
Such lack of harmony of course involves greater expense of effort and money than would be required if there was organic union. Two sets of organizations for missionary and other church purposes are kept up when one could accomplish the work, with a saving in salaries and the general cost of running the machinery. As so great a part of the money collected for these purposes goes to pay collecting agents and society officers, the practical argument for consolidation is therefore of the strongest sort. But sentimental considerations stand in the way of the unity which is so desirable as a measure of economy, and of course if the Northern and Southern members of the denominations are willing to pay in hard cash for the privilege of holding their respective prejudices, they have an undoubted right to do it. It is their money, and they can do what they please with it, though in the world of secular affairs such sacrifice of substantial benefit to mere sentiment is more and more regarded as childish short-sightedness and obstinacy.
But throughout the field of Protestant missionary effort we find analogous conflicts and division. Even in denominations which are so closely akin in creed and order that their ministers pass from one to the other, there are separate organizations for such work, and others whose differences concern more forms of church government and do not affect their theological standards, maintain distinct societies for the propagation of a common faith, as if they were radically and intrinsically at variance.
There are, for instance, eleven different kinds of Baptists, fourteen of Methodists, nine of Presbyterians, and five of Lutherans. The Congregationalists are separated from the Presbyterians only in church government, and the clergy of one satisfy the doctrinal requirements of the other; and yet they continue to work independently for religious ends. Of course, heathendom and Christendom both are confused by such a state of things, and the more so, inasmuch as all the Protestant churches known as orthodox and evangelical are substantially in agreement on their fundamental theology. The difference between the dish served up is in its form and garniture, and not in its ingredients.
The partisan spirit, in fine, is strong in all of them, and it seems that even the sectional spirit, a relic of the old days of slavery, is still unconquerable. The day of organic Christian union, of which we have heard so much of late years, seems, therefore, to be far in the future. It is among the enemies of faith that we see ranks unbroken by partisan division, while Christendom is split up into innumerable varieties of faith, each more or less at war with the rest.—N. Y. Sun.

WILL INDIA BECOME MOHAMMEDAN OR CHRISTIAN?

A thoughtful writer in the Contemporary Review maintains that entirely different methods from those now pursued by our missionaries will have to be adopted in India, in order to reach and convert her people. Mohammedanism has already achieved remarkable success there. Every fifth person in that vast empire whose inhabitants number one fifth of the whole human race, is a follower of the Arabian prophet. Nor has this success been won, as commonly supposed, by the sword. Persecution may have had some effect in exceptional localities, as for example, in Sind and Mysore. But the great and substantial gain has been the offspring of ardent and ceaseless proselytism. The Mussulman both by the conviction of his faith and by every motive of politics—love of power and aggrandizement, as well as escape from taxation through the process of unloading on to others—is a zealot determined above all things upon the propagation of his religion; and accordingly the task of bringing souls under allegiance to the prophet waits not to be done by a few priests, or missionaries set apart for the purpose, but is eagerly seized and prosecuted by every child of the crescent and star. Moreover, the genius of Islam has been found admirably adapted to the Hindu mental and moral traits, and their creeds and modes of life.
The essence of Hinduism, if not of its creeds, is fear—fear of the unknown result which may follow upon error either in conduct, or in faith, or in ceremonial. A single belief, the belief in his predestination, which is firmly accepted by every Hindu, fills his mind with vague terrors from which, while that conviction lasts, there cannot be by any possibility any full relief. He is responsible for the sins he knows nothing of, and who can say that any punishment of them would be unjust or excessive. If misfortune comes to him, that is his due; and a Hindu once unlucky, often broods like a Calvinist who thinks he is not of the elect. The modes of obtaining safety are infinite, but are all burdensome, and all, by the confession of those who use them, are more or less uncertain.
Now, the doctrine of the divine sovereignty carried to its extreme as it is in the system of Islam, meets perfectly this characteristic phase of Hindu theology. The idea of one divine being, lonely, omnipresent and eternal, revealing through Mohammed his will, that those who believe in him shall have eternal bliss in heaven, which is earth over again with its delights intensified and its restrictions removed, and that those who disbelieve in him shall suffer torment forevermore, become to its recipient a source of freedom from painful and endless ceremonies, and an assurance equal to fate itself of safety and happiness in the world beyond. Hence it meets with welcome.
Again, the followers of the prophet were not essentially alien in race. They were Asiatics, and accordingly were in a kind of unconscious sympathy and fellowship with the East Indians to whom they proclaimed their faith. Christianity has always labored under great disadvantages being preached by Europeans. “Something radical, something unalterable and indestructible, divides the Asiatic from the European.” For example, the Armenian, because he is an Asiatic, is tolerated as a Christian by the Mussulman, whereas any other Christian not an Asiatic would be slain at sight. The writer whose views we are condensing does not think that the Mohammedan privilege of polygamy in this world and the promise of houris in the next, have exerted very much influence in making converts, since all history shows that men looking for light desire a creed, and an ideal higher than their practice. For example, “the most dissolute of European societies foisted upon Christianity a restriction, celibacy, stronger than any Christ had taught; while the rigorous chastity of Christianity did not stop its spread in the abandoned society of the rotting Roman world. Once more: Islamism did not ask the Hindu to surrender absolutely his notions and practice of caste. It only asked him to exchange his caste for another and better one,—since the Islam caste is the largest, the most strictly bound, and the proudest of all,—a caste which claims not only a special relation to God, but the right of ruling absolutely all the remainder of mankind. Once in this caste the Hindu convert would be a brother of all within it, hailed as an equal, and treated as an equal even upon that point on which European theories of equality always break down—the rights of intermarriage.
The rule of Islam forbidding indulgence in wine and all alcoholic beverages is another strong feature in its favor among the better class of Hindus, for the reason that they see in alcohol a deadly poison for their race. It is claimed that while the white races do not suffer except comparatively from drinking usages, yet the red and brown and black races find in such usages an inveterate and deadly foe, not simply to their souls, but to their very bodily exertions. Fire-water to most Asiatics is fire-water in deed, as well as in name. It awakens an uncontrollable craving for more, which ends in the complete stupor of intoxication. “I drinkee not for drinkee,” said the Madras man; “I drinkee for drunk!” To get beastly, dead drunk is his Elysium, and to do it as often as possible becomes the one absorbing aim of his wretched life. Hence the call by Islam to rigorous and total abstinence seems to the philanthropic and noble Hindu like a call from heaven, by heeding which his people are to be guarded against a serious tempter that would soon kill both body and soul.
With all these things in its favor, and the significant fact that on the average 50,000 converts a year since the beginning have been added to Islamism, it is feared by many careful observers that at no distant day all India may be transferred, not to Christ, but to Mohammed. It is true that Christianity has grown in India, but not as it should have grown—not as Buddhism once grew, when it swept millions within its influence in a short period; not as Islam and other forms of error have grown. There are only 660,000 Christians belonging to all the Reformed churches in India, although it must not be forgotten that, if the aboriginal tribes be included, conversions are proportionally more numerous to-day to Christianity than to Mohammedanism. The reasons assigned for the slow spread of Christ’s gospel are three:—
First, from the peculiar nature of the Hindu mind, he is capable of holding precisely opposite creeds as true, without changing his conduct in the least. A Hindu astronomer will predict eclipses ten years ahead without a blunder, and yet believe all the while, and sincerely believe, that the eclipse is caused by some supernatural dog swallowing the moon, and will beat a drum to make the dog give up its prize. And in the same way a Hindu will state with perfect honesty that Christianity is true, that Mohammedanism is true, and that his own special variety of Brahmanism is true, and that he believes them all implicitly. What, then, can you do with a man whom you have labored with your whole soul to convince, who is convinced, and who remains just as unconvinced for any practical purpose as he was before? Another obstacle is found in the fact that Christ is not, according to Hindu notions, enough of a sovereign and legislator. He is too humble, too self-denying, too resigned to his fate. The Hindu, it is said, is not attracted to that sort of a man or god.
A second, and still more decisive hindrance lies in the Christian necessity of forcing the new convert to give up his caste. This means a surrender of his domestic law, the harem-like seclusion of his home, much of his authority over his wife and children, his right of compelling his daughter to marry early, which he holds a part of his honor, most of his daily habits, and even his method of eating his meals.
Finally, Christianity, to succeed, must abandon its expensive habit of employing some 700 Europeans and Americans as high-priced missionaries, and ally itself instead to the native population by the employment of 3,000 native preachers for the same money. In eighty years no great native missionary has arisen, nor has there been developed a real native church. Asiatic converts must do the work of proselytism among Asiatics. There must be less fear of imperfect Christianity. Christianity is always imperfect in the beginning of its career among heathen races. Give the natives a chance. Nevertheless, and by and by their doctrine and life will grow more into the lofty ideal revealed by Jesus. These views are the well-matured convictions of one who has been many years among the Brahmans, and who is deeply acquainted with Indian traits, history, and prospects. They deserve careful consideration. — T. S. Doolittle, D.D., in Christian at Work.
Continue reading: ARKANSAS TRACT SOCIETY ORGANIZATION: