In the account of the final judgment, John says that “the books were opened; . . . and the dead were judged out of those things which were written in the books, according to their works.” Rev. 20:12. The judgment here includes the retribution due to those who are judged. But there is a difference in the works recorded in the books. There are different degrees of guilt attaching to different individuals. There must, therefore, be a difference in degrees of punishment, if that is meted out according to their works. “Then,” says the believer in the immortality of the wicked and the eternal duration of their conscious misery, “the doctrine of the final destruction of the wicked cannot be true; for there can be no degrees of punishment in the condition of total extinction of being. And on the other hand some of those who believe the latter doctrine are about ready to deny a difference in degrees of punishment, which seems to be so clearly set forth in the Scriptures.”
We shall undertake to show that there are degrees in the punishment of the wicked, and that the doctrine that the wages of sin is death, is also true, and that there is no conflict between these views.
The Bible seems so clearly to recognize degrees of punishment for the wicked, that it is generally accepted without question; that is, that some are more guilty than others, and that the more guilty will be punished with more severity than the less guilty, according to their deeds.
The statement so often made in the Scriptures, that every man shall be rewarded “according to his works,” recognizes this principle, in a general way; for it is evident to all that the works of some are far more heinous than the works of others, which are also bad; and the instinct of justice implanted in every heart at once says that the sentence against these more wicked acts should be framed accordingly, as is done even in courts of justice here upon the earth.
Again: Paul shows by his own experience that there are degrees in human guilt, and that this fact will be taken into account in dealing with the offender. Speaking of himself, in 1 Tim. 1:13, he says: “Who was before a blasphemer, and a persecutor, and injurious; but I obtained mercy, because I did it ignorantly in unbelief.” Here the apostle pleads, in extenuation of his actions, the fact of his ignorance. This made him less guilty, and made possible a more lenient manner of dealing with him. Had he done these things with his eyes open, and to gratify a conscious spirit of diabolical hatred against the gospel of Christ, could he then have received mercy? Had he persisted in his injurious course, would he not have soon put himself beyond the reach of God’s grace?
James also uses language which conveys the same idea (3:1): “My brethren, be not many masters, knowing that we shall receive the greater condemnation. For in many things we offend all.” Here he shows that though we all offend in many things, and are blameworthy on this account, we may take a course to subject ourselves to greater condemnation, or become more guilty, than if we had refrained from such a course.
In Heb. 10:28, 29 the apostle Paul uses expressions which throw great light on this question. He says: “He that despised Moses’s law died without mercy under two or three witnesses; of how much sorer punishment, suppose ye, shall he be thought worthy, who hath trodden under foot the Son of God, and hath counted the blood of the covenant, wherewith he was sanctified, an unholy thing, and hath done despite unto the Spirit of grace.” Here a sorer penalty is recognized for the greater sin.
But perhaps the most direct statement of any on this question is found in Luke 12:47, 48: “And that servant, which knew his lord’s will, and prepared not himself, neither did according to his will, shall be beaten with many stripes. But he that knew not, and did commit things worthy of stripes, shall be beaten with few stripes. For unto whomsoever much is given, of him shall be much required.” And this, as shown by the preceding verses, was spoken to show how God will deal with us in our final account.
The fact of degrees of punishment being thus established, the believer in eternal suffering, as already stated, is disposed to use it against the view that the destiny of the wicked is cessation of conscious being in death; for how, it is asked, can there be any degrees in that condition? So far as the condition itself, abstractly considered, is concerned, there can be no degrees; for one cannot be more dead than another, nor more unconscious than another in death, where consciousness is completely extinct in both. But there is something more to be taken into consideration. The wages of sin is not simply “to be dead,” but it is “death;” and death includes all that leads to death, embracing, of course, the process of dying with all the conditions, emotions, and feelings attendant thereon; and in that process there are tribulation and anguish. The apostle sets forth these very conditions, as included in the penalty for sin. Mark well his words: “Who [God] will render to every man according to his deeds; . . . indignation and wrath, tribulation and anguish, upon every soul of man that doeth evil.” Rom. 2:6–9. Degrees of punishment must, of course, be confined to that stage of the infliction during which consciousness continues; for there can be no difference after that.
Now we ask the believer in eternal suffering how he will have degrees of punishment in his scheme, since the punishment of all is to be eternal? He will doubtless say that the degrees will be secured in the intensity of the suffering; that some will suffer severer pain than others, according to their guilt. Then, it may be replied that, on the hypothesis of final unconsciousness as the wages of sin, there is a place for the same distinction. That is, in the process of dying, some may suffer much more intensely and keenly than others, according to their guilt.
But right here there is another important element in favor of this view; namely, the element of duration; for while the suffering of some may be more intense than that of others, it may be also much longer continued, according to the degrees of their guilt; and so there would be, on this ground, a double means of adjusting the penalty to the degrees of guilt and the awards of judgment.
On the other hand, with the idea of eternal conscious suffering, there can be no degrees of punishment; for, remember, this is held to be absolutely without end; it is infinite; and we can find no degrees in infinity. What matters it if at any particular time one is suffering less than another, if the former is to come at length to the same degree of suffering as the other? and that whatever degree the most guilty may have reached, the others are destined in due time, to reach the same; and this without any end? No; this can never be. The justice of God and the harmony of the Scriptures can be fully vindicated only on the ground of a correct view of God’s dealings with his creatures, which is that those only who choose life will have that glorious boon at last in eternal possession, while those who reject God’s gracious offer, will reap the result of their course finally in the second death, and become as though they had not been. Obadiah 16.
There is genuine satisfaction in finding and cherishing a truth which vindicates the character of God, and enables us to exclaim with patriarch and prophet, “Shall not the Judge of all the earth do right?” and, “Just and true are thy ways, thou King of saints.” Gen. 18:25; Rev. 15:3. U. S.
OVERCOMING
By G. C. T.
One word that was in former days very current in our religious experiences has almost disappeared from the vocabulary of many. It is of frequent occurrence in the Scriptures, especially in connection with the promises of final reward. That word is “overcome,” and its immediate derivative, “overcomer.” If dropping the use of the word in the relation of our Christian experience means that we have dropped the idea out of those experiences, then we do not hesitate to say that those who have dropped it have introduced a fatal flaw into the fabric of their faith.
To overcome means to gain the supremacy, to be victorious, to conquer. It does not imply a passive, inert condition, in which there are no conflicts nor adversities. It implies deep wrestling, continued struggles for the mastery, with final victory. “To him that overcometh” some of the most precious promises are made. One which, perhaps, embraces all other promises is the following: “He that overcometh shall inherit all things; and I will be his God, and he shall be my son.” The palms of victory, the crowns of glory, are but mementoes of the struggles through which those who bear them have victoriously passed.
Let no one flatter himself that some one else is to do all his fighting for him. Neither Christ nor his angels will do for us what we are required to do ourselves. He supplies the armor and the arms; he supplies the strength, and inspires the courage; he teaches our hands to war, and our fingers to fight. We may ascribe to him all the praise and credit, but to us he says: “Stand fast in the faith, quit you like men, be strong.”
The thing to be overcome is evil,—not in the abstract, but in the concrete. The “evil one,” the author of evil, will be met in many places and in various forms. As faithful soldiers, we361are to resist him. The most effectual battleground, the most important point of contest, is the evil in our own hearts and lives. The most effectual weapon against evil is the word of God strengthened by prayer. While it is true that “the weapons of our warfare are not carnal,” it is also true that they are “mighty through God.”
The faith that overcomes the world is not that easy-going sentiment often labeled “faith,” which, while it sings, “Jesus paid it all,” really means Jesus does it all. He has never promised to do this only in the sense that he does it by us. Even though the inspiration, the strength, and the implements are furnished by another, yet we, as the intelligent and voluntary instruments, must feel the brunt of battle. We must engage the foe. We must watch his approach and resist his attacks; but under Christ we need not fear. He has overcome, and says: “To him that overcometh will I grant to sit with me in my throne, even as I also overcame, and am set down with my Father in his throne.” G. C. T.
ROOT AND BRANCH.
By Uriah Smith
When man would destroy a noxious tree, he knows that it is not enough simply to destroy the leaves, the branches, and the trunk, but the root must be destroyed also. He must cut it away, root and branch. On the same principle the Lord works in his dealings with sin and the human family. Whatever is noxious and evil in his sight, which he finds it necessary to destroy, he makes clean work of it, and destroys it root and branch.
Many evils are represented under the figure of a tree. All the hosts of evil, from the originator of sin to all its followers, are thus illustrated. The evils in the church are called roots of bitterness springing up, whereby men are defiled.
The prophet Malachi tells us how the Lord will deal with these evil things at last: “For, behold, the day cometh, that shall burn as an oven; and all the proud, yea, and all that do wickedly, shall be stubble; and the day that cometh shall burn them up, saith the Lord of hosts, that it shall leave them neither root nor branch.” Mal. 4:1.
In this figure the root is the Devil, and the branches are the followers of the Devil, including his evil angels and the wicked of this world; and in the fiery furnace of the cleansing day, when the earth will be purified for the everlasting abode of the righteous, these workers of iniquity will be cast into the fiery flame and burned up, till they cease to be, both root and branch; but the Lord proposes to destroy sin in us here, to make us his people, and he will do it root and branch, if we will submit to the process.
So in the tree of vice, it will do no good to pluck off a few leaves or trim out a few branches here and there. The root of the tree must be destroyed if the evil is ever put away. A man's sins are his outward acts. These may be pardoned continuously, but that would be dealing only with the leaves and branches of the evil tree. He would still be a sinner if the disposition to sin still remained and rankled in his heart. The heart is the root from which these bitter fruits spring, and the evil must be cured there, or it is not cured at all. But we may be thankful that this is just what the Lord proposes to do for us, not only to forgive the sin, but to cure the sinfulness of the disposition. He forgives sin, thus making the branches right. Then he goes to the root by the power of his blessed gospel in the heart, and changes it from a root of bitterness to a health-giving plant, sending forth the marrow and fatness of the gospel. Then we can work, not after the flesh, but after the Spirit. Then instead of having a carnal mind (which is not subject to the law of God, and cannot be), we have the spiritual mind, which delights in that law. Then we pass out of old ways and old things, and to us, as new creatures, old things become new in Christ Jesus; sins disappear from the record of our lives, and best of all the sinfulness disappears from the fountain of the heart. Thus the work is done for us root and branch.
Shall we fully yield ourselves to the Lord, that he may work this great and essential change in us, that we may be his, root and branch?
U. S.
NORTH CAROLINA.
By D. T. Shierman; B. F. Purdham
GREENSBORO.—Our tent-meetings in this place still continue with increasing interest and attendance. The rains have prevented a few services, but at other times the people have come out to hear and have manifested a desire to learn the truth. We have quite thoroughly advertised through the daily paper and by hand-bills, and think this has been a great help to the meetings.
The “stay-away” argument is being used effectively with some of the people, while many others show that they want better argument than that. We hope the Lord may gather out some precious fruit at this place. The workers' institute is now in session here, and is deeply interesting. We are of good courage in the Lord.
May 24. D. T. SHIERMAN, B. F. PURDHAM.
FLORIDA
By L. H. Crisler
SINCE returning from the General Conference, my time has been occupied in visiting churches. This has afforded ample opportunity to see the sad havoc wrought by the late freeze. It is truly heart-rending to see the life-work of hundreds of individuals blotted out in a single night.
However, we have had a favorable growing season since the catastrophe, and the otherwise barren land is covered with a bountiful harvest of vegetables and growing corn. But as Florida is not by any means wholly dependent on the orange industry, we shall hope to see her recuperate rapidly, learning profitable lessons concerning diversified industries.
The manufacturing and railroad interests are so active at present that Jacksonville and Tampa, the principal cities of the State, are gaining in population more rapidly than at any other period in their history. The following is a very succinct and fair summary of the situation, which is clipped from the Review of Reviews for May:—
“Railroad building on the east coast is only one of many signs of activity in the Floridian peninsula. Until a few years ago, central and southern Florida were almost as little known as the heart of Africa. It was supposed that most of the peninsula below St. Augustine was a marshy waste. Exploration and official survey have indeed shown that much of the southern end of the island is an irredeemable swamp. But as for the greater part of the peninsula, it is a land of wonderful resources and possibilities. Not only are its agricultural resources almost limitless, but also it has an inexhaustible wealth of phosphates and other mineral deposits. The immense cotton belt of the South will afford a constant demand for high-priced fertilizers, like the phosphates of South Carolina and Florida. The progress of this phosphate industry would astonish those who have not as yet had their attention called to the recent facts. The destruction of the orange groves of Florida and of adjacent Southern States by the February frosts, is indeed a heavy blow; but the result will be a more diversified farming and fruit culture, and in the end, Florida as a State will perhaps have gained more than she has lost.”
The spiritual interests are encouraging. The Waldo church has a comfortable building in which to hold services. There were three accessions to their membership during our last visit, and there are more to follow.
The Tampa church has a good building, which362will comfortably seat 200 people. We are most happy to report that their indebtedness on the building is becoming greatly reduced, and the membership was never in a better spiritual condition.
The Cuban element, on which the growth and prosperity of the city largely depend on account of the cigar industry, pays but little regard to the Sunday, which calls out occasional articles in the public prints on Sunday desecration. This enables our writers on religious liberty to get in some sturdy blows on this line. Our largest church, Terra Cei, is forty miles south of Tampa, in the Manatee country.
The ordinances of the Lord’s house were celebrated here, and altogether we had a most precious meeting. It has been my privilege to visit the Bartow work several times this spring, which is being conducted by Elder Butler. The most determined and persistent effort has been and is being made at this point, to demolish Seventh-day Adventism. But all to no avail. The mist of error is being brushed from the eyes of the people, and some are embracing the truth. The meetings continue in the tent some three and one-half miles from the city, with a fair interest, after having been held in the city some three months.
On the whole, though our finances are somewhat short, we think there is great reason to praise the Lord in this State, as there never was a time in our history when more people were inquiring after and embracing the truth. To the Lord be all the praise. L. H. Crisler.
MISSISSIPPI
By M. S. Babcock; R. M. Kilgore
Meridian.—Our meetings continued about two weeks. The interest was small from the beginning. We closed them last Sunday night. The small-pox scare which has raged here was more than we were able to withstand. Other towns have quarantined against Meridian, and we have been shut in here. We are packing up and will leave as soon as the way may open. We are not alarmed ourselves. Our hope is in God. We shall go forward as soon as we can. The small-pox is now subsiding, and we hope the quarantine will be raised in a short time. M. S. Babcock, R. M. Kilgore.
MICHIGAN
By O. Soule
MECOSTA.—Since the General Conference I have spent some time securing for the brethren of Mecosta a building for a church, and now the work of completing it is going on as fast as the hard times will permit. I began a series of meetings in a school-house four miles distant, May 1. So far six have accepted the message. O. SOULE.
VERMONT
By H. E. Rickard
EAST RICHFORD.—May 10 I returned to East Richford, Vt., where the Lord so richly blessed my labors a few weeks ago. The keeping power of God had been over those that started to serve him when I was there before, and some desired to follow their Lord in baptism. May 19 I baptized four persons of mature years, and they, with one who had previously been baptized, were received into the church. During the meetings three more decided to keep the Sabbath of the Lord, and at our closing meeting ten came forward for prayers. Brother F. S. Porter, who was holding a canvassers’ school at that place, rendered valuable assistance in conducting the meetings. We feel to praise the Lord; for he “giveth the increase.” H. E. Rickard.
TRUST
By Mary M. Cook
BY MARY M. COOK.
(Fresno, Cal.)
I HEAR a voice surpassing sweet
Above the gloom glad words repeat:
Be not dismayed, I am thy God,
I’ll keep thee while beneath the rod.
’T is music to my heart so lone;
I will not fear, but travel on;
And though I cannot see my way,
His presence sweet shall be my stay.
Then though no stars or sun appear
For many days, I will not fear;
While He is with me, all is well;
I’ll help the notes of praise to swell.
His counsel now shall be my guide,
His word within my heart I’ll hide;
By faith upon his arm I’ll lean
And trust the glorious One unseen.
So shall I safely reach my home;
So surely I shall overcome;
So, fearless, pass from earth away,
And meet the loved in endless day.
J. N. LOUGHBOROUGH
By John Norton Loughborough
DISTRICT NO. 5.
The work is onward in Dist. No. 5. We are continually hearing of souls that are accepting the truth, not only from the efforts of our ministers, but from the reading of our periodicals and books. From May 10-15 I was in council with our ministers and laborers in the Oklahoma Conference, in Oklahoma City. I learned from the president, brother J. M. Rees, that the number of members in the churches in that Conference is now 540, and there are about two hundred scattered Sabbath-keepers within the bounds of the Conference, who have not yet been organized into churches. About one hundred have been added to their number since the Conference was organized last August. Three churches have been organized, which are awaiting admission to the Conference. The tithes for the three quarters since the organization, amount to $1882. A camp-ground has been secured in a nice elm grove near Oklahoma City, and the Conference and camp-meeting are to be held there. Two tents are already in the field in the Oklahoma Conference. Elder Rees will devote his time to the churches and scattered ones, while brethren Brock, Russell, and White work with the tents. The drouth generally complained of in the West has cut off the wheat and the oat crop in Oklahoma. Their hope is that they may raise a little corn. This is true of Oklahoma proper, but in the Cherokee Strip and some parts of the Indian Territory, I think the drouth is not quite so severe.
Our ministers through Dist. No. 5 are now mostly out with the tents, and report good interest. I have spent a few days in Topeka, where we have settled, and have spoken to the church in their meetings the last two Sabbaths. Next week I expect to enter upon general meetings and camp-meetings which continue without intermission till Oct. 6. I trust the Lord for his sustaining grace through this series of meetings.
The same spirit that leads the people in other parts of the world to secure more stringent Sunday laws, prevails here. Just at present the ministers of Topeka have formed a “union” to enforce the laws for Sunday-keeping. I went last Sunday to hear one of these advocates. He gave his audience many assertions, which they most seemed to swallow greedily, as though they needed no proof. He told us the Sabbath was instituted at the close of the Lord’s six days of labor in creating the heavens and the earth; that those days were now conceded by all to be long, indefinite periods of thousands of years each; the Lord’s rest day was sanctified for himself to rest on, and that rest was still going on; it had been going on for six thousand years, and no one, “not even the angels in heaven,” could tell how much longer that rest would continue.
He told us that the decalogue, fourth commandment and all, was binding, just as God gave it at Mount Sinai. He said that the Sabbath was little referred to in the New Testament; but that whenever it was mentioned, it was with reference to another day which was to be kept for “higher reasons” than the Jews had in keeping the Sabbath. He told us that God was dishonored by Sunday trains, Sunday newspapers, Sunday ice-cream venders, and by people going to the post-office on Sunday for their mail. He said that God expected his church to enforce his law and to compel obedience to it. The Lord made known his will to his people, and then it became their duty to “execute” his will. He said he did not ask for more law on the Sunday question. The law was ample; but what he did ask for was that the church lend its influence to the executive officers in enforcing the law. His discourse in its closing portion seemed to be on the line of a religion of force, and compelling the people to be good. So the work goes on; and so the Sunday, the badge of papal power, is being exalted everywhere. It is not all smooth sailing among them here, however, for one of their ministers told them (when they presented to him a petition to sign, to secure a more rigid observance of Sunday) that he “would sooner go to jail” himself “than sign a petition to have men compelled to keep Sunday in opposition to their own convictions of conscience.” But then, that candid minister had read the American Sentinel.
J. N. LOUGHBOROUGH
Zoreno, Italy, May 13
By J. D. Geymet
FROM ITALY.
DEAR REVIEW; Permit me to say from this distant place that every week you are welcome in our midst, and that the many truths which you contain are of great help and encouragement to me while the powers of darkness are pressing around. The precious truth of Jesus is strong, giving peace and leading to salvation. We are but few here, but we feel deeply that the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus give light, and are a barrier between the right and the wrong.
I will copy from our newspapers some extracts which will show how the enemy is working in this country. In La Stampa Piedmont Gazette, of Venice, we read: “Lately an association was established between the agents and the masters of warehouses with the design to promote an agitation to the end that an absolute day of rest be sanctioned and secured by the law of the State. In this purpose the following action was voted, considering that the agents of storehouses after six days of labor need a day of rest. Considering that this principle is demanded by many and the laws of hygiene, and in view of humane principles, we resolve that the Italian Parliament be requested to consider the rightful claims of warehousemen to a day of rest, and that we petition for a law which will sanction a complete rest on the feast day.”
This action was forwarded to the president of the Council and the chairman of the Chamber. The same question is now before the Milan Communal Council, and is supported by many influential men throughout the peninsula.
We quote from the Bulletino Missionary, the organ of the Waldensian Churches, of April, 1895, as follows: “The Waldensian Synod appointed the third Sunday in January to be especially observed in all the churches in behalf of Sunday sacredness. The object is to secure a unanimity of action, and thus form a stronger movement in behalf of the recognition of Sunday. The memorial issued by the synod gives extended reasons for the observance of the day from moral, spiritual, and health standpoints.” By these examples we see that the image of the beast is springing up, and even the Waldenses are receiving the spirit of the papacy. The very Scriptures which support the Sabbath are used to enforce the idea of Sunday observance.
I spent the winter in the valleys with some success. I am temporarily in Zoreno, with friends, giving private Bible readings and doing missionary work. I hope soon to begin meetings in a hall, and work openly among the Catholics. May God help his servants and bless their work throughout the world. J. D. GEYMET.
Zoreno, Italy, May 13
THE IMPORTANCE OF PROMPT ACTION IN THE CIRCULATION OF PRESENT-TRUTH LITERATURE.
By F. W. Morse
THERE are truths brought out in “Great Controversy” that are of special interest just now. A prominent one is the great price that our forefathers paid for the maintenance of liberty of conscience. They could yield their lives, but not the precious principle of the right to act as they believed to be just and true in whatever God required of them.
In wise purchasing, we value things by their intrinsic usefulness as well as by what they cost. Then what value should we set upon this principle of human freedom and liberty to think? Those who lived before us poured out their blood like water upon the cruel altars of Roman persecution; and we are gathering the fruits of that vast and priceless expenditure of the lives of millions, yielded up even cheerfully, rather than let go the Heaven-given right to individual choice in matters of religious duty. The intolerant majority decreed death to all who dared differ with them in things of faith, thus demanding entire submission to the ruling powers of this world, regardless of personal convictions as to the claims of God.
Do we suitably estimate this treasure of free choice? and do we properly hate the opposite, which is so wholly wrong and evil in its tendency, that, sooner than adopt it, those martyrs submitted to flame and torture almost beyond human belief? “Great Controversy” brings these things before the people, and it shows that what the great deceiver attempted to make appear as the aim of our Creator, is really his own wicked purpose from first to last; and all who seek to make men religious by force of law, are only taking the side of those who lighted the martyr fires of the Dark Ages, and are joining hands with the prince of darkness, the common enemy of God and man.
These are most important things, and they should be brought before the people everywhere just now. I am persuaded that when we properly understand the mission the Lord has assigned to this book, we shall all feel like standing in that position toward canvassing for this and other books and publications of its stamp, which is indicated by the plea, Lord, “here am I; send me.”
I also believe that, when the same spirit that dwelt in those who stood for the right at the cost of life itself, shall be in us, we may reasonably expect the sound of the loud cry to be heard in our descriptions of these publications that carry the solemn warning of God to the people. And in this view of the case, I see a solution of the question of how to advance the canvassing work. Met by God’s power, the gathering hindrances cannot stay the work; but our God works only through willing workers, those who feel his mighty word as the living fire363pent up within, and who must speak forth what the living Christ begets within them.
“O for that flame of living fire
Which shone so bright in saints of old;
Which bade their souls to heaven aspire,
Calm in distress, in danger bold!”
Shall we not consider that drawing “nigh to God” can only be a fact insomuch as we act in line with God’s sacred truth which is for this present time? That means to warn our fellow-men of the present evil designs and work of the great adversary of all souls. Is not the wise circulation of such literature as “Great Controversy” particularly calculated to do this? Read and re-read the book, dear friends; ponder upon it; pray God to give you the burden for souls, and answer this question for yourself. The affirmative response will appear as you learn to describe such publications, learn to turn readily to such paragraphs in them as will impressively show to others the warnings that God is delivering through their pages; and then go out cheerfully and find homes where you can place them. What do you say, my brother? Here is an invitation for you, and if you will address me at Moncton, N. B., I will give you further particulars.
F. W. MORSE, General Agent for Maritime Provinces.