Your ShelfYour Projects

Review and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 35.

The War in Egypt

Review and Herald

Aug 29, 1882

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 29, 1882

The War in Egypt.

[Synopsis of a sermon preached in St. John’s Episcopal Church, Cincinnati, by Rev. J. S. Jenckes, Sunday morning, July 30.]
TEXT: “And the sixth angel poured out his vial upon the great river Euphrates, and the water thereof was dried up, that the way of the kings of the East might be prepared.” Rev. 16:12.
The text, taken from the book of Revelation, suggests a subject which is now of thrilling interest to the whole civilized world, as well as to many millions of people whom we do not rate as civilized. And this subject, if you please, is the “Eastern Question.”
This question involves the social, the political, and the religious interests of all the great powers of Europe, if not also the very autonomy and existence of some of them. And although, fortunately for us, five thousand miles of ocean lie between ourselves and the seething caldron of European political complications, still there is no other question of such present vital concern to at least the commercial interests of the United States as this Turko-Egyptian, or “Eastern Question.” Else why is it that in the very face of, perhaps, the most bountiful wheat crop we have ever had, the high price of wheat is maintained, aye, more than maintained, at Chicago?
In order to understand clearly the full nature of the great interest which surrounds this subject, and which is likely to surround it for several years to come, it will be necessary to take a hasty review of the history of Egypt and of Turkey.
From the year 622 of the Christian era dates the Mohammedan system of chronology—the year in which Mohammed left the city of Mecca and removed to Medina, from which place his remarkable career of conquest began. His successors extended still farther the dominions whose standard was the Crescent, until they became in the eighth century more extensive than even the Roman empire in its palmiest days. This was the empire of Arabia, whose emperors, called caliphs (signifying both the spiritual and temporal successors of the prophet), reigned through different dynasties for nine hundred years.
They were a gallant, accomplished, and powerful people, great in war, great in arts and sciences, and great in learning. Their architectural remains are still wonders of beauty and symmetry; their astronomers, physicians, poets, orators, and philosophers were distinguished; their language, in which the Koran is written, is a marvel of strength and polish, and of capability of expressing the most abstruse thoughts, the most exalted sentiments, with the greatest possible force, coupled with the most delicate discrimination of meaning. In this respect it greatly resembles the Greek. And these Arabs are the people who, after their astonishing vigor and military success, and after their extravagant grandeur and voluptuousness of living, and after their degeneracy and decay—the old, old story, you will perceive—were overrun and vanquished by the wretched Turks in the thirteenth to the sixteenth century. These are the people who are the ancestors of Arabi Pasha, who, through the lines of their caliphs, traces his pedigree away back to Joktan, who was a son of Shem, who was the eldest son of Noah!
Is it any wonder that the late dispatches inform us that Arabi looks down upon his Turkish masters with infinite derision and scorn, as an inferior race? For the Turks were a tribe of foreign barbarians, who swept down from the cold tablelands of Central Asia, precisely as the Goths and Vandals, at an earlier day, swept down upon the Roman empire and destroyed it, and crushing easily the degenerate ranks of the now effeminate Arabs, conquered their country, and made it their own. The invaders eliminated all the good and strong features of the Arabic policy derived from the teachings of Mohammed, such as (1) the maintenance of municipal liberty, (2) the practice of direct taxation, and (3) freedom of commerce. And they retained all the horrible and repulsive features of those teachings, which were (1) the intolerant propagation of their religious faith at the point of the sword, (2) the fanatical persecution of all who might differ with them in belief, and (3) a blind fatalism, which taught them that they would live until the time came for them to die, whether exposed to great danger in battle or not; and to these may be added (4) a firm belief in a sensual, material paradise, to which, if they were killed in battle, they were instantly transported, without the intervention of either a purgatory or an intermediate state.
The chief of this rude tribe, Othman I., was the founder of the Turkish, called from him the Ottoman empire. His successors swallowed up pretty much all the countries which the Arabs had once conquered, and appropriated to themselves the spiritual title of caliph, which their emperor, the Sultan, still enjoys at Constantinople.
Egypt was conquered by them in 1517, and has ever since been governed by a viceroy, now called khedive, who is tributary to the “Sublime Porte”—this being the self-styled name of the Ottoman Government—so called from the grand gate of the Sultan’s palace, where he has, or used to have, justice administered; for it is a very long time since any justice was administered there.
The Turkish Government has for many years been extravagantly administered. When the French Empress Eugenie visited Constantinople in 1869, on her way to attend the opening of the Suez canal, the Sultan, out of compliment to her Majesty, spent millions of francs to build a macadamized road for many miles over a swamp simply to show the Empress some natural curiosity, as a lake or a grotto; and this, although but a single trip was to be made over the road, and it would be of no earthly use to anybody forever afterward.
This and other extravagances have brought the Sultan and the Government deeply into debt. Over a hundred millions of pounds, or $500,000,000 worth of Turkish bonds, are owned in London. Now Egypt, as a tributary of Turkey, has long paid her a large annual tribute. And this tribute, instead of being at present paid directly to Turkey, is paid by Egypt, through pressure brought to bear by the English Government, directly into the Bank of England, to apply as interest upon these five hundred millions of Turkish bonds.
Moreover, in 1873, the Sultan, for prudential reasons, enlarged the Khedive’s powers, and granted him a quasi-autonomy in the administration of the internal affairs of that country. This enabled the then Khedive, Said Pasha, to borrow money on his personal account, and to hypothecate Egyptian productions, actual and prospective, and Egyptian credit as security for the same.
Said made good use of his opportunities, until he piled up a debt over half as large as that owed by Turkey to English capitalists. And Turkey herself owes nearly as much more to Frenchmen and Austrians, and anybody else whom she can possibly borrow from. I have not had opportunity to get the present gross amount of all this indebtedness of Turkey and Egypt to the European powers; but eight years ago it was about $1,133,000,000! And the interest upon almost all of it is from six to nine per cent! And their annual expenditures are steadily and increasingly larger than their receipts, and they are bankrupt already, both of them, if they were put in liquidation.
Now their English and French creditors succeeded lately in persuading their respective governments to exert themselves for the protection of their interests which are represented by these bonds, and a joint English and French Commission was quartered upon the Egyptian people, with the consent—reluctant, no doubt—of both the Khedive and the Sultan.
These Commissioners, as good, shrewd business men, are looking out smartly after their employers’ interests. They see that the annual tribute due from Egypt to the Sublime Porte is promptly paid, as the interest accrues, into the Bank of England. They have gotten rid of the extravagant old Khedive, who contracted the indebtedness through the profligacy of his life, and the lavishness of his personal expenditures, and they have secured his young son Tewfik in the succession. They have the absolute handling of all the revenues of Egypt, taking especial care that as much of it as possible is applied to the interest of the indebtedness. They have large salaries for this service, and also numerous assistants, who are not Egyptians, nominally to help them; but Arabi says they are helping them, with large pay and no work, to eat out the substance of the country and the people, like a swarm of Egyptian locusts. This foreign occupation has become intolerable to the native population, and they are striving vigorously to throw it off, and are using for their battle-cry the sentiment, “Egyptians shall rule Egypt,” while holding in reserve another still more terrible watchword for their future rallying, and ’tis this: “Allah achbar! God is great, and Mohammed is his prophet!” and when this refrain shall begin to resound through the mountain gorges and over the arid plains of the Turkish dominions, as it now seems more than probable it soon will, it will arouse to frenzied action more than one hundred and three millions and a half of bigoted, ignorant, superstitious Mohammedans.
The reports come to us that the late events at Alexandria have suspended this joint Anglo-French arrangement for the collection and payment of this interest. And these two countries are naturally interested in re-establishing the arrangement and in maintaining Tewfik’s authority, and are, accordingly, working to that end. In their efforts they do not seem to have the entire sympathy of the other powers.
Italy and Germany seem to desire the success of Arabi Pasha, and the establishment of an independent national government in Egypt. While Russia and Austria are anxious to see Turkey interfere, by sending an army to Egypt, and becoming inextricably involved in the conflict, to her inevitable destruction, so that they may step in and administer upon her estate and partition her territory. Was there ever such a witch’s caldron?
And to add to the gravity, difficulty, and danger of the situation, we are advised that this is the thirteenth hundred year of the Mohammedan calendar, and that it will close on the twelfth day of next November, and that a very old Moslem prophecy positively predicts that El Mehdi, their Messiah, will publicly proclaim himself upon that day. We are assured that this mysterious personage has already made his appearance in the country of Soudan, lying to the south of Egypt; that he has fought a battle with, and gained a victory over, opponents who would have barred the progress to his manifest destiny; that he is approaching, gradually but surely, the center of Mohammedan influence, where, by lifting up the standard of the prophet and declaring himself as his successor, he can rally many millions of fanatical followers to do his righteous bidding, and again send fire and sword into the rebellious ranks of infidel heretics and “Christian dogs.”
The liability is great that when Admiral Seymour, on the morning of the 11th inst., gave orders to “let loose the dogs of war” upon the defenses of Alexandria, he not only furnished Arabi Pasha with an excellent pretext for rallying some five millions of people around the standard of national rights and self-government, but he also incurred the grave responsibility and risked the great danger which would inevitably arise to the whole of Europe from this exasperated and reckless Arabi’s invoking the sympathy and aid of more than a hundred millions of fanatical Mohammedans, thus precipitating a terrible and possibly a general religious war. And what is, what has ever been, what ever can be, so fearful, so calamitous, as a religious war?
All wars are bad, very bad. And yet they have often seemed to be necessary. Our Saviour says: “It must needs be that offenses come; but woe to that man by whom the offense cometh!” “He that taketh up the sword shall perish by the sword.” Such a conflict as that which is now threatened would be, in the end, terrible indeed.
There are short-sighted people who think that a general foreign war would be of great advantage to this country; that business would be very active; that we could feed them with our surplus breadstuffs, and furnish them with munitions of war, and control the carrying trade of the world; and so we see that when war is threatened, prices are advanced. But such a war would necessarily be very destructive of life, and of treasure, and of all kinds of property, and the aggregate amount of the world’s wealth would be greatly diminished. It would also inflate values, and conduce to excessive speculation, and be very damaging and demoralizing, in many ways; and for many reasons such a result would be greatly deprecated.
But before closing I desire to refer to a class of people, whether in this country or in the Old World, whose feelings and sympathies are stirred to their utmost depths by the prospect of a general European war, with this momentous “Turkish question” for its moving cause; and these are the students of prophecy.
There are over a hundred authors who have published more than two hundred volumes within the past twenty years, all of them, or almost all, tending to show that the lines of prophecy converge to a point of time very near to these days in which we are now living.

CANST THOU BY SEARCHING FIND OUT GOD?

Thought plumed her wings of heavenly birth, And sought through all the fields of earth The footsteps of her God. She scanned its surface bright and fair, And searched the viewless tides of air, And farthest ways untrod.
She passed the sunbeam in its flight, And smote the azure plains of light, With never-tiring wing; She kept her course from star to star, And searched the universe afar, But sought her God in vain.
Then back she came to earth again, With mournful heart and lowly mien, Oppressed by sad despair; To her, cast down by sore unrest, A voice ariseth sweet and blest, “Lo, God is everywhere!”
She hears the voice, she lifts her eyes, And lo! beneath the bended skies Sees everywhere his power; The sunshine speaketh from above, It speaks a benison of love, And God himself is there!
—Christian Advocate.

TREASURE FOR THE LAST DAYS.

BY ELD. R. F. COTTRELL.
Selfishness, covetousness, greed of gain, and the heaping up of treasure, are noted in prophecy as characteristic of the last days. We see these predictions verified at the present time. Men are insatiable. They can never have enough; and as it is with those who have accumulated millions, so it is with those of less means. The sin of covetousness is not confined to the wealthy; but the poor are subject to it, wishing to rise in some other way than by industry and economy. Many professed believers in Christ are as eager in the pursuit of riches as worldlings; and even those who profess to believe that the end of all things is at hand, drink of the same spirit, and are liable to become drunken with the “cares of this life,” notwithstanding the repeated and emphatic admonition of Christ to watch, lest the day of the Lord come upon them as a snare.
This anxiety and strife for worldly wealth was never consistent with the profession of Christianity; then how emphatically inconsistent it is in these last days! This is the cause of astonishment. Says the testimony, “Ye have laid up your treasure in the last days.” (New Version.)
Anxiety to accumulate beyond a competency is folly. Says an apostle, “We brought nothing into this world, and it is certain that we can carry nothing out.” In the parable it is said to the rich man, “Thou fool, this night thy soul shall be required of thee; then whose shall those things be, which thou hast provided?” Who shall possess what we leave in the world? “Who knoweth whether he shall be a wise man or a fool?” Eccl. 2:19.
The folly of straining every nerve and muscle, and depriving one’s self of needful rest to accumulate property, may be illustrated by what my father once told me concerning blue jays. He said that they had acquisitiveness enough to work very diligently to gather corn or beechnuts, and go and drop their precious store through some small crack in a hollow tree, where it would be utterly impossible for them ever to reach it. When any one should come near the spot where their treasure was hid, they would manifest, by their cries, great fear of being robbed of that which was out of their reach, and as impossible for them to use as it is for a rich man to use his hoarded wealth. Some little mouse might creep through the crevice and enjoy the store laid up with such labor and care; but no profit could come to the laborer. It is much better to lay up treasure where it is safe.
The scramble after the “uncertainty of riches,” viewed from the standpoint of worldly wisdom, might be amusing; but when we consider that eternal life and enduring treasure are being lost in the senseless chase, it is terrible.

Foundation Work.

BY ELD. J. H. COOK.
“Therefore whosoever heareth these sayings of mine, and doeth them, I will liken him unto a wise man, which built his house upon a rock. And the rain descended, and the floods came, and the winds blew, and beat upon that house, and it fell not; for it was founded upon a rock.” Matt. 7:24, 25.
No minister of the gospel can overestimate the importance of being thorough in giving instructions, especially when laying the foundation on which to build up a church. “Warning every man, and teaching every man in all wisdom; that we may present every man perfect in Christ Jesus.” Col. 1:28. In building, we readily see the importance of having a solid foundation, that the structure may stand. If the foundation be faulty, it affects unfavorably the whole building. No one would want it, though the building itself might be ever so desirable, as it would be liable to fall in a storm.
The foundation principles of our faith should be laid sure. Some points of our faith expose us to the assaults of Satan more than others; namely, the Sabbath, the testimonies, and the health reform. Of course the Sabbath, being a leading doctrine, is made very prominent in our sermons. This is as it should be. And, as we should expect, those who embrace the Sabbath after careful thought, canvassing every point, are prepared to hold on to it, and defend it against every assault. But it is not so with the testimonies and the health reform. Often they are given only a passing notice, and the interested ones are told that these things are no test of fellowship; hence they come to the conclusion that they are not important. The minister has passed them by lightly. Satan steps in with his opposition, and finds ready access, and ere we are aware, minds are poisoned against the Bible teaching on these points. The minister did not design to leave things in this shape, but simply to pass them till another time, or leave them for some one that should follow him. And when some one else comes around, he finds, to his surprise and sorrow, that what appeared to be a good work at first, was largely lost for lack of a solid foundation. But can it not still be laid? Usually not. The people say, “We did not hear that kind of preaching at first. The minister drank tea or coffee, or ate pork with us, and surely we have not heard any smarter preacher than he.”
Now what shall we do? We do not want to say that such persons do not properly represent Seventh-day Adventists; for it would be said, ‘Why do you give them license?’ Here we are at our wit’s end; but the difficulty is not removed. We labor, pray, and try to hold up the truth and the former minister; but if the truth prevails, the minister sinks. If you cannot be successful in converting them fully on these points, the former minister maintains his standing with his influence on the side of error. We cannot wonder when they say, “You preach one thing: another minister comes along and preaches something else. Every one has a doctrine.” It appears to me that if all our ministers had seen as much of this sad work as I have, they would never leave a company till they were thoroughly instructed on all these points. I have sometimes thought that if companies thus left had never heard the truth, there would be more hope for them than in this partially instructed condition.
I write thus at this time for the benefit of our Kansas ministers. The tents are in new fields, and most of those laboring with them are new hands at the work. Brethren, be thorough in your instructions. You are engaged in a great work. Much depends on laying a good foundation. You are doing work for eternity. Do not leave your work, if you have an interest, till you have thoroughly canvassed these points. Be a workman in the Master’s vineyard who needs not to be ashamed. So instruct your converts that they may be your epistles, known and read of all men. So build that when the storms come, your work will stand, and your brethren will be able to give a reason for their faith with meekness and fear.

Dr. Abbott and Conditional Immortality.

One of the most important events that have recently transpired in the theological world is an editorial in a late number of the Christian Union, in which Dr. Lyman Abbott, the well-known editor of that paper, announces his belief in the probability of the doctrines of conditional immortality and the destruction of the wicked. Although the article is long, our readers will doubtless be glad to read it entire, together with the letter which called it out.
“In your various articles concerning the teachings of the Scriptures with regard to future punishment, I notice that you always declare that they do not teach that there shall be an end of punishment, and, therefore, that all men shall become, finally, holy and happy. Your reiterated assertion, therefore, is that the Scriptures do not teach Universalism. The more I read these wonderful writings, the more I am amazed at your earnest and oft-repeated declarations. May I therefore ask you to explain two passages: ‘And I, if I be lifted up, will draw all men unto me.’ ‘And when all things shall be subdued unto him, then shall the Son also himself be subject unto him that put all things under him, that God may be all in all.’
“For my part, I do not need these and similar passages to convince me that God punishes his children in order to improve them, and therefore the end—improvement, holiness—will finally be attained. The Master taught that God is our Father. If he is our Father, he will not make punishment endless. The Master gave us the parable of the Prodigal Son. Its teaching is that punishment, at last, will cause the sinner to ‘come to himself,’ and that then he will go to the Father, and the Father will receive him. I stand with Stopford Brooke. He says: ‘If there is endless punishment, then there is no Heavenly Father.’ I stand with James Freeman Clarke. He says the parable of the Prodigal Son sufficiently explains the question of punishment. And when I read ‘Salvator Mundi,’ written by the Rev. Samuel Cox, an English Trinitarian Congregationalist, then I wonder how you, or any one else, can say that the Scriptures do not teach the final holiness and happiness of all men. A ‘master in Israel,’ you have pondered this question deeply. Many times before I have been prompted to address you in order to express my amazement at your conclusion. Your recent editorial on Andover has added power to my impulse. Under its influence I send you these fraternal words. Cordially yours,
“HENRY BLANCHARD, “Pastor of Shawmut Universalist Church. “Boston, Mass.”
“This fraternal letter I welcome with the same cordiality with which it was sent. We are both students of the same mystery, disciples in the same school, and may well help one another toward a larger light. I have no desire to conceal my convictions on this subject, nor even my doubts and questionings.”
“The problem of the future is approached by men of every school who are sure what God will do, who even assert with assurance what he must do. To me it is shrouded with mystery; I approach it with awe; I cannot assert what God will do, still less what he ought to do; I understand too little this awful mystery of sin. What it is, what its nature, whence its origin, what is the ever-shifting line which separates between crime and disease, what almighty love can do for the deliberately, persistently wicked; what all-wise justice must do for the protection of the innocent; what possibilities of redemption there are in any human soul; what reserves of mercy in God’s omnipotent love; what awful power there is in the human soul to reject all love, even the love of the Almighty; what limits there are to the power of love, even the omnipotent love of God—all this I know not, and not knowing, I cannot dogmatize; I cannot be sure; I look out into the great unknown future with beating heart in silence, and I fear and hope and wonder.”
“1. Many Christians regard the Bible as a clear and comprehensive revelation concerning God and divine government, which contains the whole truth concerning him and his purposes, so that, humbly studied and heartily believed, it will furnish a complete science of God and divine things. I do not so understand the Bible. It appears to me to be simply a book of practical directions for godly living in this present life. It tells enough about God to draw out the heart in love toward him; enough about his will to enable us to show our love by our obedience; enough about the future to furnish motives of hope and fear to re-enforce the larger motive of love. We sail upon an ocean whose further bounds are far beyond our sight. The Bible gives every soul a course to sail by; follow this course, it says, and you will reach harbor; follow any other, and you will come to shipwreck. But what that harbor is, and what possibilities of rescue at the last from shipwreck there may be, it tells not. The wise father neither promises nor threatens; he leaves his children to understand that obedience brings happiness, disobedience suffering. God governs his children as a wise father; and to all our questionings, ‘What pay for doing right?’ ‘What penalty for doing wrong?’ keeps a silence that is more eloquent than speech. The Bible contains no clear revelation respecting the nature of either eternal life or eternal death. It discloses nothing to curiosity. We can gather from its intimations some probable conclusions; but every kind of dogmatism respecting the eternal future is unscriptural. Not until the church furnishes a prophet who can foretell the rewards of virtue or the penalties of sin which God will award to a single individual next year, shall I accept the foretellings of its would-be prophets concerning the rewards and penalties which he will award at the further end of eternity.”
“2. The Scriptures, especially the New Testament, do, however, contain intimations addressed to both fear and hope; the one seems to me to awaken well-grounded fear of a hopeless doom; the other, well-grounded hope of a perfected redemption.”
“It is impossible within the compass of a newspaper article to group the words of Christ and his apostles which foreshadow the awful fact that sin is sometimes incorrigible; that it is within the power of the human will to set at defiance the divine love; that a human will, set to do evil, can resist all the gracious influences of a divine will seeking to save the soul from its own undoing. If I were a John Calvin Calvinist I should be a Universalist. If I believed that it is in the power of God to coerce a virtuous choice from a free moral agent, I should be sure that he would. A study of life and a study of Scripture both forbid. God influences, but does not compel; he entreats, but does not coerce; he knocks at the heart, but will not break in; he will have children, not slaves; love, not obedience; and love is not compelled and cannot be. If he is a Father he will receive every child that love can draw and sorrow can drive to him; but he will not go after the fugitive with blood-hounds, and bring him back in chains. This seems to me to be the teaching of the New Testament, especially the teaching of Christ himself. He is not a Master come to capture by force men who have no choice; he is a friend come to capture by persuasions men who have a fatal power to resist, and whose resistance is soul-suicide, eternal death. This terrible fact—man’s power of resistance to all gracious influences—seems to me to underlie all Christ’s life and teachings, his arguments, entreaties, persuasions; his incarnation, his tears, his nights of prayer, his Gethsemane agony, his breaking heart, his tragic death, his descent into Hades in merciful quest of the lost, his resurrection, his perpetual intercession, his ever-living presence with his church. All this would be meaningless unless man is in a true sense the arbiter of his own destiny, and God is pleading before him to enter into life eternal. The terrible possibility of a hopeless fate gives pathos to the sorrowful tones of the Pleader’s voice. It appears in his explicit declaration that the wicked go away into eternal punishment; that they are left at last in the outer darkness; that they are cast into the fire of Gehenna; that they lose their own soul; that they may sin a sin which shall not be forgiven, neither in this world nor in the world to come. It re-appears in reiterated type and metaphor. They are guests arriving too late for the marriage feast and are shut out, and the feast goes on without them; they are chaff to be burned with fire, useless fish to be cast away, fruitless trees to be hewn down and burned to ashes, bankrupts consigned to perpetual imprisonment, rebels slain before the throne of their king. So terrible is this death-doom that any maiming, though it were as the cutting off of the right hand and the plucking out of the right eye, is to be preferred. If I turn to the epistles, their language seems to me scarcely less explicit; the wicked are without God, and therefore without hope; their sentence is death, their end destruction, their punishment everlasting destruction from the presence of the Lord. I am not unaware of the interpretations which Universalist scholars give to these and kindred words of awful warning. I could perhaps accept explanations of isolated verses. But I am sure my correspondent will not understand me as impugning the honesty of other Biblical students when I say that I could not with honesty accept the authority of Christ’s teachings for myself and still preach ‘an eternal hope.’ The possibility of incorrigible sin, the hopeless doom of the incorrigible sinner, appear to me to be as clearly taught by Christ as words can teach them.”
“3. But if the New Testament warnings may well awaken fear in every sinner lest his sin become incorrigible, its prophecies give to every Christian good ground of hope in a final, perfect redemption. They foretell a kingdom of Christ to which all the kingdoms of this earth shall belong; an hour when every knee shall bow and every tongue shall confess Jesus Christ to be Lord, to the glory of God the Father; a reconciliation of all things unto the Redeemer, whether upon the earth or in the heavens; a millennial glory in which his kingdom will come and his will be done on earth as in Heaven; a new song unto Him that sitteth upon the throne and unto the Lamb forever, sung by every creature which is in Heaven, and on the earth, and under the earth, and such as are in the sea, and all that are in them. In the New Testament picture of this hour of triumph I see no shadow of scowling faces, of angered and unrepentant rebels; in the New Testament echo of this song of the redeemed I hear no interrupting of wail or wrath from any far-off prison-house of despair. After the last enemy is destroyed, shall sin, worst of all enemies, still live, and work his ruin eternally? When God hath put all enemies under Christ’s feet, shall this worst of all enemies still rule in triumph over some remote, reserved corner of creation? I cannot, will not, dogmatize; but I can and do believe that God is always better than his promises, and that these promises of the perfect accord of all God’s creatures in him and with him mean not less but more than they seem to us to mean. I cannot, will not, dogmatize; but I can hope. The more I study my Bible the more unscriptural seems to me the conception of endless sin; the nearer I come into fellowship with God my Father, my Saviour, my Comforter, the more intolerable grows the thought of it to me. And I thank God for the good hope in his word, which permits me to look forward to and haste toward the day when this terrible tragedy of sin and pain will come to an end.”
“4. If I believe in the hopeless doom of incorrigible sin, and also in the undimmed glory of a perfected kingdom of love, I must believe in the annihilation of the incorrigibly wicked. Yes, that would be the logical conclusion. If I thought that logic were a glass which reveals the secrets of eternity, I should believe in this as the final doom of unrepented sin. As it is, I can only say that I think this a probable doctrine, more probable by far than the doctrine of endless sin and suffering. There are phrases in Christ’s teaching which give some color to that terrible dogma; but more often those quoted in support of it are misquoted or misinterpreted. Fire is generally in the Bible an emblem of destruction, not of torment. The chaff, the tares, the fruitless tree, are thrown into unquenchable fire, not to be tortured, but to be destroyed. The hell-fire of the New Testament is the fire of Gehenna, kept burning outside the walls of Jerusalem to destroy the offal of the city; here was the worm that dieth not and the fire that is not quenched; emblems of destruction, not of torment. Except two, or at most three, passages in the gospels and a few enigmatical symbols in that most enigmatical book, the Revelation of St. John, I find nothing in the New Testament to warrant the terrible opinion that God sustains the life of his creatures throughout eternity only that they may continue in sin and misery. That immortality is the gift of God through our Lord Jesus Christ, that man is mortal and must put on immortality, that only he can put it on who becomes through Christ a partaker of the divine nature, and so an inheritor of Him ‘who only hath immortality,’ that eternal life is life eternal, and eternal death is death eternal, and everlasting destruction is destruction without remedy or hope of restoration—this is the most natural, as it is the simplest reading of the New Testament.”
Dr. Abbott wrote to Addison P. Foster, “a conservative but broad-minded theologian” of Jersey City, N. J., asking his opinion of the above editorial. From Mr. Foster’s reply the following is taken, as illustrating the change taking place in popular sentiments toward those who believe in conditional immortality:—
“The arguments for conditional immortality are so many and so strong that, while they do not convince me, I must respect the man whom they do convince. And I can do this the more easily because I am more and more satisfied that the view is quite compatible with what we consider an evangelical faith. The test of an evangelical position seems to me to lie in its practical working. The point of church-fellowship is in the question whether we can work together. Two forces which are fighting for opposite results, or results which run counter to one another, are not in fellowship; nor are two forces which, though they may have the same aim, adopt methods which necessarily would neutralize one another. I cannot fellowship in church relationships, though most heartily as a brother Christian, with a Restorationist, because he must believe in his secret heart, as I do not, that it is no serious matter if a man fails to repent in this life—he will hereafter; nor with a Unitarian, because he denies the efficacy of the one remedy I have to propose for sin; viz., the blood of Christ. But I can fellowship, as I have already publicly said, with one who believes in conditional immortality. We both believe in a dreadful and irretrievable penalty for sin, and may work shoulder to shoulder in preaching Christ as its only escape.”

TO THE MODERN ATHEIST OF THE PLATFORM.

I know thee well,—thy covert smirk Of self-conceit, and self-applause,— Thy tongue, that like a pointless dirk Stabs blindly at the Eternal Cause.
Thy sarcasm, free of force or smart, As Harlequin’s jest!—more dull than death; Thy logic, from Truth’s Titan heart Hurled in one heave of scornful breath!
Thy zeal, by every tawdry sham Of outworn heathen dreams enticed,— Tolerance of Juggernaut, or Brahm,— Damnation to the creed of Christ!
I know thee well,—thou whited wall, Veneered with many a tinseled lie,— Braggart of freedom, yet the thrall Of foulest thoughts, outspawned to die!
The blandness of thy mien I know, When most thine ambushed hatreds flame To taint with swiftly poisonous blow The splendor of some star-like fame!
Thy greed, but loosely masked in grace Of specious plea, or dazzling plan,— Love of the boundless human race, Scorn of the single, suffering Man!
Fool! in thine own esteem so large, So learned,—thou art an insect thing, To whom its tiny empire’s marge Seems broad as boundaries of a king!
Perchance, some soul of angel birth, Leaning beyond the bourne of bliss, May mark thee, wriggling here on earth, And wonder, “What strange mite is this?”
But soon his keen, seraphic eyes Shall pierce thy nature, where it squirms, And view beneath thy frail disguise The vilest of earth’s wingless worms!
—Paul Hamilton Hayne, in S. S. Times.
Continue reading: THE OBSERVANCES OF MODERN ORTHODOX ISRAELITES