Shared conversation
Ellen G. White on Women's Suffrage and Political Involvement
Should a Christian's duty to God ever conflict with casting a vote?
Why was EGW against the suffragette movement? Did EGW believe women shouldn't vote?
AdventAI
Participation in the women’s suffrage movement was discouraged because its spirit was not in harmony with the special message of the third angel. While there were no prohibitions against voting on specific moral issues, the primary focus for women should be their sacred mission as missionaries and mothers rather than seeking political office or becoming a voter.
The Distinction Between Political Movements and Moral Duty
A Conflict of Spirit: Joining the women’s rights movement was viewed as a step that could lead to severing one's connection with the third angel's message, as the spirit attending such movements does not align with biblical truth.
The Mission of the Home: A mother's influence is profound; though she may not stand in national councils or cast a vote, she does a great work for God and her country by educating her children to have integrity.
Preparation for Political Matters: Many women of the time were not qualified to understand important political questions because they were focused on fashion, self-gratification, and custom rather than intellectual culture.
Separation from the World: Believers are called to come out from among the world and be separate, not mingling with worldly political movements 2 Corinthians 6:17-18.
Views on the Act of Voting
The Power of Choice: Every human being is given the gift of the will and the power to choose whom they will serve Joshua 24:15.
Voting for Temperance: It is a positive duty for both men and women to use their voice, pen, and vote to favor prohibition and total abstinence.
Accountability at the Ballot Box: Those who vote to sanction the liquor traffic or place intemperate men in office are held accountable for the resulting wickedness.
Silence on Political Questions: While individuals may hold opinions on political questions, they are not to proclaim them by voice or pen, as our people must be silent on matters unrelated to the third angel’s message.
Social and Moral Concerns
Legalized Immorality: The push for suffrage was sometimes linked to the need to withstand horrific laws that legalized houses of ill fame and protected lustful men while victimizing women.
Equality in the Home: Instead of focusing on "equal rights" or political privileges, energy should be directed toward the inner sanctities of home life and the fountain of pure influence within the family.
The Purity of the Church: Linking church membership or religious profession to the right to vote in civil government historically led to the corruption of the church and the promotion of unconverted men.
Wise Decision-Making in the Church
Independent Thinking: In councils and committees, individuals should not merely be "ciphers" who vote "yes" to every proposition but should weigh every matter carefully and bring plans to the Divine Counselor.
Dangers of Hasty Voting: Many matters have been carried by vote in conferences without proper sifting, leading to results that were not for the spiritual benefit of believers.
Character over Popularity: Men who are intemperate or unconverted should not be placed in positions of trust by the vote of the people.
Sources · 27
- 1T 421.4Testimonies for the Church, vol. 1
- T10 30.7Testimony for the Church — No. 10
- DG 18.1Daughters of God
- RH April 23, 1889, par. 2The Review and Herald
- T11 2.6Testimony for the Church — No. 11
- CTBH 159.4Christian Temperance and Bible Hygiene
- T25 164.2Testimony for the Church — No. 25
- 2LtMs, Ms 5, 1875, par. 13Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 2 (1869 - 1875)
- 2SM 336.1Selected Messages Book 2
- 13LtMs, Lt 4, 1898, par. 1Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 13 (1898)
- TEd 180.4True Education
- STJ 44.2Steps to Jesus
- DG 123.2Daughters of God
- Te 227Temperance
- PH093 8.4The Temperance Work
- Te 254.1Temperance
- RH November 8, 1881, par. 12The Review and Herald
- DG 252.8Daughters of God
- 10MR 69.1Manuscript Releases, vol. 10 [Nos. 771-850]
- 2LtMs, Lt 40a, 1874, par. 7Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 2 (1869 - 1875)
- HR January 1, 1873, par. 3The Health Reformer
- GC 297.1The Great Controversy
- 18MR 292.2Manuscript Releases, vol. 18 [Nos. 1301-1359]
- PH167 22.1Counsels to Physicians and Medical Students
- 3TT 424.4Testimony Treasures, vol. 3
- PCL 146.1Principles for Christian Leaders
- 16LtMs, Ms 52, 1901, par. 2Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 16 (1901)
Specifically which key aspects of the movement were anti-Christian?
AdventAI
The anti-Christian nature of the political movements of the time was rooted in their tendency to distract from the third angel’s message, create worldly alliances, and foster a spirit of strife that mirrors unregenerate hearts. 🕊️
Spiritual Misalignment and Discord
A Spirit of Contention: The spirit that attends the woman's rights movement is not in harmony with the message of mercy for these last days, and joining such movements is essentially the same as severing connection with God's work.
Stirred from Beneath: Political strife and agitation are inspired by an intense activity from beneath, leading even brothers in the same faith to wear badges of opposing parties and declare divided opinions.
The Fruit of Selfishness: Dissension and disorder brought into the church through political ideas are described as a moral poison taken into the system by selfish human beings.
Satanic Joy: Engaging in political contests makes Satan glad because he knows it causes believers to exhibit the natural attributes of unregenerate hearts, such as hatred and jealousy.
The Danger of Worldly Confederacies
Unequal Yoking: Forming alliances with political movements is a violation of the command not to be unequally yoked with unbelievers, as there is no safe ground for the loyal and disloyal to work together 2 Corinthians 6:14-15.
Linking with Iniquity: Many political parties are characterized by fraud on both sides, and God has not laid the burden upon His people to link their interests with the world's interests or its "unclean things" 2 Corinthians 6:17-18.
The Image to the Papacy: Efforts to unite church and state through political gateways, such as the push for national reform, are identical to the theory upon which the papacy was built.
Compulsory Worship: Political movements often labor to please men who will eventually use their influence to repress religious liberty and compel others to keep a spurious sabbath.
Misdirected Talents and Neglected Duties
Wrong Channels: The Lord does not want His servants to employ their God-given time and talents in wrong channels, such as arguing or writing about political issues like the "gold and silver" controversy.
Neglect of the Soul: When individuals become absorbed in political questions, they often neglect the greatest study of all: how to save their own souls and seek the kingdom of God Mark 8:36-37.
Intellectual Sloth: Many seeking prominent positions in politics were disciplined only by fashion and custom, lacking the breadth of thought and intellectual culture necessary to act wisely in important matters.
A Worldly Standard: Political activism often relies on human agencies and worldly magnificence, which God regards as the dust of the balance compared to His eternal kingdom.
A Higher Calling and Vocation
Subjects of Christ: Believers are to stand as subjects of Christ's kingdom, and their vocation is too high and holy to be brought down to the level of political strife.
Silence as Eloquence: On many political themes, silence is considered true eloquence, as the people of God are to remain separate and peculiar with the name of God in their foreheads.
Preparation for the Crisis: Instead of political agitation, the youth are called to take their place in a royal line of witnesses who value God's word above human power and policy.
Eternal Citizenship: Christians must recognize that their citizenship is above and they are merely pilgrims and strangers on the earth, looking for a city whose builder and maker is God Philippians 3:20.
Sources · 39
- 9MR 130.2Manuscript Releases, vol. 9 [Nos. 664-770]
- 11LtMs, Ms 43, 1896, par. 6Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 11 (1896)
- 9MR 129.2Manuscript Releases, vol. 9 [Nos. 664-770]
- 1T 421.4Testimonies for the Church, vol. 1
- 1T 457.3Testimonies for the Church, vol. 1
- T10 30.7Testimony for the Church — No. 10
- GCDB February 17, 1897, par. 5General Conference Daily Bulletin
- FE 483.2Fundamentals of Christian Education
- GW 395.3Gospel Workers (1915 ed.)
- CCh 316.6Counsels for the Church
- 13LtMs, Ms 75, 1898, par. 26Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 13 (1898)
- 25LtMs, Ms 29, 1911, par. 56Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 25 (1910 - 1915)
- 13LtMs, Lt 4, 1898, par. 31Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 13 (1898)
- GW 392.2Gospel Workers (1915 ed.)
- 2SM 336.1Selected Messages Book 2
- 21MR 25.3Manuscript Releases, vol. 21 [Nos. 1501-1598]
- GC88 689.1The Great Controversy (1888 ed.)
- ST March 22, 1910, par. 9The Signs of the Times
- FE 475.2Fundamentals of Christian Education
- HF 369.4From Here to Forever
- 15LtMs, Lt 28, 1900, par. 16Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 15 (1900)
- 9MR 128.1Manuscript Releases, vol. 9 [Nos. 664-770]
- 21MR 20.1Manuscript Releases, vol. 21 [Nos. 1501-1598]
- 12LtMs, Lt 11, 1897, par. 1Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897)
- 8MR 352.1Manuscript Releases, vol. 8 [Nos. 526-663]
- CTBH 159.4Christian Temperance and Bible Hygiene
- 3T 565.3Testimonies for the Church, vol. 3
- T25 164.2Testimony for the Church — No. 25
- FE 481.3Fundamentals of Christian Education
- PH049 9.2Loma Linda’s Work
- MedEv April 1, 1910, par. 12The Medical Evangelist
- GW 393.3Gospel Workers (1915 ed.)
- 14LtMs, Ms 198, 1899, par. 30Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 14 (1899)
- PH086 7.2Special Testimony to Battle Creek Church
- RH June 21, 1898, par. 31The Review and Herald
- Pr 315.3Prayer
- RH March 11, 1915, Art. A, par. 12The Review and Herald
- RH June 21, 1898, par. 42The Review and Herald
- 13LtMs, Ms 7, 1898, par. 34Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 13 (1898)