Shared conversation

Mary of Bethany's Anointing of Jesus' Feet

Was the perfume used in both anointing events the same?

AdventAI

Which Mary anointed Jesus' feet?

AdventAI

The Mary who anointed Jesus' feet with costly ointment was Mary of Bethany, the sister of Martha and Lazarus 😇 John 12:3.

This beautiful act of devotion, which has become a memorial recorded wherever the gospel is preached, occurred shortly before Christ's crucifixion Matthew 26:13.

The Devotional Anointing

Mary performed this heartfelt service at a supper held in Bethany, specifically in the house of Simon the leper Matthew 26:6.

  • The Gift: She took a pound of very precious spikenard ointment John 12:3. The precious ointment, which was sometimes estimated to cost as much as would keep a laboring family for a year, was poured upon Jesus' head and feet Mark 14:5.

  • The Act of Humility: In a profound expression of love and reverence, Mary anointed His feet and then wiped them with her long, flowing hair John 12:3. This act filled the entire house with the fragrance of the ointment, publishing her deed to all present John 12:3.

  • The Motivation: Mary's heart was overflowing with pure, holy love for the Savior, especially following the recent miracle of her brother Lazarus' resurrection John 11:1. She rejoiced at the thought that Jesus might soon be elevated to kingly authority, and she wished to be the first to honor Him. Her offering was intended as a tribute of gratitude and love, a faint representation of Christ's boundless love Psalm 116:12.

Christ's Defense of Mary's Action

The disciples, particularly Judas Iscariot, reacted with indignation and questioned the expense, suggesting the ointment should have been sold for three hundred pence and given to the poor John 12:4-5.

Jesus swiftly came to Mary’s defense, recognizing and valuing her heartfelt courtesy and sacrifice Matthew 26:10. He declared that she had done a good work for Him, adding that the poor would always be with them, but He would not always be there Matthew 26:11. Most importantly, Christ revealed the prophetic nature of her deed, stating that she had anointed His body beforehand for the burial Matthew 26:12. He then ensured that her act of devotion would never be forgotten, saying, "Truly I say to you, Wheresoever this gospel shall be preached throughout the whole world, this also that she hath done shall be spoken of for a memorial of her" Mark 14:9.

Mary's Character: Choosing the Better Part

Mary of Bethany represents the consecrated spiritual life, often contrasted with her sister Martha, who was zealous in active service Luke 10:40. Mary is noted for choosing the "one thing needful"—sitting at Jesus’ feet to hear His word Luke 10:42. The zeal and energy of the "Marthas" should first be sanctified by the grace received by sitting with "Mary" at the feet of Jesus, learning meekness and lowliness of heart Matthew 11:29.

Sources · 20
  1. ETI Mary.6Easton's Bible DictionaryMatthew G. Easton
  2. KJV — Mark 14:9King James VersionKing James Ist
  3. ETI Simon.6Easton's Bible DictionaryMatthew G. Easton
  4. HLv 372.3From Heaven With LoveEllen Gould White
  5. GBJ January 1897, page 22.15Sabbath School LessonsWilliam Warren Prescott
  6. 2SP 375.1The Spirit of Prophecy, vol. 2Ellen Gould White
  7. LTJMB4 314.2The Life and Times of Jesus the Messiah—Book IVAlfred Edersheim
  8. 20MR 146.1Manuscript Releases, vol. 20 [Nos. 1420-1500]Ellen Gould White
  9. RH August 7, 1900, par. 3The Review and HeraldEllen Gould White
  10. 12LtMs, Ms 28, 1897, par. 25Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897)Ellen Gould White
  11. 14LtMs, Lt 4, 1899, par. 33Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 14 (1899)Ellen Gould White
  12. DA 564.4The Desire of AgesEllen Gould White
  13. GCDB March 2, 1899, page 131.10General Conference Daily Bulletin, vol. 8General Conference of SDA
  14. GCDB March 2, 1899, par. 2General Conference Daily BulletinEllen Gould White
  15. RH August 7, 1900, par. 5The Review and HeraldEllen Gould White
  16. KJV — Matthew 26:12King James VersionKing James Ist
  17. SBD Mary sister of Lazarus.2Smith's Bible DictionaryWilliam Smith
  18. GCB April 16, 1901, page 273.6General Conference Bulletin, vol. 4General Conference of SDA
  19. ChS 230.1Christian ServiceEllen Gould White
  20. 10LtMs, Lt 63, 1895, par. 44Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 10 (1895)Ellen Gould White

But in Mark's account of the anointing it makes it seem like it was Mary Magdalene, because she is described as having many sins and and in Like 7:37 it says and immoral woman. It does though say of 'of that city's which would be Bethany and I don't think Mary Magdalene is from Bethany. Can you explain this a little more

AdventAI

Mark 14:3-9

3 And being in Bethany in the house of Simon the leper, as he sat at meat, there came a woman having an alabaster box of ointment of spikenard very precious; and she brake the box, and poured it on his head.

4 And there were some that had indignation within themselves, and said, Why was this waste of the ointment made?

5 For it might have been sold for more than three hundred pence, and have been given to the poor. And they murmured against her.

6 And Jesus said, Let her alone; why trouble ye her? she hath wrought a good work on me.

7 For ye have the poor with you always, and whensoever ye will ye may do them good: but me ye have not always.

8 She hath done what she could: she is come aforehand to anoint my body to the burying.

9 Verily I say unto you, Wheresoever this gospel shall be preached throughout the whole world, this also that she hath done shall be spoken of for a memorial of her.

AdventAI

Luke 7:37

37 And, behold, a woman in the city, which was a sinner, when she knew that Jesus sat at meat in the Pharisee’s house, brought an alabaster box of ointment,

AdventAI

That is a wonderful question that delves into a common point of confusion, as the Bible records two distinct anointing events involving different women and circumstances 🧐. I can certainly explain the details regarding Mark 14:3-9 and Luke 7:37 to clarify why Mary of Bethany is confirmed to be the woman who performed the act recorded at the end of Christ’s ministry.

The belief that Mary Magdalene performed the act described in Mark 14 is a misconception; there is no evidence to connect her with either of the recorded anointings Mark 14:3.

Two Distinct Anointing Events

It is essential to understand that the Gospels describe two separate occasions where Jesus was anointed, which helps distinguish the women involved.

Event Location Host Anointing Woman Primary Accounts Timing
Earlier Anointing Galilee (unnamed city) Simon the Pharisee A local woman "who was a sinner" Luke 7:36-50 Early in His ministry
Later Anointing Bethany Simon the Leper Mary, sister of Lazarus John 12:1-3 Six days before the Passover

1. The Later Anointing (Bethany)

The event described in ** Mark 14:3-9** (which is also paralleled in Matthew 26:6-13 and confirmed by John 12:1-3 took place in Bethany, at the house of Simon, whom Jesus had cured of leprosy Mark 14:3.

  • Identity of the Woman: Although Mark and Matthew refer generally to "a woman" Mark 14:3 John’s Gospel, which provides circumstantial details, explicitly identifies her as Mary, the sister of Lazarus John 12:1-3.

  • The Act: This Mary came with an alabaster box of very precious spikenard ointment, which she poured on Jesus’ head and feet Mark 14:3. Her deep love stemmed from her faith in Him and immense gratitude for the crowning miracle of her brother Lazarus’ resurrection.

2. The Earlier Anointing Luke 7

The passage in ** Luke 7:37** describes an incident that happened much earlier in Christ’s ministry, likely in Galilee, not in Bethany Luke 7:36.

  • The Sinner: This event features "a woman in the city, which was a sinner" Luke 7:37. This woman was a local person of ill repute, and she came weeping, bathing Jesus’ feet with her tears and wiping them with her hair, then anointing them with ointment Luke 7:37-38.

  • Significance: Jesus used this act to teach Simon the Pharisee a lesson about love and forgiveness, confirming that the woman’s sins, which were many, were forgiven because she loved much Luke 7:47. This was the first of the two great anointing acts, performed by a recently forgiven sinner.

The use of the phrase "a woman in the city" Luke 7:37 indicates she was locally known, but this event cannot be chronologically or geographically equated with the Bethany anointing Mark 14:3.

Why Mark's Account Confirms Mary of Bethany

Mark’s account of the anointing must be understood in the context of the location and timing, which align perfectly with John's more specific account Mark 14:3.

  1. Location: Mark clearly places the event in Bethany Mark 14:3 which was the town of Mary, Martha, and Lazarus John 11:1.

  2. Timing: Mark records this anointing just two days before the Passover Mark 14:1 confirming it as the final, significant act of devotion before Christ’s passion, consistent with John’s timeline John 12:1.

Mary of Bethany was celebrated by Jesus for her sincere devotion and spiritual focus, having chosen "that good part, which shall not be taken away from her" Luke 10:42. Her love was deep, and her faith in Christ was strong.

Clarifying the Mary Magdalene Misconception

Although Mary Magdalene was certainly a devoted follower of Christ and had been delivered from seven devils Luke 8:2 she is definitively not the same person as Mary of Bethany, nor is she the unnamed sinner in Luke 7. The sources explicitly caution against the historical error of identifying the "sinner" Luke 7 or Mary of Bethany John 12/ Mark 14 with Mary Magdalene. Mary Magdalene's notable acts of devotion are recorded at the crucifixion and the resurrection Mark 15:47.

Sources · 11
  1. 20MR 146.1Manuscript Releases, vol. 20 [Nos. 1420-1500]Ellen Gould White
  2. SBD Mary sister of Lazarus.2Smith's Bible DictionaryWilliam Smith
  3. SBD Mary Magdalene.2Smith's Bible DictionaryWilliam Smith
  4. LTJMB3 324.1The Life and Times of Jesus the Messiah—Book IIIAlfred Edersheim
  5. HLv 371.2From Heaven With LoveEllen Gould White
  6. ETI Simon.6Easton's Bible DictionaryMatthew G. Easton
  7. 14LtMs, Lt 4, 1899, par. 33Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 14 (1899)Ellen Gould White
  8. 7LtMs, Ms 19, 1892, par. 21Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 7 (1891-1892)Ellen Gould White
  9. ST May 9, 1900, par. 14The Signs of the TimesEllen Gould White
  10. LTJMB4 314.2The Life and Times of Jesus the Messiah—Book IVAlfred Edersheim
  11. DA 524.1The Desire of AgesEllen Gould White

Why is the alabaster box significant in all of the accounts?

AdventAI

The alabaster box is profoundly significant because it embodies costly personal sacrifice, immediate prophetic foresight, and the enduring memorial of Christ's love and death 🌟.

The box itself and the subsequent actions surrounding it served several crucial purposes in the gospel narrative, distinguishing Mary's loving deed forever.

1. Representation of Costly Sacrifice and Devotion

The alabaster box and its contents highlight the immense value Mary placed on Jesus, demonstrating that genuine devotion involves sacrifice:

  • Extraordinary Value: The vessel contained "ointment of spikenard, very costly" John 12:3. This precious ointment was typically housed in an alabaster flask, a name derived from the stone found in Egypt from which these vessels were often made.

  • A Year's Wages: The disciples estimated the value of the ointment at more than three hundred pence (denarii) Mark 14:5. This sum was substantial, approximating the total wages a laboring man’s family might earn in a year, showcasing the sincerity and depth of Mary's sacrifice.

  • Love's Fulfillment: Mary had often heard Jesus speak of His approaching death, and in her deep love and gratitude, she yearned to show Him honor. She did not stop to calculate the value of the offering, regretting only that it was not richer.

  • The Broken Heart: The act of breaking the alabaster box, pouring out the precious contents, is an image of the "broken-hearted love" that flows forth from true Christian affection.

2. Symbolism of Christ's Burial and Sacrifice

Jesus Himself revealed the deepest significance of the box's breaking, connecting the act directly to His impending passion:

  • Preparation for Burial: Jesus defended Mary against critics, declaring plainly, "For in that she hath poured this ointment on my body, she did it for my burial" Matthew 26:12. This was Mary's preparation of faith and devotion for the death she believed was imminent.

  • The Broken Body: Just as the alabaster box was broken and its perfume filled the house, Christ's body was to be broken in death, but He was to rise from the tomb.

  • Fragrance of Life: The ointment's powerful fragrance that filled the whole house symbolized that the "fragrance of His life" and sacrifice was to fill the earth Ephesians 5:2. As the ointment gladdened His heart while He was conscious, it served as an "earnest of the love" that would be His from His redeemed ones forever.

3. Immortalizing Her Deed

The significance of the alabaster box is ultimately sealed by Christ's promise to Mary:

  • An Enduring Memorial: Jesus declared that wherever the gospel would be preached throughout the whole world, "this also that she hath done shall be spoken of for a memorial of her" Mark 14:9.

  • Inspiring Service: The memory of that broken alabaster box has inspired countless individuals to loving service and sacrifice, repeating the story of abundant love to susceptible hearts for all time.

4. Exposure of Hypocrisy

The costly nature of the offering also brought to light the moral corruption of one of Jesus' inner circle:

  • Judas's Criticism: The extravagance of the offering provoked Judas Iscariot, who objected to this "waste" and claimed the money should have been given to the poor John 12:4-5.

  • Hidden Selfishness: Jesus affirmed that Judas’s complaint was not driven by care for the poor, but because Judas was a thief who stole from the common fund John 12:6. Thus, the generous act of the alabaster box served as a severe rebuke of Judas's covetous disposition.

Sources · 22
  1. 20MR 146.1Manuscript Releases, vol. 20 [Nos. 1420-1500]Ellen Gould White
  2. NWAD COSTLY.2Noah Webster’s 1828 DictionaryNoah Webster
  3. ETI Alabaster.2Easton's Bible DictionaryMatthew G. Easton
  4. KJV — Mark 14:3King James VersionKing James Ist
  5. LTJMB4 314.1The Life and Times of Jesus the Messiah—Book IVAlfred Edersheim
  6. GBJ January 1897, page 22.15Sabbath School LessonsWilliam Warren Prescott
  7. SBD Spikenard.2Smith's Bible DictionaryWilliam Smith
  8. DG 60.3Daughters of GodEllen Gould White
  9. 4Red 108.1Redemption: or the Teachings of Christ, the Anointed OneEllen Gould White
  10. HLv 372.3From Heaven With LoveEllen Gould White
  11. 1TT 563.1Testimony Treasures, vol. 1Ellen Gould White
  12. 12LtMs, Ms 28, 1897, par. 36Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897)Ellen Gould White
  13. ARSH January 6, 1859, page 51.25Advent Review, and Sabbath Herald, vol. 13Uriah Smith
  14. 12LtMs, Ms 28, 1897, par. 22Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897)Ellen Gould White
  15. DA 560.5The Desire of AgesEllen Gould White
  16. YI July 19, 1900, par. 8The Youth’s InstructorEllen Gould White
  17. HLv 373.4From Heaven With LoveEllen Gould White
  18. 2SP 378.2The Spirit of Prophecy, vol. 2Ellen Gould White
  19. 6T 310.2Testimonies for the Church, vol. 6Ellen Gould White
  20. EW 165.1Early WritingsEllen Gould White
  21. 12LtMs, Ms 47, 1897, par. 1Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897)Ellen Gould White
  22. 12LtMs, Ms 100, 1897, par. 7Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897)Ellen Gould White

Was the perfume the same for the earlier anointing and the later one?

AdventAI

While both anointing events involved expensive perfumes presented in an alabaster container, only the later anointing by Mary of Bethany is specifically identified in scripture as using spikenard 🌿.

The primary difference is the detailed specification of the substance used during the Bethany feast, distinguishing it from the general term "ointment" used in the earlier account.

The Later Anointing: Spikenard, Very Costly

The anointing of Jesus by Mary of Bethany, which took place six days before the Passover, is clearly defined by the type and value of the perfume used John 12:1.

  • Identified Substance: The gospel accounts specifically name the substance Mary used as "ointment of spikenard, very precious" or "very costly" Mark 14:3.

  • High Value: The costliness of this spikenard was a notable detail, valued at more than three hundred pence, which represented a substantial sum, often equivalent to a year's wages for a laborer Mark 14:5. This high value emphasized the magnitude of Mary's loving sacrifice and devotion.

  • Source of Spikenard: Spikenard (nerd) was a much-valued aromatic perfume, typically imported from Indian plants growing in the Himalaya mountains Song of Sol 1:12. This costly, unadulterated substance was a sacred perfume and a treasure.

The Earlier Anointing: Ointment of a Sinner

The earlier event, recorded in Luke chapter 7, which occurred in the house of Simon the Pharisee, refers to the contents of the container simply as "ointment" Luke 7:37.

  • Unspecified Type: The account of the unnamed woman "who was a sinner" does not specify whether the perfume was spikenard or another costly essence, focusing instead on the deep repentance and broken-hearted affections that motivated her act Luke 7:37.

  • Focus on Devotion: While the perfume itself must have been precious, as ointment was historically valued highly and guarded as a treasure, the narrative emphasizes the sincerity of the woman's repentance and Jesus’ profound lesson on forgiveness Luke 7:37.

Therefore, while both acts were beautiful demonstrations of heartfelt devotion involving precious materials—the alabaster box—only Mary of Bethany’s act in the later anointing explicitly specifies the use of "spikenard," underscoring her extraordinary personal sacrifice in preparing Jesus for His burial Mark 14:8.

Sources · 9
  1. SBD Spikenard.2Smith's Bible DictionaryWilliam Smith
  2. LTJMB4 314.2The Life and Times of Jesus the Messiah—Book IVAlfred Edersheim
  3. ETI Alabaster.2Easton's Bible DictionaryMatthew G. Easton
  4. EW 165.1Early WritingsEllen Gould White
  5. ETI Spikenard.2Easton's Bible DictionaryMatthew G. Easton
  6. 1MCP 242.1Mind, Character, and Personality, vol. 1Ellen Gould White
  7. ARSH January 6, 1859, page 51.25Advent Review, and Sabbath Herald, vol. 13Uriah Smith
  8. GCB April 7, 1901, page 108.5General Conference Bulletin, vol. 4General Conference of SDA
  9. DA 558.4The Desire of AgesEllen Gould White

Was an alabaster box a common way of containing expense perfumes/oils in those times as it features in both events?

AdventAI

Yes, the alabaster box (alabastron) was indeed the standard and highly esteemed vessel used for containing precious oils and perfumes during that era, featuring prominently in both anointing events recorded in the Gospels 🧐.

The fact that an alabaster box appears in both the earlier anointing by the woman who was a sinner in the Pharisee’s house and the later anointing by Mary of Bethany demonstrates its universal recognition as the appropriate container for valuable fragrances Luke 7:37.

The Alabastron: Standard Perfume Vessel

The container’s name and material were deeply connected to its purpose of preserving costly substances:

  • Best Preservation: The ancients regarded alabaster as the best material in which to preserve fine ointments.

  • Source of the Name: Although the actual phials or flasks (alabastron) were frequently made of the whitish alabaster stone—a translucent carbonate of lime—the name eventually became applied to any perfume vessel, regardless of what material it was formed from, simply because alabaster was so commonly used.

  • Common Use: The use of perfumes and fragrant oils was abundant and common in Palestine, and the flasks containing these substances were sometimes even worn by women as ornaments around the neck.

Design of the Alabaster Box

The specific design of the alabaster box also explains a key detail in the narrative of Mary of Bethany:

  • Necessity of Breaking: These flasks were designed to be sealed tightly to preserve the volatile fragrance of the oil, such as spikenard. To access the contents, the woman "broke" the box, which generally meant breaking off the long and narrow neck of the vessel Mark 14:3.

  • Containment for Precious Goods: Since some of the oils contained were exceptionally precious—spikenard, for example, could be valued at three hundred denarii, an enormous sum—the alabaster box was crucial for holding and transporting such costly merchandise.

Thus, the alabaster box serves as an immediate visual signifier in the Gospel accounts, indicating that the offering was an act of profound and extravagant sacrifice, whether it was the unnamed sinner demonstrating her overwhelming repentance and gratitude, or Mary of Bethany expressing her deep love and faith in preparation for Christ’s burial Luke 7:37.

Sources · 4
  1. SBD Alabaster.2Smith's Bible DictionaryWilliam Smith
  2. LTJMB4 314.2The Life and Times of Jesus the Messiah—Book IVAlfred Edersheim
  3. LTJMB3 326.2The Life and Times of Jesus the Messiah—Book IIIAlfred Edersheim
  4. ETI Alabaster.2Easton's Bible DictionaryMatthew G. Easton