IMMORTALITY

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 29, 1880

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 6.

Read the full edition

IMMORTALITY

The following article we take from Messiah's Herald of June 16, 1880. As the reader will see, it was called out by an article in the Signs of the Times, of Oakland, Cal. We are happy to see that there is so much agreement between the Herald and the Signs, and that there is on the part of the Herald such an apparent distrust of the propriety of the common use of the phrase “immortality of the soul.” In short, if we mistake not, the reader will find the whole article to present the air of one who sees the inconsistency and is tugging at the restraints of the dominant theology which he is not yet quite ready to wholly discard. It will therefore be read with interest.
The Signs of the Times, a weekly paper published in Oakland, Cal., in the interest of the Seventh-day Adventists, has an editorial in its issue of April 22, in which it says:—
“Most people think that the sole or special characteristic of Adventists, is a belief in the mortality of man. But this is not so; the oldest Adventist paper published in the United States—Messiah's Herald, formerly the Advent Herald—holds to the belief of the immortality of the soul. In this, however, Seventh-day Adventists do not agree with it.”
Now it is true that First-day Evangelical Adventists, represented by Messiah's Herald, do hold that men may “kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul” (Matt. 10:28),—that the soul and spirit leave the body at death, and exist in a state of comfort or of discomfort until the resurrection, when they will be reunited to the body; but we refrain from using the term “immortality of the soul,” because the Scriptures do not use it. This, with us, is nothing new. The subject of man's condition in death was very fully discussed in our columns twenty or thirty years ago, when Bro. Bliss was editor; and from the position then taken on this point we have never seen reason to dissent. In one of his articles on immortality he said:—
“This word, when popularly used, and often as used theologically, to express merely an eternity of matter, irrespective of its nature, is, we conceive, grossly perverted from its Scriptural significance—that being expressive only of a glorious and incorruptible existence.” Then, after taking up every passage in the New Testament in which the Greek words occur which are rendered “immortality” in our translation; namely, athanasia and aphtharsia (with its adjective aphthartos), he remarks:—
“When predicated of God, it is additional to that which is expressive of his eternity (1 Tim. 1:17); in its highest sense it is predicable of God alone (1 Tim. 6:13–16); it is sought for by the saints (Rom. 2:6–9); it is to be put on by this mortal and corruptible at the resurrection (1 Cor. 15:50–54); it is brought to light through the gospel (2 Tim. 1:10); it is descriptive of the glory of God, of the crown, and of the inheritance of the redeemed (Rom. 1:23; 1 Cor. 9:25; 1 Pet. 1:4); expressive of doctrinal truthfulness, of sincerity of purpose, and of meekness and quietness of spirit (Tit. 2:7; Eph. 6:24; 1 Pet. 1:23; 3:4); and it is contrasted with the mortality and corruptibility of our present condition, its weakness and dishonor, and with the ‘tribulation and anguish’ of the lost (1 Cor. 15:42–44; Rom. 2:6–9). It cannot, therefore, properly be expressive of anything pertaining to the lost, and it is not applicable to man in his present changing and mortal state, or to the unresurrected condition of the departed. And hence it follows that its use is an unscriptural one, and should be discarded by those who would ‘hold fast the form of sound words.’”
Believing as we do, that “the meek shall inherit the earth,” and “shall dwell therein forever,” the “reward of the inheritance” necessitates, in our judgment, “the resurrection of the just”; and we would no more think of calling the rest and comfort of “the spirits of just men” in paradise—between death and resurrection—their reward, or any part of it, than we would the rest and blessing of salvation experienced by believers in this life. The coronation of the saints is “when the Chief Shepherd shall appear” (1 Pet. 5:4), not at death. The crown implies regal dignity, and that will only be given when the King comes (Matt. 25:31–34). But though the righteous will be uncrowned till then, they are not necessarily unconscious; just as the Prince of Wales—heir apparent to the British throne—is uncrowned, but not unconscious. It will thus be seen that when the editor of the Signs makes the following statement respecting the Seventh-day Adventists, he is only saying what is equally true of us:—
“They hold that immortality is to be sought for. Rom. 2:7. That it is obtained only through Jesus and the resurrection, for it is in the resurrection that ‘this mortal shall put on immortality.’ 1 Cor. 15:51–54. This view greatly increases their love for the appearing of Jesus; see 2 Tim. 4:8; for the Saviour himself said that we ‘shall be recompensed at the resurrection of the just,’ Luke 14:14; and that when he comes he will bring his reward with him. Rev. 22:12. And Paul said, ‘The dead in Christ shall rise’ when ‘the Lord himself shall descend from Heaven.’ 1 Thess. 4:13–18. From these scriptures we learn that, 1. The just will not be raised till the Lord comes; 2. The reward, or recompense, will not be given until the Lord comes; 3. And, hence, if ‘the Lord himself’ never comes again, the just will never be raised, and the reward will never be given. Thus, ‘the hope and resurrection of the dead,’ (Acts 23:15), or ‘the glorious appearing’ of Jesus, becomes to us, as it was to Paul, ‘that blessed hope.’ Titus 2:13. To this glorious theme our hearts turn with ever-increasing delight. For this we are willing, if need be, to be ‘everywhere spoken against.’ Acts 28:22.”