THIS year Pres. Noah Porter, D. D., LL. D., preached the baccalaureate sermon before the graduating class of Yale College, on the subject of “The Hopelessness of Godlessness.” Pres. Porter’s name is a sufficient guaranty of the excellence of the discourse; but our readers may judge of its merits from the following extract, taken from the Independent of July 15:—
Without God there is no well-grounded hope for science. This may seem to be a very daring or a very paradoxical assertion. There is more truth in it, however, than is usually discerned. Inasmuch as it is in the name of science that ignorance of God is exalted into supreme wisdom, it may be worth while to inquire, What would the effect upon science be could it cast out God from all its thinking? I say, could it do this; for it would be very hard to do so. Our newly-fledged agnostics are apt to forget that all modern science has been prosecuted in the broad and penetrating sunlight of faith in one living and personal God, and that not a single theory has been proposed or experiment tried in nature, except with the distinct recognition of the truth that a wise and loving mind, at least, may uphold and direct the goings on of nature. The most passionate atheist cannot deny that this is the conviction of most of the living and breathing men about him. The most restrained agnostic cannot but know and feel that the theory which he strives to cherish is rejected by most of the women and children who look up into the sky and walk on the earth. The simple teachings of Christian theism are capable of being expanded into the grandest conceptions that science ever attempted to formulate; so grand that human reason is overwhelmed with their sublime relationships, and the human imagination is dazed to blindness when it would picture them. The first proposition of the creed which the infant pronounces with confiding simplicity—“I believe in God, the Father Almighty, Maker of heaven and earth”—is easily expanded into those conceptions that the man necessarily and intuitively supplies as the background upon which science traces all its propositions, and through which it connects its theories and proceeds to its conclusions.
That science must have faith and hope appears whether we consider it as an interpreter, an historian, or a prophet. Though it begins with facts, it does not stop with facts. Though it begins with the seen, it looks beneath the visible and strives after the invisible. So soon as it compares and explains, it connects the sensible and interprets events by forces and laws, by hypotheses and theories. Let it test its theories by experiments, a thousand times repeated; what it tests is what it has gained by interpretation—that is, what is not seen, but believed. Following the unseen on the lines of interpreting thought, it is led into the very presence of a thinking God.
We know that, for eminence in any specialty, the natural faith and hope of men in science as interpretation and history and prophecy, is altogether sufficient, and this need not be expanded into faith in God. We do not object in the least that science stops short in its explanations of phenomena at molecules, and motion, and inertia, and attraction, and heat, and electricity, and heredity, and development, and variation, and environment. But we do contend that atheistic agnosticism gives no solution of those explanations that are essential to science which is so satisfactory as the creed of Christian theism. We also contend that the personal thinker is more than the scientist who interprets and prophesies, and the living man demands and accepts a personal God as the best solution of all the problems which every special science raises, but which no special science can solve.
Perhaps you have traversed a forest at midnight, and have painfully and slowly felt out your path among the objects which the darkness seemed to conceal, rather than reveal. You have mastered it by slow but sure steps, such as the blind man feels out by exact and reasoning touch. Anon you traverse the same forest by noon. How luminous has it become, through the all-pervading light! Perhaps you do not think of the glorious sun from which this light proceeds; but you know that what was an obscure thicket, beset with dimness and shade, is flooded with the revealing light, and hope and joy have taken the place of caution and doubt and fear. So does the recognition of a personal Intelligence who may be known by man give an assured hope to what men call science. So has it been to its advancing hosts a pillar of fire by night and a cloud by day. The denial of such an intelligence, or the assertion that he cannot be known, takes from science its hope, because it withdraws from the universe the illumination of personal reason and personal love, which all scientific thinking accepts as possible and rational.
To be without God is to be without hope in respect to moral culture and perfection. What we are is of far greater consequence than what we know. Strength and perfection of character are the supreme aim of all right-judging men. When they think of what man was made to be, and of what they themselves might become, they cannot but aspire. But, strong as conscience is to elevate, control, and command, a personal God is needed by man, to give energy and life to conscience. Personality without is required to re-enforce the personality within.