A CONVERSATION ABOUT THE TITHING SYSTEM.
By R. M. Kilgore
Mr. Investigator.—I have lately been investigating the views of S. D. Adventists, and I must say that there seems to be a greater degree of harmony between them and the Bible than I expected to find; but there is one point about which I am somewhat troubled, and that is the tithing system which your people have so generally adopted; and I have come over this evening to ask some questions concerning it. Adventist.—I am glad you have come; and I hope you will be perfectly free to present your objections, and if I can help you I shall be glad to do so. I presume you design to be as candid in the examination of this subject as you have been on the other points. Mr. I.—Certainly; I cannot afford to be otherwise. My happiness depends on my being in perfect harmony with the will of God. If I know it to be my duty to pay a tenth, I shall do so. But I have always looked upon the tithing system as an ordinance applicable to the Jews as God’s peculiar people. Can you show that it was carried out prior to, and continued after, the Jewish dispensation? A.—The first mention we have of it in the Bible is about one hundred and sixty years before the tribe of Judah (Jews) existed, and more than four hundred years before the covenant was made which brought them into that peculiar relation to God, or before any ordinance concerning it had been given to them. In the history of Abraham’s paying tithes you will see that it has not the form of a new arrangement into which he then entered, and that no law was at that time given concerning tithes; but there was only an acknowledgment of a claim, and the performance of a duty, which had previously been understood and recognized by him. Mr. I.—When do you think the system was first ordained? A.—Just as soon as it became necessary that men should be employed to minister in sacred things. If God should appoint priests to offer sacrifices for the people, and to minister at the altar, and not ordain any means for their support, it would show great injustice on his part. The system must have been understood immediately after the fall. In the arrangement of the plan of salvation, God would have men to be partners with him; and while he would employ men as priests to minister before him in offering sacrifices in behalf of sinners, he would also give man the privilege of sustaining his servants in this sacred work. Mr. I.—But we see no law that was given concerning it. A.—Very true. Neither do we see any law given concerning sacrifices immediately after the fall, yet “Abel offered unto God a more excellent sacrifice than Cain.” Gen. 4: 3-5; Heb. 11: 4. Noah built an altar unto the Lord, and offered burnt-offerings. Gen. 8: 20. Melchizedek is priest of the Most High God. Chap. 14: 18. Isaac builds an altar. Chap. 26: 25; and Jacob built his pillar (altar), and offered sacrifices, and saved a tenth of all that the Lord would give him. Chap. 28: 18-22; 31: 54. Now, while no written law appears, this conformity to a common principle on the part of both antediluvians and patriarchs is good evidence that, at a very early period, oral precepts must have been given concerning these things. Mr. I.—That early priesthood must have been very inferior to that which succeeded it; there is so little said about it. A.—No, indeed; it was superior. This the apostle proves most clearly, from the fact that the less always pays tithes to the greater. Abraham, and Levi, who was yet in the loins of his father Abraham, paid tithes to Melchizedek, and thus to God, as a sign of gratitude for mercies shown to them. Heb. 7: 4-9. If the Levites, who received tithes of their brethren, paid tithes to Melchizedek, that former priesthood was the greater. Mr. I.—I am satisfied that the obligation to pay tithes was recognized, and the system carried out, before the Jewish age. But is it clear that it did not pass away when the system of types and sacrifices came to an end at the cross of Christ? A.—If it did, then we must conclude that God would no longer employ men in divine service; or that he would institute some other system whereby his ministers might be supported. And if another system, there is no reason why the proportion required should be any less than the tenth. We see that Christ commissioned his disciples and their successors to go into all the world, and preach the gospel. Would it be just and wise for him to command them to go to the ends of the earth, and make no provision for their support? Would it not require as much to sustain them away from their homes and earthly friends, while laboring for and amid strangers, and sometimes even enemies, as it did to sustain God’s ancient ministers, who always remained at home? Mr. I.—I cannot see that it would be just, or that it should take any less; but Christ or his apostles did not seem to leave any orders about the amount that each should give, and there appears to be a silence in the New Testament about a continuance of the ancient tithing system. A.—Certainly, then, there cannot be any grounds for believing that a new system was ordained, or that the old one was abrogated. Their silence would argue a continuance, unless it can be shown to expire by limitation. But Christ does state to those living in his time, that they “ought” to pay tithes of even the smallest garden herbs, as was then the custom. Matt. 23: 23. And the apostle orders that on the first day of the week, every one should lay by him in store as God had prospered him. 2 Cor. 16: 2. The proportion must have been understood. To leave each one to decide the proportion he should give would be unwise; for the liberal would be too heavily burdened, while the stingy would give but little. He would178 not have this, but an equality. 2 Cor. 8: 13, 14. Mr. I.—But does not the apostle, in this order, make provision for the poor saints, and not the ministers? A.—The Greek word from which “saints” is translated is hagious, and is rendered by Greenfield, “holy, consecrated, pure, sanctified.” This language would certainly embrace those who had been set apart, or ordained, to the work of the ministry. In this case, you will observe that there is a stated weekly contribution for the “holy ones;” but when the poor ones are to be ministered unto, he speaks of a “certain contribution” for them; Rom. 15: 26; and this they “were pleased” to do, since they had been the recipients of their “spiritual things.” Notice the distinction which the apostle makes between that which the poor saints at Jerusalem had given to send the gospel to those of Macedonia and Achaia, and that which they were returning. One is “spiritual,” the other he styles “carnal.” Verse 27. Mr. I.—What does the apostle mean in this distinction? A.—That which God has sanctified, and reserved as his, is holy, as he plainly declares the tithe to be. Lev. 27: 30. It is not ours, but it is committed to us in trust, to dispose of for a particular object,—the maintenance of God’s ministers; but the nine-tenths is ours in a very different sense. With it we are to pay taxes, support ourselves, school our children, and relieve the afflicted and needy. From this, also, we are to draw our offerings to support the different benevolent societies which may be necessary for the spread of the truth, and for the amelioration of fallen humanity. Mr. I.—I have always supposed that we paid the Lord’s claim when we gave to the poor. A.—When we give to the poor, we only lend to the Lord, and the Lord promises to return it again. Prov. 19: 17. You see it is a mistaken idea; for if what we give to the poor were the Lord’s, it would not be a loan, but the payment of a debt, and if a debt, it is not ours to lend, or to give to another. You owe me ten dollars. You could not lend that money to me; and would you feel at liberty to give it to that poor widow, Mrs. P.? Mr. I.—I have viewed this matter in a wrong light, and I must examine this subject more fully. I want to know more about this “claim of the Lord.” I have always considered as my own what I have labored for and obtained. A.—That is the general opinion. You always hear Mr. H., whose herds number more than the shingles on his house, say, “My cattle;” and Mr. B. says, “All this farm is mine;” and Mr. A. says, “This store is mine;” and that miser says, “This coffer of gold and silver is mine.” This is the common parlance of the day. We are liable to claim unwittingly what is not our own. But who is the rightful owner? he who is the Creator of all things, or the creature, who is not even an heir, but a sinner? What says the Lord? “Every beast of the forest is mine; and the cattle upon a thousand hills. I know all the fowls of the mountains; and the wild beasts of the field are mine. If I were hungry, I would not tell thee; for the world is mine, and the fullness thereof.” Ps. 50: 10–12. In Haggai 2: 8, he says, “The silver is mine, and the gold is mine.” Being the Maker, he has a right to claim it, and is the rightful owner. If man has any claim whatever, it is a subordinate one. Mr. I.—Have I not read that the Lord gave the earth, with every living thing upon it, to man for a dominion? If he gave it to man, how, then, can it be that the Lord says it is his? A.—In Ps. 115: 16, he says, “The earth hath he given to the children of men;” and in Gen. 1: 28, he said to Adam, “Have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the fowl of the air, and over every living thing that moveth upon the earth.” This was the property of man; and had he continued a loyal subject, it doubtless would have remained his, and no annuity or weekly tribute would have been required of him. But in his rebellion he lost his title, and sold himself. Paul says, “Thou hast put all things in subjection under his feet. For in that he put all in subjection under him, he left nothing that is not put under him. But now we see not yet all things put under him.” Heb. 2: 8. You see it was his, but it is not now. We are “carnal, sold under sin.” Rom. 7: 14. Sin has ruined the world. When man lost his innocency, he forfeited all that he had; his life also. But God loves the world. His Son offers himself a ransom. The Father gives him to the world a sacrifice for sin. The just suffers for the unjust; his blood pays the price. Man’s lost possession is purchased, Eph. 1: 14; and man who had sold himself is bought with that price. We are therefore not our own. We are God’s. 1 Cor. 6: 19, 20. All we have and are, our time and talents, are his; and in gaining any of this world’s treasures, it is God who gives us the ability. Deut. 8: 18. God will therefore have the right to dictate the terms upon which we shall receive his bounty, and how much we shall receive, if any at all. He reserves the tenth as his, as we have seen. Mr. I.—I think the tenth is too heavy a tax. I could not support myself and family if I should be compelled to give so much. A.—You think, then, that God is unjust that he demands so great a proportion of what we receive. Let us look at this a moment. How much do you expect to receive of Mr. A. this fall, for the privilege of cultivating your land this season? Mr. I.—Out of twenty bales of cotton, which he thinks he will raise, I shall get five; and of the wheat and corn I shall receive one-third. He furnishes everything, and puts my share of the crops into the granary. I never let my land out on any other terms. A.—Of course you think that is just and right. It is the custom of the country, and we shall not question its equity. But let us see: you do not water or warm the ground, clothe or feed him or his team, nor give him strength when he is not able to work; and yet you demand of him the one-third and one-fourth. Now what does God do for you, while you are laboring in the adjoining field? He furnishes the ground by giving you a limited title; the team you work, he lends you; you borrowed of him the grain you planted; he sprouted it, caused it to grow, and ripened it by watering it with his own rain, and warming it with his own sun. He gave you health and strength to put it into the ground, and gather it in the harvest. He asks you to return to him one-tenth. I wonder that his terms are so liberal. Mr. I.—I have not viewed the subject from that standpoint. You have opened up before me a new field of thought. A.—Permit me again to bring this matter before you, in another form. We have seen that we belong to God because he purchased us with the blood of his Son, and that we are not our own. We are, therefore, the servants of God. Our time, our talents, our possessions, are properly his, and he has a pre-eminent right to demand at our hands our entire service. Here is an illustration right to the point: Just before the war you had five thousand dollars invested in negroes. You and your neighbors said they were your property. You demanded that all their time should be employed for your benefit. Everything they acquired, whether on the farm or at labor for another, you required the proceeds in full to be returned to you. You clothed and fed them, just as you furnish harness and feed for your team. In fact, you regarded them in the light that if they were fed and clothed, it was all they ought to demand at your hands in return for their labor. You bought them; they were your servants. You said that was just. Your neighbors agreed with you in this. The law supported you. And had your servants risen up and demanded the one-tenth of the proceeds of their labor as their own, it would have been considered unreasonable. Now, before I make the application, I wish to know if my statements in this are correct. Mr. I.—They are; for it is just in this light that I considered the relation existing between me and my servants; and every one who owned slaves looked upon it just as I did. A.—Very well. 1. We are God’s by creation. We are his workmanship, and therefore should render him all our service, just as that windmill which you have made serves you by pumping all your water. In this, the rich, the poor, the righteous, and the wicked, all stand in the same relation to their Maker. 2. We are his by purchase and redemption. The immense price that has been paid for us and the great sacrifice which has been made, by which we might be redeemed from our lost condition, certainly gives to God the highest claim possible upon us, with all that we have and are. Who would say that he was unjust if he should demand it? Since God is able to enforce his requirements, man would have to submit, or suffer the consequences. But what has God done? Does he demand all our time to be employed in his service? No. Is it one-half? That would be reasonable. One-fourth would be very liberal. Is it one-sixth? No. His requirement is, “Six days shalt thou labor, and do all thy work; but the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God; in it thou shalt not do any [of thy] work.” Here we concede this claim to be just and right. All Christian nations acknowledge it, and refrain from labor one day out of each week. You granted this to your slaves. Now, what proportion of the money does he reserve as his? Will he allow us the proceeds of extra hours? This you did, and your servants thought you a good master. Has God said, “Return the one-third or one-fourth of what you make,” as you do to your renter? If it is just for you to do that, it would be for him, from whom come all our blessings. But no; he does not ask even the one-seventh, as he does of our time. The one-eighth would be less than one-half of what you demand. He is more liberal still. All he has reserved as his is the one-tenth. He says, “All the tithe of the land, whether of the seed of the land, or of the fruit of the tree, is the Lord’s; it is holy unto the Lord.” Lev. 27: 30. Mr. I.—Your argument is very convincing, and I must acknowledge the justice of God’s claim. I never saw before that God had regarded the “tithe” in the same light as the Sabbath—as his, and “holy unto the Lord.” A.—That is very clear, and I think all may see it. Here is another, which adds force to this. Let us read Mal. 3: 8: “Will a man rob God? yet ye have robbed me. But ye say, Wherein have we robbed thee? In tithes and offerings.” It would be impossible for us to rob God in tithes if he had not reserved the tenth as his. If your renter should carry off and sell those five bales of cotton, you would have him arrested, because he had robbed you in taking that which you had reserved of the fruit of your field. God charges us with robbery in taking from him what he has reserved as his. We are also criminal if we appropriate any part of the tenth to our own use; for God says, “All the tithe of the field is holy,” and commands us to “bring all the tithe.” I am fearful that when we, as stewards, are reckoned with, this charge of robbery will be sustained because of our unfaithfulness in this respect. Those who are so careful to give God all his own holy day, ought to be just as particular to return all the tithe. The command is as imperative in the one case as the other. We talk about “giving” and “paying our tithe.” It would be better to say, We will return them. For how can we “give” or “pay” to another what is already his? Mr. I.—Well, I must admit that you have more proof for, and the Scriptures are clearer on, this position, than I had supposed when I came here this evening. I am satisfied that, as stewards of the Lord’s179 property, we are responsible for it; and that God will hold us accountable for making unfaithful returns. But I have tarried longer than I intended. I promise you that I will still inquire, “What is truth?” and seek for it till I have found it. I will call again. Good night. A.—If you have no objections, please let us pray before we separate.