AdventAI

CORRUPT MAXIMS, PRINCIPLES, AND METHODS OF OUR COMMERCIAL MORALITY.

By J. Milton Greene

From Review and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 10., August 26, 1880

I do not mean by this to refer to that withholding of information from the buyer which the law of self-preservation makes necessary on the part of the seller, nor do I forget that there are certain words which are used by business men in a technical sense, especially the words “cost,” and “profit,” and “percentage.” They have a perfect right to employ these terms among themselves, and in talking with their customers where the meaning in every case is clear to the person addressed. But when business maxims and principles, under cover of any of these terms, or without them, sanction intentional deceit, there is most clearly an infringement of neighborly obligation. And I arraign the business practices of to-day as rotten to the core, because of this very intentional deceit for the sake of profit.

I can best set forth what I have in mind by some facts which I believe to be fairly representative of the general state of things among business men. There are exceptions, doubtless, but they only serve to prove the rule.

A. is a large dealer in precious stones in an Eastern city. On a certain day he receives an order from a Western customer for a certain gem which he is to sell for $185. He is to pay for it $150, but he asks that a bill may be sent him which he may show to the party to whom he is to make the sale, on which the price fixed shall be $175. He does this so that his expected customer may be led to believe that he receives a profit of but $10 on the sale, whereas he realizes a profit of $35, and the Eastern house conspires with him in the trick.

B. is a good friend of mine and an elder in the Presbyterian church, who, a few years since, was employed in one of the two great cities of the Empire State by a representative firm in the furniture trade. His position was that of salesman and his salary very liberal. His custom was to make sales of suits for samples. But very soon he was made aware of frequent complaints by the customers that the articles purchased were not equal to the samples shown them. B. examined into the matter and ascertained that it was the habit of the principal men in the firm to give instructions to the subordinates in making up the orders and shipping them to put in here a slightly inferior sofa and there chairs of a cheaper grade, and here an imitation of marble instead of a counterpart of the genuine marble from which the selection had been made. By this means an increase of profit resulted to the firm of from ten to fifty dollars on each sale. B. could not endure the fraud, and left the place.

C. is a young man who came from New England to New York a few years since and went into the dry-goods trade. His religious education had been of the Unitarian type. He learned the business rapidly and rose in position very soon to rank with the foremost salesmen. Meantime he became greatly interested in the word of God as preached by a devoted pastor of one of the evangelical churches in the city. His mind was illumined and his conscience greatly quickened. The daily practices of his business life troubled him. Anticipating marriage to a lovely Christian lady, this anxiety was intensified. I saw him in his distress, and he opened his heart to me. What burdened him was the fact that he had been accustomed, as instructed by his employers, to falsify habitually to his customers. Whatever cost price would enable him to make a sale he was told to name.

This sliding scale of alleged cost prices was a torture to his moral instincts. I told him my view of the case, that nothing but falsehood would properly characterize such statements. He agreed with me, but added, “Everybody does it, and if I am to do business I must do it.” And so far as I know, he steeled his conscience against these unrighteous acts; for he is still in the same employ as formerly.

D. is a man who occupies the position of agent for certain vineyards. He has subordinates who receive the wine in barrels and prepare it for sale in bottles. In his representations to his customers he says: “So far as I know, not a drop of alcohol has been put into this. So far as I know, it is the pure juice of the grape fermented.” But what does he mean by “know”? He is morally certain that alcohol has been put into the liquors, but he has not actually seen it done. He is careful not to go where it is done. And so his customers are deceived by this crafty device in the use of a word and his own profits are increased, he seeks to quiet his own conscience by the claim that he has not been guilty of a formal falsehood.

Now these are but samples of scores upon scores ofp. 153 facts which might be adduced to show how, under the fair guise of honorable and even generous dealing, our business men very generally are guilty of substantial theft and falsehood in obedience to the prompting of covetousness.

But I can hear some one ask, Is not this an overdrawn picture? Do you not forget that there are still many honest men of business? My reply is simply this, that I am not dealing with exceptional cases, but with the accepted code of commercial morality. Men do the things I have described without losing their standing in business circles, in society, or what is worst of all, in the church, and there is no doubt that these things are to-day doing more to fill up the ranks of infidelity than all the frank, outspoken skepticism that has ever been written in books or uttered upon the platform. I am not a pessimist, but I have eyes and ears to know facts, and I fully believe there is a crying need that many prophets of repentance go through our stock and produce exchanges and into our counting and sales rooms, and declare to men who are violating the law of God and dealing deceitfully with their fellow-men the fact that “judgment is turned away backward, and justice standeth afar off; for truth is fallen in the street, and equity cannot enter.” There is not one of these evil practices to which I have referred and which have become “regular,” as the term is, that could stand for a moment before the test of the Golden Rule, or that any man can do in good conscience who has given God the throne of his affections and the guidance of his conduct.—Rev. J. Milton Greene, in Christian Weekly.