THE GREAT DELUSION AND ITS FRUITS

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 26, 1880

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 10.

Read the full edition

THE GREAT DELUSION AND ITS FRUITS.

The doctrine of the natural and necessary immortality of man is the prolific source of an uncounted number of subordinate errors. It ever has been and ever must be the case, so long as it is believed. This delusive lie, “Ye shall not surely die;” “ye shall be as Gods,” and live forever; ye cannot forfeit your existence, even by disobeying your Creator, for he made you immortal—this is the tempter’s most cunning masterpiece. It not only flatters the pride of man, but it can also be used with terrible effect to asperse the character of God, and obscure and pervert the whole system of divine truth. No wonder that Satan began his work of temptation with this false assurance, nor that he should have succeeded, when once this assurance was accepted as the truth. No wonder that he should employ all his artifice to perpetuate a delusion that has wrought such mischief—in the world and in the church.
So long as the word of God can be so perverted as to seem to teach that sinners are immortal beings, and that death does not mean death, nor life, life, in any true sense; but only certain conditions of being; that fallen man needs no Saviour to perpetuate his being, but only one to rescue him from eternal sin and misery, and to give him eternal blessedness; so long as the church of God can be held to the acceptance of this doctrine as one of the chief foundation-stones of their religion, and the ministers of Christ can be persuaded to preach this as the gospel, the message of life to dying man,—so long will the truth of God fail, in great part, to exert its legitimate influence upon man. While a few here and there may be won to the embrace of the gospel in spite of the clouds that envelop it, the great mass of men will “turn away their ears from it, and be turned unto fables.” Atheists, infidels, skeptics, and errorists, of every sort, will be multiplied. However it may have been in the darker and ruder ages of the past, this doctrine, in the light of the present day, is seen to lead to conclusions that cannot be reconciled with that system of truth commonly called orthodox. Thinking men are compelled to the denial, either of the God of the Bible, or of the Bible as the word of God, or to such an accommodation of its teachings to their philosophy concerning the natural immortality of all men as will give them the comforting assurance that they are orthodox believers.
Starting with the assumption that every human life is an endless life, they will not, they cannot, accept of the conclusion that a just God will perpetuate the existence of any human life in helpless, hopeless, unending misery. If the Bible is the word of God, it cannot, they are sure, teach a doctrine so monstrous and horrible. Hence the inclination, the temptation, the effort, to make it teach something else, on the part of those who would maintain their faith in its teaching. What else, then, can it teach, with respect to the final destiny of the sinner, if he is inevitably to live forever, than that he will in some way, at some time in the future, if not before death, be restored to the favor of God and to a condition of eternal blessedness? This is just the process, through the insidious working of this error of immortality for all men, that is now going on throughout the whole Christian world. Restorationism—which, by whatever soft names it may be called, is really nothing but Universalism—is becoming more and more prevalent and popular.
The demoralizing influence of this error is seen, also, in respect to the great doctrine of the resurrection of the dead, which occupies so prominent a place in the gospel, and upon which the early disciples fixed their hopes. It is fading out of sight. Its “power” is gone. Indeed there is hardly any place or reason for it. Death is not death. There is no interruption of our consciousness. In fact, we are released from the bondage of the body when we die. We become more alive than ever. The righteous go at once into a state of blessedness, yea, into Heaven; and the wicked into a state of misery. They are now in hell, but their probation is not ended. They are in a better condition to see the truth and to embrace it, if offered. It is offered. They become penitent, are forgiven and saved.
This brings back, in substance, if not in name, the old papal doctrine of purgatory, which the Reformers thought they had discarded, but which cannot be suppressed so long as the root from which it springs is permitted to remain.
The doctrine of ghostism or spiritualism—so prevalent at the present time—has also its source in the same root.
These, and other correlated errors that might be mentioned, cannot be effectually dispelled, so long as the great primal error, in which they all center and from which they naturally and necessarily flow, bears sway. Nor is it, perhaps, possible to do much effectually to dethrone the original error by way of argument; for it is not founded upon argument. It finds no support from Scripture, or science, or sound reason. Indeed, they are all arrayed against it. Theologians, scientists, and philosophers confess their inability to prove this doctrine, to which they so tenaciously cling; and all the more tenaciously, it would seem, because they cannot prove it. It is a sentiment, a feeling, a desire, and as such, no reasoning has any force against it. Men believe it because they wish to believe it; because they are unwilling to allow that they have forfeited so much by sin, or need so great a salvation through Christ. It is a delusion—the great delusion, as we believe, of our arch adversary. It has been inwrought into our souls by early education, and has been made a part of the mind, as it were. It enters into all our modes of thought on religious questions. Our theological systems are founded upon it as upon an established truth, and permeated with it as though it were an axiom not to be questioned. Our philosophy, our poetry, and our literature, of every sort, is saturated with it to overflowing. And nothing, as we believe, but the Spirit of God, will suffice to open the eyes of men to the falsity of this delusion, and lead them back to the truth so plainly and constantly reiterated in his word—that “the wages of sin is death, but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord.” “If ye live after the flesh, ye shall die; but if ye through the Spirit do mortify the deeds of the body, ye shall live.”
We certainly take no credit to ourselves that we have been able to break away from the bondage of error, in which we were so long held, and to come into the liberty and joy of this glorious gospel truth, that Christ is the resurrection and the life, and that he alone is the only sure hope of immortality for mortal man. It is due alone to the enlightening and leading influences of the Spirit of God. Here, too, is our hope for our dear Christian brethren who are still in bondage to the same traditional error. Instead of desponding, in view of the prevalence and increase of these errors to which we have alluded, we are encouraged to believe that this is to be one of the means by which the church of Christ will be led back to the faith once delivered to the saints. To what extremes of folly and false notions Christian men may be allowed to go, we know not. But the miserable fruits of this great delusion are daily becoming more and more manifest. The time cannot be far distant, it would seem, when every true disciple will be able to see the source from which they come, and how far, how very far, they have been seduced from the simple truths of the Scriptures, and how necessary it is to come back to the plain letter and teachings of God’s word.—J. H. Pettingill, in Bible Banner.