DEMENTED

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 4, 1880

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 19.

Read the full edition

DEMENTED

MESSIAH'S HERALD, published in Boston, Mass., has, since Eld. J. M. Orrock became editor, maintained a very gentlemanly and Christian bearing toward the REVIEW and S. D. Adventists. Eld. O. is temporarily absent on a vacation, during which time Eld. J. Litch has charge of the Herald. Eld. L., it seems, cannot forego the opportunity of this brief period of authority to make a thrust at S. D. Adventists and the Sabbath, as he does in a recent number of the paper.
Of his arguments against the Sabbath, there is no necessity of speaking at length. He heads his article, “Why We Do not Hold and Teach the Observance of the Jewish Sabbath.” The very heading betrays the confusion that exists in his own mind on this question. No one is advocating such an institution as the “Jewish Sabbath.” The term is unscriptural, as is that of “Christian Sabbath,” which terms are never used in the Bible as pertaining to a weekly Sabbath, and only spring from ignorance or prejudice.
He claims that the ten commandments were the old covenant. Sufficient answer to this has been abroad for years in our works on this subject. His position makes necessary the conclusion that no persons before the time of Moses were under obligation to obey the ten commandments; but this is false, as we find all the commandments, or the principles of them, mentioned, and their violation condemned, before the time of Moses.
He says that all that Christ made obligatory on his followers, he quoted and “reinforced” in the gospel. This, on his own ground of argument, is an error, or it is still lawful to worship images. But how long before these principles were “reinforced” in the gospel? When were the new enactments made? What was the condition of the world between the abolition of the old and the enactment of the new? It was years after the crucifixion of Christ before the apostles, in their gospels, made quotations from the ten commandments. But they simply quoted, they did not re-enact. They treat them as a living law; a law not made void by faith in Christ; a law by which we shall be judged; a law of which, if we break one commandment, we are guilty of them all; a law which shall neither be changed in one jot or tittle nor pass away, while the heavens and the earth endure. Romans 3:31; James 2:10-12; Matt. 5:17-20.
He says, “There is no record in the New Testament that the apostles or the early church ever held religious services on the Jewish Sabbath, except as for convenience they went into Jewish meetings.” Has he ever read Acts 13:42-44, or Acts 16:13? Or will he tell us where a meeting was ever held in the daytime of the first day of the week, from the New Testament record?
The Jerusalem council, Acts 15, he says, said not one word about the Sabbath. Very well. Did that council say anything about worshiping other gods, or blasphemy, or murder, or false witness, or covetousness, or disobedience to parents? Why not mention these things as well as the Sabbath always? This was not the subject of discussion; but it was circumcision and the ritual of Moses. Verse 1.
He refers to Romans 7 in a way to betray the utmost confusion of ideas in reference to the teachings of Paul. In Paul's figure of marriage, Eld. L. would have the law die instead of the husband. It is “we” who die, through the crucifixion of the “old man of sin,” and then, being no longer under condemnation by the law, we can, without guilt, become married to Christ.
He says, “It is claimed that Paul referred to the ceremonial law, not to the moral.” We never before heard of any who made such a claim.
In 2 Cor. 3:7 he utterly confounds the ministration of a law with the law itself. Christ, he said, did not instruct his disciples to teach the observance of the Sabbath. We answer, Christ taught them to keep the moral law in its entirety, not abating therefrom one jot or tittle, and they were to teach and keep it, or be excluded from the kingdom of Heaven.
He quotes Romans 10:4, “For Christ is the end of the law for righteousness to every one that believeth,” and claims therefrom that the Sabbath is abolished. But what about those who do not believe? The law has not ended for them, on this argument, and hence they should keep the Sabbath, and all the other commandments. But if the Sabbath has ended for Christians, then every commandment of the decalogue has ended in like manner, and Christians may lie, steal, swear, or commit any other immorality. If our friends do not like this conclusion, let them cease to use arguments which inevitably lead to it.
A little further on Eld. L. reveals where lies at least one root of his difficulty, by utterly confounding the ceremonial and moral laws, which are as distinct as heaven and earth. See pamphlet on “The Two Laws.”
Finally he quotes Col. 2:16, 17, and tries to make it apply to the weekly Sabbath. But Paul is careful to limit his language by reference to meats, drinks, feast-days, and the ceremonial sabbaths of the Jews, and finally declares that all that he speaks of are a shadow of things to come. But the weekly Sabbath is not, and never was, a shadow. It was instituted before a type or a shadow could possibly exist. Gen. 2:2, 3.
So much by way of argument. Now we come to the real spirit of the article. The old charge is reiterated that we accuse every one of having the mark of the beast who observes the first day of the week, and that they are forever damned. He declares the basis of our work to be that the “day of mercy was shut in 1841, and there is no such thing as repentance and forgiveness.” This is the first we ever heard of the “day of mercy being shut in 1841”!
We must certainly be a consistent set of beings to go forth preaching repentance, and exhorting men to seek the Saviour and be converted, if there is no salvation for any. “If it shall be denied,” he says, “that the shut-door theory is the basis on which that structure was reared up, there are plenty of witnesses yet living who will attest to it.” We remember that the enemies of Christ found witnesses to testify against him, but unfortunately their testimony did not agree. Our experience has shown us that like witnesses can be found to-day, and they fall into the same difficulty. But he adds, “And if the ten thousand dollars’ worth of Ellen White’s works are fairly published, they will attest the fact.” The facts respecting her work are, that by her views the error into which some were falling in reference to the shut-door was corrected.
As regards the mark of the beast, those who have cared to become honestly acquainted with all or any of our teachings, well understand what we have uniformly claimed and proved; namely, that the third message warns us in reference to an issue yet future; that the mark of the beast cannot be received in the sense of the prophecy until certain conditions shall exist; and these are that a human institution shall, by the law of the land, be enforced in opposition to an institution established by the law of God; and understanding this issue, men make their decision. Then they receive the mark of the beast or the seal of God, accordingly as they bow to the authority of man or that of Jehovah.
Would it not be consistent indeed for a message to be given warning men not to receive the mark if indeed all men already had it? Does Eld. L. regard the whole body of S. D. Adventists as a company of hopeless idiots?
With one more precious morsel from the pen of Eld. L., we will relieve the patience of the reader. He says, “But the most brazen-faced audacity in the whole matter is that they should go through the land teaching and insisting on the extinction of the wicked.” What makes this quotation especially interesting is that the Restitution, published in Plymouth, Ind., copies the whole article of Eld. Litch’s, this last quotation included. But the Restitution stands with us on the doctrine of the destruction of the wicked. Nevertheless, it is willing to take this blow in the face from the fist of Eld. L. for the sake of trying to help Eld. L. do some damage to the Sabbath. The old spectacle of Pilate and Herod making friends was strange enough; but that Herod should, as in this case, be willing to receive a kick from Pilate and yet maintain his friendship is more astonishing still!