Explanation.
We do not care generally to occupy the attention of the readers of the REVIEW with references to the unfairness which the truth frequently suffers at the hands of its opponents. But when silence is misinterpreted, and truth is placed in a false light and its defenders are misjudged, a word of explanation becomes necessary.
Our readers will remember that some time ago, Eld. Barnes, of Salem, Mass., published in the World's Crisis an article against the Sabbath, to which a reply was given in the REVIEW. To this a reply was addressed to the REVIEW by Eld. Barnes, which we agreed to insert, provided the Crisis would publish our response. To this that paper consented; and the articles accordingly appeared in the REVIEW of Jan. 11, 1881, and in the Crisis a few weeks later.
To the article in the REVIEW Eld. B. published a reply in the Crisis, introduced with language which was evidently designed to court further discussion, and virtually amounted to a challenge to us to continue the investigation. With this we were well pleased, provided a fair hearing could be secured. Hence, as soon as other duties permitted, we addressed a note to Eld. B., asking if a reply to his article would be admitted into the Crisis, requesting that it be so given, promising on our part, in case this proposition was accepted, to insert his article in the REVIEW. This proposition the Crisis flatly declined, on the ground that the question had been sufficiently canvassed in its columns, though we notice that it does not hesitate still to admit article after article of the merest flatulency on its side of the question. Here for the time being we dropped the matter, as it was the readers of the Crisis we wished to reach, and we were denied access to them.
But now a friend writes asking why we did not replyp. 73 to the challenge of Mr. Barnes, and intimating that perhaps we dare not go on with the discussion, or that we have met with an argument we cannot answer. Thus the course of the Crisis causes us to be misjudged in this matter; for had that paper announced that we had proposed to respond to the challenge, but that it had decided to shut out further discussion, the facts would have been known, and we should not have been misjudged by its readers.
Of course the Crisis has a right to decide with what matter its columns shall be filled. But we submit to any candid umpire whether it is just fair to admit into its columns a virtual challenge to the investigation of a question, and then close its columns to the party so challenged; in other words, whether it is the most manly and honorable course for a person safely ensconced behind the ramparts, to challenge another to a personal trial of strength, and then refuse him admittance into the fortress where such meeting can be had.
The object of a discussion, as we look at it, is to place the views of both sides before those on the opposite side. But a so-called discussion of a question which brings the proof for the affirmative before those only who believe in the affirmative, and the arguments for the negative before those only who are already established in the negative, is the most transparent puerility. So Mr. B. might go on ad infinitum opposing the Sabbath before those who are already unanimous in rejecting it, and we arguing in its favor before those who are already established in its favor, and scarcely one point which it is the object of a discussion to secure, would be gained.
We are willing to admit any and all first-day and no-day arguments to any number of Sabbath-keepers, provided we can have fair access to just the same number of non-Sabbath-keepers; for we have the fullest confidence that, when a person has once become acquainted with the evidence, and is established in the glorious and Heaven-ordained truth of the Sabbath, no amount of opposing argument would any more shake him, than a storm of thistledown would overturn Gibraltar. Our opponents evidently have not this confidence in the strength of their position, and hence wish to keep from their readers as much as possible of the evidence on the other side.
The question at issue in the articles above referred to, was, whether or not Moses, in Gen. 2:2, 3, introduced into the narrative of the events of creation the record of another act which did not take place for 2500 years afterward, namely, the sanctification of the Sabbath, without intimating any such change in the record. Mr. B. claims that he did, on the ground that Genesis was not written till after the ten commandments had been spoken from Mt. Sinai. This is the foundation and main support of Mr. B.'s theory. This he takes for granted; but this we designed next to show was the sheerest assumption, conclusive evidence being at hand to prove that Gen. 2:2, 3, was written long before the law was proclaimed from Sinai. This being established, that whole theory, which certainly is not complimentary to either the candor or intelligence of those who originated it, is simply a tub without a bottom. On this point we may ere long prepare an article for the REVIEW, if time for this purpose can be gained from more pressing duties.