How much of a minister’s preaching should be doctrinal and how much practical, is a question which is always coming up, and probably always will come up, as even honest, devoted men will look at things from different standpoints. But it is certain that the Bible always insists upon sound doctrine, urges that it shall be studied, preached, and believed. Take a few quotations at random.
“Beware . . . of the doctrine of the Pharisees.” Matt. 16:12. “Ye have filled Jerusalem with your doctrine.” Acts 5:28. This was what the apostles did as their very first work. They preached doctrine, and it succeeded grandly. “Ye have obeyed from the heart that form of doctrine which was delivered you.” Rom. 6:17. For this he commends them. “Now I beseech you, brethren, mark them which cause divisions and offenses contrary to the doctrine which ye have learned, and avoid them.” Rom. 16:17. Charge them “that they teach no other doctrine.” 1 Tim. 1:3. “Till I come, give attendance to reading, to exhortation, to doctrine.” 1 Tim. 4:13.
Again he tells them that the Holy Scriptures are profitable for doctrine. 2 Tim. 3:16. And again he says, “Exhort with all long-suffering and doctrine.” 2 Tim. 4:2. “In doctrine showing uncorruptness.” Titus 2:7. “By sound doctrine both to exhort and convince the gainsayers.” Titus 1:9. And John says, “If there come any unto you, and bring not this doctrine, receive him not into your house, neither bid him God speed.” 2 John 10.
All these quotations show the importance which the Bible attaches to holding and teaching sound doctrine. The reason is that error in doctrine is sure to result in error in practice. This is a point which should not be overlooked. What causes the great diversity in practice in different churches? Plainly, it generally results from the difference in their doctrines. They believe differently, and therefore they practice differently. What is the difference between a Mohammedan and a Christian? Evidently the difference lies in their doctrine. Each one practices according to the doctrine he holds. What is the difference between a Unitarian and a Methodist? A Mormon and a Baptist? The difference is great, but it results from difference in doctrine. From this we can see the great importance of preaching sound doctrine.
Moreover, it is a fact that no healthy, permanent reformation was ever wrought without preaching positive and clear-cut doctrine. Look at the reformation wrought by Moses. His whole work was to propagate and establish a clearly-defined doctrine in direct opposition to the theories of all nations around him. Behold the success and stability of his work. So of Jesus and his apostles. The grand burden of their lives was to establish a doctrine, and they unhesitatingly condemned those who did not receive and believe it. Luther, and Wesley, and Miller, and all others who have ever accomplished any permanent work, have preached a clearly-defined doctrine.
Those who have largely ignored doctrine, and have preached only practical religion, have had only a local and temporary success. Mr. George Whitefield is an example of this. His preaching was excellent and did vast good; but having no system, and working with no organization, his work closed with his death; while that of his fellow-laborer, Wesley, has gone on increasing until to-day. Mr. Moody is another example of laxity in doctrine, and it is plain to be seen that his influence can only be local and temporary.
Why have Seventh-day Adventists succeeded so much better in the Sabbath reform than the Seventh-day Baptists? Simply because they have made it a radical part of their doctrine, and have preached it uncompromisingly. The life and denominational success of any people depends upon the positive, aggressive manner in which they hold and preach their doctrine. When they cease to do this, unless they have become old, numerous, and powerful, they will cease to grow.
But yet there is another side to this question, as well as to all others. There is great danger of merely loving the theory, and being zealous for the idea, without having the heart and life purified and sanctified by it. Thus the Jews were very zealous for their doctrines and their temporal worship, while they were entire strangers to God, and devoid of love to their fellow-men. The Lord accuses them of saying, “The temple of the Lord, the temple of the Lord, the temple of the Lord, are these,” Jer. 7:4, while they cared neither for God nor for the poor. And so Paul says that while they have “the form of knowledge and of the truth in the law,” Rom. 2:20, they “hold the truth in unrighteousness.” Rom. 1:18. And of certain dead churches he says, “Having a form of godliness, but denying the power thereof.” 2 Tim. 3:5.
We often see churches in this condition. They are very zealous for “our doctrine and our church.” For this they will contend, for this they will sacrifice, and for this they will work. Yet it is evident that the love of God is not in them. Look at the Free Masons. You will often find them just as full of zeal for their society as the most devoted Christian is for Christ; but it is only a party zeal; and the same is in many cases true of church-members. They think they have a great zeal for God and perishing souls. And so Jehu thought when he said, “See my zeal for the Lord.” 2 Kings 10:16. Yet the prophet adds, “But Jehu took no heed to walk in the law of the Lord.” Verse 31. So men deceive themselves by their zeal for a theory, for a church, or for a cause, thinking that this is the love of God; when the fact is they are bigoted in their ideas and wholly selfish in their affections.
Men may love the truth without loving the God of truth. They may love a doctrine enthusiastically without receiving the grace which that doctrine is designed to bring to them. The whole aim of the Bible and all its grand doctrines, is to lead men to warmly, affectionately, and devotedly love God himself, and our Lord Jesus Christ. Paul says, “If any man love not the Lord Jesus Christ, let him be Anathema,” that is, let him be accursed. 1 Cor. 16:22. This, then, is the object which a faithful minister must always keep prominently in view. Whatever else he may accomplish, if he fails in leading men to love Christ personally, his work is a failure. He may get them to love his doctrine, to be zealous for his church, and devoted to the cause. They may join the church, and freely use their means in the work; they may outwardly observe all the forms of religion; yet all this will be in vain if the tender affections of the soul are not thereby given to the Lord. Hence the Saviour’s grand summary of man’s duty, “Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy strength, and with all thy mind; and thy neighbor as thyself.” Luke 10:27. But this is just what, above all things, the carnal heart is not disposed to do.
Hence the minister must always be on his guard, or his labor will only build up hay, wood, and stubble. Simplicity will be lost sight of. It has always been found comparatively easy to propagate a doctrine and build up a society. Almost anybody can do that. These abound on every hand,—the land is full of them. But to convert men to God, to lead them to live a life of purity, holiness, and devotion, is quite another thing. Here is where the failure generally comes. And it is where we shall fail, as well as all others, if we do not watch closely. Therefore we say that earnest, close, practical preaching, such as will reach the motives of the heart, and test them on every side by the word of God, must be constantly, thoroughly interspersed with all our doctrinal preaching. Particularly is this the case after a church has first been thoroughly instructed in the doctrine. Sound doctrine may appropriately be compared to the bones in the human body, and practical religion to the flesh covering these bones. The bones give it shape and strength. Without these, all else would be useless. But bones alone would only be a lifeless skeleton. It is the flesh and blood that give symmetry, beauty, and life to the person. So doctrine alone is but a skeleton; while practical, heartfelt, emotional religion must be built upon this to give it life, beauty, and efficiency.
D. M. Canright.