AdventAI

THE FATHERS.

By H. Wren

From Review and Herald, Vol. 58, No. 6., August 2, 1881

BY H. WREN.

In the great controversy now going on in the United States and Europe on the Sabbath question, the writings of the Fathers are often brought forward to substantiate the position of those who maintain that the first day of the week is the Sabbath, or Lord’s day. It is claimed in behalf of the Fathers that they are competent and trustworthy witnesses in the case, because they lived near the times of the apostles, and must therefore have received first-day observance from them.

It is the object of this article to lay before the reader, in a brief manner, what the Fathers really did say on this subject and some others having a bearing on the question, along with the estimation in which they have been held by the best Protestant writers, in order that a fair and just conclusion can be arrived at as to the amount of influence which should be allowed their writings in deciding the question at issue.

By the term Fathers is meant all those theological and ecclesiastical writers who lived between the close of the apostolic age and the middle of the fourth century. We shall only notice the more prominent ones, however, of those who are appealed to in the Sabbath controversy. And we shall begin with

BARNABAS.

In regard to this writer, two things are claimed; first, that he held to the observance of the first day of the week; and second, that he is the same Barnabas who was Paul’s companion, mentioned in Acts 4:36, and numerous other places in the New Testament. Let us see just what he said. Here it is:—

“We observe the eighth day with gladness, in which Jesus arose from the dead, and, having manifested himself to his disciples, ascended into Heaven.”

Here Barnabas simply says that they observed the day in which Christ arose from the dead, but does not give his reasons for so doing. He does not say that Christ or any apostle required it of them. In the sentence preceding the one just quoted, he does assign as the reason of this observance that, “the Sabbaths, says he [the Lord], which you now keep are not acceptable to me; but those which I have made when resting from all things. I shall begin the eighth day—that is the beginning of the other world—for which cause we observe the eighth day on which Christ arose,” etc. It will be noticed that Barnabas, in the above, professes to be quoting Scripture. But there is no such passage in the Bible. The passage he had in mind was probably Isa. 1:13, which says that God had become “weary of their new moons and sabbaths, and the calling of assemblies.” All the rest is the word of Barnabas, and not of the Lord. The Bible says, “Add thou not unto his words;” yet Barnabas does not hesitate to palm off a lot of nonsense as the word of the Lord.

What does this show in regard to this writer? It proves that, in his estimation, his cause was such that it could not be maintained without perverting and falsifying the word of God; and that he does not hesitate to pervert and falsify that word to make out his case. The whole matter may be fairly regarded as a confession by this writer that the cause of first-day observance could not be sustained by correctly quoting the Bible. And the above is the only reason he gives. If Christ and the apostles had given authority to substitute Sunday in place of the Sabbath, why did not Barnabas refer to that authority? If they had authorized any change of the Sabbath, would not this writer have been likely to know it? The reader will find what is above quoted in the “Epistle of Barnabas,” chapter 13, section 10.

We will now show in what estimation this Barnabas has been held by the best Protestants, whether he is the Barnabas of the New Testament, and what is the general character of his writings. The Encyclopedia of Religious Knowledge, under the head, “Epistle of Barnabas,” says that “that epistle is full of forced analogies, extravagant and unwarrantable explications of Scripture, together with stories respecting beasts and such like conceits.” One of the stories about beasts is about the hyena, and he says of it that it “changes its kind every year, and is sometimes male and sometimes female.” Coleman, in his Ancient Christianity, chap. 2, sec. 2, says that this epistle “abounds in fabulous narratives, . . . fanciful conceits, and is generally regarded by the learned to be of no authority.” Mosheim says he was a man of “mean abilities, and a very different person from the true Barnabas who was Paul’s companion.”—Eccl. Hist., Cent. 1, part 2, chap. 2, sec. 21.

Neander says: “It is impossible that we should acknowledge this epistle to belong to that Barnabas who was worthy to be the companion of Paul.”—Rose’s Neander, p. 407. Kitto, in the Encyclopedia of Biblical Literature, article “Lord’s Day,” says, “The so-called Epistle of Barnabas was probably a forgery.” Domville says, “It was not written by Barnabas. It would be a disgrace to him, and to the Christian religion.” So much for this Barnabas, and the claim of his inspiration. And yet he is one of the main supports to the argument for first-day observance! We now refer briefly to

PLINY.

Pliny is not a “Father,” but was a governor of a Roman province, and his office required him to punish Christians. He says, in a letter to the Emperor, that the Christians “affirmed that the whole of their guilt or error was that they met on a stated day before it was light, and addressed themselves in a form of prayer to Christ.” This is generally quoted as if Pliny said they met on the first day of the week; but he says on a “stated day,” which may just as well have been the seventh as the first day. One Sunday-keeping author says: “It is just as probable that this was the seventh day as that it was the first; as the Sabbath appears to have been quite as commonly observed (if not more so) at this date as the sun’s day.” Is it not a little like begging the question to assume that Pliny meant first day when he said “stated day”? But this must be done, or there is nothing in Pliny’s letter to favor first-day observance. We next take up

IGNATIUS.

This writer is generally quoted as follows: “No longer observing Sabbaths, but keeping the Lord’s day.” In regard to this, it may be said that in the original it is not keeping the Lord’s day, but “living according to the Lord’s life.” This is what Kitto says in the Encyclopedia of Biblical Literature, article “Lord’s Day,” pages 206, 207. But no matter what may be said in the “Epistle of Ignatius to the Magnesians,” from which the above is claimed to be taken, since the whole epistle is a forgery.

Dr. Killen says: “In the fifteenth century, fifteen letters were brought out from beneath the mantle of hoary antiquity and offered to the world as the productions of the pastor of Antioch [Ignatius]. Scholars refused to receive them on the terms required, and forthwith eight of them were admitted to be forgeries. In the seventeenth century the seven remaining letters, in a somewhat altered form, again came forth from obscurity, and claimed to be the works of Ignatius. Again discerning critics refused to acknowledge their pretensions.” See “Ancient Church,” pages 413, 414. The same writer says, in another place, that it is “no mean proof of the sagacity of the great Calvin that upward of three hundred years ago he pronounced a sweeping sentence of condemnation on these Ignatian epistles.” Professor Hudson, however, thinks that three of them are genuine; but that from which the above is professed to be taken is not includedp. 82 among them. There is no other passage in the so-called letters of Ignatius that makes any reference to the first day of the week as a day to be observed. We next notice

CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.

He says: “And the Lord’s day Plato speaks of in the tenth book of the Republic, in these words: ‘And when seven days are passed to each of them in the meadow, on the eighth they are to set out and arrive in four days.’ By the meadow is to be understood the fixed sphere, as being a mild and genial spot, and the locality of the pious; and by the seven days, each motion of the seven planets, and the whole practical art which speeds to the end of rest.” See “Miscellanies of Clement,” book v., chap. 14. Clement, instead of perverting and falsifying the word of God, as we have seen that Barnabas did, appeals to Plato. And who is Plato? Is he a prophet or an apostle? Was he an inspired writer? Oh, no. Plato was the great heathen philosopher of Greece. Are we to exchange the Bible, with its clear and sublime language, for Plato and such stuff as the above? Clement’s appeal to Plato is a good confession that he could do no better. This same Clement quotes Plato as saying, in another place, that “the seventh day is sacred;” which is what the Bible says also. Clement, also, has expressed himself in regard to the seventh day. In book vi. and chapter 16 of his writings, is this language: “And the fourth word [commandment] is that which intimates that the world was created by God, and that he gave us the seventh day as a rest. . . . But we who bear flesh need rest. The seventh day, therefore, is proclaimed a rest. From this day the first wisdom and knowledge illuminated us.” More might be given from this writer to show that the seventh day was prized by him much more than the first. We now come to

JUSTIN MARTYR.

He is appealed to with great confidence. He says: “On the day called Sunday, all who live in cities or in the country gather together to one place, and the memoirs of the apostles and the writings of the prophets are read as long as time permits.”—Apology, chapter 67. This passage is generally quoted as if he said Lord’s day, and not Sunday. Justin nowhere calls Sunday the Sabbath or Lord’s day. In the same chapter just quoted, he says: “When our prayer is ended, bread and water and wine are brought, and there is a distribution to each, and a participation of that over which thanks have been given; and to those who are absent a portion is sent by the deacons.” He here says they used water in the sacrament as well as bread and wine, and that a portion was sent to the absent. Where in the word of God is there authority for these things? There is none. They are changes that men had made in Christ’s ordinance; and Justin’s reference to them as being done in their religious meetings shows that he and those whom he represented had begun to depart from the word of God, and establish customs not authorized by that word. Perhaps their meeting on Sunday was another custom of their own invention. It certainly was, and there is nothing in the word of God requiring it.

Socrates, a writer of the fifth century, says: “Almost all churches throughout the world celebrate the sacred mysteries on the Sabbath of every week; yet the Christians of Alexandria and Rome, on account of some ancient tradition, refuse to do this.” This shows that there was a tradition at Rome and Alexandria which caused them to meet on Sunday and receive the sacrament of the Lord’s supper. Now, Justin wrote his apology at Rome; and, moreover, it was Rome and Alexandria that led off in the work of corrupting the truth of the Bible, and in developing all those traditionary customs and doctrines that afterward constituted the Roman Catholic apostasy. Before Justin gets through, he gives some of his reasons for these Sunday meetings. He says: “But Sunday is the day on which we all hold our common assembly, because it is the first on which God, having wrought a change in the darkness and matter, made the world; and Jesus Christ our Saviour on the same day rose from the dead.” The first of these reasons is directly against the word of God, which tells us to observe, not the day on which he began the work of creation, but the day after he had finished that work. The second reason is wholly without authority from the Bible. Where in the word of God are men authorized to use the resurrection of our Saviour to overthrow the Sabbath and establish first-day observance in its place? There is no such authority, and is it not rather daring to venture upon such a work?

IRENÆUS.

Irenæus was one of the principal Fathers, and it is alleged that he used this language: “On the Lord’s day every one of us keeps the Christian Sabbath.”—Justin Edwards, in “Sabbath Manual,” p. 114. “Every word of this pretended testimony of Irenæus is a fraud.”—J. N. Andrews, in “History of Sabbath,” p. 217. In a collection, known as the Lost Writings of Irenæus, he is represented as saying, “We should not kneel upon Easter day;” and he, or the compiler, says that “Easter is of equal significance with the Lord’s day.” This shows that, if this language were that of Irenæus, he held that Easter was equal to Sunday. There is no Bible requiring the observance of Easter, and Irenæus does not claim that there is any requiring the observance of Sunday. If he had thought there was, he would not have said that the human institution of Easter was equal to it. Irenæus speaks of the Sabbath in this way: “Upon the seventh day, which has been sanctified, in which God rested from all the works which he created, which is the true Sabbath of the righteous, in which they shall not be engaged in any earthly occupation.”—Book v. chap. 23, sec. 3. Speaking of the ten commandments, he says: “They remain permanently with us, receiving, by means of his advent in the flesh, extension and increase, but not abrogation.”—Book iv., chap. 16, sec. 4. More might be given from this writer to show that he thought much more of the commandments of God than some do at this day. But we pass to

DIONYSIUS.

Dionysius says: “We passed the holy Lord’s day, in which we read your letter,” etc. (letter to the Roman church.) He does not use any language to enable us to determine whether he means by Lord’s day the first day or seventh day of the week. He says “holy Lord’s day,” an expression very unusual among the Fathers when speaking of Sunday, and it is more than likely he means the Sabbath; for the Lord says in the 58th chapter of Isaiah, that the Sabbath is “my holy day.” The Sabbath, then, is the holy Lord’s day; and if Dionysius applies this term to Sunday, we should be glad to know where in the word of God he gets the right to do so.

(Concluded next week.)