AdventAI

A Lutheran View.

By Editor

From Review and Herald, Vol. 57, No. 8., February 22, 1881

The question whether the first day of the week as a day of rest is a divine institution or only a human ordinance, is a vital one in the present Sunday movement. No merely human ordinance can secure any hold upon the consciences of the people; and no Sabbath will, or can, be of any account, which is not able to take hold upon the conscience. Hence the necessity of showing that first-day observance rests upon divine authority,—a necessity keenly felt by those who are trying to secure a better regard for that day.

It seems that in the Lutheran Theological Seminary at Gettysburg, a recent course of lectures has given support to the opposite view; that is, that Sunday-keeping rests wholly on ecclesiastical or human authority. Whereupon M. Valentine, D. D., president of the Pennsylvania College, comes to the rescue to show that Sunday is a divine ordinance, in an article in the Lutheran Quarterly for January, 1881.

What especially interests us in his remarks is the unqualified manner in which he commits himself to the position that the whole Sunday movement is destined to prove an utter failure from a moral standpoint, unless the institution itself is sanctioned by the divine law. This he does in the following language:—

“A mere holiday, as the chief receptacle for the dissipation, abandon, and licentiousness of the week, will not answer. And nothing can be more certain than that the maintenance of our Christian Sabbath, with its true blessings, will depend upon our recognition of it as a law of God for all the world. Once let the truth of its divine character fall out of the Christian conscience and the public conscience of our land, and no human laws will be strong enough to withstand the powers of Sabbath desecration. The civil laws for its quiet will soon be swept from the statute book, or be as if they were not. No mere church day, or ‘human ordinance’ of ecclesiastical origin can hold the consciences of men or command their respect. Disbelief of the divine authority of the day lies at the bottom of much of its present desecration. Only when men shall clearly recognize upon it the stamp of God’s own commandment for all the race, will it be rightly esteemed and observed.”

And right here, as we have said repeatedly, is the fatally “weak spot” in the Sunday cause; for it is a “mere church day,” it is only of “ecclesiastical origin,” it is only a “human ordinance,” and hence can never command the respect of the people from a moral point of view. President Valentine seems not to have been aware of this fact. And we predict that when he shall come to apprehend it, he will change his position, as others in like circumstances have already done, and are doing. And as Sunday has no divine law, just in proportion as it lacks this divine sanction, it must have a human law more strict and rigid.