AdventAI

“SEVENTH-DAY SABBATARIANS AND NEANDER.”

By Roswell F. Cottrell

From Review and Herald, Vol. 57, No. 8., February 22, 1881

The above is the heading of an article in the New York Evangelist of Jan. 6, 1881. The writer calls in question the honesty of our teachers who quote the assertion of Neander that the “festival of Sunday, like all other festivals, was always only a human ordinance.” He admits, however, that “the passage is correctly copied.” In what, then, consists the unfairness or dishonesty of quoting it? Because seventeen years afterward Neander “recast the first volume,” and left this out. This is true; but does the fact that he omitted it in the later edition prove that it was not true? Certainly not. Does Neander say it was false? No; it is simply omitted.

Neander still ascribes the change of the day to “opposition to Judaism.” He refers to Acts 20:7 as “the first indication of this change.” He also refers to Rev. 1:10, in a doubtful way, thus: “By the ‘Lord’s day’ can hardly be understood the day of Judgment.” He then very safely refers to “the catholic epistle ascribed to Barnabas” as proof. Yes, ascribed to Barnabas! “And in the Epistle of Ignatius to the Magnesians,” says he, “it is presupposed that even the Jews who had come over to Christianity substituted Sunday in the place of the Sabbath. A spurious, or forged epistle, presupposes a thing for which there is not the slightest evidence!

Now does not the editor of the Evangelist know the truth in regard to these spurious epistles? If he does, why does he reproduce their testimony from Neander? Would it not be better to prove, if he can, that Neander’s assertion that the Sunday festival “was always only a human ordinance” is false? Who will disprove the assertion?

R. F. COTTRELL.