AdventAI

INFIDELITY VS. FIGURES.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 57, No. 3., January 18, 1881

The old assertion that so many billions of human beings have lived on the earth that they could not find standing-room in case of a general resurrection, continues to be foolishly maintained in some quarters. It seems from the following article quoted from the N. Y. Journal of Commerce, that a man who tacks “Rev.” to his name, recently stood before an audience in Music Hall, Boston, and presented the same absurdity as an objection to the doctrine of a future general Judgment. The article deals well with the man and his position, and we leave the reader to its perusal:—

Figures do not lie. It is a great pity that so many men talk at random in books, reviews, and public lectures, when they should learn wisdom from school boys’ arithmetic. A lecturer in Music Hall, Boston, on a recent Sunday evening—the Rev. Mr. Murray—is reported as dealing in glittering generalities of figures to disprove the theory of a final Judgment of all men, and it would appear that his audience accepted his arithmetic as solid truth. We have nothing to do with his theories of the Judgment, but there ought to be a judgment and condemnation in Boston of any man who delivers such trash to an audience having ordinary common-school education. He is reported to have spoken thus:—

“Now the population of the earth is 1,000,000,000, and a generation dies every thirty years. In every thirty years, then, 1,000,000,000 of human beings go out of the world and 1,000,000,000 come in. Forty years ago the church taught that the world was 6,000 years old. She does n't to-day pretend to guess within 100,000 years how old the world is. Very well. What has been the population of the world since the race began? Who can estimate the number? By what arithmetic shall you compute the swarming millions? Take the globe, and flatten it into a vast plain, 24,000 miles by 24, and it would accommodate but a fraction of the human beings that have lived upon its surface. Where is the locality of the Judgment to be, then? Can it have a locality?”

Now make the wildest conceivable estimates. Suppose that the human race has existed on this earth 100,000 years, and that the population has never, from the first day, been smaller than this estimate for the present time; namely, 1,000,000,000. For the sake of easy calculation, instead of the estimate of thirty years to a generation call it three generations to a century. There will then appear to have been 3,000 generations of 1,000,000,000 each, who, being assembled, require standing room. For a crowded meeting of men, women, and children, it would be ample estimate to give each two square feet of room. A square mile contains, in round numbers, 25,000,000 square feet, and 12,500,000 persons could stand on it. Therefore eighty square miles would hold a generation, and three thousand times that space would hold the population of a hundred thousand years. That is to say, 240,000 square miles would contain them, and, gathered in a parallelogram, they could stand in a space six hundred miles long by four hundred broad. They could be easily accommodated in one or two of our States.

Dead, and buried side by side, they would require only five times their standing space, or (say) 1,200,000 square miles, and the United States of America has ample wild lands, as yet unwanted and unoccupied, to give them a cemetery. If any one wishes, he may estimate how many thousand years of generations could find graves in this country without crowding one another.

Whoever will, may imagine the population assembled in a circle, or in a vast theater with floor above floor, each floor diminishing the surface area of the building. It will do people of vivid imagination good to reduce such imaginations to the facts of figures, and any school girl can do it.

But it is just as well, before leaving the subject, to say that the hundred thousand years of the reverend lecturer’s imagination is as wild talk as his figures. Men of uncertain faith are very fond of saying that other men have no faith. Nothing can be more absurd than what he says about the church. The confused man who fell off a stage-coach into the mud thought the coach had upset. Mr. Murray will soon find out that the church, whatever its denominational name, is a great deal more steady in its ancient faith than are he and others who would gladly convince outsiders that the old coach has actually gone over.

In his lecture, as reported, he makes a sad jumble of two distinct subjects,—the age of the world and the age of the human race on its surface. The men who hold notions about the extreme antiquity of the human race have been very few, and have produced no sensible effect on the faith of the church or the general opinion of the world; and among what are called scientists, the present difference of opinion as to the age of the human race is limited to a comparatively short period. Bunsen’s theory of a date B. C. 20,000 for Egyptian origins has vanished, and Maziette Bey’s date of B. C. 5,000 for Menes (or Misraim) will satisfy the views of the most extreme among recognized men of sense.

The bone-cave men have met with the simple rules of evidence, which apply to their supposed discoveries as they apply to all questions of fact; and it is found that they have not proved, in a single instance, that human bones have been lying fifty, forty, or even ten centuries in those caves. The theory that the Mississippi had been 40,000 years depositing drift over human bones found in the deposit, disappeared in mist when Humphreys and Abbot, United States Engineer officers on duty, having no theory to sustain, accurately observed and satisfactorily determined that the entire Delta of the Mississippi has required only 4,000 years for its total deposit. It is no longer a question of religion against science,p. 36 but a case in which common sense and a knowledge of the laws of evidence are demanding something more than assertion without proof, asking for facts in distinction from theory. On the whole, it has become the fashion to laugh a little at the fantastic theories of science falsely so called.

Meantime, none of these theories have produced any sensible effect upon the church or its teachings. There are just as many good people and just as many great intellectual people as ever who still believe and teach that the human race is about six thousand years old, and that a deluge has once reduced its population to next to nothing. Faith in the old record of Moses is so prevalent, and there are so many millions of educated and reasonable people holding it, that it is really worth the while of boys and girls, and perhaps of some adults, to apply arithmetic to the facts as accepted by these good people of old and modern times. Thus in 6,000 years there are 180 generations, and as we know something by historic evidence of the sparse populations of former times in some parts of the world, and must make allowance for the deluge (which all nations believe to have occurred), we shall be more than safe in estimating one-half the present population as the average in all past generations. Thus one hundred and eighty generations each of 500,000,000 give us 90,000,000,000 for the whole human race. Graves of ten square feet for each would be easily found in each of quite a number of the States in the Union, and this assembly of all the generations of mankind could stand in a circle around Mount Blanc, Mount Washington, or Mount Sinai, so near that every eye could see the summit fifty miles distant.