The following article in relation to the late convention of the National Reform Association held in Syracuse, N. Y., was written by Eld. E. W. Whitney, and published in the Sunday Herald of that city, in its issue of Dec. 12, 1880. The subject itself, and the fact that it has been laid before the numerous readers of the Herald, will give it interest to the friends of the REVIEW:—
SUNDAY OBSERVANCE; SOME THOUGHTS FOR THOSE ENGAGED IN THE WORK OF THE NATIONAL REFORM ASSOCIATION; THE UNION OF CHURCH AND STATE DISCUSSED.
While attending the Convention of the National Reform Association recently held in your city, some questions were naturally suggested by the remarks of the different speakers, which seem to me to be worthy of careful consideration by all who feel any interest in this movement, either pro or con.
We were told repeatedly that the principal object the organization had in view was the securing of such an amendment to the Constitution of the United States as shall place “all Christian laws and usages upon an undeniable legal basis in the fundamental law of the land,” an expression used in the Constitution of the Association. At the same time it was emphatically stated that they were not seeking for a “union of church and state.” (?) If the former expression does not virtually imply the latter, who will tell us what it does mean? It may be replied that no one thinks of establishing a national church, or making any particular form of Christianity the religion or creed of the nation. We answer, This is not necessary to a virtual union of church and state, any more than the adoption of precisely the same constitution by the different States and the nation is necessary to a union of States. The different states, though distinct and separate, unite under the general, or fundamental, law to form a political union, or the “State.” The professed Christian churches, though distinct and separate, may unite on points of faith and “usages” common to all, and so form an ecclesiastical union, or the “Church.” Now when this ecclesiastical union, or church, shall have secured a recognition of these common points of faith and practice in “the fundamental law” of the political union, or “State,” with power to enforce them upon the people, we ask, What will be wanting to constitute it, in all essential respects, a union of church and state? We can see nothing.
We now inquire if these are not precisely the steps which those engaged in this movement are laboring to have taken. If we can understand aright, they are. Whatever may be our religious predilections, are we prepared, as a liberty-loving people, to favor a move which in its results will bring us so near an approach (to say the least) to a union of church and state, with its consequent ostracism and persecution?
When once this subject is considered thoughtfully, a series of grave questions at once urge themselves upon our attention. Not least among these is one which was brought before the late convention, i. e., How is this to affect the Jew? Of course one of the most important results hoped for by the friends of this movement, is the universal observance of Sunday, the first day of the week. This observance, too, must be enforced, regardless of conscientious scruples, if it really amounts to anything; because as soon as an exception is made upon this ground, the whole question of Sabbath observance becomes as much an open question as it is now. It is not difficult, then, to understand how it will affect the Jews, who observe Saturday, the seventh day of the week. They will either be compelled to observe two days, or change their observance from the seventh to the first. We give their own answer to this question: “The world is wide, and if they are not pleased to remain with us, they are at liberty to go. This is not a Jewish, but a Christian nation.”
But this is not by any means the most vexed question that presents itself for solution. If we are to have the observance of a day forced upon us by the law of the land, which day of the week ought to be chosen for such observance, the first or the seventh? This question does not concern the Jews alone, but a respectable (if not large) portion of the law-abiding, Christian citizens of the United States, whose rights are just as sacred as those of other people, whether Jews or Christians; and they ought at least to receive a satisfactory answer to the foregoing question before a measure is adopted which would restrict their rights or violate their consciences.
There are in the United States at the present time between thirty and forty thousand conscientious Christian people who already bear a heavy cross in observing strictly the seventh day of the week, or Saturday, because on it God rested and afterward blessed and sanctified it, and then commanded it to be kept holy. What is to be done in their cases? If to this it be answered, that they ought to observe the first day of the week, because on that day Christ arose from the dead, they reply in turn that if it can be shown from the Bible that any such observance is enjoined, or that Christ or the apostles sanctioned it by precept or example, they will cease to observe the seventh and commence the observance of the first day.
While this is not shown, but, on the other hand they find that both the Old Testament and the New are harmonious in acknowledging and teaching one Sabbath—that not one of the New Testament writers, though some of them wrote more than sixty years after Christ’s resurrection, even hint that such a change had taken place; and while a careful examination of church and secular history reveals the fact that the change was made gradually by the church, hundreds of years this side of the resurrection, it seems to be not only just, but absolutely necessary to proper action in this matter, that this question receive careful and candid investigation. If coercion must come, shall it be in the line of truth or error? What is truth? The apostle John says, “Thy word is truth.” What says the word?