A WRONG ISSUE

17%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 5, 1881

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 57, No. 14.

Read the full edition

A WRONG ISSUE.

BY N. J. BOWERS.
There are those who seem to think that because the words soul and spirit are found in the Bible, they are justified in charging the deniers of natural immortality to man with dishonesty and deception; and they think to shut the mouths of their opponents by quoting texts containing these words. Now the charge is by no means fair, nor the reply logical. We do not deny that the Bible has a great deal to say about soul and spirit, and that it uses the words a great many times. We have no disposition to make such denial, but we do deny that the conclusions reached by those who differ with us because of the occurrence of such words, are either proper or necessary. We do not deny that man has a soul, we only differ with our friends as to the nature of that soul. They say it is an entity, having the inherent capacities of continuous, endless life. This we deny. They seem to think that because the Bible speaks of soul and spirit, they are, therefore, “immortal” and “deathless.” This by no means follows. These are attributes not given them by divine inspiration. We have here a wide breach between premise and conclusion, which breach is bridged over only by human dogmatism.
The word soul, standing alone, does not define its nature, any more than the word man defines the characteristics belonging to man. We gain no more from the word alone than we do from the word man. We have no more right to assume that the soul is immortal because the word is found in the Bible, than we have that man is, because that word occurs there. We certainly cannot tell from the single term man anything about the qualities and attributes of that to which the word belongs; we cannot even know whether it is stone, plant, bird, brute, or human. That must be ascertained in some other way, and from some other source. So of soul and spirit.
Again: after having found out that man means a human being, we cannot know, from that fact alone, whether the particular human being that the word may at any time represent, is old or young; short or tall; white, black, or copper-colored; rich or poor; good or bad. We must get this additional information elsewhere than from the word alone. So of the words under notice. They cannot, of themselves, inform us of the qualities and capabilities of that which is indicated by them, whether it will live for a day or last through all eternity.
In looking at the various adjectives connected with the word soul in the Bible, we find living soul (Gen. 2:7); idle soul (Prov. 19:15); liberal soul (Prov. 11:25); thirsty soul (Prov. 25:25); hungry soul (Prov. 27:7); afflicted soul (Isa. 58:10); righteous soul (2 Pet. 2:8); and unstable souls (v. 14); but never immortal or never-dying soul. We there read of a broken and contrite spirit (Ps. 51:17); of an excellent spirit (Dan. 5:12); of a faithful spirit (Prov. 11:13); of a good spirit (Neh. 9:20); of a haughty spirit (Prov. 16:18); of a humble spirit (Prov. 16:19); of a meek and quiet spirit (1 Pet. 3:4); of a new spirit (Eze. 11:19); of a patient spirit (Eccl. 7:8); of a perverse spirit (Isa. 19:14); of a quickening spirit (1 Cor. 15:45); of a right spirit (Ps. 51:10); of a sorrowful spirit (1 Sam. 1:15); of an unclean spirit (Mark 3:30); of a wounded spirit (Prov. 18:14); but never of an immortal or deathless spirit.