AdventAI

CHURCH AND STATE.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 57, No. 24., June 14, 1881

WE give this week the concluding portion of “An American Citizen’s” address to the Hon. Felix R. Brunot. Of the Sunday movement he says:—

The success of this enterprise would destroy the public faith in the validity and truthfulness of the Scriptures relative to one of the oldest and most important institutions, acknowledged by the Association to have been designed to be observed and enjoyed by all the human family. A discussion of this subject, in all its aspects and bearings, may be confidently expected at no distant day. The Association must not only possess the knowledge that the sacredness of the Sabbath, affixed to that institution by Jehovah himself, has been transferred by him to the first day, so as to render that day, designated in the fourth command as a working day, a Sabbath, with all the sanctity attached to the original Sabbath, and the original Sabbath divested of the sanctity which it had at first by Jehovah himself, so as to become a common working and business day; but they must be able to show this so clearly that the people cannot fail to see it, or they will be regarded as “corrupters of the word of God,” rather than as reformers. Claiming to be religious reformers, and to believe in divine revelation, they must not hope to prove the first day the Sabbath by a command which enjoins the hallowing of the seventh, and asserts it to be the Sabbath of Jehovah. Too much knowledge of the Scriptures is possessed by the people to be thus deceived. They will pity and scorn all those who attempt it, whatever their position in society, and however great their numbers; and though they may apply flattering titles to one another till the alphabet is exhausted, they will fail to convince the people of the truth of their theory while they oppose the Bible. They will find the contest unequal in the controversial fight before them. They will find their best Damascus blades hacked into saws and wrested from them, when crossed by the sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God, wielded by living faith. “If God [and his word] be for us, who shall be against us?”

It may be regarded as fortunate for the country and favorable to the best interests of society that this question is precipitated on the nation at this time. People fancy they are free. An organization of high respectability has arisen, and introduced itself under the imposing claim of a reformatory combination. They have published their plans and methods of operation, and told the world what they intend to do. They possess eminent and lofty talents, and occupy influential and exalted positions. Their officers, numbering one hundred and seventy, are distributed through nearly or quite all the States, Territories, and Districts of the United States, and embrace doctors of divinity numbering ninety-nine, of law nineteen, presidents of colleges, seminaries, divinity schools, judges of United States and State courts, editors, generals of the United States army, professors, ex-governors and lieutenant-governors, mayors, chaplains, members of Congress, etc., representing every class and phase of American society, with an immensely numerous constituency, all pledged to prove their enterprise not only feasible and necessary to the public weal, but Scriptural, and suggested by the condition of morals and religion.

This organization, pledged to the support of existing Sunday laws, must be considered able to prove the first day to be the Sabbath by divine authority, if that is possible to be done; and if they fail, and fail they must—it being as impossible to prove such assumption from the Bible as to construct a double-track railroad from the earth to the moon—then, if they possess the honesty which is an essential quality in true reformers, we shall see this great array of talent, piety, and influence on the side of truth, and supporting the claims of the Sabbath of the fourth command. The world will be benefited, and Jehovah honored. If they fail to sustain the claims of the first day to be the “holy day” of Jehovah, and still pursue their practice of keeping it under pretense of its being such, they will be looked on as insincere, unworthy the places they fill, and despised by those they have sought to convert to their theory. They have bodily presented the issue to the American people that the first day is the “holy Sabbath,” instead of the original day sanctified by Jehovah; now let them sustain their position by the exhibition of divine statute, or abandon their claims and practice. To assume that they are right because others before them have so held, is as unsatisfactory as for a Mormon to attempt to sustain polygamy, because Nicholas, one of the first deacons in the Christian church, is reported to have taught the community of wives; and to procure the enactment of a law in favor of the first day, and in default of being able to sustain its claim by Scripture proof, wield that law persecutingly against sincere Sabbath-keepers, is as preposterous as for Mohammedans to present the false miracles of their pretended prophet, and if argument fails, bring the sword to induce the required faith in that fallacious and abominable system. To procure the constitutional recognition of the first day as holy time, and establish by constitutional law the creed of the Association for the nation, would be followed by dire consequences. To change our free Constitution for a sectarian document, though claiming to be Christian, would dissatisfy all except the favored sect, and might be followed by scenes as revolting as those predicted by the French poet, relating to the devastating strife in that country:—

“In this seat of peace, tumultuous wars Shall, kin with kin, and kind with kind, confound; ... Disorder, horror, fear, and mutiny shall here inhabit, And this land be called the field ‘Aceledama,’ And of dead men’s skulls.”

Having lived under a free Constitution, the people will not yield assent to one which discriminates in favor of sects, and establishes caste, favoring some sects, and placing at a disadvantage and crushing all others, “right or wrong.” It is useless to inquire, “Are the good men engaged in procuring a religious amendment to the Constitution capable of persecuting others for opinions’ sake?” Are they “dogs” that they “should do this thing?” The good Puritans could do it, when they had power. In one of the colonies they had a law, by which, if a person was found “robbing orchards” (i. e., taking fruit on Sunday), he should be punished for the first offense by having “one of his ears cut off.” For the second offense, he should lose his other ear, and for the third offense, he should “suffer death.” Since the formation of our national government, it is believed, Connecticut has not punished any one so summarily, or claimed to hold in force such cruel laws. She has been distanced in zeal for Sunday by the State erected mainly by Wm. Penn and his friends. For more than eighty years, Pennsylvania has had a law in force against a respectable class of her citizensp. 370 who keep the true Sabbath and would work on Sunday “according to the commandment;” and she enforces the law, which can hardly be obeyed without disobeying it. If the Sunday-breaker is arrested at all, he must be taken within three days after committing the “offense.” He cannot be arrested after the fourth day of the week, Wednesday. If sentenced to prison that day, he must unavoidably work both Sabbath day and first-day; for to hold him in prison more than six days would make somebody liable for false imprisonment, and might starve him “on bread and water only,” as the law runs; and if he were not “kept at hard labor” for the full term of “six days,” the law would be unsatisfied, and the jailer would be culpable. I repeat, What a law! What an illustration of Christian civilization! If such a state of things can exist in the State with the constitutional rod held over her head, what may be expected of her when free to do as she will!

It is safe to predict that Pennsylvania has imprisoned her last man who conscientiously keeps the Sabbath and works first-day, for that alleged offense. The next arrest (if there is another), the case will go up to the Supreme Court of the United States, and the unconstitutionality of the State law will be settled. The expense of such testing will not be a tithe of the amount wrung indirectly from these people each year. A gentleman, a friend of religious equality, and an officer in one of the banks in Harrisburg, last winter had the curiosity to know the amount indirectly wrung from these peoples in the last eighty-two years, reckoning one dollar a day for one-fifth of their number (a very moderate estimate) each week while the State law has prohibited labor on a day they feel bound in duty to work, and with compound interest, he found the aggregated amount to exceed two hundred millions of dollars.

To this law, the State Legislature (perhaps representing the Association’s views fully) has clung with strange tenacity for many years; but though legislators should continue recreant to duty, though courts disgrace their ermine, though ministers of the sanctuary array themselves on the side of oppression, though the judgment of the wise should be subverted, the great Author of the Sabbath lives; and in his own good time will rise and “plead his own cause,” and send headlong all wicked counsels. Meanwhile, lawmakers who allow unconstitutional laws to remain on the statute book, under their oath to support the Constitution of the country and that of the State; judges who forget the dignity of the high places they fill, and descend to the level of putrifiers; divines who sacrifice truth to party and sectarian interests, “having men’s persons in admiration because of advantage,” would be more suitable occupants of an asylum than of the halls of legislation, the forum, the bench, or the divinity chair.

Will “reformers” of the American nation stand up and say it is a step in reformation to secure a constitutional recognition of the first day as the nation’s Sabbath, when the command of Jehovah, which they admit to be imperative on all men, makes it the duty of all to use it as a working and business day? Will they say it is the holy “Sabbath,” when God says no such thing, but repeatedly and clearly asserts the contrary? Will they, in the presence of senates, in the high places of the earth, in the sanctuary of Jehovah, in the presence and in behalf of listening millions, call the first day of the week “the holy and sanctified Sabbath of the Lord,” shamelessly confronting the Holy Ghost respecting matter of fact, and offering the greatest insult to Jehovah by indirectly hurling the charge of falsehood in his face? The sin of Ananias and Sapphira may well be regarded as a peccadillo in comparison with such effrontery in this age of light. Is this inconsiderately and ignorantly done? Remember Uzzah, who, though not a priest, concerned for the safety of the ark of God, put forth his hand and touched it, and met his death on the spot! The sin of ignorance always required an atonement, while those who sinned presumptuously were deemed to suffer condignly, no atonement for their offenses being admissible under either law or gospel.

The people will look at these efforts claiming to be reformatory; and if the pretensions of the Association are not fully sustained or humbly recanted, they will render a verdict to the effect that, instead of being reformers, they are innovators, deceivers, self-seekers, and enemies to God and the right! As Israel was directed beforehand to build an altar in Canaan “of whole stones,” for, according to God’s decision, to “lift up a tool of iron on it” would be “to pollute it,” so the great chart of religious freedom must remain unpolluted by sectarian touch and modeling, or forever cease to be the palladium of religious rights. If it seems mysterious that truth has so long appeared in the persons of its defenders, clad in sackcloth, for reasons inscrutable to human minds, let it be remembered that God himself is the exponent of his own administration, and in due time will make everything plain, both to friends and mockers. If the Constitution is to be amended in the interest of sects calling themselves Christians, for the purpose of enforcing obedience to their practices, which cannot be sustained by the Bible; if instead of fining and imprisoning only, for obeying God’s commands to secularize the first day of the week, they proceed to extremities, as has been done in England and elsewhere, punishing such alleged offenses with death; if all the horrid enginery of persecution is to be put in requisition, and the post of honor to die is first assigned to observers of the Sabbath; if professed disciples of the “meek and lowly One,” who grasp after his power, must succeed and initiate such summary proceedings by divesting the Constitution of its best provisions, and sacrificing all who will not comply with their notions, till the demon is sated with martyr blood,—it is desirable that the intended victims of this anti-Christian spirit bear themselves nobly, and “glorify God in the fires.” The crown of the martyr might be preferable to the chains of the slave. May the humble, heroic firmness necessary to meet the ordeal be vouchsafed, and Jehovah and truth honored in the result.

These are not the creations of a distempered fancy, but clear foreshadowings of probable occurrences, if the sheet anchor of equality of religious rights is lost. It is safe to affirm that there is not a sect now existing in the United States to whom the advantage asked for could be safely given. While the successors of the pilgrims have every right under the Constitution, why do they demand the power to force by law all dissenters to do as they do, right or wrong? and most evidently wrong in the matter of the Sabbath. If they say they would not persecute with the advantage sought, let them abandon their efforts to obtain power to persecute, and thus avoid the temptation to do so. The persons more immediately interested would be glad to see your position more fully explained and defended, and none more so, or more willing to be convinced, if in error, than “an American citizen.”