Considerable discussion having taken place in the columns of The Church Union with regard to the observance of Sunday, or the first day of the week, as the Sabbath, in place of the seventh day, a few extracts from an interesting sermon on the subject recently preached by the Rev. H. P. Mendes, a Jewish divine, will not be out of place here. Mr. Mendes said:—
There are few among the Christian laity and few among the Jewish who are acquainted with the origin and history of the Christian Sabbath. Aided by a prominent Christian minister, who kindly furnished me authorities on the subject, I have for months past studied it, and will place before you part of the result. I am conscious that all I have to say upon it is new to you, and I fear new to the immense majority of the Christian laity. I say I fear, for I think that were the subject better known, there would be an expression of Christian opinion as loud and as fierce as any of those whose echoes ring through history from the day when Luther raised his voice against indulgences down to our era.
We are naturally curious to trace the transfer of the seventh-day, or Jewish Sabbath, to the first or Sunday-Sabbath of the Christians. We know that the Nazarene himself kept the seventh-day Sabbath. We know that the apostles kept the seventh-day; we know the Nazarene declared that he came not to destroy the law, but to fulfill it; and that not one jot or tittle of the law should pass away. When, then, did he authorize the abolition of that most emphasized and oft-repeated command of the law,—the sanctification of the seventh-day Sabbath? Ridgley, one of the authorities to which I was referred, says, “This is an over-curious inquiry,” and gives no certain information; but such an answer will not suffice for us in these days. And how could the Nazarene consistently abolish it, or give directions for its abolition, when he declared that he came not to destroy the law? And how could the apostles, fathers of the church, or any Christians, call themselves Christians, or followers of Christ, when they act in direct opposition to his sentiments by making pass away what is more than a “jot or tittle of the law”?
I find six texts usually adduced as evidence of, or reasons for, the institution of the first day, or Sunday Sabbath. But Christian opinion even is not unanimous upon them; and certainly they do seem, to say the least, most insufficient. The first text states that the Nazarene appeared to his disciples “the same day at evening, being the first day of the week;” that is, on what is now popularly known as Sunday evening. This is taken to afford grounds for a sanctification of the Sunday Sabbath. But the veriest tyro knows that the Nazarene, the apostles, all the Jews then, as all the Jews do now, reckoned the day from the evening before; hence, our Sabbath commences on what is commonly styled Friday evening. Sunday evening, therefore, when the Nazarene is said to have appeared to his disciples, belongs to and forms part of Monday. Evidently if his reappearance is the ground for the sanctification of the Christian Sabbath, they should keep Monday and not Sunday. Moreover, there is no evidence to show that this meeting with the disciples was held for the purpose of instituting a new Sabbath day. If any such importance was to be attached to it, would Matthew have been silent about the whole affair, as he is? Would not all the apostles have noted it?
The second text states that he again appeared eight days afterward. This is open to the same criticism as the other.
The third text is Acts 2:1: “And when the day of Pentecost was fully come, they were all with one accord in one place.” This text is supposed by the Christians to be another proof of the institution of the Sunday Sabbath, but they are not even certain whether Pentecost was on Sunday or not in that year. One of the authorities to which I was referred states that the day of Pentecost was always on the first day of the week. We know, but the Christian laity do not, that such a statement is absurd and false, but I give it you as a sample of their authorities. So absurd is this text that Paley passes it in silence.
The fourth text is Acts 20:7: “And upon the first day of the week, when the disciples came together to break bread, Paul preached unto them, ready to depart on the morrow, and continued his speech until midnight.” We know, but the Christian laity do not, that the phrase “breaking bread” means the taking of an ordinary meal. Calvin knew this, and gave it as his opinion. There is no evidence to show that this meeting was held on the first day of the week because it was the first day. Paul preached at any opportunity.
The fifth text is I Cor. 16:2: “Upon the first day of the week let every one of you lay by him in store, . . . that there be no gatherings when I come.” Milton rejects this as grounds for the institution of the Sunday Sabbath, remarking that the apostle enjoins not the celebration of the day, but that on the first day of the week each should lay by something for the poor, thatp. 371 the amount would be ready for the speaker when he came.
The last text is Rev. 1:10: “I was in the Spirit on the Lord’s day.” What is the day honored by such a title? The first mention, outside of the book referred to, is not to be met with, I learn, till about the year 170, or seventy years after the book was written, and occurs in a letter from Dionysius, Bishop of Corinth, to the Bishop of Rome. It does not appear either in the epistles of Clement and Barnabas, nor in the writings of Ignatius, Polycarp, Justin Martyr, and other great authorities. Tertullian uses it about the year 200. But how does the text authorize the institution of the Sunday Sabbath?
Mr. Mendes continued: To sum up, there is not a single instance in the New Testament that Sunday, in the time of the apostles, was specially used as a prayer day, and as Ridgley declares, “We do not find that the seventh-day Sabbath was abolished by positive law.” The New Testament speaks continually of the Sabbath of the Jews, or seventh-day Sabbath, but never of its abolition and the institution of the Sunday Sabbath.
The earliest proofs of Sunday’s observance as a stated day of public prayer and religious instruction are in the letter of Pliny to Trajan in the year 100, and the apology of Justin, written between 139 and 150. In the year 321 Constantine, Emperor of Rome, prohibited all except agricultural work on Sunday. Leo I., of Constantinople, forbade even that. Bishop Taylor “affirms without qualification that the primitive church kept both the Sabbath and the Sunday until the time of the Laodicean Council (364), and almost in everything made them equal, and therefore did not esteem the Sunday to be substituted in place of the obliterated Sabbath, but a feast celebrated by great reason and perpetual consent, without precept or necessary heavenly injunction.”—Church Union.NOTE